volatile
Scholar and a Gentleman
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2006
- Messages
- 6,729
There is no easy definition of what 'a people' means. It is rather an mixture of various criteria, which eventually boil down to the self identity of members of the group. The Jewish people have self identified as a group for more than two thousand years, and that is enough to make them a people.
And I certainly wouldn't dispute that. What is at question is the status of the origin of, and the veracity of, the particular group concept. Sand doesn't deny that Jews are a "people", simply that the reasons they use to define who is and who is not part of their group are, in the first instance, mythical and in the second, politically problematic.
The consensus on this thread seems to be that the first is true. The stories of exodus (with a small "e") are myths.
Now, the politics that follow from that truth are still up for debate. Fine. I can see the pros and cons either way. But to disregard Sands' work even where the evidence backs him up simply because its implications are politically contentious seems to be rather far from sceptical.
Yes, this is an ethnocentric type of law.
Yes, it is. I already said that. I think such laws are anachronistic, anti-democratic, anti-liberal, anti-modern and, ultimately irrational. But that's just me, and it's beside the point for this thread, really. To think that in the globalised 21st century we are still affording people preferential status based on where their distant ancestors happened to have lived (or are supposed to have lived, or are imagined or mythologised to have lived) is rather depressing, from a humanist perspective.
[/quote]It exist as a result of many centuries of Jewish persecution, which are still ongoing today. (You can look at the situation of the few remaining Jews in Yemen as an example.)
This law have the same rational behind it as affirmative action. It gives a preference to member of a group trying to correct past wrongs. In the case of Jews it is meant to give them a place to go to if they are discriminated against, which was more or less the case. There are only two large Jewish centers today, which have very little overlap with the demography of Jews in the 19 century. It is fair to say that most Jews had to leave their home during that period and more than half have used this law.
I understand all that. Of course, you're entirely correct. The treatment of Jews and their scapegoating over centuries is a permanent stain on humanity. Reading about the pogroms and walking around Prague, Vienna, Berlin sends shivers down the spine. I understand, appreciate, accept and acknowledge the historical conditions which necessitated the creation of the modern state of Israel. Please don't think I'm questioning Israel's right to exist or belittling the recent and historical plight of Jewish people, because I'm not. Let me make that very, very clear.
What I question, and it seems what Sands questions, is simply whether the continued delineation of Israel on ethno-cultural lines is the best policy for the 21st century, It seems to me that there are persuasive arguments that it is not, especially given the fact that the "ethno" part of the equation is based on some fallacious social constructions.
You may think that way, you may want it to be that way, but this does not make it right. The need to belong to a part of a group is part of human nature. This inevitably leads to a separation to groups based on cultural lines. They can be cultural, ethnic, religious but they will still be with us as long as human culture survive.
Well, that's a matter for another thread, really. It'd be an interesting discussion.
Except that Sand does not promote history, but rather a pseudo history which he created to promote a political viewpoint.
Which part of his history is incorrect? I may have missed it in the morass of this thread, but it seems that (what I had understood to be, from the brief interview I heard) Sand's principal point about the myth of a geographically-localised ethnicity is one which you all agree with.