The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

I remember once when I was a child, and bored by all the election flapdoodle, remarking to my father that I didn't see why all the fuss because no matter what the outcome life just went on as before. I got an earful about how much it really did matter and how much of a difference it could actually make.

Of course I realised much later he was a Tory so who knows.

I don't think politicians are all corrupt by any manner of means. I know quite a few, and they're passionate about changing the country for the better. The problem is that political activism is a way into a nice cushy job and a big hike in income for some people. The ones who are cunning enough to play the system well enough to get selected for a safe seat are a blight on the system. Any party with a hope of getting members elected will attract them.

The trouble is, political activism is seen as a pretty bottom-feeding hobby - until suddenly you wake up and realise that a bunch of those bottom-feeders got elected and are in government and are now your actual boss. At that point you better hope it was the passionate, idealistic ones and not the self-serving careerist ones. And that they have at least a couple of neurones to rub together. This isn't necessarily a given though.

Rolfe.
 
A minimum standard of IQ would be a terrible thing, implementing some kind of meritocracy. IQ can't measure wisdom.

If you want the politicians to be less aloof and disconnected from the population, don't implement IQ tests on prospective MP's.


Soapy didn't say where the bar should be drawn. Not necessarily all that high, in my opinion. But there does come a point where you want these guys to be able to navigate their way through at least a short chain of syllogisms, for the benefit of everybody.

Rolfe.
 
I was hoping I'd be out of the UK for the election. It seems not.
I confess to amazement that anyone actually reads party manifestos- this is the first time in my life I have known anyone even mention the idea- but I suppose if trashy, incredible fiction is your thing, why not?
I am by no means sure I will bother to vote. (Pause to allow screams of protest to die down).
I simply no longer have any belief that anyone standing for parliament is anything other than a self-serving crook of the lowest moral standing.
I'm not sure how many other UK citizens share this jaundiced view of their leaders, but I suspect quite a few.
We don't need a new government. We need a new electoral system; one that , for a start , sets a minimum qualification for the position of MP; a competitive examination, a reasonable standard of IQ, a complete tax and police record check, full and ongoing publication of any and all sources of income , business connections and property ownership - and one which mandates an immediate loss of all pension rights and a mandatory jail sentence for unreasonable betrayal of trust of the electorate; the latter to include demonstrable failure to try to achieve campaign promises.

Call me cynical, but does anyone honestly think it makes the slightest difference which bunch of jackasses we vote in? Because I don't.

My MP is one of the good guys. The nasty little Tory running against him has run a dirty campaign that has backfired on him big time. I admit that people have every right to have little or no trust in large amounts of the MP's but they are not all bad.
 
It was the Labour party who helped block this.

That's spin worthy of Campbell! The Labour government tried to flippin pass it! And then they bullied cajoled and made all sorts of underhand trades to ram through 45 day detention.

Granted. And a large quantity of labour activists and members opposed the war, like a large quantity of US Democrats supported the war. Yet seeing as we are doing tu quoque, one has to question why the Green Party took the stance of standing back and not supporting the halt to genocide in Kosovo. Did they not care for lives then? Do they not care for the women or schoolgirls in Afghanistan, who they would leave to the mercy of the Taliban?

Come on, afghanistan never has been about human rights - if we were interested in human rights we'd probably do a lot better putting our multi-billion dollar committment elsewhere. Labour care as much about human rights in afghanistan as they do human rights in the DRC - ie. bugger all.


What's the continuation? From the national minimum wage to Surestart, from the winter fuel allowance to paternity leave, from civil partnerships to the lowest NHS waiting lists in decades, Labour has helped transform the country. Unemployment is currently lower during this catastrophic recession than in the 90's or the 80's recessions. Repossessions have halved. The average person on low-income is 1,600 pounds better off since 1997. It was only due to the Stephen Lawrence inquiry that the Metropolitan Police was finally judged to be institutionally racist. Would the Tories have got justice for the Lawrences?

paid for by an unsustainable housing bubble and lax credit lending which Brown let get way out of control, not to mention his culpability in saddling the country with a budget deficit this year of £120 billion. We'll be paying for Brown's ineptitude two decades from now. Surestart will be pared to the bone. The NHS will decline. Unemployment is still over 2 million - higher than when Labour came to gment. And is the £1600 rise real term?

I loathed the Iraq war, I loathe their assault on civil liberties. No Government is perfect, but there are some far better than others.

The trouble is if you keep holding your nose and voting despite the smell, then where is the accountability? When former ministers tout their wares to the highest bidder, when MPs swindle their expenses, when the government completely fail in the management of the economy, when the government preside over a monumental assault on civil liberties, at what point do you say enough is enough? Maybe the Tories will be worse, but persistently voting for labour no matter what they do will be worse in the long run for the country.
 
Andyandy: what control did the government have over credit extended to house buyers and consumers? The credit controls were abolished more or less as part of the Tory "bonfire of regulations" long ago. Or at least that is what I thought happened.

I believe that was one of the most disastrous policies ever: But it was used to promote the "property owning democracy" and by the time labour came to power the whole attitude to housing was frankly insane: it still is. If you listen to the words used when the housing market is discussed the lunacy is obvious.

It was cowardly of labour not to tackle that: but it would have been difficult to do that. Again their attitude to debt makes it not possible for me to vote for them: but that is exactly true for the Tories and Lib Dems as well. The whole country and all mainstream parties went stark staring bonkers on that issue. Or so I think.
 
Come on, afghanistan never has been about human rights - if we were interested in human rights we'd probably do a lot better putting our multi-billion dollar committment elsewhere. Labour care as much about human rights in afghanistan as they do human rights in the DRC - ie. bugger all.

Regardless of this, pulling out of Afghanistan will surrender the Afghan people to the mercy of the Taliban. What is the Greens solution to this? I'm open.

Also, what was the explanation for their refusal to support the intervention in Kosovo? Why did they not care for Human life then?


saddling the country with a budget deficit this year of £120 billion. We'll be paying for Brown's ineptitude two decades from now. Surestart will be pared to the bone. The NHS will decline. Unemployment is still over 2 million - higher than when Labour came to gment.

Of course it is higher, there has been a worldwide recession deeper than any since 1933. Yet it is still far lower than at any time during the 90's or 80's (lesser) recessions.

Besides, why complain about the deficit at the same time as complaining about unemployment? Brown's borrowing of 5bn in order to halt taxes for 200,000 businesses saved over 1.5 Million jobs.

It's worth noting that our debt from WW2 was only paid back 4 years ago. We didn't live through the doomsday scenario that you paint of our future because of it.

The trouble is if you keep holding your nose and voting despite the smell, then where is the accountability? When former ministers tout their wares to the highest bidder, when MPs swindle their expenses, when the government completely fail in the management of the economy, when the government preside over a monumental assault on civil liberties, at what point do you say enough is enough? Maybe the Tories will be worse, but persistently voting for labour no matter what they do will be worse in the long run for the country.

I don't accept many of those accusations, and one cannot exist in an purely idealistic world. It must be married with pragmatism and realism. Something I don't think the party which had the Holocaust denying, shape-shifting believing David Icke as a main spokesman can deliver.
 
Last edited:
The whole country and all mainstream parties went stark staring bonkers on that issue.
I thought this was a discussion of UK politics. This could describe almost any issue in US politics.
 
Who allowed the sale of all those council houses? That didn't help the housing problems in this country.

Let's face it, if it wasnt for the global credit crunch and recession the Tories would not have a hope in hell even after a bad session for Labour.
 
The tories did not "allow" the sale of council houses, funk de fino, For all practical purposes they forced the sale of them. It is true they did not make it legally compulsory for you to buy: but the discounts; combined with the threat of turnng the remaining houses over to private landlords; and the move to so- called "market value" rents,amounted to the same thing
 
The tories did not "allow" the sale of council houses, funk de fino, For all practical purposes they forced the sale of them. It is true they did not make it legally compulsory for you to buy: but the discounts; combined with the threat of turnng the remaining houses over to private landlords; and the move to so- called "market value" rents,amounted to the same thing

Nicely clarified, thanks!
 
Andyandy: what control did the government have over credit extended to house buyers and consumers? The credit controls were abolished more or less as part of the Tory "bonfire of regulations" long ago. Or at least that is what I thought happened.

I believe that was one of the most disastrous policies ever: But it was used to promote the "property owning democracy" and by the time labour came to power the whole attitude to housing was frankly insane: it still is. If you listen to the words used when the housing market is discussed the lunacy is obvious.

It was cowardly of labour not to tackle that: but it would have been difficult to do that. Again their attitude to debt makes it not possible for me to vote for them: but that is exactly true for the Tories and Lib Dems as well. The whole country and all mainstream parties went stark staring bonkers on that issue. Or so I think.

True. And the answer to "would the Tories have done any differently?" almost certainly is no.....that emcompasses the whole lassaiz faire "market knows best" creed. Which is a large part of the problem.
 
Of course the tories would not have done differently, andyandy: they are supposed to do things like that. That is their political view: and now it is labour's too. On so many important issues you could not put a sheet of paper between them: Blair and his pals are tories and there is no labour party any more. Nor is there any meaningful choice
 
Please clarify for ignorant American here. What is a 'council house'?

