The Official UK Election Thread! 6th May it is!

According to the information I found and linked above, there has been a "structural deficit" consistently since at least 1979. It has varied in amount but it seems to be nearly always there. It is argued here that we need to eliminate structural deficit one way or another: at least that is what I take from Francesca's post where she says
I never said that the budget had to balance. If the government borrows at about the same rate as the economy grows, then the public debt ratio is stable. I thought you raised the idea that current spending could, and should be paid for entirely out of revenue. It couldn't. And no credible analysis I have seen thinks it can be sustained with borrowing either, nor a combination of borrowing and tax. Ergo--spending cuts.
 
Last edited:
I think there is a strong argument that since the public wants services at least at the level of countries like France and Germany than we have to increase taxation.
Sounds like a very weak argument to me. A strong one would be "if the public wants services at the level of countries like France and Germany and is willing to pay the tax necessary, then we should increase taxation".

I would like to hear a justification of why you think that an answer to the question "Do you want the service" automatically implies willingness to pay.
 
I said: There is no way on god's green earth that you can raise the tax take by 2% of GDP just by soaking the rich, never mind the more like 5% additional burden that the UK would need in order to continue with present spending (post recession). in post 167, using the degree of tightening that is in the budget numbers. All political parties are proposing that, over 5 years. All of them expect the bulk to come from public spending cuts.

Since nobody mentioned "soaking the rich", perhaps it is you who is reading things which have not been said?

2% of GDP is 28 billion. Income tax produced 157 billion last year. My arithmetic is not good but it seems to me that if we raise it to 25% we achieve the same result in 5 years as we do by cutting public spending, if what you say is correct. As to continuing the same level of spending in a recession: we increase debt to do that; at least we have done so for a very long time. That brings us back to the level of debt which is sustainable, does it not?

And of course none of the big political parties is offering that as an alternative: that is what this conversation is about. It has not been established that this is not an alternative: yet that is what we are asked to believe. I don't.

Then there was some discussion about keeping all spending unchanged and some implicit suggestions from yourself and Darat that this could all be financed by tax increases,

It is not implicit. I am asking for a good reason why it is not an alternative. And I am not following your argument which purports to show that.


and I have pointed out the extra revenue that would be required to do this with no borrowing at all. (It is one of Gordon Brown's fiscal rules that borrowing to finance public investment is OK by the way, which is why the Treasury considers the structural deficit to be "only" -5%, that is really the "sustainable" deficit according to those fiscal rules.)

You have chosen a set of figures which support your argument: you have not shown why those are to be preferred. You have said that we need 137 billion. So let us go with that. How do you propose to cut 22% from public spending. What programmes will you cut and what financial burden will those cuts place on the people of the country? More or less than the increase in tax which you see as impossible? How much more or less?
 
Sounds like a very weak argument to me. A strong one would be "if the public wants services at the level of countries like France and Germany and is willing to pay the tax necessary, then we should increase taxation".

I would like to hear a justification of why you think that an answer to the question "Do you want the service" automatically implies willingness to pay.

My argument was of the form "If we want X we have to pay Y", how isn't that clear?
 
I never said that the budget had to balance.

Then I have misunderstood your post. If government income equal to government outlay does not come to a balanced budget on the current account what does it mean?

If the government borrows at about the same rate as the economy grows, then the public debt ratio is stable. I thought you raised the idea that current spending could, and should be paid for entirely out of revenue.

Don't see how you could have got that out of what I said. We are not communicating well it seems. I have pointed out twice that the ratio of public debt fluctuates a lot and has done since 1979. What I am asking is why is this a problem now, since it seems that public debt is either within the range of fluctuation or slightly above it: not enough above it to show that debt will rise to the 12% which is conventionally judged to cause a debt crisis

It couldn't. And no credible analysis I have seen thinks it can be sustained with borrowing either, nor a combination of borrowing and tax. Ergo--spending cuts.

I know that is what you think: but you have not shown why you think it. All you have said is that the people will not stand for the tax increase which will be required. That has nothing to do with "credible analysis", or at least not on what you have told us so far.
 
Sounds like a very weak argument to me. A strong one would be "if the public wants services at the level of countries like France and Germany and is willing to pay the tax necessary, then we should increase taxation".

I would like to hear a justification of why you think that an answer to the question "Do you want the service" automatically implies willingness to pay.

I can't speak for Darat: I never said it automatically means a willingness to pay. I said the alternatives should be put before the electorate honestly and they should vote on that if they think it is the most important thing.

It is you who is assuming that it is not an option because they are automatically unwilling to pay
 
My argument was of the form "If we want X we have to pay Y", how isn't that clear?
You said "Since [we want X . . . ]" which implies that we do. We might in the sense of wanting our cake and eating it too, but we might not, knowing it will cost Y.
 
Dangerous precedent, asking the populace what they are willing to pay for.
They might decide not to pay for nuclear submarines. Or politicians.
Then where would we be?
 
2% of GDP is 28 billion. Income tax produced 157 billion last year. My arithmetic is not good but it seems to me that if we raise it to 25% we achieve the same result in 5 years as we do by cutting public spending, if what you say is correct.
The IFS "Green Budget" published in February has a list of possible tax increases and estimates of their revenue yielded in table 7.2 page 162. That has raising it to 24% raising £16bn. So maybe it needs to go to at least 27% to get £28bn. It has been at that rate before.

That's for a 2% tightening which is not enough to remove HMT's cyclically adjusted deficit excluding investment, which needs 5%. In other words, if the only tax hike was +7% on the basic rate, there would still have to be spending cuts to get the other 3% of GDP covered, and that assumes that borrowing to finance investment continues, and that the aggressive looking growth assumptions are fine.

It has not been established that this is not an alternative: yet that is what we are asked to believe. I don't.
It hasn't been established that it is an alternative. As you say, no party is running for election with such an alternative. My default assumption is that it is not at all viable, and that the MRLP would poll higher.
 
Last edited:
Wow, you live in L.Square?

Actually, I have just moved from Leicester Square to Islington
Leicester square is only about 2km from me, but Holborn & St Pancras is in between the constituencies, where Frank Dobson has been Labour member for decades (He was Labour candidate for Mayor of London in 2000 but was obliterated in the Ken Livingstone snafu*)

So far I am seeing about 4x as many Labour signs on people's railings than flourescent orange LibDem diamonds. I wonder if opinion has swung back to Labour. I don't think anyone would dare show a Tory sign.

*snafu in that Livingstone was willing to run for Labour but they didn't select him so he ran independently and won by a mile. He won again, but back with Labour, in 2004.
 
Last edited:
29 billion from a 3 p increase in tax on basic and higher rate, it looks like. In one year.

What are the costs to the population of a cut of 22% in public spending?
 
In one year means in one year. You said the public spending cuts would be spread over 5 years, I think. And what you say we need is 137 billion. 27 billion each year. So if you are correct and those are two estimates then we achieve the same effect by in increase to 25% as we do by the public spending cuts. Or so it seems to me.

What we need is a comparison of what that costs for the people: we cannot do that unless you can say how much it will cost them for the public spending option. That seems to be wholly missing from this debate. Curious.
 
I didn't say "we need £137 billion" either. That number is the total cyclically-adjusted UK deficit according to the OECD. So if real spending stays steady and there is no borrowing (or privatisations) then it would need to be raised in tax. In real life, spending will fall, borrowing will continue, and tax will raise a lot less than that.

I still don't know what you mean with the rest of the post, sorry.
 
According to the IFS's Gemma Tetlow (whom I've met), using HMT forecasts, £67 billion (see page 26 and 27, I linked this above).

According to private sector it varies, but is generally higher than that.
 
You said "Since [we want X . . . ]" which implies that we do. We might in the sense of wanting our cake and eating it too, but we might not, knowing it will cost Y.

First part of my statement:....since the public wants services at least at the level of countries like France and Germany....

Since ;) the governments since 1997 have all been elected on a promise to raise the standards of services such as the NHS and education, indeed in regards to the NHS a big talking part has been to get our NHS spending up to a so-called "EU average", and the electioneering message for this election is that Labour & Tory will both "ring fence" NHS and education spending I'm pretty confident that the major parties believe that the public does want that level of service. Now it may be they are wrong as to what the public wants but my own anecdotal evidence is that they aren't. So that establishes the first part of my argument.

My second part was ".... we have to increase taxation."

I stated what I thought we wanted and then how we had to pay for it. So that is, as I said, an argument of the form of "If we want X we have to pay Y".


Now if you want to argue that we can reach and maintain the "service levels" of countries such as Germany and France in regards to health and education without having to have a similar tax burden as those countries I'd like to hear how you propose we do that.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom