RandFan
Mormon Atheist
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2001
- Messages
- 60,135
There's no definitive geographical genetic origion for any group. I allready explained that. I'm not sure why you ignored it. Like relgious groups there is intermingling. At best we can find genetic markers unique to some Italians but not all. We can find unique markers unique to some Germans but not all. We can find unique markers for some Jews, not all. So no, no difference.No, we can't find a geographical genetic origin for Jews, as a group (see statement above).
See, the point is isolation. If any group becomes somewhat isolated then markers will become unique to that isolated group. Jews did largely marry other Jews. As did Italians. As did subsets of Italians and subsets of Jews.
Probe, please adress my specific points.
A) Any geographical or cultural based separation can lead to unique markers.
B) No group is entirely and completly isolated to exclude any other mixed markers.
C) Some groups are more isolated than others.
Last edited:
