"The Invention of the Jewish People"

<snip>

As for you obsession about the ethnicity of this law. The legislators could not find a good criteria to decide "who is a Jew". Instead the law is based on the criteria used by Jew haters, as to find who is likely to be persecuted as a Jew. These were adopted for the lack of a better alternative. To repeat, the origin of this criteria is from Jew haters.

<snip>


Thank you, Doctor Evil, for your contributions to this thread. I have been gifted by you with much to contemplate.

I did not pick out the above as being singularly insightful in the company of your many insightful offerings, but rather because it frames the discussion in such a pragmatic fashion.

I am grateful for the food for thought.
 
Was trying to figure out why people - including me - ever bought into the Judaism-as-an-ethnicity woo.

People who've chosen to practice Judaism have been heavily persecuted, as a group (obviously). Maybe they associate their justifiably defensive reactions with that of people who have been racially persecuted.

Claiming common racial lineage could serve a dual purpose: create a stronger sense of unity against the "dangerous others", and It create a deeper sense of unity, deeper than religious ties, because each sees others in the group as "common blood" (albeit erroneously).

There's an ethnic component though.

My grandfather looked really Jewish.
My wife couldn't look that Catholic, even if she had plastic surgery.
There are no Nazi cartoons of characters that look over-the-top Free Mason or Jehova's Wittness.
 
Dr. Evil - thanks for all of that, and for taking the time to set it out so clearly. Most clear and most enlightening.
 
I just don't see what the point of this discussion is. We're speaking of two different meanings of "ethnicity" or "ethnic group". Inasmuch as "ethnic group" is defined as "part of a race" or "racially pure group", then of course Jews aren't an "ethnic group". But inasmuch as "ethnic group" means -- as it usually does -- people of the same nation, culture, religion, and so on, then Jews are a group.
 
Last edited:
Dr. Evil - thanks for all of that, and for taking the time to set it out so clearly. Most clear and most enlightening.

Thanks for your reply. It took me a while to figure out that we were talking past each other to an extent. This tend to happen when the issues under discussion are not clearly defined. In this case Sand's claims, and how they compare to the current accepted historiography, as well as for the DNA evidence.

Ironically, I tend to hold the opinion that it is the cultural links that manner. The self identification of Jews as a people, and not the direct genetic inheritance. The factual basis of Sand's main thesis would not affect my political viewpoint in any way.
 
Thank you, Doctor Evil, for your contributions to this thread. I have been gifted by you with much to contemplate.

I did not pick out the above as being singularly insightful in the company of your many insightful offerings, but rather because it frames the discussion in such a pragmatic fashion.

I am grateful for the food for thought.

Thank you too for your reply. I am glad that some people find my viewpoint to be of interest. Especially the discussion took time which should have been spent on rather pressing real life issue.

As for the issue of the law of return. There is much more to discuss here, but this discussion is almost never done. This is because this law is a type of 'affirmative action' but this rational is typically ignored. (Also, similar laws are quite common in other countries, with less historical justification.)

Going behind this point allow to ask more useful questions. One can ask whether this law was used to help Jews in the past. The answer is a clear yes. (Jews from Arab countries, Russian Jews, etc.) One may ask whether this law is still needed today. In my opinion yes, but this is a question of judgment. (Which requires knowledge of the history of Jews in the diaspora, as well as some estimate of the projected future. The last one is the tricky part.) Then one may ask whether the Israeli government sometime misuse the law. (They do, but the correct solution in my opinion is not necessarily changing it, but rather changing how it is used.)

This could make a fascinating discussion, but one which I will do my best to avoid, as least until I have more free time.
 
There's an ethnic component though.
My grandfather looked really Jewish.

There's no evidence for the existence of an "ethnic Jew". Or if there is, please provide it. How does one "look Jewish"? Tell me what features you think a Jew has? Thanks.
 
But inasmuch as "ethnic group" means -- as it usually does -- people of the same nation, culture, religion, and so on, then Jews are a group.

Wrong. You can find people who call themselves Jews amongst just about any "group" of people on the planet. You can find them in just about any country. Conversely, there is no "Jewish country". You can't even say that about Israel, which is comprised, historically, of Arabs, Christians and Jews.
 
There's no evidence for the existence of an "ethnic Jew". .

indeed..there is no longer a single Jewish ethnic group. there was, 2,000 years ago, but no longer.

there are now at least 20 seperate Jewish ethnic groups.
 
Jews CANNOT be one ethnicity, for they live all over the world and speak many different languages and have different foods/customs going back 2,000 years.
So if I go to a Jewish deli I can't get ethnic food? Odd. It's time we protested these establishments. It's time that we demanded that Jews stop with the charade. They've no culture. They've no traditions.

(isn't religion itself a cultural aspect with customs, traditions, art, food, etc..?) Shhhh......
 
Last edited:
Wrong. You can find people who call themselves Jews amongst just about any "group" of people on the planet. You can find them in just about any country. Conversely, there is no "Jewish country". You can't even say that about Israel, which is comprised, historically, of Arabs, Christians and Jews.
Americans are not a group? Italians are amongst many groups including American. Can't groups overlap? My sister, a Mormon of Irish decent, married the son of of a Polish Jew. What does that make her children? Polish? Mormon? American? I guess not Jewish since my sister isn't a Jew and religion is transfered only through the mother (bizarre). I've a friend whose parents are from Italy and she maried a man whose racial background is Italian. They consider theselves proud Italian Americans and follow the customs and culture of both. How does a group within a group nulify one of the groups?

Perhaps there aren't really such precise designations. Perhaps people who share traditions (weddings) and culture (art, food, dance) are in fact a people no matter how tenuous we might think the relationships.
 
Last edited:
So if I go to a Jewish deli I can't get ethnic food? Odd. It's time we protested these establishments. It's time that we demanded that Jews stop with the charade. They've no culture. They've no traditions.

But you don't understand, RandFan.

If Americans or Britons come in all kinds of shapes and sizes and versions, this just shows how diverse and open-minded the USA and the UK is.

If Jews come in different shapes and sizes, it just proves they are a culture-less, mixed-race, rag-tag, inferior group which isn't really a nationality and, therefore, don't deserve their own state.

At least, that's the argument on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays.

On Tuesdays, Thursdays, and weekends the Jews are, mysteriously, a nation, due to their close knit religious, ethnic and cultural identity.

Now, if some other group -- say, the Nepalese -- are homogeneous and remained racially apart for a long time, that is quaint and cool and shows their ancient traditions.

But in the half of the week the Jews are like that, it just proves how racist and exclusive they are, how evil their thoughts, and, of course, proves that such a racist, evil people don't deserve their own state.
 
indeed..there is no longer a single Jewish ethnic group. there was, 2,000 years ago, but no longer.

there are now at least 20 seperate Jewish ethnic groups.

Well I keep asking for evidence and I keep getting unfounded statements. What is your source to back the idea that there was ever - even 2,000 years ago - such a thing as an "ethnic Jew"? Please ... some sources.

And then, please offer a source for there being twenty "Jewish ethnic groups". Thanks much.
 
Americans are not a group? Italians are amongst many groups including American. Can't groups overlap?

There are many groups, sure. And Jews can be found in pretty much any ethnic pool/group you can think of. So for every ethnic group in the world, people within that group will worship as Jews. That's because Judaism, like Islam, Christianity or Wicca, etc., is just a religion; a set of religious principles with attending philosophies, that are being observed. Anyone of any ethnicity can be a Jew.

My sister, a Mormon of Irish decent, married the son of of a Polish Jew. What does that make her children? Polish? Mormon? American?
Your sister's religion is Mormonism. Which means she chose to follow the religion of the Mormon Church. Meanwhile, her ethnicity is Irish.

