"The Invention of the Jewish People"

I suspect you are assuming here too much. I do not think that any Jewish historian would claim that the whole population was exiled. However, a fairly large number were taken as slaves, and send to Rome. (I seem to vaguely remember a book claim that the price of slaves dropped at the time. Can't remember the name.)
Not historians, but the destruction of the temple has gone down in popular discourse as the start of the Diaspora. Which is blatantly untrue.

There is plenty of evidence for Jewish communities around the Mediterranean in the 3rd and 4th centuries. The assumption that all remaining Jews were located in the Galilee is not true. (Not necessarily an assumption you make, but one needed for Sand's thesis.)
I certainly didn't want to claim that. In Jesus' times, there were big Jewish communities outside the Holy Land, e.g., in Babylon, in Alexandria and, IIRC, in Massilia (Marseille), and many had been there for centuries: that in Babylon dates back at least to the Babylonian captivity, and in Alexandria the Septuagint was compiled from the 3th Century BC on. There was already a big Diaspora before the Romans destroyed the Temple. Can you put a ballpark percentage on how many Jews lived outside the Holy Land at that time?

Moreover, Judaism has long been a proselytizing religion, until approx. the 10th Century AD - witness the Khazar mass conversion (*).

Sand's thesis is not that current Palestinians are related to Israelites, but rather that current European Jews are not. That thesis is simply wrong. For instance, the same genetic tests you mention clearly show that European Jews are related to i) middle eastern Jews, ii) Palestinians, and iii) Kurds.
And depending on which of the many, many studies you cite, they leave more or less room for European, North African and Khazar admixture. I have a problem with the claim that the European Jews are solely descended from Judean ethnic Jews, given Judaism's proselytizing history. I equally have a problem with the claim that they'd be solely descended from converts and not from Judean ethnic Jews. According to wiki:
Sand argues that most contemporary Jews do not originate from the ancient Land of Israel.
and from the genetic evidence I've seen thus far, this is clearly the wrong way round.

I'd be surprised though if Jews were fundamentally different than other people, which all are a motley of different ethnic origins. Take England for example: pre-Celtic inhabitants, Celtic invaders, Romans (from all over the Empire and beyond, including Sarmatia), Angles Saxons and Jutes, Danes and Norwegians, and Normans all left their marks. Which makes the science of DNA evidence quite hard. So forgive me if I'm skeptical of wide-ranging conclusions on the basis of DNA evidence, especially when I read of studies that only test one or two dozen people.

The general problem with all study of Jewish history - be it DNA studies or historical studies - is that its outcomes can and will be used to argue for or against the existence of Israel; and furthermore, that the scholar(s) doing the study has his/her own agenda or preconceptions in this which may bias the study. Sand clearly has an agenda in this, not so much against the existence of Israel but against Israel as a Jewish state.

(*) with "mass" I mean more than just the king and his next advisors, not necessarily that the whole people was converted.
 
I'd be surprised though if Jews were fundamentally different than other people, which all are a motley of different ethnic origins.

And this seems to be Sand's bone of contention. The Jewish state is a racial state (he calls them a nation-race), and the national identity of Israel is predicated on this concept (and, apparently myth) of racial homogeneity. This seems problematic, doesn't it?

Nick Griffin says English people have lived in England since the last Ice Age. Absurd, and his political aims to base a state around this racial myth are terrifying and ludicrous. If Sand is correct, and racial Judaism is a recently constructed myth, don't the objections raised against the BNP's stupid claims start to look applicable to arguments which claim Israel as a nation principally for racial Jews? That seems to be the force of Sand's position, anyway.

Has anyone actually read the book?
 
And this seems to be Sand's bone of contention. The Jewish state is a racial state

No, it is more of an ethno-religious state, as Jews can be of any race..and are.

Just go to Israel and see the black, white, and brown Jews. Jewish is not and CANNOT be a race.

Jews are one race..huh?

13946_1190411574476_1653977305_471097_3833999_n.jpg


13946_1190413174516_1653977305_471099_1397670_n.jpg


13946_1190415334570_1653977305_471100_4530749_n.jpg
 
Last edited:
And this seems to be Sand's bone of contention. The Jewish state is a racial state (he calls them a nation-race), and the national identity of Israel is predicated on this concept (and, apparently myth) of racial homogeneity. This seems problematic, doesn't it?

Creating a straw man to represent ideas one does not like is indeed a problem.
 
No, it is more of an ethno-religious state, as Jews can be of any race..and are.

Just go to Israel and see the black, white, and brown Jews. Jewish is not and CANNOT be a race.

Jews are one race..huh?

[qimg]http://photos-h.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc3/hs072.snc3/13946_1190411574476_1653977305_471097_3833999_n.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://photos-a.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc3/hs052.snc3/13946_1190413174516_1653977305_471099_1397670_n.jpg[/qimg]

That photo reminds me of Blazing Saddles:)
 
I wonder how many other "ethnic" groups would display a high degree of genetic similarity?

Not many, I'll wager.

What do you mean? There are people across all cultures that call themselves "Jews".

It's just that those with the most power are White (Ashkenazis); are of Eastern European descent (Russian, German, Polish ... ), so they get more recognition IMO than say, African, Asian or Latino Jews. So people end up selectively associating Jews with White people with Eastern European features.
 
Last edited:
I'd be surprised though if Jews were fundamentally different than other people, which all are a motley of different ethnic origins. Take England for example: pre-Celtic inhabitants, Celtic invaders, Romans (from all over the Empire and beyond, including Sarmatia), Angles Saxons and Jutes, Danes and Norwegians, and Normans all left their marks. Which makes the science of DNA evidence quite hard. So forgive me if I'm skeptical of wide-ranging conclusions on the basis of DNA evidence, especially when I read of studies that only test one or two dozen people.

I mostly agree with what you wrote. (Though you forgot Rome as a place with a large Jewish presence in the 3-4th centuries.) I do have two comments on this: Of course Jews are not different and are mixed with other populations, but I would suspect that there was less mixing compared to other populations. The reason, the Jews have lived under the thumb of other religions for more than a millennium. This made intermarriage difficult, unless the Jewish bride/groom converted and stopped seeing himself as a Jew. So there is a kind of self selection mechanism here, where the part of the population which mixed less is the one which kept its identity.

As for the conclusion of the DNA studies, they are somewhat tenuous, but this can be equally said for our historical knowledge of the relevant periods. There is evidence for Jewish life across the Roman empire but it is very fragmentary. It is hard to know where these communities came from.
 
No, it is more of an ethno-religious state, as Jews can be of any race..and are.

Just go to Israel and see the black, white, and brown Jews. Jewish is not and CANNOT be a race.

Jews are one race..huh?

You are correct, Judaism is not a race. I called myself a Jew for most of my life because one of my parents identifies as a Jew and we went to Temple occassionally. But now I'm agnostic and it gets tired hearing people insist that someone like myself must be a Jew due to lineage. That's as ridiculous as insisting that Obama is a Muslim because his father was Muslim.

Yes, I occasionally pepper my speech with Yiddish, and once in a while I celebrate Passover or whatever, as an excuse to spend time with relatives, but certainly not out of a sense of belief in Judaism. And in no way do I consider myself a "racial" Jew, any more than I consider myself a "racial" agnostic.

I started realizing the absurdity of the whole "racial Jew" thing when my aunt, raised as a Jew and is partially of German descent, said to me, "As a Jew, I will never set foot in Germany." But she is German. And we probably have relatives that committed some awful atrocities, especially considering how common our German surname is. And we probably have relatives who helped hide Jews.

I understand she's upset about what happened to the Jews, but it's 2009 and it's not the same country (obviously). I mean, crap, many German citizens supported a Black presidential candidate as leader of the free world. Things have changed and she needs to stop holding it against all Germans.
 
Creating a straw man to represent ideas one does not like is indeed a problem.

A strawman? Are you denying that Israel defines its national identity in broadly ethnic terms? What is Zionism if not an ethno-centric politics?

I'm interested in criticisms of Sand as his arguments seem persuasive, but dismissing his position as a "strawman" without further explanation doesn't help me understand the criticisms you're making.
 
Last edited:
And this seems to be Sand's bone of contention. The Jewish state is a racial state (he calls them a nation-race), and the national identity of Israel is predicated on this concept (and, apparently myth) of racial homogeneity. This seems problematic, doesn't it?

Nick Griffin says English people have lived in England since the last Ice Age. Absurd, and his political aims to base a state around this racial myth are terrifying and ludicrous. If Sand is correct, and racial Judaism is a recently constructed myth, don't the objections raised against the BNP's stupid claims start to look applicable to arguments which claim Israel as a nation principally for racial Jews? That seems to be the force of Sand's position, anyway.

Has anyone actually read the book?

I haven't read that particular book, but I would consider the idea of _any_ human race to be a myth. Honestly, humans have some of the lowest degrees of genetic diversity, short of the tasmanian devil.

There is more diversity in a single race of cats than the whole human species has. Look at the difference between an Egyptian Mau, a Siamese, a Manx, a Siberian, etc. _That's_ races. Or look at the difference between a Lion and a Tiger, which are really borderline between species and races, as even some hybrids can be fertile.

Nobody would consider a blue British Shorthair cat is a different race from a mackerel tabby British Shorthair, but for some reason we do the same for humans. Never mind that there are probably less genetic differences between a Nubian and a Caucasian than between the aforementioned blue and tabby cats.

So, yes, I think that all human races are a bogus notion.

Luckily I don't know of any country which is based on racial purity nowadays, though. Cultural identity, yes. Religious, well, some of them. Racial purity, no, we kinda all outgrew that one way or another.
 
A strawman? Are you denying that Israel is founded upon and bases its immigration policy on ethnic criteria? Or that Israel defines its national identity similarly? What is Zionism if not an ethno-centric politics?

I'm interested in criticisms of Sand as his arguments seem persuasive, but dismissing his position as a "strawman" without further explanation doesn't help me understand the criticisms you're making.

Yes, it is a straw man.

Zionism was a movement whose goal was to create a nation state for the Jewish people. Unsurprisingly it originated at a time where similar movements existed in many places in Europe.

Belonging to a group is basically a matter of self identity, not of race, and this applies to the Jewish people as well. The claim that Jewish idenity is based on race is a straw man. It has nothing to do with reality.

Due to a convoluted and long history, determining who is Jewish is difficult. The current rules are a mixture of religious practices, and lineage. You can convert, though the process may be painful, and you will be considered to be a Jew.

Israel does have a law which grants Jews, and their close descendants (which may not be Jews) a fast track citizenship. This law is a direct result of many centuries of Jewish persecution, and whose goal is to ensure that any Jew which feels unsafe could find a home in Israel.

Can you please explain what do you mean by 'ethno-centric politics'? Do you find Greece an enhto-centric state? Or Ireland? How about Japan? Are you for the abolishment of national identities in general? Wouldn't it be best to start from places where the chance for violence is lower?
 
Yes, it is a straw man.

Zionism was a movement whose goal was to create a nation state for the Jewish people. Unsurprisingly it originated at a time where similar movements existed in many places in Europe.

Sure. But the quibble here is exactly what "The Jewish People" means, right? The meaning of that concept is what Sand's title is probing.

Belonging to a group is basically a matter of self identity, not of race, and this applies to the Jewish people as well. The claim that Jewish idenity is based on race is a straw man. It has nothing to do with reality.
Can you, or can you not, be classed as Jewish even if you do not practice the tenets of the Judaic religion? If so, on what grounds? I happen to agree with Parky' helpful clarification that "ethnic" is probably more apt a term than "racial", but the point still stands.

Can you please explain what do you mean by 'ethno-centric politics'?
All you described - descendants, lineage, ancestry - is an enthno-centric politics to my eyes. When you say "Israel does have a law which grants Jews, and their close descendants (which may not be Jews) a fast track citizenship", you're describing a politics anchored in notions of ethnicity, aren't you? Arguments about whether or not basing a state on these grounds is legitimate or not (the persecution issue) is entirely separate from whether or not the politics are ethno-centric in the first place.

I happen to think that it's not legitimate, but I am sympathetic to the historical contingency which lead to the foundation of contemporary Israel. Questions of the legitimacy of a policy come after a statement of what the policy is, though - and from the way you've outlined it, from what I've read and understand and from what Dr. Sands was talking about on the radio this morning, it does not seem inappropriate to say that Israel self-identifies culturally and politically as primarily and principally a nation of ethnic Jews.

Do you find Greece an enhto-centric state? Or Ireland? How about Japan?
Do those states require any specific lineage or ancestry in order to immigrate? No. Are there laws on the statute books in Greece which mean "ethnic Greeks" are afforded preferential treatment?

Are you for the abolishment of national identities in general?
As it happens, yes. Nation states and national identities are anachronisms of a pre-globalised world, and their continued existence are an obstacle to peace, cohesion and co-operation. But that's a broader discussion.

Wouldn't it be best to start from places where the chance for violence is lower?
This is irrelevant to the discussions at hand. I'm not proposing a programme for the "abolition of national identity". I'm just concerned about modern nations grounding themselves in antiquated and ultimately mythological notions of racial identity - as, it seems, is Dr. Sands.

My principal interest in this topic comes from this debunked notion of racial purity (and indeed of race itself) as discussed on this forum many times. Human beings are human beings. If we can laugh at Nick Griffin for claiming an unbroken lineage of Britons back to the Ice Age, why can't the same criticisms be levelled at the idea of "Jewish lineage"? Dr Sands couldn't find a difference and it seems, even following your informed clarifications, that there isn't one.
 
Last edited:
(Though you forgot Rome as a place with a large Jewish presence in the 3-4th centuries.)
I listed some examples, and mentioned Jezus' times. Was there already a large Jewish presence back then? (When you say 3-4th C., you mean AD, don't you?)

I do have two comments on this: Of course Jews are not different and are mixed with other populations, but I would suspect that there was less mixing compared to other populations. The reason, the Jews have lived under the thumb of other religions for more than a millennium. This made intermarriage difficult, unless the Jewish bride/groom converted and stopped seeing himself as a Jew. So there is a kind of self selection mechanism here, where the part of the population which mixed less is the one which kept its identity.
I agree with you that the mixing would be less than with other populations. I forgot to mention that in my previous post.

As for the conclusion of the DNA studies, they are somewhat tenuous, but this can be equally said for our historical knowledge of the relevant periods. There is evidence for Jewish life across the Roman empire but it is very fragmentary. It is hard to know where these communities came from.
So there are also no reliable estimates on how big the diaspora was?
 
Not historians, but the destruction of the temple has gone down in popular discourse as the start of the Diaspora. Which is blatantly untrue.

I understand that it is common knowledge in Christianity that the letters at the end of the new testatament of the bible are written to communities of ex-gentile and ex-Jewish Christians and these communities predate the destruction of the Temple.
 
ddt: your facts are basically correct, of course. But:

1). This is well known, and certainly not some sort of "horrible truth" that is "hidden" by Jewish historians. Just take any course in Jewish history in your local community college and you'll be taught the same facts you posted.

2). Just because the schoolboy "the romans kicked us out in 70 AD" version is false doesn't mean there was no diaspora or that it was not caused to a great degree by the roman conquest. The details are more complicated, but the basic truth is still true.

Yup. The Diaspora happened. Both times (two related but separate periods).

3). The argument in (2) is true for every historical event whatever. Washington didn't actually chop down the cherry tree, but that doesn't mean the American revolution is a fiction. Joshua didn't conquer Cna'an in a fierce battle like in the Bible -- there is evidence of great amount of non-Israelite people living in the area hundreds of years after the first Israelite settlements -- but that doesn't mean the conquest of Cna'an is not an historical fact.

Not to pick at nits, but modern genetic evidence seems to imply that the people of Canaan and the Israelites were the same ethnic group of different cultural bents. Hence the long period of living together and the political and social landscape evolving into historical Israel. The Palestinian and Israeli people are more close in origin and ethnicity than many would prefer to admit.
 
I listed some examples, and mentioned Jezus' times. Was there already a large Jewish presence back then? (When you say 3-4th C., you mean AD, don't you?)
I meant 3-4 century, not Jesus' time. I was not clear enough.

So there are also no reliable estimates on how big the diaspora was?

Hard for me to answer, as I am not sure I know enough. I do know that Jewish artifacts were found in many places, hence my 4th century-Rome-comment. I am not sure what can be deduced from that.

As for earlier periods, I found this, which is quite interesting.
The last one was not only the largest catacomb, but also the oldest. It was probably used from the late first century BCE (until the fourth century CE) and its early date confirms the words of Philo that many Jews were settled in Rome after the war against Pompey in 63 BCE. The oldest inscriptions mention freed slaves, who must have been Pompey's prisoners of war.
 
The Palestinian and Israeli people are more close in origin and ethnicity than many would prefer to admit.

actually, the Israelis love to flaunt this while the Palestinians don't wanna hear it. but like I said, Jews share more genes with the Kurds then any other group on Earth, not the Arabs.
 
I'm under the impression that whenever one devotes enough time picking apart what an ethnic identity really means, the concept starts to fall apart.

I once read a book about the Arabs (sorry forgot title) that started off by defining what an Arab actually is. There is no fitting definition.
Is it genetic? No they are genetically similar to other peoples.
Is it in the language (Arabophone)? No, there are non-Arabs that speak and write Arabic.
Is it religious? No, there are plenty of Christians that self identify as Arabic (including 70's Palestinian terrorist Abu Nidal).

The more you look at the issue, the more it disintegrates, or the more illusive it becomes.

Group identity seems to be a psychological thing before anything else.
See the psychological experiment where they made sports teams that were either white or black. then later created teams consisting of whites and blacks.
In both cases the team members thought off their team-mates as 'us' and of the other teams as 'them'.

If you'd take a bunch of Chinese, Caucasians, Africans and Pygmies and dump 'm on an Island for a generation or two. They'd self identify as a group pretty soon. Just as a result of the shared experience of having to rely on each other for survival.

Hence the absurdity of Marc39's repeated claims that the Palestinians do not exist.
The shared experience of the Nakba would have led to them having a shared identity and thus part of a group they identify with.
IMHO Dr. Shlomo Sand is making the same mistake.

If anyone should understand this it should be Jewish people.
Nothing re-enforces group identity more than an attack from the outside, especially if said attack is carried out with the intention to annihilate.

Such a situation immediately leads to tribal instincts bubbling to the surface.
Grab your gun and circle the wagons!

And don't members of the majority secretly have a bit of envy for all this socially acceptable tribalism? Especially since it became not PC to be proud of being white? (Damn you Victorians! Damn you Nazi's!)
Didn't we all imagine ourselves in the place of Al Pacino when we watched the Godfather? Didn't white kid's deeply envy blacks for getting to call each other 'brother' and 'sister''?

And Jews of all people get to have their cake and eat it two.
They get to be white liberals, yet jokingly refer to other Jews as members of the tribe.:)
 
Last edited:
Sure. But the quibble here is exactly what "The Jewish People" means, right? The meaning of that concept is what Sand's title is probing.

Can you, or can you not, be classed as Jewish even if you do not practice the tenets of the Judaic religion? If so, on what grounds? I happen to agree with Parky' helpful clarification that "ethnic" is probably more apt a term than "racial", but the point still stands.

There is no easy definition of what 'a people' means. It is rather an mixture of various criteria, which eventually boil down to the self identity of members of the group. The Jewish people have self identified as a group for more than two thousand years, and that is enough to make them a people.

All you described - descendants, lineage, ancestry - is an enthno-centric politics to my eyes. When you say "Israel does have a law which grants Jews, and their close descendants (which may not be Jews) a fast track citizenship", you're describing a politics anchored in notions of ethnicity, aren't you? Arguments about whether or not basing a state on these grounds is legitimate or not (the persecution issue) is entirely separate from whether or not the politics are ethno-centric in the first place.
Yes, this is an ethnocentric type of law. It exist as a result of many centuries of Jewish persecution, which are still ongoing today. (You can look at the situation of the few remaining Jews in Yemen as an example.)

This law have the same rational behind it as affirmative action. It gives a preference to member of a group trying to correct past wrongs. In the case of Jews it is meant to give them a place to go to if they are discriminated against, which was more or less the case. There are only two large Jewish centers today, which have very little overlap with the demography of Jews in the 19 century. It is fair to say that most Jews had to leave their home during that period and more than half have used this law.

As for you obsession about the ethnicity of this law. The legislators could not find a good criteria to decide "who is a Jew". Instead the law is based on the criteria used by Jew haters, as to find who is likely to be persecuted as a Jew. These were adopted for the lack of a better alternative. To repeat, the origin of this criteria is from Jew haters.

Do those states require any specific lineage or ancestry in order to immigrate? No. Are there laws on the statute books in Greece which mean "ethnic Greeks" are afforded preferential treatment?
Yes, in the same way that applies in Israel. They have a special track of gaining citizenship. The same applies to several other countries, see the list in the link.

As it happens, yes. Nation states and national identities are anachronisms of a pre-globalised world, and their continued existence are an obstacle to peace, cohesion and co-operation. But that's a broader discussion.
You may think that way, you may want it to be that way, but this does not make it right. The need to belong to a part of a group is part of human nature. This inevitably leads to a separation to groups based on cultural lines. They can be cultural, ethnic, religious but they will still be with us as long as human culture survive.

This is irrelevant to the discussions at hand. I'm not proposing a programme for the "abolition of national identity". I'm just concerned about modern nations grounding themselves in antiquated and ultimately mythological notions of racial identity - as, it seems, is Dr. Sands.
Except that Sand does not promote history, but rather a pseudo history which he created to promote a political viewpoint. As someone who likes history, this is a perversion of scholarship. Worse, it is easily demonstrated to be false, for instance by comparing genetic markers between population. Frankly, I do not care much for all the political viewpoints you try to push here, my main concern is with the idea that one needs to distort history to support current political viewpoints. Have you read the link I gave earlier? The historian reviewing his book finds his arguments ludicrous, and in fact makes fun of his straw man arguments.

My principal interest in this topic comes from this debunked notion of racial purity (and indeed of race itself) as discussed on this forum many times. Human beings are human beings. If we can laugh at Nick Griffin for claiming an unbroken lineage of Britons back to the Ice Age, why can't the same criticisms be levelled at the idea of "Jewish lineage"? Dr Sands couldn't find a difference and it seems, even following your informed clarifications, that there isn't one.
This is a terrible argument. First, you place a huge straw man, and then argue against it. No one have ever claimed anything about racial purity. This is ludicrous. If you want to persist in imagining that Jews think they are somehow "racially pure" there is not much we can discuss about. It is just not true.

As for your second point. One can try to criticize anything, and if one makes a scholarly sound case, based on evidence, that new theory will eventually be accepted. If one instead promotes a conspiracy theory of history, based on cherry picked evidence, while ignoring the majority of the evidence, which contradicts his theory, then he will be laughed at. Sand's history is bunk, which justifies the criticism of his book.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom