For many of us, increasing inequality is the problem, Cwalner. To answer Giz, for me I would certainly go for more equality because I think that it is obvious that increasing inequality is bad for all of us. A society does not live on purchasing power alone. And indeed I think that it is a false dichotomy, or something like it.
In most western democracies poverty is not absolute, at least if that is conceived of as literal starvation and homelessness (though there are people who are both homeless and hungry, that is not really the problem we, on the whole, have to address)
Many people believe that increased material inequality is ok: and some argue that it is a positive good. I have seen this argued in at least two ways:
1. it provides incentives to hard work and innovation, and that this is the foundation of our success as societies, in terms of material wealth (and in terms of "freedom").
2. it is an inevitable consequence of the inherent "inequality" which biology or evolution determine for us: and that we must either promote it, or at the very least accept it: so that pursuing this kind of policy is working with the grain of human nature. To do otherwise must inevitably fail, on this analysis.
There are probably other philosphical positions which lead to the same conclusions, as well. But let us stick with those.
We have been living under governments who have subscribed to these ideas for most of the last 30 years in this country. They have become established as the conventional wisdom, and other ways of looking at the issues have been crowded out to an astonishing degree. In some ways it is hard to challenge it. That is true of all ascendant philosophies, because they get to determine what is relevant to debate. They also get to tell the story ("history is written by the winners" has some small application here: it is not written by the winners once and for all; it is written differently by all sides when there are competing philosophies, and by the ascendant philosophy once that is established for any given period). And this philosophy has deep roots and a strong intellectual and emotional appeal.
I disagree with it for a number of reasons.
In the first place I do not believe that a very unequal society provides incentives. I think the opposite is true. If I am poor and the rich people in my society have a lifestyle which bears some relation to my own, then I can aspire. If the difference becomes too big then I might still believe that I can get there if I put in enough effort and have been lucky enough to be born with skill and talent: but that is not what most people will think. Most people will think it is hopeless, and they will give up. As an example, I have often heard it said that anyone can become president of the united states. I am sure that many believe that to be true and in theory it is true. But in practice? Well others will know better than me how it plays out in the states. But I think it is self evidently false: you need too much money.
But that is a minor point. Much more importantly this notion of incentive rests on an assumption that hard work and talent bring big rewards. I see no evidence of this. Leaving aside the very wealthy for the moment, let us look at our shared experience. Can you argue that that view is supported by what we know of the membership? I do not wish to lift names: but think of those who have shared personal stories with us: outcomes do not seem to be very closely related to those factors: not as I see it.
Social mobility is essential to this narrative. A very unequal society can only be "fair" if that mobility is high. It presupposes that opportunities are available, and it is up to the individual to grab them. But social mobility has not increased with the adoption of more laissez faire policies. It is a complicated issue and I do not wish to pretend otherwise: but whatever the reasons, and however it is measured, in this country social mobility seems to have been greater when we were pursuing more egalitarian policies: and less since we abandoned them. This is not so true for women, because their entry into the labour market and increasingly into the professions has given a different trajectory. Yet it remains true that social class (or occupational place) is best predicted by that of your parents and I think this is true in the US and UK more than it is in more equal societies. Since social mobility is the only basis for fairness in an unequal society, that is at best ironic.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2005/apr/25/socialexclusion.accesstouniversity
http://www.hmg.gov.uk/newopportunities/opportunities/historic.aspx
http://research.dwp.gov.uk/asd/asd5/rports2007-2008/rrep450.pdf
Even if that is not accepted (and it is open to dispute) and one can demonstrate that we have high and increasing social mobility ( I do not accept that but take it for the sake of argument) what is the benefit of great inequality? Why is it fair that those born with great talent get great rewards? it is no more a personal triumph than being born an aristocrat in a feudal society. It is exactly analogous to blue blood.
One can say that such people contribute more of worth for the rest of us: and some inequality can be justified on that basis: but huge disparity? I don't see the argument for it
One can say that hard work is what counts and that the indigenous talent is secondary: well maybe. But lots of people work very, very hard and get nowhere; they are unlucky through serial unemployment or through illness or for a whole variety of causes. Both sides of this debate accept that there will be some inequality: but for me the social contract is such that all should have at least a reasonable quality of life, no matter what their circumstance. The desire to punish the feckless is understandable, but it costs us more than a more forgiving attitude does. Or so I think.
I want to live in a society where at least some of the people will choose to work in jobs which do not give great financial rewards but are rewarding in other ways: but if we reduce the measure of man to money then that is what they will pursue. And the loss is to us all.
In 1980 the basic state pension was 24% of average earnings. In 2000 it was 16%
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200304/cmhansrd/vo040719/text/40719w12.htm
It is possible that this increase in inequality represents an improvement for the poor and that less inequality would have left them worse off. But inflation in the same period was 258%
http://www.ecademy.com/node.php?id=144515
That is what pensions (and benefits) have risen by: wages have risen by much more
I cannot find figures for the source of increased inequality for the whole period, but this site shows that:
Over the last decade, the poorest tenth of the population have, on average, seen a fall in their real incomes after deducting housing costs. In other words, after adjusting for inflation, their incomes are, on average, slightly lower than a decade ago. This is in sharp contrast with the rest of the income distribution, which, on average, has seen substantial rises in their real incomes.
http://www.poverty.org.uk/09/index.shtml?2
If the real income of the poor is falling then inequality is not coming from an across the board percentage rise, as is often claimed. I would oppose increased inequality even if it were true: but until it is true it is not even a question, for me