She married the son of a Polish person (Polish is his ethnicity), whose religion is Judaism.

Conclusion? Her children's ethnicity is Irish/Polish. Aside from that, there is no such thing as inheriting a religion (like it were a bloodline), so they get to choose whether or not they will worship as a Mormon, Jew or whatever else. ... Or maybe they will choose atheism or agnosticism instead.

Citizenship is a separate issue also. As long as they have American citizenship they are American by nationality.

I guess not Jewish since my sister isn't a Jew and religion is transfered only through the mother (bizarre).
Yes, that's bizarre. A newer Jewish tradition would have me being a Jew because my father identifies as a Jew (equally bizarre), even though he is actually just an atheist LOL.

I've a friend whose parents are from Italy and she maried a man whose racial background is Italian. They consider theselves proud Italian Americans and follow the customs and culture of both. How does a group within a group nulify one of the groups?
Sorry, you lost me here. When you say "both", what two categories are you describing? Thanks.

Perhaps there aren't really such precise designations. Perhaps people who share traditions (weddings) and culture (art, food, dance) are in fact a people no matter how tenuous we might think the relationships.
That could be. But it seems patently absurd to consider a religious belief system (Judaism, Islam) and its behavioral customs (culture) something that is genetically inherited, like eye color. How obviously ridiculous.
 
So if I go to a Jewish deli I can't get ethnic food? Odd. It's time we protested these establishments. It's time that we demanded that Jews stop with the charade. They've no culture. They've no traditions.

(isn't religion itself a cultural aspect with customs, traditions, art, food, etc..?) Shhhh......

Why do people keep conflating culture with ethnicity? Culture, in and of itself, is nothing more than common behavioral patterns. It needn't be based on genetic similarities. You can't inherit a culture, genetically - or behaviorally - speaking. A Jewish deli is no more "ethnic" than a Muslim bakery. Notice how anyone can be Muslim? Well, same with a Jew. Being either thing is a conscious choice and has nothing to do with genetic programming. ... Or if anyone disagrees, please, offer scientific evidence to support your view.
 
Last edited:
Why do people keep conflating culture with ethnicity?
Hmmm.....

ethnicity [(eth-[SIZE=+0]nis[/SIZE]-uh-tee)]

Identity with or membership in a particular racial, national, or cultural group and observance of that group's customs, beliefs, and language.
 
Last edited:
Words are not physical laws that govern the universe. They are mearly a means to convey information. Ethnicity means, in part, shared identity. Culture is a part of that shared identity. It's true that it is problematic to say that there is only a single Islamic or Jewish ethnicity however there ARE universaly shared identifiers.

A Jewish deli is no more "ethnic" than a Muslim bakery.
Which is to say that both are ethnic.

If there was nothing that was exclusive to Jewish identity I would agree with you. There IS shared cultural aspects to Jewish and Muslim identity. IOW: Both are ethnic.

Muslim (Islamic) Culture.

Islamic Culture

Islamic Culture refers to the customs and traditions that Muslims have adopted in their respective countries including the Islamic / Muslim Clothing they wear, foods they eat, wedding traditions and other such aspects of their Islamic Life.

Islamic Art

One more thing Probe, culture is not fixed. There is overlap and mixing of identies and customs. Take Italians for instance. Leaving aside the Americanized version the customs and cultural aspects are not monolithic throughout the nation (see What are the differences between North and South Italy). So, what is ethnic Italian? Does such a designation exist at all?

On more thing more: What the hell do you think ethnic food is exactly?
 
Last edited:
There's no evidence for the existence of an "ethnic Jew". Or if there is, please provide it. How does one "look Jewish"? Tell me what features you think a Jew has? Thanks.

I can't speak for anyone else, and it's probably just some subset or lineage of Jews, but I've definitely met people who looked "Jewish," and then turned out, were Jewish. How does one look German, or British, or Asian? It's hard to describe but you can still frequently tell. It's obviously not absolute, but growing up I had a lot of Jewish friends (well, Jewish family, atheist personally), and yes, they had black curly hair and distinctive noses. One would say they "look Jewish." If it is only a certain lineage of Jews that have these traits it would be interesting to know what lineage that is, as it's obviously not an absolute since there are many "sects" of Judaism and people can convert.

But from a quick google image search:
Jewish:
http://www.lukeford.net/Images/photos1/1219994.jpg
http://www.kosherica.com/images/scholars/rabbi_marvin_hier.jpg
http://judicial-inc.biz/91alex8.jpg

Not-Jewish:
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_t_KSMDOgPtw/R_ccftZch1I/AAAAAAAAAwU/kxFp1OHC5sA/s400/brad.jpg
http://www.istockphoto.com/file_thu...te-caucasian-girl-using-laptop-in-kitchen.jpg
http://cache4.asset-cache.net/xc/rbbw_58.jpg?v=1&c=NewsMaker&k=2&d=F96248E29EDD0687FB9C4375789F3B3D
 
I can't speak for anyone else, and it's probably just some subset or lineage of Jews, but I've definitely met people who looked "Jewish," and then turned out, were Jewish. How does one look German, or British, or Asian? It's hard to describe but you can still frequently tell. It's obviously not absolute, but growing up I had a lot of Jewish friends (well, Jewish family, atheist personally), and yes, they had black curly hair and distinctive noses. One would say they "look Jewish." If it is only a certain lineage of Jews that have these traits it would be interesting to know what lineage that is, as it's obviously not an absolute since there are many "sects" of Judaism and people can convert.

But from a quick google image search:
Jewish:
http://www.lukeford.net/Images/photos1/1219994.jpg
http://www.kosherica.com/images/scholars/rabbi_marvin_hier.jpg
http://judicial-inc.biz/91alex8.jpg

Not-Jewish:
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_t_KSMDOgPtw/R_ccftZch1I/AAAAAAAAAwU/kxFp1OHC5sA/s400/brad.jpg
http://www.istockphoto.com/file_thu...te-caucasian-girl-using-laptop-in-kitchen.jpg
http://cache4.asset-cache.net/xc/rbbw_58.jpg?v=1&c=NewsMaker&k=2&d=F96248E29EDD0687FB9C4375789F3B3D

[One sec Ferguson ... ] Randfand, I'll respond to your posts tomorrow, when I have additional time.

There are certain countries that happen to have a higher than average percentage of Jewish worshippers (i.e.: Russia, Poland, Germany). This results in people erroneously thinking that all people with Eastern European features are "Jewish".

While it's true that many people from Eastern Europe have the aforementioned features (me included), also happen to have chosen to worship as Jews, it does not mean all of us are Jewish (I'm not, for example, as I don't observe Judaism).

It only means that the likelihood is relatively high that people with Eastern European features will practice Judaism (It's simply a correlation). And since many of us aren't Jews, people with Eastern European features cannot be viewed as being genetically (ethnically) assigned as Jews in the context you mention. That's especially the case because cultural practices and beliefs (like those of Muslims or Mormons or Jews) aren't things you inherit, like eye color.
 
Last edited:
Well, one can go "heads I win, tails it doesn't matter" to define a look for any nation. Because it seems to me like "jewish look" is exactly like that. A small subset of jewish people actually look like that, and let's pretend that the overwhelming majority of exceptions don't matter.

E.g., Reinhard Heydrich (the butcher of Prague) was jewish enough under the Nazi racial purity laws to have that used against him as threat to keep him in line, but on the other hand he obviously wasn't "jewish looking" enough to prevent his promotion to one of the top places in the SS or to be in charge of Bohemia and Moravia. I mean, they wouldn't promote someone all the way to the top if there was some kind of blatant "yep, he's a jew" face on him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom