The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

Andy, how do you feel about the fact that the Greens don't practice skepticism?

http://www.layscience.net/node/581

Sure they have some dumb ideas - but so do all the parties. Labour's drugs policy is about as dumb and unskeptical as you could possibly imagine.

In the greater scheme of things, homeopathy on the NHS vs a party who tried to bring in 90 day detention without charge, who supported a war killing hundreds of thousands, who presided over the biggest boom and bust in the country's history, who.. [continued on page 94.....]

well, i'll take the water....;)
 
When's BBQ season in Scotland? From memory it is during the second week of Wimbledon when the all rain in the UK invariably descends on the south.

Tonight apparently. I can see folk having one from my window.

Apparently they see no contradiction in having a BBQ whilst wearing a ski jacket.
 
Sigh. I delivered nearly 200 leaflets yesterday. Bits of me hurt.

Rolfe.

I'm so jealous that you have such a good fit. I couldn't bring myself to do the same for whoever I hold my nose and vote for here.

And yay, the Labour manifesto is out! Time to read.
 
The conservative lead is starting to slip again or at least the gap is closing.

http://ukpollingreport.co.uk/blog/

Which is actually interesting and due to the dates of the poll sampling (before the Labour manifesto) it makes me wonder why.

The Labour party really have not done anything in the last few days to make themselves look better (manifesto aside they really hadn't done much of anything at all), Cameron has plugged on relentlessly.

Which kind of makes me wonder if there a danger that the conservatives will start to look like a head with no body, it could be that by using their biggest (and only) asset (imo) so much, people will a) just become weary of seeing him, b) the rolled up sleeve/sweatshirt/jogging/one of the "ordinary people honest!" tactic loses impact without contrast, c) might the continuing addition of names to the business "leaders" list be a step too far, not knowing when to stop and just bank the initial advantage? d) Conjure up reminders of Thatcher's less than consensual style?
 
funny-pictures-cat-naps-on-chair.jpg


:c1:
 
Jim Devine is a turnip. Or that might be an insult to turnips, which are a tasty and healthy dish.

Rolfe.
 
I am not particularly familiar with Jim Devine, but I have met Elliott Morley, and he is definitely a turnip.
 
Jim Devine is a turnip. Or that might be an insult to turnips, which are a tasty and healthy dish.

Rolfe.

What happened to the traditional pigs's bladder on a stick.
 
Sure they have some dumb ideas - but so do all the parties. Labour's drugs policy is about as dumb and unskeptical as you could possibly imagine.

In the greater scheme of things, homeopathy on the NHS vs a party who tried to bring in 90 day detention without charge,

It was the Labour party who helped block this.

who supported a war killing hundreds of thousands,

Granted. And a large quantity of labour activists and members opposed the war, like a large quantity of US Democrats supported the war. Yet seeing as we are doing tu quoque, one has to question why the Green Party took the stance of standing back and not supporting the halt to genocide in Kosovo. Did they not care for lives then? Do they not care for the women or schoolgirls in Afghanistan, who they would leave to the mercy of the Taliban?

who presided over the biggest boom and bust in the country's history, who.. [continued on page 94.....]

What's the continuation? From the national minimum wage to Surestart, from the winter fuel allowance to paternity leave, from civil partnerships to the lowest NHS waiting lists in decades, Labour has helped transform the country. Unemployment is currently lower during this catastrophic recession than in the 90's or the 80's recessions. Repossessions have halved. The average person on low-income is 1,600 pounds better off since 1997. It was only due to the Stephen Lawrence inquiry that the Metropolitan Police was finally judged to be institutionally racist. Would the Tories have got justice for the Lawrences?

I loathed the Iraq war, I loathe their assault on civil liberties. No Government is perfect, but there are some far better than others.
 
Last edited:
Which is actually interesting and due to the dates of the poll sampling (before the Labour manifesto) it makes me wonder why.

The Labour party really have not done anything in the last few days to make themselves look better (manifesto aside they really hadn't done much of anything at all), Cameron has plugged on relentlessly.

At this point everyone with three braincells knows that their is nowt left in the kitty so the tories spending promises may not be as atractive as they first appeared. Alturnatively it could just be that the tactical anti tory vote is starting to kick in.

Which kind of makes me wonder if there a danger that the conservatives will start to look like a head with no body, it could be that by using their biggest (and only) asset (imo) so much, people will a) just become weary of seeing him,

Doubtful. Hardly the first party to focus almost entirely on their leader in their campanin.

b) the rolled up sleeve/sweatshirt/jogging/one of the "ordinary people honest!" tactic loses impact without contrast, c) might the continuing addition of names to the business "leaders" list be a step too far, not knowing when to stop and just bank the initial advantage?

Their's also the liability issue that at least one has changed their mind.

d) Conjure up reminders of Thatcher's less than consensual style?

Reminding people of Blair is more likely to be a problem.
 
What happened to the traditional pigs's bladder on a stick.


The infamous Krishnan Guru-Murthy interview was doing the rounds on the comedy programmes, and one announced this as K G-M interviewing a dishcloth.

It was pretty bad, I have to say. Devine didn't seem to have a coherent thought in his head - it was almost FOTMish the way he seemed to think that repeating pre-prepared mantras about what he thought the rules meant (for example that it wasn't fraud if he hadn't personally pocketed the money) would satisfy the interviewers.

Krishnan, for his part, seemed a bit non-plussed. I don't think he really knew how to cope with such a stupid interviewee. It was embarrassing all round, particularly that this guy had actually managed to get elected to parliament.

Rolfe.
 
Krishnan, for his part, seemed a bit non-plussed. I don't think he really knew how to cope with such a stupid interviewee. It was embarrassing all round, particularly that this guy had actually managed to get elected to parliament.

From rumors I have heard, it could be worse. You could be in Italy

Or from recent news, Poland.

ETA: not that we Americans have much right to gloat. Ever since one of our congress critters questioned a general testifying before them about concerns about too many troops on Guam causing it to tip over.
 
Last edited:
I was hoping I'd be out of the UK for the election. It seems not.
I confess to amazement that anyone actually reads party manifestos- this is the first time in my life I have known anyone even mention the idea- but I suppose if trashy, incredible fiction is your thing, why not?
I am by no means sure I will bother to vote. (Pause to allow screams of protest to die down).
I simply no longer have any belief that anyone standing for parliament is anything other than a self-serving crook of the lowest moral standing.
I'm not sure how many other UK citizens share this jaundiced view of their leaders, but I suspect quite a few.
We don't need a new government. We need a new electoral system; one that , for a start , sets a minimum qualification for the position of MP; a competitive examination, a reasonable standard of IQ, a complete tax and police record check, full and ongoing publication of any and all sources of income , business connections and property ownership - and one which mandates an immediate loss of all pension rights and a mandatory jail sentence for unreasonable betrayal of trust of the electorate; the latter to include demonstrable failure to try to achieve campaign promises.

Call me cynical, but does anyone honestly think it makes the slightest difference which bunch of jackasses we vote in? Because I don't.
 
I simply no longer have any belief that anyone standing for parliament is anything other than a self-serving crook of the lowest moral standing.

You'd be wrong.

Call me cynical, but does anyone honestly think it makes the slightest difference which bunch of jackasses we vote in? Because I don't.

Yes.
 
We need a new electoral system; one that , for a start , sets a minimum qualification for the position of MP; a competitive examination, a reasonable standard of IQ, a complete tax and police record check, full and ongoing publication of any and all sources of income , business connections and property ownership - and one which mandates an immediate loss of all pension rights and a mandatory jail sentence for unreasonable betrayal of trust of the electorate; the latter to include demonstrable failure to try to achieve campaign promises.


UW has dealt with part of that post, but I have to say this part has some good ideas in it. The trouble is, how do you enact that into law when the people doing the enacting are the present, unreconstructed bunch?

Rolfe.
 
I was hoping I'd be out of the UK for the election. It seems not.
I confess to amazement that anyone actually reads party manifestos- this is the first time in my life I have known anyone even mention the idea- but I suppose if trashy, incredible fiction is your thing, why not?

...snip...

I've read them every single time, I am always astonished that people don't read them. Sadly what I've seen time after time is that people will form their opinions on what is being offered based on a few sound bites and how the media decides to spin stuff.

...snip...
I simply no longer have any belief that anyone standing for parliament is anything other than a self-serving crook of the lowest moral standing.
I'm not sure how many other UK citizens share this jaundiced view of their leaders, but I suspect quite a few.

...snip...

Of course I am sure that many are as you describe but many aren't - but that is true of any group of people so I think expecting that politicians as a whole will somehow not be like us as a whole is just setting yourself up for a huge disappointment.

My personal experience of knowing a lot of politicians over the decades and lot of politically active people is that on the whole they do want to change things for what they consider the better.

...snip...

Call me cynical, but does anyone honestly think it makes the slightest difference which bunch of jackasses we vote in? Because I don't.

I do. Because of congenital health problems I have had first hand experience of the NHS since I became a teenager and the difference today in the NHS compared to ten years ago is nothing short of miraculous. That is just one example that I personally know about. I also remember the schools of my primary and junior school years, with the buildings failing down about our ears (quite literally - lumps of paint and plaster falling from the ceilings was a regular occurrence) in my secondary years I was lucky to go to an almost brand new school (open the year before I went there) - that school remained a construction site for over 8 years because there was not the funding to complete the building. Plus I remember notes being sent home to the parents asking if at all possible could they buy the text books we had to share, often one between 3 of us and we were encouraged to ask our parents to photocopy the content of books! All because the school just could not afford to buy text books. And in science classes there was only enough equipment (in these brand new purpose built science classrooms) for about half of us to do any given experiment. Over the last ten years I have seen my niece's junior school replaced with a brand new school and a refurbishment of my nephews' secondary school, and neither school has ever had a shortage of the basic equipment or textbooks that they need.

Now those are just two areas, there have of course been many things that the last few governments have totally screwed up, made mistakes and so on the above was not about praising the government rather just making the point that yes it can make a huge difference to the country as to which party gets in.

(Oh and of course being able to enter into a civil partnership and it no longer being legal to be sacked for being homosexual - they are two huge differences for many of us in this country.)
 
UW has dealt with part of that post, but I have to say this part has some good ideas in it. The trouble is, how do you enact that into law when the people doing the enacting are the present, unreconstructed bunch?

Rolfe.

A minimum standard of IQ would be a terrible thing, implementing some kind of meritocracy. IQ can't measure wisdom.

If you want the politicians to be less aloof and disconnected from the population, don't implement IQ tests on prospective MP's.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom