Indeed so- but why could they not afford to buy? There were historical reasons for my (and I guess your generation's ) parents- a war, for one thing. My folks paid rent for about 30 years. They had nowt in terms of property to show for what they paid. I agree they had a house- even if the ceiling collapsed several times from damp due to an attempt to adapt an Israeli ! design to the Scots climate and the winter of discontent shut off the power in a house with no fireplaces, and a few other quibbles. My father was dead before the house was bought. My mother never had the money to buy it. I did. (It now belongs to my sister , by the way, not to me, though I know many folk effectively "bought out " relatives. Not my way.)
Well yes and no. While my parents were still tenants the LA refurbished their flat to a very high standard.......What you will also see in some streets is a few houses with no double glazing because the tenant bought the house before the refurbishements. So that is not all one way.
Accepted. Like I said, there are many facets to the story- you listed , to my mind , one version of the council schemes , I was just giving a rather different POV. In general (pre 1960s) council houses were excellent designs and the fittings were generally good. I
do criticise the way much of the property was treated by some tenants. I could show you two identical "schemes" - same houses, street patterns, date of construction. One was a slum, the other an extremely nice place. The difference was people - but that's another thread.
... those who did not buy their houses were generally the poorest, as you say. And the loss of the rental income meant that the LA could not maintain them as well as formerly.
I'm not sure that works. By the time most CHs were sold, the initial build cost was long amortised.
Maintenance costs though would constantly increase. Having far fewer to maintain may well have actually
increased their income. We would need the numbers. How much of maintenance cost was paid by rent v how much by central gummint funding. It would vary from place to place. I'd suspect central lowland authorities with large, prewar estates would have been winners for example. A lot of those houses would be due for demolition by now.
The shame of Scottish local authorities was the atrocious quality of build after about 1958 and the relatively small number of houses built. My old man worked in the Motherwell building department as a draughtsman. He often commented that between 1948 and 1958 they built far more houses- mostly semi-det, with a handful of staff, than they did between 1959 and his retirement in ?1981, by which time they had many times the staff. The local authority budget for housing was paying the salaries of the expanded staff and funding civic buildings and shopping centres instead of housing- because population predictions showed a steady fall. Nobody expected half the population would choose to live alone, so that tens of thousands of flats would be needed. Nobody expected immigration to pick up and emigration to fall. The Scots have stayed home in droves the last thirty years, compared to our long history of wandering of all over the world.
In fact this is part of a self fulfilling analysis, because the evidence from the earlier refurbishment I mentioned above is that the councils were willing and able to maintain those houses to a high standard when they had the income to do it. And a lot of their income came from rents.
Oh I never knew a Labour cooncil feart to spend other folks' money. I agree with you there!

The difference is that the sold properties are now maintained
at the expense of their owners, to the standard they choose, or can afford. But again, how much of the income was rental I don't know.
Sure: there are some folk who have different priorities. Satellite TV is not at all the same kind of outlay as double glazing:
I imagine not. But if you can bolt a sat dish to your wall, you
can afford the water to
wash the windows once in a while. A lot of maintenance costs little- picking up trash, washing the path, clean the windows, cut the grass- borrow a ladder and clear the gutters-but you know as well as I do that a lot of folk just can't be arsed. They sit and watch the roof leak rather than fix it because it's not their problem. They spend money on the tv, because it's theirs.
and in fact for the poorest it is good use of resource because it is one of the cheapest ways to secure entertainment, and poor people have kids. Fact is that it is one of the most visible "extravagances" of the poor, because you can see the dish. But it is a rational purchase if you are poor, the same as a taxi from the supermarket is. You have to understand the actual economics. Drugs are a very separate issue, however.
It keeps them off the streets you mean? Opiate of the masses. Aye, well and good. What are you a social engineer for the NWO?
(I'm kidding. I'm aware you're no more the 2D bleeding heart socialist than I'm the evil Kapitalist landlord , twirling my mustachios , but it's a good argument, so what the hell...)
Certainly they are not sitting empty. And certainly many are still owned by the original tenants or their families. But that is not really a plus for many. As an example: a young couple with one child would have been eligible for a council house, and before the sell-off they would probably have got one reasonably quickly (thought waiting times varied a lot, and it also depended where you were prepared to take one).
And that last is still the kicker. You could get one in most central Scotland areas next week. But you wouldn't want it. And I wouldn't blame you.
How much that has to do with housing policy and how much with other social change you would know better than I. I doubt CH sell off is the sole cause.
It is also true that if your family grew you would have been eligible for rehousing to a home suitable for your needs. So if you had two children, a boy and a girl, you were considered to need 3 bedrooms once the older of those children was of a certain age (8, I think, but that may vary). But if you bought your 2 bed flat that was it. You could only get another bedroom if you bought a bigger house. And the second house was not subsidised. People on low incomes could not afford to do that really: so they had the choice to take advantage of the looser credit rules (what we now call sub prime mortgages,I think): or, if they were prudent, they stayed put. One interesting fact is that throughout this period inflation was held to be A REALLY BAD THING. Unless of couse it was house price inflation which was simultaneously held to be A REALLY GOOD THING. (don't ask me, it is "their" analysis). So now we have either crippling levels of debt or overcrowding. I just can't see how that is progress.
I never understood how house price rises are "good" while fuel price rises are "bad" either, but then I'm the owner of a 2 bed Barratt box that's actually worth less after inflation now than when I bought it in 1983, so you can tell I'm a whiz economist. Fi, I again agree with most of the above. I just don't think the sell off is he major cause of social change in Scotland. It sounds like you do. AS I said, it's a multifaceted situation- since the 80's average family size has fallen. Most houses built in the private sector are 1-2 bed flats, (though, bizarrely, the next biggest growth area seems to be in huge houses of five bedrooms or more. No clue what that's about).
If it's your opinion that UK house prices are totally out of line with reality, I absolutely agree. I fully expected prices to fall 30-40% in the last two years. As in parts of the USA. Didn't happen. Again, I have no idea why, unless it be that the remaining stock of council houses and housing association stock has helped damp the swing.
There is no shortage of houses for sale. I can take you to dozens (mostly 2-bed flats)that have been on sale in my home town for two years. Nobody wants them because they are ludicrously expensive and shoddily built. The price will fall, or the builders will go broke and the banks will auction them off, maybe to housing associations.
As to being a drain on local authority finance: I do not see that at all: the rents were low, certainly. But most of the stock was built a long time ago and ongoing rent was income. If they were a drain then can you show how? Because there are people who specificallly "buy to let" and they seem to think it is income not expenditure. They also have to pay for maintenance. What makes the difference and why are the Local authorities so very short f money?
Same reason as anyone else. They spend more than they earn.
Buy to let works when people want to rent. It doesn't work if they don't.
For a while there, people didn't want to rent. That may be changing back.
Like any other business it has cycles. You can lose your shirt at it.
Like I say- I'd bet some LAs made more from rent than they spent on maintenance and new building- and I'd bet others lost. I doubt there was much they could do about it either way.
That just confuses me. You are absolutely correct to say that the houses were well built and that they are often much cheaper than the private alternative. But the private alternative is expensive because the council houses were sold.
I can't see how you conclude that. The market force that drives house prices up has nothing to do with council housing. That force is greed, acquisitiveness, demand, call it whichever suits.
Rural prices around Edinburgh have risen 200% at the same time council houses in the city are sitting empty - that's because people WANT one and don't want the other, because one is in a nice place and t'other aint.
There's no reason council house prices- sold or unsold have not risen as fast as private build houses- excpt that folk do not want them as much.
It is not a natural law. That same young couple with one child will not get a council house now because there are hardly any left, and where they do exist they tend to be in areas which have become ghettos: there are no longer the kinds of council estates where I (and presumably you) grew up: the ones with a mix of people.
You said this before. It does not match my memory.
As was always true in london (or so I believe) they are now sinks for the very poorest. The young couple we are both talking about has not benefitted from this: they have suffered. You know as well as I do that the mortgage is absurdly high compared to what it would have been for a bought house when the council stock was intact. You know that wages have not kept pace with house prices: not anything like it. It is positively perverse to present this as you have, IMO.
A wee bitty perversion never hurt.
The difference is this: before this happened one could buy a small flat for 2.5X a single income: now you can maybe do it on 2.5 X two incomes. What do you think young people in poor jobs earn, Soapy? Minimum wage is £5.80 an hour last time I looked. About 12000 a year before tax. So they can't afford your £88,000, even: where are these people supposed to live?
The sad part is that the banks convinced them they
could afford it. It may amuse you to know the seller of the 88K house (bought 1988-90 for about 15) was a social worker. It belonged to his uncle. Some folk
are upwardly mobile!
Or let us turn to the older generation: as you said many of these houses are occupied by the original tenants or their families. That was also one of the carrots: you poor people will get an asset to pass on to your children. Well true: so long as you dont get ill that is. If you need residential care for any length of time you have to sell the house to pay the bill: so you gain nothing. Another thing that people did not fully appreciate when they did this.
Fiona- people are
allowed to make choices. Sometimes they work out badly. I still don't think it's your place or mine to tell them what to do.
What about the working age people who are not starting out and are not elderly? If you live in a council house and lose your job your home is not at risk because rents were in line with the ceiling on benefits and were covered by those benefits. But mortgages are not covered (though for some of the period interest on mortgages was met: not sure how that is now). That is as it should be: why should the rest of us buy a capital asset for someone? But it means that there is increased insecurity:
loss of a job is a bigger disaster than it used to be: and this in a time of long term high unemployment. Historically in Scotland jobs have been insecure: and that is part of the background as to why council housing was so widespread. That part has not changed: the background rate of unemployment in Scotland has always been higher than it was in the SE of england. Even in the 60's when there was "full employment" that meant 2% unemployed in the SE and 4% in scotland. That average covers a wide variation of course: and we have not seen such levels of employment since those days.
I agree with everything except your apparent conservatism. Why do you want to keep things this way?
In your remarks you have assumed that owning a house is a good thing in itself: but I don't see why it is.
Nope. Or I didn't mean to. Not in itself. I think it's a choice people should be free to make, just like buying anything else- if they can afford it. I think it results in better maintenance of the property than if it was rented- that's a good thing.
People in Scotland did not really share that view so much before this was pushed so strongly, though I think it was perhaps more prevalent in England. The advantages were sold very hard, and maybe that was pushing at an open door. But the disadvantages were hardly mentioned. Do you really think this has had good results?
Am I detecting a hint of anti- English sentiment here? If so few Scots wanted to own their own homes, then why are we having this discussion?
Fiona this is where you and I differ fundamentally. I don't
care whether it has good results, if by "good" you mean socially beneficial to maintenance of the status quo. I think people are free to make up their own minds what they want. If they want to jump off a cliff that's their business and not mine. I don't think it's up to me to do anyone else's thinking. A change was made. It had good results for some, bad for others. Your complaint is that the bad result wa worst for the poor and the feckless. Did you ever hear a social change that wasn't? Is that a reason to change nothing?
If people really wanted to own their homes then they started out in a council house and saved and bought: that meant they moved out and the house was there for the next young couple just like them: but now they stay and so the young couple have to buy at the prices you rightly pointed out in the private sector. Or live in a private let which is not subsidised and does not allow of saving for that next move.
If only it had been that simple, I doubt the sell off would ever have happened, but it wasn't. You know it wasn't.
Lets draw a line under this. Knowing what I know now, if I had a time machine would I advise Thatcher to go ahead with the sell off?
Probably yes, but with restrictions and safeguards.
Would I still buy? Yes.
Now this has been a long and rambling reply , interrupted often and I'll now spend an hour fixing all the quote tags.