"The Invention of the Jewish People"

Hmmm.....

ethnicity [(eth-[SIZE=+0]nis[/SIZE]-uh-tee)]

Identity with or membership in a particular racial, national, or cultural group and observance of that group's customs, beliefs, and language.

Oh what the heck, I have a couple more minutes. There are actually several definitions for ethnicity. There is an active dispute over the definition also, over at wikipedia (not surprising, I guess). The definition I'm using concerns genetics and means "people who are believed to belong to the same genetic stock" (ethnic group). Perhaps I assumed too quickly that it was the definition others were using. My bad.

And I point to this definition because some people on JREF threads seem to treat the idea of an "ethnic Jew" as a genetic assignment, as in: you are or aren't considered a Jew depending on your matrilineal or patrilineal heritage (genes). So to clarify, I think there is no such thing as a "genetic (ethnic) Jew", under that banner. It is a religion and culture (meaning: set of chosen behaviors), unlike things like eye color. And I will continue to use the word "ethnic" in the context of genetics as long as people continue the same meme about genetic Jews.
 
One more thing Probe, culture is not fixed. There is overlap and mixing of identies and customs. Take Italians for instance. Leaving aside the Americanized version the customs and cultural aspects are not monolithic throughout the nation (see What are the differences between North and South Italy). So, what is ethnic Italian? Does such a designation exist at all?

See above post about genetics. I'm not arguing culture. You are correct that culture is not fixed. And it's easier to answer the question of "what is an ethnic Italian" when you examine the person's DNA, using the definition of ethnicity that means genetic.

On more thing more: What the hell do you think ethnic food is exactly?
Oh this has always been a pet peeve with me, since I use the definition of "ethnic" that deals with genetics. As far as I'm concerned Rand, "ethnic food" is everything under the sun, since we all have a genetic makeup. But if you ask the average person on the street what they think "ethnic food" is (and I quote ... ), I've often heard it is "Anything that doesn't come from White folks" ;)
 
Last edited:
Oh what the heck, I have a couple more minutes. There are actually several definitions for ethnicity. There is an active dispute over the definition also, over at wikipedia (not surprising, I guess). The definition I'm using concerns genetics and means "people who are believed to belong to the same genetic stock" (ethnic group). Perhaps I assumed too quickly that it was the definition others were using. My bad.

And I point to this definition because some people on JREF threads seem to treat the idea of an "ethnic Jew" as a genetic assignment, as in: you are or aren't considered a Jew depending on your matrilineal or patrilineal heritage (genes). So to clarify, I think there is no such thing as a "genetic (ethnic) Jew", under that banner. It is a religion and culture (meaning: set of chosen behaviors), unlike things like eye color. And I will continue to use the word "ethnic" in the context of genetics as long as people continue the same meme about genetic Jews.
That's cool.
 
Aren't ancient Israeli and Muslim "Palestinians" Canaanites altogether - and thus the only difference between those early Jews and Muslims is their effing stupid religion? :confused:

[That's what they claimed in a documentary about antisemitism I watched a short while ago]

Also concerning Parky's explanation about Ashkenazi Jews:

Ashkenazi Jews, also known as Ashkenazic Jews or Ashkenazim (Hebrew: אַשְׁכֲּנָזִים‎, pronounced [ˌaʃkəˈnazim], singular: [ˌaʃkəˈnazi]; also יְהוּדֵי אַשְׁכֲּנָז, Yehudei Ashkenaz, "the Jews of Ashkenaz"), are the Jews descended from the medieval Jewish communities of the Rhineland valley (in the west of Germany) and northern France. Ashkenaz is the medieval Hebrew name for the region which in modern times encompasses the country of Germany and German-speaking borderland areas. Ashkenaz is also a Japhetic patriarch in the Table of Nations (Genesis 10). Thus, Ashkenazim or Ashkenazi Jews are literally "German Jews."
 
Last edited:
Well, one can go "heads I win, tails it doesn't matter" to define a look for any nation. Because it seems to me like "jewish look" is exactly like that. A small subset of jewish people actually look like that, and let's pretend that the overwhelming majority of exceptions don't matter.

There actually really is a distinction that is deserving of attention. The fact that some people from Eastern Europe worship as Jews doesn't justify treating the religious practice called Judaism as a genetic group, any more than someone would say that there's a "Muslim" look, because many people who happen to worship Islam happen to be Arab, or a "Mormon" look because many happen to be British (Utah). That's just silly.

Hitler's Germany - the "leadership" - found out first-hand how futile it was/is to try and weed out a so-called "genetic" Jew from a German. It was a situation where you often had Germans trying to kill other Germans because they worshipped as Jews. The paranoia that resulted was pervasive because there was simply no objective way to locate a "racial Jew", since Judaism is nothing but a set of behavioral practices and beliefs. Judaism is behavioral, not genetic.
 
Last edited:
Being Celtic is not genetic. And yet, they are still a diverse but recognized ethnicity.
 
It only means that the likelihood is relatively high that people with Eastern European features will practice Judaism (It's simply a correlation). And since many of us aren't Jews, people with Eastern European features cannot be viewed as being genetically (ethnically) assigned as Jews in the context you mention. That's especially the case because cultural practices and beliefs (like those of Muslims or Mormons or Jews) aren't things you inherit, like eye color.

That is good to know, thanks for that. I hope I made it clear in my post that I wasn't suggesting all Jews look alike, only that a "stereotypical Jewish look" does exist culturally, and that often one meets a Jewish person who "looks Jewish." Many Jewish comedians reference their own "Jewishness" when talking about their appearance, (John Stewart, Woody Allen, etc.) I was just attempting to define the stereotype (and its origins in real people), not define reality, in answering your question "How does one look Jewish?"

Though I agree with you that culture and beliefs are not inherited, many would disagree with us in certain cases, for example, a close friend of mine describes himself as an "Atheist Jew." Since he doesn't believe in god, but is still "Jewish" by "blood." And, of course, there's the whole "Jewish status passes through the mother" orthodox position.
 
That is good to know, thanks for that. I hope I made it clear in my post that I wasn't suggesting all Jews look alike, only that a "stereotypical Jewish look" does exist culturally, and that often one meets a Jewish person who "looks Jewish." Many Jewish comedians reference their own "Jewishness" when talking about their appearance, (John Stewart, Woody Allen, etc.) I was just attempting to define the stereotype (and its origins in real people), not define reality, in answering your question "How does one look Jewish?"

Though I agree with you that culture and beliefs are not inherited, many would disagree with us in certain cases, for example, a close friend of mine describes himself as an "Atheist Jew." Since he doesn't believe in god, but is still "Jewish" by "blood." And, of course, there's the whole "Jewish status passes through the mother" orthodox position.

I see what you mean about people like John Steward calling joking about the "Jewish look" thing. I used to think I "looked Jewish". But we've all just suffered from a basic logical fallacy (aforementioned), even created jokes based on it ;)
 
there are a few facial characteristics that are associated with Ashkenazi Jews. just like there are facial characteristics associated with East Africans.

but for every Jew who looks "Jewish", there are a million more who don't.

take a look at all the current Jewish actors today, and ask yourself how many of them actually look "Jewish".

I mean, honestly, do James Franco and Jennifer Connely actually look Jewish? I don't think so.

How about Robert DeNiro?
 
Being Celtic is not genetic. And yet, they are still a diverse but recognized ethnicity.

It's an ad populum fallacy if the definition of "ethnicity" that means "genetic" is actually being applied erroneously.
 
there are a few facial characteristics that are associated with Ashkenazi Jews. just like there are facial characteristics associated with East Africans.

No. What people call an 'Ashkenazi' Jew, is nothing more than a genetically German, Russian or Polish person who happens to have chosen Judaism as a form of worship. Not all Eastern Europeans have chosen Judaism. Please look up the word "correlation" to help you overcome your misunderstanding about what is falsely getting claimed here as "genetic" (a fabled "Jewish look").

take a look at all the current Jewish actors today, and ask yourself how many of them actually look "Jewish".

I mean, honestly, do James Franco and Jennifer Connely actually look Jewish? I don't think so.

How about Robert DeNiro?
Just like it's more likely (high correlation) that Eastern Europeans (people with their features) will worship as Jews, it's more likely that someone who looks like Robert Deniro (Italian) or Jennifer Connely (Irish) is also more likely to worship as a Catholic.

But those Italian and Irish people don't have a "Catholic look" any more than an Eastern European has a "Jewish look". And people from India don't have a "Muslim look" just because there happen to be many genetically East Indian people who choose to worship Islam. Come on now.
 
No. What people call an 'Ashkenazi' Jew, is nothing more than a genetically German, Russian or Polish person who happens to have chosen Judaism as a form of worship. .

wrong....wrong...very very wrong.

most Ashkenazi Jews are descended from Jews who moved east from Germany during the Crusades, and spread out across the Roman Empire since before the time of Christ.

the same goes for Sephardic Jews.

read:

http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1202742130771&pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull
 
Last edited:
It's an ad populum fallacy if the definition of "ethnicity" that means "genetic" is actually being applied erroneously.
FWIW: I think you are pushing the "ethnicity" that means "genetic" a bit too far. While ethnicity can mean genetic I don't think there is any bright and shiny line for it's use.

If you are saying that it is your use of the word then fine. It's not my use of the word and I don't think it is the use of most people.

You are engaging in semantics to make a point that I don't think you can fairly make.
 
Well we are humans. The only difference between any group of individuals is genetic drift and culture (including religion, art, food, traditions etc.).

The genetic stuff I find silly and beside the point. There is as much genetic variation between any two individuals as there is between any two people of different ethnic or racial background. The only difference genetically is in some markers for some traits like skin color and height.
 
Last edited:
FWIW: I think you are pushing the "ethnicity" that means "genetic" a bit too far. While ethnicity can mean genetic I don't think there is any bright and shiny line for it's use.

If you are saying that it is your use of the word then fine. It's not my use of the word and I don't think it is the use of most people.

You are engaging in semantics to make a point that I don't think you can fairly make.

There are a lot of people - Jews and non-Jews - who buy into the whole 'Matralinial/Patralinial' woo. This type of logically and factually unsupported exclusionary practice is deserving of scrutiny.

It is plain that the above instance is a case of someone using the word "ethnic" to confirm an unfounded "genetically-based" claim. If you can't see that I'm not sure what to say. You say the way I'm referring to all this ("semantics") is unfair. But what I think is unfair, is that some are attempting to dismiss said faulty claims (on a skeptics' site), by attacking the words being accurately used to describe that faulty, unfounded claims.

Some people in these threads (like Parky) have attempted to defend the woo above (and the fabled "Jewish look", that is also is a genetically-based claim based on fairy-tale genetics), by stating that there is such a thing as a genetically-based Jew. Then, nothing but crickets are heard when I ask for that person to please present the evidence. I've asked this several times and people ignore their responsibility to back their claims ... But what was I thinking, it's just an issue of me and my semantics :rolleyes:
 
The genetic stuff I find silly and beside the point.

Well it would be merely silly, except that some religious people conflate religion and alleged genetic ties in order to try and pronounce who can or can't be a part of their religion (for exclusionary purposes, based on falsehoods). That's not just silly, it's demoralizing and scientifically erroneous.

And the "genetic stuff" is medically helpful when it comes to tracking a propensity of certain groups to various diseases.
 
There are a lot of people - Jews and non-Jews - who buy into the whole 'Matralinial/Patralinial' woo. This type of logically and factually unsupported exclusionary practice is deserving of scrutiny.

It is plain that the above instance is a case of someone using the word "ethnic" to confirm an unfounded "genetically-based" claim. If you can't see that I'm not sure what to say. You say the way I'm referring to all this ("semantics") is unfair. But what I think is unfair, is that some are attempting to dismiss said faulty claims (on a skeptics' site), by attacking the words being accurately used to describe that faulty, unfounded claims.

Some people in these threads (like Parky) have attempted to defend the woo above (and the fabled "Jewish look", that is also is a genetically-based claim based on fairy-tale genetics), by stating that there is such a thing as a genetically-based Jew. Then, nothing but crickets are heard when I ask for that person to please present the evidence. I've asked this several times and people ignore their responsibility to back their claims ... But what was I thinking, it's just an issue of me and my semantics :rolleyes:
When you specifically respond to an issue I don't mind so much, though I don't think your case is as strong as you think it is. Jews have been a people for a long time and do tend to marry other Jews. All groups mix. Ethnic Italians are not likely as pure as some might think. I don't really accept the idea of genetically based groups however I think there is very likely a *standard deviation for a number of Jewish groups that is different from other groups. And keep in mind, Southern Italians are likely to have a standard deviation that is different from Northern Italians. Jews have sub groups as do most ethnic groups. It's of no real consequence.

*I don't vouch for the veracity of everything on that site.
 
Last edited:
Well it would be merely silly, except that some religious people conflate religion and alleged genetic ties in order to try and pronounce who can or can't be a part of their religion (for exclusionary purposes, based on falsehoods). That's not just silly, it's demoralizing and scientifically erroneous.

And the "genetic stuff" is medically helpful when it comes to tracking a propensity of certain groups to various diseases.
None of this obviates my point. We are people. Human beings. There is as likely to be as much genetic variation between two people of different ethnic backgrounds as there are between two people of the same ethnic background. There are families with unique genetic markers. That doesn't make them a separate ethnic group.

I stand by my point. The ethnic stuff as it is used in this discussion is silly and beside the point.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom