"The Invention of the Jewish People"

When you specifically respond to an issue I don't mind so much, though I don't think your case is as strong as you think it is. Jews have been a people for a long time and do tend to marry other Jews. All groups mix. Ethnic Italians are not likely as pure as some might think. I don't really accept the idea of genetically based groups however I think there is very likely a *standard deviation for a number of Jewish groups that is different from other groups. And keep in mind, Southern Italians are likely to have a standard deviation that is different from Northern Italians. Jews have sub groups as do most ethnic[sic] groups. It's of no real consequence.

*I don't vouch for the veracity of everything on that site.

Oh it doesn't matter how strong I think your case is or vice versa. Let's just stick to content. The "new study" is problematic on its surface. Twenty-nine "populations" were studied, but not all populations. So there's no way of saying that the gene isn't prevalent in every population on earth, in numbers that make the deviation statistically negligible or non-existent. ... And logically it would likely be, since people in every community claim to be Jewish. And certainly not everyone who claims to be Christian or Muslim, etc. with the "Jewish" gene can be said to be "Jewish".

Also, note that studies like these are almost entirely headed by people who have a vested interest in the the outcome of the studies - Jews. In noting these type of studies one often finds that one or more rabbis is conducting the study. That makes the new "discovery" potentially dubious. Additionally, these studies on a so-called "Jewish gene" aren't consistent in the way they define the "Jews" whom they are studying for a genetic code. I am Eastern European and part of my family follows that tradition. In this study paternal lineage would be examined. They might find a gene in him they label "Jewish" and therefore conclude I am Jewish. And they would be wrong.
 
None of this obviates my point. We are people. Human beings. There is as likely to be as much genetic variation between two people of different ethnic backgrounds as there are between two people of the same ethnic background. There are families with unique genetic markers. That doesn't make them a separate ethnic group.

I stand by my point. The ethnic stuff as it is used in this discussion is silly and beside the point.

Right. Never mind the bit about how it helps track medical disease or that fact that certain religious groups try and use it as an exclusionary tool, which is the crux of much of this discussion. Kumbaya.
 
I try to use spell check and make every effort to use proper grammer and spelling. I fail from time to time. Many of the posts I respond to have errors. I don't focus on the errors unless it's a significant one that could cause confusion or if someone habitually makes a mistake.

The "new study" is problematic on its surface. Twenty-nine "populations" were studied, but not all populations. So there's no way of saying that the gene isn't prevalent in every population on earth, in numbers that make the deviation statistically negligible or non-existent. ... And logically it would likely be, since people in every community claim to be Jewish. And certainly not everyone who claims to be Christian or Muslim, etc. with the "Jewish" gene can be said to be "Jewish".
I don't understand your last point at all. If they had a so called "Jewish" gene it wouldn't obviate the notion that there was a group or groups of individuals with a specific marker and later people mixed with other groups. As to the rest it's simply asserted and I'd like to see some additional peer review.

Also, note that studies like these are almost entirely headed by people who have a vested interest in the the outcome of the studies - Jews. In noting these type of studies one often finds that one or more rabbis is conducting the study. That makes the new "discovery" potentially dubious. Additionally, these studies on a so-called "Jewish gene" aren't consistent in the way they define the "Jews" whom they are studying for a genetic code. I am Eastern European and part of my family follows that tradition. In this study paternal lineage would be examined. They might find a gene in him they label "Jewish" and therefore conclude I am Jewish. And they would be wrong.
Could be ad hominem. It's worth pointing out that such studies could be scrutinized for objectivity. I would be very critical of any study funded by Templeton however some of those studies have stood up to peer review (so far such studies have been negative to Templeton's views).

Your complaints are worthy of consideration but I don't at all think you've put the matter to rest. But I do appreciate the response. I'll dig up some other studies. Unless you want to focus on typos and grammer. Then I'd rather bow out.
 
Right. Never mind the bit about how it helps track medical disease or that fact that certain religious groups try and use it as an exclusionary tool, which is the crux of much of this discussion. Kumbaya.
Of what significance is tracking medical disease to the discussion? A person with sickle cell anemia is a human being. Due to isolation as a group evolution endowed that person with genetics ever so slightly different than other humans. So what? Are they really a different species? Is it helpful from a scientific perspective to track genetics groups. Sure. So what? What does that have to do with this discussion?

I think the creation of vague differences is what contributes to tribalism. I think it would be better to see us all as human. Forget the arbitrary boundaries. Sickle cell anemia doesn't make a person less of a human being.

So I really don't get your point.
 
Last edited:
T

Some people in these threads (like Parky) have attempted to defend the woo above (and the fabled "Jewish look", that is also is a genetically-based claim based on fairy-tale genetics), by stating that there is such a thing as a genetically-based Jew.

what exactly is your objective here?
 
Aren't ancient Israeli and Muslim "Palestinians" Canaanites altogether - and thus the only difference between those early Jews and Muslims is their effing stupid religion? :confused:

No. the Canaanite people were slaughtered, died out, or mixed into the Israelite population. by 235 AD, when the Romans finally crushed the Jewish uprising, there were close to a million Jews already living outside of Judaea/Israel. A large majority of the Jews in Judaea after the Roman defeat left for Mediteranean lands, but a minority of Jews stayed in their homeland.

There is no evidence then any sizeable percentage of the modern day Palestinian people are descended from ancient Jews. that is true woo.

...with a cherry on top.
 
I don't understand your last point at all. If they had a so called "Jewish" gene it wouldn't obviate the notion that there was a group or groups of individuals with a specific marker and later people mixed with other groups.

Sure, there is a particular tribe that certain bias people (chiefly rabbis and self-described Jews) attempt to frame as "Jewish" (i.e. the Cohenim clan), because of a high correlation between the original people of that clan and the religion many - not all - of them, chose to worship. In fact they attempt to boost such claims with further "evidence" from the Bible.

Consider this example: you unfortunately stumble upon a dead man hidden behind some bushes (or wherever). DNA testing shows that he is of strong African descent. Another test shows he has a haplotype labeled as Cohen, meaning his paternal lineage can be traced back to that tribe of people.

Great. Now can you objectively say he was Jewish? It depends on who you ask. If you ask a Rabbi, or even a scientist with a bias to believe Cohenism=Judaism, the answer would likely be "yes". But there is merely a correlation between the practice of Judaism and the Cohen gene (post hoc ergo procter hoc fallacy).

Truth is, the dead man's DNA connects him to a "family" of people that long ago, had a tendency to practice Judaism, but no one can confirm all of them were worshipping Jews. Nor do all people with the Cohenim marker identify as "Jewish". No scientist worth his salt will state that the dead man, who was a practicing Christian, was "Jewish", via his DNA results, just because he had the Cohenim marker. All the scientist can say is that this man and his Cohen gene is associated with a culture that tended to worship Judaism. Seems pretty plain and obvious to me.

Could be ad hominem. It's worth pointing out that such studies could be scrutinized for objectivity. I would be very critical of any study funded by Templeton however some of those studies have stood up to peer review (so far such studies have been negative to Templeton's views).

As stated, the study itself is not in question, rather the way the results are being spun by certain Jewish organizations. Correlation is the only thing the study shows, which is interesting, but not enough to say the gene means everyone with the marker is "Jewish".

Your complaints are worthy of consideration but I don't at all think you've put the matter to rest.

The burden is on the Rabbis and Jews who interpret these tests, to justify their assumption that all people with this haplotype are "Jewish". The burden is also on the people here who - without clear evidence - portray Jews as if they are a genetic group.

So basically, unless someone can prove there's such a thing as a genetic Jew, then it will be completely appropriate to continue placing the burden of proof back on the claimant, when s/he claims things like: Your mom or dad determines your "Jewishness", or lack thereof. And that silly claim comes up fairly often on this site.

Addendum: If I called you out on grammar or spelling, I do apologize. I honestly don't recall doing that. Have you confused me with someone else?
 
Your perpetual defense of all that woo about genetic Jews.

you consider me having possibly 5% genes of people who lived around the Fertile Crescent....to be woo??

lol. now that's some sad woo...i gotta say.

i mean, if I claimed I was 50% Israelite..or even 25%..that may qualify as woo....but 5%??

damn...that's just really flimsy woo. that woo needs some Viagra.
 
Last edited:
The burden is on the Rabbis and Jews who interpret these tests, to justify their assumption that all people with this haplotype are "Jewish". The burden is also on the people here who - without clear evidence - portray Jews as if they are a genetic group.

oh...so Jews consider ANYONE who possess the Cohain or Levite haplotype, to be a Jew???

tell that to the Lemba tribe in South Africa. many of the men have these genes, but because they practice Christianity..are NOT considered Jewish by faith or practice. they would have to convert to be considered true Jews.

take that!! :p
 
Your perpetual defense of all that woo about genetic Jews.

waiting for you to respond to the Lemba or Falasha Mura situation. "Genetic" Jews who would have to actually convert to be considered true Jews.
 
waiting for you to respond to the Lemba or Falasha Mura situation. "Genetic" Jews who would have to actually convert to be considered true Jews.

These groups aren't inherently "Jewish", because there's no proof that all members of either tribe chose to worship in the tradition of Judaism. You have the exact same problem here as you do in trying to create a false definition of a "genetic Jew" from people who have the Cohenim gene. Not all people who have any of these genes today, identify themselves as Jews; that we know. So once again, there is a correlation. Nothing less; nothing more. You're out of gas.
 
you consider me having possibly 5% genes of people who lived around the Fertile Crescent....to be woo??

lol. now that's some sad woo...i gotta say.

i mean, if I claimed I was 50% Israelite..or even 25%..that may qualify as woo....but 5%??

damn...that's just really flimsy woo. that woo needs some Viagra.

I can no longer tell if you're going so off-topic because you realize your argument is flimsy, or if you genuinely fail to understand how poorly your debating skills are.

The gibberish above in no way addresses the flaws in the arguments about an alleged "Jewish" gene.

oh...so Jews consider ANYONE who possess the Cohain or Levite haplotype, to be a Jew???

Do you consider anyone who possesses either gene to be a Jew?

tell that to the Lemba tribe in South Africa. many of the men have these genes, but because they practice Christianity..are NOT considered Jewish by faith or practice. they would have to convert to be considered true Jews.

take that!! :p
You're highlighting my point: no one can consider herself/himself automatically "Jewish" just because that person happens to have a gene from the Lemba tribe (or a Cohen, et. al.). So, do you agree?
 
Last edited:
Errrm....

I kind of see your point, but you've missed or at least misunderstood my point.

I, for one, am not "condemning" anyone, let alone Jewish people. What I'm questioning (and what Sands is questioning) is why a modern-day democratic country should define itself ethnically or ethno-culturally.

Didn't mean you. I was thinking of a few other people. I have no quarrel, for the record, with what you said at all -- I have a problem with how some people misuse such studies.

It's the double standard: Gee, Jews are not a pure race and "Jewish" is also culturally defined? You don't say. That's true, needless to say, for any nation whatever. Yet for some people, that, too, is "proof" the Jewish nation is an "artificial creation" which, naturally doesn't deserve it's own state.
 
Last edited:
Do you consider anyone who possesses either gene to be a Jew?

one can have the levite or cohain haplotype and be as far from Judaism and Jewish culture as possible. simply possessing these genes does not make on Jewish by religious standards or by common cultural standards.

religiously speaking, I consider someone to be a Jew if they are born of a Jewish mother, or converted to Judaism and practise the faith.

i also personally consider someone to be half Jewish or quarter Jewish based on their lineage, but this is just my personal belief.

so really, the true answer to your question is "NO". simply possessing these genes does not make you a true Jew.
 
Truth is, the dead man's DNA connects him to a "family" of people that long ago, had a tendency to practice Judaism, but no one can confirm all of them were worshipping Jews. Nor do all people with the Cohenim marker identify as "Jewish".
Straw man. My only argument is that there was a group of individuals who identified themselves as Jewish and this group is traceable. This isn't different from any other self identified group be they Italian, Germanic, Celtic, etc.

There is no such thing as an absolute objective genetic profile for any ethnic group. To the extent that we can genetically trace markers or find unique markers to any group we can find them for Jews.

You are way over complicating this.
 
I would love to see a post at JREF or in any newspaper that states that just because someone has the Levite or Cohain haplotype, they are considered a Jew by Jewish religious law and the State of Israel.

I will not...hold my breath.
 
It's the double standard: Gee, Jews are not a pure race and "Jewish" is also culturally defined?

Yet for some people, that, too, is "proof" the Jewish nation is an "artificial creation" which, naturally doesn't deserve it's own state.

If someone poses the argument that Jews not being a genetic ethicity, is reason to state that Jews don't deserve their own state, then I have to agree that's a silly reason to offer.

But the argument regarding the perceived rights of a particular religious group to acquire a "state", especially one that already has an established people there, is problematic from its inception. It's problematic regardless of the said group's religion, ethnicity, height or favored dessert.
 
one can have the levite or cohain haplotype and be as far from Judaism and Jewish culture as possible. simply possessing these genes does not make on Jewish by religious standards or by common cultural standards.

Right. And it doesn't even make them an "ethnic Jew". Glad we've come to some middle ground on this.

religiously speaking, I consider someone to be a Jew if they are born of a Jewish mother, or converted to Judaism and practise the faith.
Why do you consider only the person with a Jewish mom - not father - to be Jewish (not referring to conversion) ... as if Judaism is genetically inherited, and genetically inherited only via the mother?

i also personally consider someone to be half Jewish or quarter Jewish based on their lineage, but this is just my personal belief.
I just wonder how these beliefs get accepted when they are absolutely devoid of scientific (genetic) confirmation? Is this just people having fun following non-sensical rules and then believing them? What on earth is your rationale for indulging this system of thinking?

so really, the true answer to your question is "NO". simply possessing these genes does not make you a true Jew.
Correct (the word "true" isn't needed). So you can understand how some of the beliefs above, like someone's only Jewish if their mom (or dad, depending on sect ...), is Jewish, sounds a bit random and nutty, right? A "true" Jew, as you say it, is really just someone who believes and/or practices Judaism. A "true" Muslim, is just someone who believes and/or practices Islam. There is no Jewish or Christian or Muslim gene. Either you believe in the relgion, or you don't.
 
Straw man. My only argument is that there was a group of individuals who identified themselves as Jewish and this group is traceable. This isn't different from any other self identified group be they Italian, Germanic, Celtic, etc.

Yes, it is plenty different. You see, there are many people who have identified as "Jewish" who inevitably don't have the genes that we've talked about in this thread.
And the one thing that history shows with certainty, so far, is that Jews, like Muslims and Christians, cannot be traced to any definitive region or origin, genetically. But a geneticist can and does trace markers for geographic regions like Italy, Africa, Germany, etc. There is no such genetic region of original Jewish ancestry called "Jewy" or "Jewregion", etc. Just like there's no such place of as "Christianregion" or "Muslimcountry".

There is no such thing as an absolute objective genetic profile for any ethnic group. To the extent that we can genetically trace markers or find unique markers to any group we can find them for Jews.
No, we can't find a geographical genetic origin for Jews, as a group (see statement above). I haven't complicated anything. What I've said is clear and logical. People confabulate religion with ethnicity. That's the problem.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom