ddt
Mafia Penguin
Not historians, but the destruction of the temple has gone down in popular discourse as the start of the Diaspora. Which is blatantly untrue.I suspect you are assuming here too much. I do not think that any Jewish historian would claim that the whole population was exiled. However, a fairly large number were taken as slaves, and send to Rome. (I seem to vaguely remember a book claim that the price of slaves dropped at the time. Can't remember the name.)
I certainly didn't want to claim that. In Jesus' times, there were big Jewish communities outside the Holy Land, e.g., in Babylon, in Alexandria and, IIRC, in Massilia (Marseille), and many had been there for centuries: that in Babylon dates back at least to the Babylonian captivity, and in Alexandria the Septuagint was compiled from the 3th Century BC on. There was already a big Diaspora before the Romans destroyed the Temple. Can you put a ballpark percentage on how many Jews lived outside the Holy Land at that time?There is plenty of evidence for Jewish communities around the Mediterranean in the 3rd and 4th centuries. The assumption that all remaining Jews were located in the Galilee is not true. (Not necessarily an assumption you make, but one needed for Sand's thesis.)
Moreover, Judaism has long been a proselytizing religion, until approx. the 10th Century AD - witness the Khazar mass conversion (*).
And depending on which of the many, many studies you cite, they leave more or less room for European, North African and Khazar admixture. I have a problem with the claim that the European Jews are solely descended from Judean ethnic Jews, given Judaism's proselytizing history. I equally have a problem with the claim that they'd be solely descended from converts and not from Judean ethnic Jews. According to wiki:Sand's thesis is not that current Palestinians are related to Israelites, but rather that current European Jews are not. That thesis is simply wrong. For instance, the same genetic tests you mention clearly show that European Jews are related to i) middle eastern Jews, ii) Palestinians, and iii) Kurds.
and from the genetic evidence I've seen thus far, this is clearly the wrong way round.Sand argues that most contemporary Jews do not originate from the ancient Land of Israel.
I'd be surprised though if Jews were fundamentally different than other people, which all are a motley of different ethnic origins. Take England for example: pre-Celtic inhabitants, Celtic invaders, Romans (from all over the Empire and beyond, including Sarmatia), Angles Saxons and Jutes, Danes and Norwegians, and Normans all left their marks. Which makes the science of DNA evidence quite hard. So forgive me if I'm skeptical of wide-ranging conclusions on the basis of DNA evidence, especially when I read of studies that only test one or two dozen people.
The general problem with all study of Jewish history - be it DNA studies or historical studies - is that its outcomes can and will be used to argue for or against the existence of Israel; and furthermore, that the scholar(s) doing the study has his/her own agenda or preconceptions in this which may bias the study. Sand clearly has an agenda in this, not so much against the existence of Israel but against Israel as a Jewish state.
(*) with "mass" I mean more than just the king and his next advisors, not necessarily that the whole people was converted.