The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

So why do you care about the people of Afghanistan and not the people of DRC or Sudan or Central African Republic or Somalia or any one of a huge number of countries where life is much much worse? I'd rather we pull out of Afghanistan after a decade long war, and use our forces for humanitarian aid where they can do more good.

Because NATO forces are there, and owe it the Afghan people (95% of whom oppose the Taliban).

The green party with no power and no influence made a statement calling for negotiated settlement which was ignored.

Would it have worked better?

And I don't remember any great clamour for military intervention from labour in 1994 - how many died in Rwanda? 1 million?

No, about 8 Million. Whether that was wrong or not (And yes, their silence was), it changes nothing with respect to my question about why the Greens would leave the Afghan people to the mercy of the Taliban. Do they not care for Human rights? What do they think will happen if the forces pull out?

Apologies, but you sound like you've swallowed one of Brown's speeches.....complaining about the deficit is relevant because it's astronomical.

As is the States. I don't think I've ever heard it mentioned in a Brown speech. I can't really sit through them for long.

And "saved 1.5 million jobs"? Any evidence for this beyond "Because the Great Leader said so"?

"Great Leader"? This is the kind of language a teabagger uses. Sticking to the facts, rather than insults (What is with the venom on this forum?), this was a claim made by the Small Business Federation of the United Kingdom.
 
Last edited:
No, about 8 Million. Whether that was wrong or not (And yes, their silence was), it changes nothing with respect to my question about why the Greens would leave the Afghan people to the mercy of the Taliban. Do they not care for Human rights? What do they think will happen if the forces pull out?

"Great Leader"? This is the kind of language a teabagger uses. Sticking to the facts, rather than insults (What is with the venom on this forum?), this was a claim made by the Small Business Federation of the United Kingdom.

(Googling i think it was 800,000 est for Rwanda....)

I always use Great Leader for Grim Gordo - it's a Private Eye joke. No hostility to you - just to New Labour ;)

Re Afghanistan - i see it as a case of utilitarianism - you could ask "do you not care about the Afghans?" when someone mentions withdrawl, but as i've said, you could just as easily reframe the question to ask "why do you not care about Sudan?" We only have limited resources - the question should be where best to employ them. We've spent over 10 years fighting a civil war in Afghanistan, sooner or later we need to start thinking about leaving - and when we do leave it'll be with a negotiated settlement with the taliban. Will it be perfect? Unlikely - but then the very concept of nation building in afghanistan is so remarkably far-fetched given the circumstances on the ground. And who are we even fighting for at the moment? A group of corrupt and affluent politicians in Kabul, who are propped up by regional warlords....We need to start looking for a way out - and that would then free up resources to actually provide a greater humanitarian benefit elsewhere.
 
And just for a bit of balance, some of the New Tories' policies are dreadful....

plebiscite veto for council tax rises (just a small-state low tax wheeze - the public are always going to vote against tax....) - the result will be council services which serve those that can't shout loudest - ie. the poor, elderly and infirm will be sliced....

More acadamies - private/public partnerships in schools are unnecessary... the public sector still bears all the burden of any failure in any case, and academy "successes" are achieved by pouring millions into the schemes...

Votes to elect police chiefs (or mayors - i can't remember which) - anyway, putting overall accountability of policing in the hands of locals. Sounds good in theory....but what will happen is a drift to the right-wing, greater tabloid influence over our policing policy and knee jerk reactionary measures governed by general ignorance rather than professional knowledge....
 
We need to start looking for a way out - and that would then free up resources to actually provide a greater humanitarian benefit elsewhere.

Ok, but I don't think the Greens are looking further than simply pulling out.

I'd say the least NATO owes the Afghans, after fighting for 9 years in their country, is to not surrender them to the very people they are so opposed to, not to just cut and run. Do you not agree?
 
The "Council House Sell-off" is a tale of many aspects.
Another side to the story is that the sale enabled people who had been tenants all their lives- and looked likely to remain so, because banks back then didn't give mortgages to just anyone-the chance to own their own home. My mother, for one.

It was fun spotting the ones that had been bought- they were the ones with the double glazing and the new front doors. It was astonishing to me to see how very differently people treated property when their name was on the mortgage deed and not on the rent book. In the street where my mother still lives, only a minority of houses are still local-authority owned. They are easily identified, by their poorer upkeep. This is, in some cases,I'm sure because their tenants lack funds- but oddly, several of them seem to have the funds for satellite TV and ludicrously powerful cars. In several cases, ironically, said funds are well known to come from drug sales.

In any case, none of the purchased homes is sitting empty. In most cases they are still owned by the original tenants or their families. They are just better maintained and no longer a drain on local authority finance.

Yes, some have been sold. A 1963 3 bedroom house in that street recently went for 88000 pounds. A New build of similar size in the same area would cost around 190-230,000 and would be of inferior construction. So the sold stock actually provides precisely the market niche for folk on low-mid income with young families that is lacking from the private sector.

It's not as if these houses disappeared from the face of the Earth.

ETA- RE my comments about politicians being scumbags.
OK, maybe I was a tad over the top. I daresay there are some decent people out there- but they are doing a poor job of informing us about it. I just ran a straw poll on six Brits who happen to be working with me. (I'm in Kazakhstan at the moment)*
All six expressed similar disgust. Three said they consider voting a waste of time. If this is a representative sample, then this election may be marked by the lowest turnout ever. How low must it go before the system itself is reexamined?Why is there no NONE OF THE ABOVE" option on ballot papers?

And re the IQ thing- I don't demand genius. Proven ability to formulate , hold and defend an opinionwould be nice, rather than the ability to wear a tie of whatever colour.

And, as I'm on a rant anyway- I'm neither a citizen of Afghanistan nor of Iraq. It is not my damned business to tell those people what sort of government they need. I'm not even convinced the system WE have is worth a damn!


* You want to see REALcorrupt politics in action- Google "Karachaganak".
 
Last edited:
A minimum standard of IQ would be a terrible thing, implementing some kind of meritocracy. IQ can't measure wisdom.

If you want the politicians to be less aloof and disconnected from the population, don't implement IQ tests on prospective MP's.

See above- but I'd force them to be less aloof, because they would have to live in their constituency at all times. There would be no London financial scams, because they would never need to go there, unless that's where they were elected. There would be a constituency office , funded by central gummint, preferably in the local Social, from where they would operate. Voting in debate could be done by email., video conferencing on 24/7 if they want it. They would go home at night right where they live. Westminster palace could be sold to Conrad Hilton at a profit. Who needs it?

They need to meet? Fine . Once a month in the town hall of every major city, by rotation. 1st class rail fare return to be paid from their home- legitimate expense. Hell, give' em a free railcard.

Those are the sort of reforms I want for our government, just as I'd like to see our court system booted swiftly up the backside and dragged at least into the 20th century if the jump from 19th to 21st is too much.


ETA- Anyway, what's so bad about a meritocracy? I'd rather be ruled by clever crooks than stupid ones.
 
Last edited:
The "Council House Sell-off" is a tale of many aspects.
Another side to the story is that the sale enabled people who had been tenants all their lives- and looked likely to remain so, because banks back then didn't give mortgages to just anyone-the chance to own their own home. My mother, for one.

It is true that was the carrot, Soapy: it is also true that many (like my parents) were effectively forced, and I know it made my father deeply unhappy. But there is more to it. Many who bought were tenants because they could not afford to buy. That was why the discount was there. And buying a house is not a "one off", as you well know

It was fun spotting the ones that had been bought- they were the ones with the double glazing and the new front doors. It was astonishing to me to see how very differently people treated property when their name was on the mortgage deed and not on the rent book.

Well yes and no. While my parents were still tenants the LA refurbished their flat to a very high standard. The whole street were decanted into caravans for several months and they came back to new kitchens, bathrooms, double glazing, central heating, and roof. That was a programme which was being rolled out across the country (faster or slower depending on how much money the councils had). What you will also see in some streets is a few houses with no double glazing because the tenant bought the house before the refurbishements. So that is not all one way.

There was a problem though: in many local authorities one was not allowed to replace windows and doors if one was a tenant. That was based on the fact that it easier and cheaper to maintain houses if the bits are all standard: it was a bit stalinist, and more flexibility would have been better: bu it is not the end of the world.

In the street where my mother still lives, only a minority of houses are still local-authority owned. They are easily identified, by their poorer upkeep.

That is certainly true: those who did not buy their houses were generally the poorest, as you say. And the loss of the rental income meant that the LA could not maintain them as well as formerly. In fact this is part of a self fulfilling analysis, because the evidence from the earlier refurbishment I mentioned above is that the councils were willing and able to maintain those houses to a high standard when they had the income to do it. And a lot of their income came from rents.

This is, in some cases,I'm sure because their tenants lack funds- but oddly, several of them seem to have the funds for satellite TV and ludicrously powerful cars. In several cases, ironically, said funds are well known to come from drug sales.

Sure: there are some folk who have different priorities. Satellite TV is not at all the same kind of outlay as double glazing: and in fact for the poorest it is good use of resource because it is one of the cheapest ways to secure entertainment, and poor people have kids. Fact is that it is one of the most visible "extravagances" of the poor, because you can see the dish. But it is a rational purchase if you are poor, the same as a taxi from the supermarket is. You have to understand the actual economics. Drugs are a very separate issue, however.

In any case, none of the purchased homes is sitting empty. In most cases they are still owned by the original tenants or their families. They are just better maintained and no longer a drain on local authority finance.

Certainly they are not sitting empty. And certainly many are still owned by the original tenants or their families. But that is not really a plus for many. As an example: a young couple with one child would have been eligible for a council house, and before the sell-off they would probably have got one reasonably quickly (thought waiting times varied a lot, and it also depended where you were prepared to take one). It is also true that if your family grew you would have been eligible for rehousing to a home suitable for your needs. So if you had two children, a boy and a girl, you were considered to need 3 bedrooms once the older of those children was of a certain age (8, I think, but that may vary). But if you bought your 2 bed flat that was it. You could only get another bedroom if you bought a bigger house. And the second house was not subsidised. People on low incomes could not afford to do that really: so they had the choice to take advantage of the looser credit rules (what we now call sub prime mortgages,I think): or, if they were prudent, they stayed put. One interesting fact is that throughout this period inflation was held to be A REALLY BAD THING. Unless of couse it was house price inflation which was simultaneously held to be A REALLY GOOD THING. (don't ask me, it is "their" analysis). So now we have either crippling levels of debt or overcrowding. I just can't see how that is progress.

As to being a drain on local authority finance: I do not see that at all: the rents were low, certainly. But most of the stock was built a long time ago and ongoing rent was income. If they were a drain then can you show how? Because there are people who specificallly "buy to let" and they seem to think it is income not expenditure. They also have to pay for maintenance. What makes the difference and why are the Local authorities so very short f money?

Yes, some have been sold. A 1963 3 bedroom house in that street recently went for 88000 pounds. A New build of similar size in the same area would cost around 190-230,000 and would be of inferior construction. So the sold stock actually provides precisely the market niche for folk on low-mid income with young families that is lacking from the private sector.

That just confuses me. You are absolutely correct to say that the houses were well built and that they are often much cheaper than the private alternative. But the private alternative is expensive because the council houses were sold. It is not a natural law. That same young couple with one child will not get a council house now because there are hardly any left, and where they do exist they tend to be in areas which have become ghettos: there are no longer the kinds of council estates where I (and presumably you) grew up: the ones with a mix of people. As was always true in london (or so I believe) they are now sinks for the very poorest. The young couple we are both talking about has not benefitted from this: they have suffered. You know as well as I do that the mortgage is absurdly high compared to what it would have been for a bought house when the council stock was intact. You know that wages have not kept pace with house prices: not anything like it. It is positively perverse to present this as you have, IMO. The difference is this: before this happened one could buy a small flat for 2.5X a single income: now you can maybe do it on 2.5 X two incomes. What do you think young people in poor jobs earn, Soapy? Minimum wage is £5.80 an hour last time I looked. About 12000 a year before tax. So they can't afford your £88,000, even: where are these people supposed to live?

Or let us turn to the older generation: as you said many of these houses are occupied by the original tenants or their families. That was also one of the carrots: you poor people will get an asset to pass on to your children. Well true: so long as you dont get ill that is. If you need residential care for any length of time you have to sell the house to pay the bill: so you gain nothing. Another thing that people did not fully appreciate when they did this.

What about the working age people who are not starting out and are not elderly? If you live in a council house and lose your job your home is not at risk because rents were in line with the ceiling on benefits and were covered by those benefits. But mortgages are not covered (though for some of the period interest on mortgages was met: not sure how that is now). That is as it should be: why should the rest of us buy a capital asset for someone? But it means that there is increased insecurity: loss of a job is a bigger disaster than it used to be: and this in a time of long term high unemployment. Historically in Scotland jobs have been insecure: and that is part of the background as to why council housing was so widespread. That part has not changed: the background rate of unemployment in Scotland has always been higher than it was in the SE of england. Even in the 60's when there was "full employment" that meant 2% unemployed in the SE and 4% in scotland. That average covers a wide variation of course: and we have not seen such levels of employment since those days.

In your remarks you have assumed that owning a house is a good thing in itself: but I don't see why it is. People in Scotland did not really share that view so much before this was pushed so strongly, though I think it was perhaps more prevalent in England. The advantages were sold very hard, and maybe that was pushing at an open door. But the disadvantages were hardly mentioned. Do you really think this has had good results?

If people really wanted to own their homes then they started out in a council house and saved and bought: that meant they moved out and the house was there for the next young couple just like them: but now they stay and so the young couple have to buy at the prices you rightly pointed out in the private sector. Or live in a private let which is not subsidised and does not allow of saving for that next move.
 
Last edited:
That is a masterly explanation Fiona - you covered points I hadn't considered before.

I'm slightly conflicted about this, because I was solidly against the sale of council houses at the time. My father retired in 1979 at the age of 75 from a job with a tied house. Our family was eligible for a council house and after a little bit of toing and froing we were offered a well-built 1920s two-bedroomed semi. The house was empty and practically stripped bare when we saw it, but the room sizes were good and it had a nice feel. I remember wandering around the house and saying, I think we could be happy here. My parents had the house redecorated and new central heating installed, at their own expense.

Time passed, and I got a job in England and moved out to my own flat. My parents stayed on in the semi. Maggie Thatcher happened, and my father decided to buy the house. He didn't get as good a discount as many of our neighbours, because of his shorter tenancy, but it was still a deal that would have been madness to turn down. I was deeply unhappy in one way, because I wanted to know what was going to happen to the next person retiring from a tied house. Where were they going to be housed? On the other hand, I could see it was good for us.

More time passed, and my parents installed double glazing and made other improvements to the house. It was obvious the houses in the street that were now privately owned were getting more upgrading than the ones remaining in council ownership. (This was somewhat reversed much later, when all the council-owned ones got new roofs and pebble-dashing though.)

More time passed, and my father died. My mother stayed on in the house. Gradually, she was less able to manage on her own, though by the time of her 90th birthday she was still living there independently.

However, at that exact time, I got a new job, only 35 miles from that house. I moved back in, temporarily, while I looked for a permanent place. I suggested to my mother that we might look for a place for both of us, so that I wouldn't have to worry about her trying to live on her own in her 90s. She agreed, and we put the house on the market. That was 27 years after my parents were allocated it by the council. She got £105,500 for it.

That made all the difference between being able to afford a house with a "granny annexe" and all the space and facilities we wanted, and having to squeeze ourselves into a smaller house possibly without the layout that would make it easy for Mum to get around. I love our new house, but I recognise I wouldn't have been able to afford that without the proceeds on the ex-council house.

So it benefited me personally. But I'm still against it. I see young people unable to afford a decent place to live, and old people retiring from tied houses with nowhere to go. I see people trapped in houses that are no longer suitable for them, because they can't afford to move. I see our old neighbour across the road, who bought her house at the same time as my parents, having been forced to allow the council to repossess her home to cover the cost of her residential care, so she has nothing to leave to her family.

Renting is the norm in France and Germany I believe. It's flexible, and requires no great capital outlay. I can't see the force of the ideology that says, own your own home at all costs.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Just one point, Rolfe: it the house prices had not gone crazy in the way they did, do you think you would have been able to buy the house you have now without the capital from the sale of your mother's house? I can see that in the present situation that money was necessary: but if the ratio of house prices to income had not come adrift could you have done it on your current wages? I think it is possible you could; and if that is the case you have not really benefited at all. :)
 
I can see that in the present situation that money was necessary: but if the ratio of house prices to income had not come adrift could you have done it on your current wages? I think it is possible you could; and if that is the case you have not really benefited at all. :)
This is correct. Housing booms, while they persist (above general price inflation and earnings growth) impose costs on everyone entering the market for the first time and everyone trading up. The winners are people that do the opposite.
 
Just one point, Rolfe: it the house prices had not gone crazy in the way they did, do you think you would have been able to buy the house you have now without the capital from the sale of your mother's house? I can see that in the present situation that money was necessary: but if the ratio of house prices to income had not come adrift could you have done it on your current wages? I think it is possible you could; and if that is the case you have not really benefited at all. :)


Too many hypotheticals, so I can't really say. The new house was funded approximately 50% from the sale of my old house, which hadn't quite trebled in value in the 18 years I lived there, 25% from my own savings, and 25% from the sale of my mother's house.

I just don't know what the new house would have been worth if the prices hadn't gone mad, or what I'd have got for my old house.

Rolfe.
 
...snip...


Certainly they are not sitting empty. And certainly many are still owned by the original tenants or their families. But that is not really a plus for many. As an example: a young couple with one child would have been eligible for a council house, and before the sell-off they would probably have got one reasonably quickly (thought waiting times varied a lot, and it also depended where you were prepared to take one). It is also true that if your family grew you would have been eligible for rehousing to a home suitable for your needs. So if you had two children, a boy and a girl, you were considered to need 3 bedrooms once the older of those children was of a certain age (8, I think, but that may vary). But if you bought your 2 bed flat that was it. You could only get another bedroom if you bought a bigger house. And the second house was not subsidised. People on low incomes could not afford to do that really: ...snip...

And there was another wrinkle in that in most areas the increase in value of ex-council houses did not match the increase in value of non-ex-council houses.

ETA: And the problem was made worse in that the local authorities were pretty much prevented (by central government) from using the money raised from the sale of council housing to fund the building of new council housing. (Amusingly this did mean that quite a few councils had significant sums of money sitting around that they would try to get the best return on e.g. Icelandic banks....)
 
Last edited:
Institute for Fiscal Studies (non-partisan think-tank referred to earlier) on Conservative and Labour manifestos. The complaint (which is in line with what the OECD and the IMF say, as well as government bond ratings agencies) continues to be about the lack of detail concerning necessary spending cuts/tax rises to get almost 5% off the deficit over a parliament (which both parties pledge to do without saying fully how).

According to the IFS, Labour sketch out a 2:1 ratio of spending cuts:tax rises, and the Conservatives 4:1. They point out that the Lamont/Clarke policies in the 1990s only managed 1:1, suggesting that Tory plans are not realistic.

I think the vagueness--which has not yet rattled the true arbiters of deficit doom (markets) very much--is probably right (it is obviously intended). Most of the nasty surprises are coming after 6 May (or later if there's no single party majority)
 
Too many hypotheticals, so I can't really say. The new house was funded approximately 50% from the sale of my old house, which hadn't quite trebled in value in the 18 years I lived there, 25% from my own savings, and 25% from the sale of my mother's house.
A best guess (yes, just a guess) could be that you would still have had to find 25% of the purchase price from your savings, but that 25% would be a smaller amount of dosh. The other percentages would be the same, and also smaller amounts.
 
Institute for Fiscal Studies (non-partisan think-tank referred to earlier) on Conservative and Labour manifestos. The complaint (which is in line with what the OECD and the IMF say, as well as government bond ratings agencies) continues to be about the lack of detail concerning necessary spending cuts/tax rises to get almost 5% off the deficit over a parliament (which both parties pledge to do without saying fully how).

According to the IFS, Labour sketch out a 2:1 ratio of spending cuts:tax rises, and the Conservatives 4:1. They point out that the Lamont/Clarke policies in the 1990s only managed 1:1, suggesting that Tory plans are not realistic.

I think the vagueness--which has not yet rattled the true arbiters of deficit doom (markets) very much--is probably right (it is obviously intended). Most of the nasty surprises are coming after 6 May (or later if there's no single party majority)

Labour is saying that they will reduce the structural deficit by 2/3 over 5 years, the Conservatives have not said what their target is beyond "better than Labour". :mad: (Mad smiley referring to lack of detail by both parties.)
 
Mutters to self - law needs to be passed that means a manifesto has to fit on one side of A4! Tons of waffles in both the Tories and Labour's so far (Tories are in the lead for fluffiness at the moment) very little concrete detail in either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom