ProbeX
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2007
- Messages
- 1,446
When you specifically respond to an issue I don't mind so much, though I don't think your case is as strong as you think it is. Jews have been a people for a long time and do tend to marry other Jews. All groups mix. Ethnic Italians are not likely as pure as some might think. I don't really accept the idea of genetically based groups however I think there is very likely a *standard deviation for a number of Jewish groups that is different from other groups. And keep in mind, Southern Italians are likely to have a standard deviation that is different from Northern Italians. Jews have sub groups as do most ethnic[sic] groups. It's of no real consequence.
*I don't vouch for the veracity of everything on that site.
Oh it doesn't matter how strong I think your case is or vice versa. Let's just stick to content. The "new study" is problematic on its surface. Twenty-nine "populations" were studied, but not all populations. So there's no way of saying that the gene isn't prevalent in every population on earth, in numbers that make the deviation statistically negligible or non-existent. ... And logically it would likely be, since people in every community claim to be Jewish. And certainly not everyone who claims to be Christian or Muslim, etc. with the "Jewish" gene can be said to be "Jewish".
Also, note that studies like these are almost entirely headed by people who have a vested interest in the the outcome of the studies - Jews. In noting these type of studies one often finds that one or more rabbis is conducting the study. That makes the new "discovery" potentially dubious. Additionally, these studies on a so-called "Jewish gene" aren't consistent in the way they define the "Jews" whom they are studying for a genetic code. I am Eastern European and part of my family follows that tradition. In this study paternal lineage would be examined. They might find a gene in him they label "Jewish" and therefore conclude I am Jewish. And they would be wrong.