I said: There is no way on god's green earth that you can raise the tax take by 2% of GDP just by soaking the rich, never mind the more like 5% additional burden that the UK would need in order to continue with present spending (post recession). in post 167, using the degree of tightening that is in the budget numbers. All political parties are proposing that, over 5 years. All of them expect the bulk to come from public spending cuts.
Since nobody mentioned "soaking the rich", perhaps it is you who is reading things which have not been said?
2% of GDP is 28 billion. Income tax produced 157 billion last year. My arithmetic is not good but it seems to me that if we raise it to 25% we achieve the same result in 5 years as we do by cutting public spending, if what you say is correct. As to continuing the same level of spending in a recession: we increase debt to do that; at least we have done so for a very long time. That brings us back to the level of debt which is sustainable, does it not?
And of course none of the big political parties is offering that as an alternative: that is what this conversation is about. It has not been established that this is not an alternative: yet that is what we are asked to believe. I don't.
Then there was some discussion about keeping all spending unchanged and some implicit suggestions from yourself and Darat that this could all be financed by tax increases,
It is not implicit. I am asking for a good reason why it is not an alternative. And I am not following your argument which purports to show that.
and I have pointed out the extra revenue that would be required to do this with no borrowing at all. (It is one of Gordon Brown's fiscal rules that borrowing to finance public investment is OK by the way, which is why the Treasury considers the structural deficit to be "only" -5%, that is really the "sustainable" deficit according to those fiscal rules.)
You have chosen a set of figures which support your argument: you have not shown why those are to be preferred. You have said that we need 137 billion. So let us go with that. How do you propose to cut 22% from public spending. What programmes will you cut and what financial burden will those cuts place on the people of the country? More or less than the increase in tax which you see as impossible? How much more or less?