A council house is a house which is provided by local government for rent. They were an enormous part of the housing stock post-war. Almost everyone I know grew up in one and they provided a very good quality of housing (with some problems in some areas of course) at an affordable price. The tenants were very mixed - folk on benefit; manual workers; skilled workers; teachers and nurses - all kinds of people. They helped to make a cohesive society and made it hard to demonise the poor: they gave people some security which meant they had less fear and more power. In Scotland, at least, they were an unmitigated good (though very often ugly, and in some places the schemes were badly planned)

The tories sold them to sitting tenants at discounts from market value of up to something like 60%. This was called the right to buy. It was a disastrous policy from every reasonable perspective. It was coupled by a ban on building new ones and it contributed to a housing shortage and to insane house prices financed by the abolition of credit control.
 
Please clarify for ignorant American here. What is a 'council house'?
A house owned by a local council, let on long term secure tenancies (in contrast with the private rental market, which has typically higher rents and less secure tenancies). People hoping to rent council housing have to go on a waiting list, as the supply of housing is much less than it was since a lot was sold to the tenants. Only those in priority need of social housing are likely to be granted a tenancy. There is a perception that many people in council housing are unemployed and living on state benefits.

Some councils have arm's length management organisations, ALMOs, who manage their housing stock.

There are also housing associations, who own and/or manage social housing stock. Again, there are waiting lists and the rents tend to be lower than the market. However, tenancies are not as secure (though in practical terms, they are long term tenancies).
 
It was coupled by a ban on building new ones and it contributed to a housing shortage and to insane house prices financed by the abolition of credit control.

I can't rememeber the actual details but were the councils also not allowed to spend any of the momeny raised for 20 odd years?
 
Regardless of this, pulling out of Afghanistan will surrender the Afghan people to the mercy of the Taliban. What is the Greens solution to this? I'm open.

Also, what was the explanation for their refusal to support the intervention in Kosovo? Why did they not care for Human life then?

So why do you care about the people of Afghanistan and not the people of DRC or Sudan or Central African Republic or Somalia or any one of a huge number of countries where life is much much worse? I'd rather we pull out of Afghanistan after a decade long war, and use our forces for humanitarian aid where they can do more good.

With regards to Kosovo? Well i think we were right to intervene - i don't need to try and defend a position i don't hold - but if it bothers you so much, how can you possibly vote for labour? The green party with no power and no influence made a statement calling for negotiated settlement which was ignored. The labour party ignored international law, lied to parliament and the public and dragged our country to war on false pretenses - and are directly responsible for the deaths of thousands.

And I don't remember any great clamour for military intervention from labour in 1994 - how many died in Rwanda? 1 million?


Of course it is higher, there has been a worldwide recession deeper than any since 1933. Yet it is still far lower than at any time during the 90's or 80's (lesser) recessions.

Besides, why complain about the deficit at the same time as complaining about unemployment? Brown's borrowing of 5bn in order to halt taxes for 200,000 businesses saved over 1.5 Million jobs.

It's worth noting that our debt from WW2 was only paid back 4 years ago. We didn't live through the doomsday scenario that you paint of our future because of it.

Apologies, but you sound like you've swallowed one of Brown's speeches.....complaining about the deficit is relevant because it's astronomical. This realisation doesn't seem to have filtered into the mainstream public - largely because the politicians are so disingenous about it. £5billion is absolute peanuts - it's neither here nor there relative to the deficit. Check out what happens to the bond markets post election if there aren't savage cuts lined up - we can kiss goodbye to AAA, and then our £1 trillion debt is going to get a whole lot worse. WW2 debt payments are meaningless - it's the interest payments that are going to be crippling. And "saved 1.5 million jobs"? Any evidence for this beyond "Because the Great Leader said so"?

I don't accept many of those accusations, and one cannot exist in an purely idealistic world. It must be married with pragmatism and realism. Something I don't think the party which had the Holocaust denying, shape-shifting believing David Icke as a main spokesman can deliver.

Icke was a pretty normal chap BBC journalist etc, and then went loopy around the turn of the decade - then resigned from the Green Party in 1991...none of his nutty beliefs were green policy. Why this has any impact on whether someone should vote for the Green party 20 years later is pretty strange. You may as well say that you shouldn't ever vote for labour because Michael Foot tried to kiss his stepdaughter. It doesn't mean that labour have ever been pro-incest.....
 
Last edited:
I can't rememeber the actual details but were the councils also not allowed to spend any of the momeny raised for 20 odd years?

I think that is correct: they were certainly not allowed to spend it on building houses and I think they had to devote it to clearing debt, and were not allowed to use if for providing services. But I cannot be sure of that
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom