"The Invention of the Jewish People"

There is no easy definition of what 'a people' means. It is rather an mixture of various criteria, which eventually boil down to the self identity of members of the group. The Jewish people have self identified as a group for more than two thousand years, and that is enough to make them a people.

And I certainly wouldn't dispute that. What is at question is the status of the origin of, and the veracity of, the particular group concept. Sand doesn't deny that Jews are a "people", simply that the reasons they use to define who is and who is not part of their group are, in the first instance, mythical and in the second, politically problematic.

The consensus on this thread seems to be that the first is true. The stories of exodus (with a small "e") are myths.

Now, the politics that follow from that truth are still up for debate. Fine. I can see the pros and cons either way. But to disregard Sands' work even where the evidence backs him up simply because its implications are politically contentious seems to be rather far from sceptical.

Yes, this is an ethnocentric type of law.

Yes, it is. I already said that. I think such laws are anachronistic, anti-democratic, anti-liberal, anti-modern and, ultimately irrational. But that's just me, and it's beside the point for this thread, really. To think that in the globalised 21st century we are still affording people preferential status based on where their distant ancestors happened to have lived (or are supposed to have lived, or are imagined or mythologised to have lived) is rather depressing, from a humanist perspective.


It exist as a result of many centuries of Jewish persecution, which are still ongoing today. (You can look at the situation of the few remaining Jews in Yemen as an example.)

This law have the same rational behind it as affirmative action. It gives a preference to member of a group trying to correct past wrongs. In the case of Jews it is meant to give them a place to go to if they are discriminated against, which was more or less the case. There are only two large Jewish centers today, which have very little overlap with the demography of Jews in the 19 century. It is fair to say that most Jews had to leave their home during that period and more than half have used this law.
[/quote]

I understand all that. Of course, you're entirely correct. The treatment of Jews and their scapegoating over centuries is a permanent stain on humanity. Reading about the pogroms and walking around Prague, Vienna, Berlin sends shivers down the spine. I understand, appreciate, accept and acknowledge the historical conditions which necessitated the creation of the modern state of Israel. Please don't think I'm questioning Israel's right to exist or belittling the recent and historical plight of Jewish people, because I'm not. Let me make that very, very clear.

What I question, and it seems what Sands questions, is simply whether the continued delineation of Israel on ethno-cultural lines is the best policy for the 21st century, It seems to me that there are persuasive arguments that it is not, especially given the fact that the "ethno" part of the equation is based on some fallacious social constructions.

You may think that way, you may want it to be that way, but this does not make it right. The need to belong to a part of a group is part of human nature. This inevitably leads to a separation to groups based on cultural lines. They can be cultural, ethnic, religious but they will still be with us as long as human culture survive.

Well, that's a matter for another thread, really. It'd be an interesting discussion.

Except that Sand does not promote history, but rather a pseudo history which he created to promote a political viewpoint.

Which part of his history is incorrect? I may have missed it in the morass of this thread, but it seems that (what I had understood to be, from the brief interview I heard) Sand's principal point about the myth of a geographically-localised ethnicity is one which you all agree with.
 
A strawman? Are you denying that Israel defines its national identity in broadly ethnic terms?

You can't have it both ways.

If by "ethnicity" you mean (roughly) "same skin color and language", then, no, Jews are not an ethnic group -- but by that definition, Israel does not define itself in broadly ethnic terms, because it considers Black Jews, Chinese Jews, European Jews, Yemenite Jews, etc. all equally as Jews.

If, however, by "ethnicity" you mean "same national group", or "same nationality", then yes, Jews are a nationality -- but a nationality that is not based on ethnicity or race but on common beliefs and history. But in this, it is not different than any other nation -- no different than the USA, for instance.

It is annoying in the extreme that no matter what the Jews would do, some people would condemn them.

If the Jews were all of one race, color, etc., some people here would be apoplectic about the racist and exclusive Jews who refuse to let people join their religion due to a disgusting feeling of exclusion and superiority. They are not a real nation, we would be told -- no other nation on earth is so exclusive! They are at most an extended closed family, or a cult, or something; certainly such a bunch of racists like that don't deserve their own nation.

Now that Jews are not all of one race, color, etc., some people here are claiming that this makes the Jews infeior: they are not a real nation, this rag-tag group of foreigners descendended from all kinds of bastard tribes from all over the earth; certainly they don't deserve their own country, not even being a nation. Yes, folks -- when it comes to the Jews, all of a sudden our paragons of multiculturalism and inclusiveness are acting like white-power folks: seeing the lack of racial homogenity within the Jewish nation as a sure sign of its bastard, inferior, status.
 
You can't have it both ways.

If by "ethnicity" you mean (roughly) "same skin color and language", then, no, Jews are not an ethnic group -- but by that definition, Israel does not define itself in broadly ethnic terms, because it considers Black Jews, Chinese Jews, European Jews, Yemenite Jews, etc. all equally as Jews.

If, however, by "ethnicity" you mean "same national group", or "same nationality", then yes, Jews are a nationality -- but a nationality that is not based on ethnicity or race but on common beliefs and history. But in this, it is not different than any other nation -- no different than the USA, for instance.

It is annoying in the extreme that no matter what the Jews would do, some people would condemn them.

If the Jews were all of one race, color, etc., some people here would be apoplectic about the racist and exclusive Jews who refuse to let people join their religion due to a disgusting feeling of exclusion and superiority. They are not a real nation, we would be told -- no other nation on earth is so exclusive! They are at most an extended closed family, or a cult, or something; certainly such a bunch of racists like that don't deserve their own nation.

Now that Jews are not all of one race, color, etc., some people here are claiming that this makes the Jews infeior: they are not a real nation, this rag-tag group of foreigners descendended from all kinds of bastard tribes from all over the earth; certainly they don't deserve their own country, not even being a nation. Yes, folks -- when it comes to the Jews, all of a sudden our paragons of multiculturalism and inclusiveness are acting like white-power folks: seeing the lack of racial homogenity within the Jewish nation as a sure sign of its bastard, inferior, status.

Errrm....

I kind of see your point, but you've missed or at least misunderstood my point.

I, for one, am not "condemning" anyone, let alone Jewish people. What I'm questioning (and what Sands is questioning) is why a modern-day democratic country should define itself ethnically or ethno-culturally.

Who's talking about "deserving" anything at all? That's to frame this discussion in a very odd way, isn't it?

In both of your two hypothetical and supposedly mutually exclusive anti-Israel rants, you're still talking about one particular class of people - defined along ethno-cultural lines - "deserving" or "not deserving" a nation. You're begging the question, in other words. The whole point is that when the debate is framed in terms of who "deserves" what, the debate is already off on the wrong foot.
 
Jews CANNOT be a race, for there are black/white/brown/Asian Jews.

Jews CANNOT be one ethnicity, for they live all over the world and speak many different languages and have different foods/customs going back 2,000 years.

Jews...can only be a religion. It is the ONE thing that truly unifies us.
 
Jews...can only be a religion. It is the ONE thing that truly unifies us.

So how do you feel about people who (self-)identify as Jewish but who neither practice nor believe in any of the tenets of the Jewish religion?
 
So how do you feel about people who (self-)identify as Jewish but who neither practice nor believe in any of the tenets of the Jewish religion?

oh, you mean folks like me?

:)

now, mind you, I said that Jews cannot be one ethnic group. however, I do believe that there are MANY Jewish ethnic groups. Such as Ashkenazi, Sephardic, Maghreb, the Mountain Jews, Indian Jews, Yemenite Jews, etc etc etc.

I personally feel that my ancestry is Ashkenazi Jewish. that is my ethnicity. not simply "Jewish", for the reasons I have said above.

now, what is my religion? according to the Orthodox I am a 100% Jew.

but as far as I am concerned, when you boil it down to practice and belief, Im really just an agnostic...who enjoys Passover Seders and Hannukah Menorahs.
 
oh, you mean folks like me?

Well, yes. That's why I asked the question! :D

now, mind you, I said that Jews cannot be one ethnic group. however, I do believe that there are MANY Jewish ethnic groups. Such as Ashkenazi, Sephardic, Maghreb, the Mountain Jews, Indian Jews, Yemenite Jews, etc etc etc.

I personally feel that my ancestry is Ashkenazi Jewish. that is my ethnicity. not simply "Jewish", for the reasons I have said above.

now, what is my religion? according to the Orthodox I am a 100% Jew.

but as far as I am concerned, when you boil it down to practice and belief, Im really just an agnostic...who enjoys Passover Seders and Hannukah Menorahs.
If you don't mind me asking, would you qualify for the "fast-tracking" to Israeli citizenship under the laws Doctor Evil quoted upthread?

It seems that if the answer is "yes", we're right back where we came in, aren't we?
 
Errrm....

I kind of see your point, but you've missed or at least misunderstood my point.

I, for one, am not "condemning" anyone, let alone Jewish people. What I'm questioning (and what Sands is questioning) is why a modern-day democratic country should define itself ethnically or ethno-culturally.

Who's talking about "deserving" anything at all? That's to frame this discussion in a very odd way, isn't it?

In both of your two hypothetical and supposedly mutually exclusive anti-Israel rants, you're still talking about one particular class of people - defined along ethno-cultural lines - "deserving" or "not deserving" a nation. You're begging the question, in other words. The whole point is that when the debate is framed in terms of who "deserves" what, the debate is already off on the wrong foot.

But the reason for the fast tracking isn't that the Jews want a "pure state", it's that it provides a way for any persecuted Jews anywhere in the world to have an escape route to somewhere that they can be safe from anti-semitic persecution.

Seems like it would be fair for the rest of the world to have to show that it has kicked it's historic anti-semitism before asking Israel to drop its policy of having fast track immigration for Jews.
 
But the reason for the fast tracking isn't that the Jews want a "pure state", it's that it provides a way for any persecuted Jews anywhere in the world to have an escape route to somewhere that they can be safe from anti-semitic persecution.

Interesting angle, and one I'd not considered. Four questions immediately come to mind, though:

1) is such an "escape route" still necessary in 2009 - in which countries are Jews still actively persecuted?

2) Aren't "escape routes" of this type adequately provided for in the UNHCR rules on asylum?

3) Even if they aren't, doesn't the case then become "Israel is a home for persecuted people" rather than simply "Israel is a home for Jews"

4) Where are the majority of new immigrants to Israel coming from? Is it from countries in which Jews are systematically persecuted and where no protection from persecution exists in their countries of origin? And how does this conception of the logic of the law account for Jewish emigres from, say, the USA?
 
Interesting angle, and one I'd not considered. Four questions immediately come to mind, though:

1) is such an "escape route" still necessary in 2009 - in which countries are Jews still actively persecuted?

2) Aren't "escape routes" of this type adequately provided for in the UNHCR rules on asylum?

3) Even if they aren't, doesn't the case then become "Israel is a home for persecuted people" rather than simply "Israel is a home for Jews"

4) Where are the majority of new immigrants to Israel coming from? Is it from countries in which Jews are systematically persecuted and where no protection from persecution exists in their countries of origin? And how does this conception of the logic of the law account for Jewish emigres from, say, the USA?


Well, I'd say:

1) No, not in 2009... but it is also possible that asking the question on a year by year basis may not really be a good way of looking at it, i.e. would many German Jews have seen a need for Israel in 1930? Probably not many. However, ask the same question 10 years later...

Viewed historically, there hasn't necessarily been much warning before large pogroms and the like. Perhaps some people feel more comfortable for having a guaranteed safe zone available for the long term.

2) Perhaps, perhaps not (the UN's record is hardly 100% on preventing ethnicly based genocide). I think a large motivator though is the feeling that Jews should no longer have to rely on the kindness of strangers (rather than, for example, finding themselves in the position of Jews fleeing Nazi Germany who were refused access to the countries they were attempting to flee to).

3) Israel is a safe haven from anti-semitism because it has a Jewish majority. If sufficient non-Jewish immigrants entered then it's Jewish population would lose that guaranteed freedom from persecution that comes from its majority status. (And while that may sound paranoid to you, heck maybe even to me, it might not to an Israeli who has lived through the Holocaust, 1948, 1967 and 1973). (I also don't deny that there obviously competing moral principles in play here)

4) Kind of irrelevant because, as per my answer to Q1, the "right of return" law is not necessarily there to deal with the specific situation in 2009.
 
I agree that most of the discussion is perhaps meant to a different thread. I am mostly interested in the historical aspect.

Which part of his history is incorrect? I may have missed it in the morass of this thread, but it seems that (what I had understood to be, from the brief interview I heard) Sand's principal point about the myth of a geographically-localised ethnicity is one which you all agree with.

This is best clarified by looking at what professional Historians specializing in Jewish history think on the level of scholarship in Sand's book. I have already linked to this piece, which I assume you did not read. (Otherwise the question would not have arisen.)

Sand's thesis suffers from many problems. For instance, he takes well known facts and present them as new. He also adds to that by falsely claiming that they are suppressed by other historians. He then proceeds to make conclusions which are not warranted.

All this is done to promote a theory that European Jews are not descendants of Jews who lived in the middle east 2000 years ago. A theory he constructs for political reasons. A theory which is furthermore easily falsified by genetic research, as well as by the majority of historical evidence available. (To clarify, the genetic evidence is that European Jews are closely related to other Jews, as well as to Palestinians and Kurds. Not that they are still 'pure', or whatever that means. I am pointing that as this non point is raised constantly.)

I will use the commentary of another Historian, Anita Shapira, to make those points. (Link to a PDF file.)
Another topic Sand likes to punch holes in is the myth of exile: the Jews (were there any or weren’t there any?) were not expelled from the land of Israel, not exiled from it; most of them remained there and in the end adopted Islam, and they were the forefathers of today’s Palestinians. On the other hand, the Jewish diaspora in the Second Temple period and later originated mainly with Jewish converts who had no ties to the land of Israel. This is the obverse of the conversion claim: not only were the Jews not forced out of the land of
Israel, not only were Jews in the diaspora unconnected to the land of Israel, not only do diaspora Jews not belong to the land of Israel, but those who do belong to the land of Israel are, rather, the Palestinians, the land’s inhabitants since antiquity. Again, he uses the words of Dinur and his colleagues, who questioned the concept of expulsion: they often stressed that a significant Jewish community had remained in the country until the seventh century, remnants of whom, according to current research, lingered on until the conquest by the crusaders of the eleventh century. The Zionist movement sought to show that Jews cleaved to the country; from its point of view, the question of expulsion was less important than showing that Jews had stayed in the land. Again, Sand erects a phantom – exile – and “proves” that it never happened, something historians do not deny. On the other hand, he ignores the fact that even if Jews were not exiled from their land, and many of them did scatter all over the Roman Empire of their own free will, the very loss of Jewish sovereignty in the land of Israel, the Romans’ change of its name to Palestine out of a desire to erase all trace of Jews from it, and the establishment of an idolatrous Roman
colony on the ruins of Jerusalem after the Bar-Kokhba Revolt was crushed, went down in Jewish collective memory as traumatic.

As to the question of exiles. Are we supposed to believe that the claim that Jews never made the exodus from Egypt is new, or revolutionary? This is the equivalent of claiming that the earth in not flat in a new book. It is embarrassing.

The same can be said as to the straw man that Sand creates with respect to the other exile, the Roman one. No one who is even remotely interested in Jewish history will claim that after the Bar-Kohba revolt there were no Jews left in current day Israel. The Jews of Judea were either killed, driven out, or sold to slavery, but Jews continue to live and flourish in the north.

In fact, the Mishna, the oldest part of the Talmud, was composed in that period, presumably by Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi. One version of the Talmud was composed in what is current day Israel. This is the wrongly named Jerusalem Talmud. (It was not written in Jerusalem, but in the north.) These are all elementary facts from Jewish history. What Sand is doing is creating a historical straw man, and then attacking it.

Sand's goal here is to claim that Romans did not drive a large number of Jews out of Palestine. This is supposed to lead us to conclude that there were no other reasons for Jews to scatter around, such as economic ones. This is of course wrong. Jews moved around for economic reasons in that and earlier periods. I would venture a guess and say that the large Jewish community in Alexandria was a result of economic immigration.

As for the question whether the Romans exiled Jews in numbers, there is a reason to believe they may have done so. Namely slavery. Roman society needed slaves, and many of them. The Romans did use war to take large numbers of slaves:
The sale of slaves was primarily done by wholesale dealers who followed the Roman armies. Slavers are recorded to have once come away with no less than 53,000 people, the entire population of a district Julius Caesar had captured in Gaul, which he sold on the spot.[5]
What about Jewish slaves? We know that quite a few were Taken by Pompey:
The last one was not only the largest catacomb, but also the oldest. It was probably used from the late first century BCE (until the fourth century CE) and its early date confirms the words of Philo that many Jews were settled in Rome after the war against Pompey in 63 BCE. The oldest inscriptions mention freed slaves, who must have been Pompey's prisoners of war.
And also after the destruction of the temple in 70AD:
during the four years of war, the Romans had taken 97,000 prisoners. Thousands of them were forced to become gladiators and were killed in the arena, fighting wild animals or fellow gladiators. Some, who were known as criminals, were burned alive. Others were employed at Seleucia, where they had to dig a tunnel. But most of these prisoners were brought to Rome, where they were forced to build the Forum of Peace (a park in the heart of Rome) and the Colosseum. The Menorah and the Table were exhibited in the temple of Peace.

The worst Roman-Jewish war was the Bar-Kohba rebellion. In that war the Romans adopted a scorched earth policy in Judea. Naturally, this was the war likely to have created the largest number of Jewish slaves, but it is also the least documented. The result is that nothing can be said for sure.

So, there was no big single exile, a fact which would be trivial to anyone with the smallest amount of historical knowledge. Hoewever, this does not mean that many Jews were not exiled by Romans over a long period of time. Roman needed slaves, and the Jewish Roman wars supplied some of them.

I will continue in the next post ...
 
Sand's goal here is to claim that Romans did not drive a large number of Jews out of Palestine.

historians believe that even before the Temple was destroyed, up to 1 million Jews lived outside of Judaea.


and genetic research proves that many Jews do in fact share a chromosomal link to the Middle East. Kurdistan, specifically, but still the Middle East.

and since the Hebrews most likely followed the part of the Fertile Crescent to get from Mesopotamia to Canaan, picking up a good deal of Kurdish genetics seems to make a great deal of sense.
 
So why does Sand claim that Jews were not exiled by Romans. What is his main point:
At the heart of Sand’s book we find the claim that the Jews of Eastern Europe, the “Yiddish people” by his definition, do not originate with the Jews who came from the Middle East via Ashkenaz to Poland, but with the Khazars, nomadic tribes that built an empire between the Black and the Caspian seas, converted to Judaism in the eighth century, and scattered to the four winds when their state was destroyed between the tenth and thirteenth centuries.


Sand promotes this claim for political reasons. Now, in my book, historical claims should be deemed true or false based on the evidence, not the other way round. This claim is baseless. Shapira provides some of the historical evidence:
There is no way of knowing. One of Sand’s main claims involves numbers: if not from the Khazars, then where did the millions of East European Jews come from? After all, in Germany’s Jewish quarters in the early Middle Ages there were only several thousand. The answer lies in the statistical data: during the census taken on the eve of Poland’s partition (1764), the kingdom of Poland and Lithuania had some 750,000 Jews. If one reckons a moderate average demographic growth of 1.6 per annum, then in 1660 Poland-Lithuania had 150,000 (by a different calculation, only 100,000). According to the calculations of historians such as Itzhak Schipper and Salo W. Baron, which are based on estimates of taxes paid by Polish Jews, in 1500 (about 400 years after the destruction of the Khazar kingdom), Poland had only 24,000 – 30,000 Jews. According to another historian (Bernard D. Weinryb), there were only 10,000.11 One way or another, these figures match both the migration rates of Jews from the west and the natural increase without having to resort to masses of Khazars to balance the account. The great demographic increase of Jews in Eastern Europe occurred in the nineteenth century, not before. This is not the place to explain the causes for its growth but it must be stated that it did not stem from unknown migrants.

The best historical evidence is that eastern European Jews migrated there from western Europe. There is essentially no evidence for migration of Khazars.

The historical evidence is fragmented. But these is another approach, based on comparing generic markers between population. There have been several studies along these lines:
A 1999 study by Hammer et al., published in the Proceedings of the United States National Academy of Sciences compared the Y chromosomes of Ashkenazi, Roman, North African, Kurdish, Near Eastern, Yemenite, and Ethiopian Jews with 16 non-Jewish groups from similar geographic locations. It found that "Despite their long-term residence in different countries and isolation from one another, most Jewish populations were not significantly different from one another at the genetic level... The results support the hypothesis that the paternal gene pools of Jewish communities from Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East descended from a common Middle Eastern ancestral population, and suggest that most Jewish communities have remained relatively isolated from neighboring non-Jewish communities during and after the Diaspora."[45] According to Nicholas Wade "The results accord with Jewish history and tradition and refute theories like those holding that Jewish communities consist mostly of converts from other faiths, or that they are descended from the Khazars, a medieval Turkish tribe that adopted Judaism."[46]
A 2001 study by Nebel et al. found Haplogroup R1a chromosomes (called Eu 19 in the paper), which are very frequent in Eastern European populations (54%-60%), at elevated frequency (12.7%) in Ashkenazi Jews. The authors hypothesized that these chromosomes could reflect low-level gene flow into Ashkenazi populations from surrounding Eastern European populations, or, alternatively, that both the Ashkenazi Jews in Haplogroup R1a, and to a greater extent all Eastern European populations in general, might have some partial Khazar ancestry.[47]
A 2003 study of the Y-chromosome by Behar et al. found that among Ashkenazi Levites, who comprise approximately 4% of Ashkenazi Jews, the prevalence of Haplogroup R1a1 was over 50%. This haplogroup is uncommon in other Jewish groups, but found in high frequencies in eastern European populations. They argued that "it is likely that the event leading to a high frequency of R1a1 NRYs within the Ashkenazi Levites involved very few, and possibly only one, founding father." They postulated that one likely source of the gene was a "a founder(s) of non-Jewish European ancestry, whose descendents were able to assume Levite status", and that an alternate "attractive source would be the Khazarian Kingdom, whose ruling class is thought to have converted to Judaism in the 8th or 9th century." The concluded that "[a]lthough neither the NRY haplogroup composition of the majority of Ashkenazi Jews nor the microsatellite haplotype composition of the R1a1 haplogroup within Ashkenazi Levites is consistent with a major Khazar or other European origin, as has been speculated by some authors (Baron 1957; Dunlop 1967; Ben-Sasson 1976; Keys 1999), one cannot rule out the important contribution of a single or a few founders among contemporary Ashkenazi Levites."[48]
A 2005 study by Nebel et al., based on Y chromosome polymorphic markers, showed that Ashkenazi Jews are more closely related to other Jewish and Middle Eastern groups than to their local neighbouring populations in Europe. However, 11.5% of male Ashkenazim were found to belong to Haplogroup R1a1 (R-M17), the dominant Y chromosome haplogroup in Eastern Europeans, suggesting possible gene flow between the two groups. The authors hypothesized that "R-M17 chromosomes in Ashkenazim may represent vestiges of the mysterious Khazars". They concluded "However, if the R-M17 chromosomes in Ashkenazi Jews do indeed represent the vestiges of the mysterious Khazars then, according to our data, this contribution was limited to either a single founder or a few closely related men, and does not exceed ~ 12% of the present-day Ashkenazim.[49]
There you have it, Sand's main point is wrong. It was shown to be wrong before he wrote his book.

I will let Ms. Shapira summarize:
The assertion that there is no Jewish people is shared by many groups: Jews who would like to appropriate a different national identity or challenge every national framework whatsoever; people looking for reasons of every sort and type to question the links between the different Jewish communities; those who object both to the bond between the Jewish people and the land of Israel and to that people’s right to a state of its own. To deny
the existence of the Jewish people sometimes stems from a search for universalism, sometimes from considerations of a rival nationalism, sometimes from mere hatred of Jews, and sometimes from intolerance of an entity that does not fit into the neat definitions of nation and religion. Sand would like to promote a new Israeli agenda, striving for harmony between Jews and Arabs, to be based on the remodeling of Jewish identity. However positive the goals he is targeting may be in their own right, there is something warped and objectionable in the assumption that for Jews to integrate into the Middle East,
they, and they alone of all the peoples in the region, must shed their national identity and historical memories and reconstruct themselves in a way that may (perhaps) find favor with Israeli-Palestinians. But reconciliation between peoples makes necessary a mutual recognition of truth, not an artificial analysis that presents a fabricated front, a quasi-mask that hides the real differences. What Sand is offering is this kind of artificial analysis.

There is much more that can be said from a political viewpoint, but I will refrain from doing so. My main interest is in the historical evidence, and I believe is should take priority over politics, not the other way around.
 
So how do you feel about people who (self-)identify as Jewish but who neither practice nor believe in any of the tenets of the Jewish religion?

Anyone at all can claim to be Jewish and perhaps that's the whole point: that it's not racially determined.

And anyone is also free to call him/herself a Communist, a Christian or anything else in the dictionary.

My sister - one of our parents is a self-identified Jew - goes to a a Baptist Church and worships under the banner of Christianity for three hours every Sunday with her kids. And when someone asks about her ethnicity, one of the items she lists is "Jewish". I find it thoroughly ridiculous. The idea of Judaism as an ethnic assignment is obvious woo.
 
Last edited:
. The idea of Judaism as an ethnic assignment is obvious woo.

2,000 years and we still can't figure this one out.

such is what happens when you are the last nationality left that has its own religion.
 
Was trying to figure out why people - including me - ever bought into the Judaism-as-an-ethnicity woo.

People who've chosen to practice Judaism have been heavily persecuted, as a group (obviously). Maybe they associate their justifiably defensive reactions with that of people who have been racially persecuted.

Claiming common racial lineage could serve a dual purpose: create a stronger sense of unity against the "dangerous others", and It create a deeper sense of unity, deeper than religious ties, because each sees others in the group as "common blood" (albeit erroneously).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom