The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

Now if you want to argue that we can reach and maintain the "service levels" of countries such as Germany and France in regards to health and education without having to have a similar tax burden as those countries I'd like to hear how you propose we do that.

Just ask US conservatives. According to them we have the best health care system in the world and the best education system in the world (far surpising any EU country) and we have a much lower tax burden than even the UK.
 
Since ;) the governments since 1997 have all been elected on a promise to raise the standards of services such as the NHS and education, indeed in regards to the NHS a big talking part has been to get our NHS spending up to a so-called "EU average", and the electioneering message for this election is that Labour & Tory will both "ring fence" NHS and education spending I'm pretty confident that the major parties believe that the public does want that level of service.
Which of course does not mean the public wants to pay for it. After all, governments since 1997 were all elected on a promise not to raise the basic or upper rate of income tax as well.

Now it may be they are wrong as to what the public wants but my own anecdotal evidence is that they aren't. So that establishes the first part of my argument.
If the public wants something that is internally inconsistent, the resolution is to change X or Y or a bit of both. In my view it is highly unlikely that the only thing that will change is Y (the tax take). And this is consistent with the budget plans of all three parties.

Now if you want to argue that we can reach and maintain the "service levels" of countries such as Germany and France in regards to health and education without having to have a similar tax burden as those countries I'd like to hear how you propose we do that.
I have argued no such thing, therefore you won't be hearing about it.
 
Last edited:
Which of course does not mean the public wants to pay for it. ...snip...

I have argued no such thing, therefore you won't be hearing about it.

Well as someone else said recently - "I have argued no such thing...", my argument was about the costs involved in wanting X.
 
Last edited:
You have been able to do so in the past - I don't know if they will bother with that route this time, I think I once bought one of the parties manifesto at a book-chain like Waterstones.
 
ETA: Bloody hell just looked at the website - ugly or what!

Perhaps after the election Labour will come to their senses and drop that hideous font they've been using for a good decade now. What's it called?

I'd choose good, reliable Bell MT.
 
You've done your bit for your community, and I'm sure it will be appreciated, after all people need some paper to help start their BBQs.... :duck:

Actually, those can be quite useful, but not often in the way intended by the distributors.

Several years ago, while living in NV, I received a piece of political literature regarding two propositions on the ballot. One was in support of an anti-gay marriage law, and the other was opposed to an initiative to decriminalize marijuana. The literature included signautures from several office seekers for various offices on the same ballot.

I went through my preview ballot and marked support for the major opposition of every candidate that signed the literature I received.
 
According to the IFS's Gemma Tetlow (whom I've met), using HMT forecasts, £67 billion (see page 26 and 27, I linked this above).

According to private sector it varies, but is generally higher than that.

Not the easiest site to understand. In fact I cant make head nor tail of it. What do you think we need. When do you think we need it. And what public spending do you think should be cut to to get it. Which departments: which costs: and what will the effects be on people?
 
?? I am not taking a position on that, beyond my view that taxation will not and can not feasibly rise enough to finance the rate of public spending in the UK (this being public spending which is adjusted for cyclically-induced (recession) spending).
 
Ok. :) We will just leave it at that. We might as well. All the major parties are refusing to address this as well and the upshot is there will be no choice. The discussion is pointless
 
When's BBQ season in Scotland? From memory it is during the second week of Wimbledon when the all rain in the UK invariably descends on the south.


Could easily have had a barbecue yesterday. Lots of people were sitting in their gardens sunning themselves. Hardly seems like 10 days ago I was digging my car out of 16 inches of snow!

Rolfe.
 
Similar here. People rushed outside to have picnics with all the frenzied fervour of traffic wardens unleashed at the starting time of controlled parking.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom