"The Invention of the Jewish People"

No, we can't find a geographical genetic origin for Jews, as a group (see statement above).
There's no definitive geographical genetic origion for any group. I allready explained that. I'm not sure why you ignored it. Like relgious groups there is intermingling. At best we can find genetic markers unique to some Italians but not all. We can find unique markers unique to some Germans but not all. We can find unique markers for some Jews, not all. So no, no difference.

See, the point is isolation. If any group becomes somewhat isolated then markers will become unique to that isolated group. Jews did largely marry other Jews. As did Italians. As did subsets of Italians and subsets of Jews.

Probe, please adress my specific points.

A) Any geographical or cultural based separation can lead to unique markers.
B) No group is entirely and completly isolated to exclude any other mixed markers.
C) Some groups are more isolated than others.
 
Last edited:
According to the Cohain/Levite Haplotype studies, the earliest Jewish ancestors originate in south-eastern Turkey, also known as the northern-end of the Fertile Crescent.
 
:popcorn1

I have a number of bones to pick with ProbeX, but I haven't the time right now. On second thought, maybe I do :).

Suffice it to say I agree with RandFan, Skeptic and Dr. Evil about what we mean when we talk about "ethnicity" and "Jews". It's really not so complicated and there are no hard and fixed lines with any of this, but people seem to want to have those bright lines and think that if they aren't there, then there's no basis in reality for what is being claimed.

ProbeX, your point about "looking Jewish" having to do only with most Ashkenazi Jews having come from Eastern Europe is not well-founded imo. Many, many, if not most Eastern Europeans do not "look Jewish", by which I mean the stereotypical dark, curly hair, dark eyes and somewhat "Mediterranean" features.

But that's really not the point of my post. Most people understand that Jews are an ethnic group (a people with shared history and customs stemming from a common religion but not necessarily inseparable from that religion) and one can be ethnically Jewish without being religiously Jewish.

The larger point is that people have a right to define themselves in a way that makes sense to them. You may have chosen to completely divorce your sense of self from your father's Jewish heritage (and he does have a Jewish heritage even if he's an atheist) but not everyone chooses to do that nor is there any reason why they should. Just because you feel that being Jewish is strictly a matter of religion doesn't mean it's true for most people of Jewish ethnic background. They have a long history as a separate people that you seem to ignore.
 
ProbeX is arguing that Jews consider themselves to be all the same genetically, and anyone with the Kohain or Levite Haplotype is a Jew.

but the fact remains that as far as religion goes, simply possessing these genes in NO way makes someone a Jew, according Jewish law.

Hitler, Stalin, Peter Stuyvesant, Torquemada, etc etc, may have indeed had this gene, as it is passed down from father to son, but it does NOT mean these men were Jewish, by any stretch of the imagination.

my father's father's father's father's father's father's father's father..and only him...may have been a Jew and passed this gene all the way down to me. but the other 255 of my ancestors would NOT be Jewish, including all the women, and I would not be considered a Jew..not by ethnicity and not by religion.
 
Last edited:
Ethnicity is a "messy" concept. Religion has to do with it. So does genes. But being a Jew is not defined exclusively through the strength of one's religious beliefs or through one's genes.

Again, why is this surprising? Consider "American". Americans are supposed to believe in the Constitution as the highest law. If I am a Zulu in South Africa and so believe, am I magically an American? No. Nor does one lose one's citizenship if one for some reason thinks the Constitution sucks. Similarly, yes, many Americans can trace their heritage to the founding fathers. Does that mean that anybody who can so do is an American -- even if he is, say, a German born in Berlin? No. Does it mean that anybody who is not related to the Pilgrims or some other historical American group is not an American? Of course not.

I fail to see why Jews, in particular, must be defined purely though their genes or their beliefs. Ethnicity just doesn't work this way.
 
Ethnicity is a "messy" concept. Religion has to do with it. So does genes. But being a Jew is not defined exclusively through the strength of one's religious beliefs or through one's genes.

I fail to see why Jews, in particular, must be defined purely though their genes or their beliefs. Ethnicity just doesn't work this way.

Let me try this again.

Genetics, as far as Jewish law is concerned, has NOTHING to do with one's status as a Jew.

One can possess the Kohain AND Levite Haplotype, and not be considered a Jew at all...by Jewish religious leaders and institutions.

ALL that counts..is that your mommy is a Jew or you converted to Judaism under a recognized branch of Judaism.

you can have ALLLL the Jewish genetics in the world, but if your mom ain't a Jew and you didn't convert...then you ain't no Hebrew.

now, many Jews might recognize that certain groups around the world are likely descended from Jews, due to their possession of certain genes, but if they do not practice Judaism, Du bist kein Yid!! (you are no Jew)

do you understand?

:eek:
 
Last edited:
Ethnicity is a "messy" concept.

Genetics, as far as Jewish law is concerned, has NOTHING to do with one's status as a Jew.
I don't see a conflict. Jewish law isn't the final arbiter or what it means to be Jewish. Besides, it's entirely absurd since according to Jewish law David Cross is a Jew regardless of the fact that Cross is an atheist and people who are raised Jewish, believe in it and live it are not if their mother isn't Jewish. Silly and absurd.



But perhaps I don't understand your point.
 
Last edited:
I don't see a conflict. Jewish law isn't the final arbiter or what it means to be Jewish.

as far as the Jewish people as a whole is concerned, it is indeed.

I, however, consider someone to be Jewish (or for a better word "half-Jewish") if they have a Jewish mom or dad, regardless of their religious practice.

but that's just me. as far as the Jewish people is concerned, all that matters is your mom's religion, and if you converted.

genetics is meaningless.

and yet, it appears that some people in this forum insist on accusing the Jews of having some sort of "blood-test" for Jewishness, which is such a lie.....based on either pure and stubborn ignorance of the Jews and Judaism, or anti-Semitism. but I will not guess which one.
 
Last edited:
as far as the Jewish people as a whole is concerned, it is indeed.
I'm skeptical but even so I'm not sure why it's at all important. Jewish people don't own the word nor do they dictate how the word can be used.

I, however, consider someone to be Jewish (or for a better word "half-Jewish") if they have a Jewish mom or dad, regardless of their religious practice.

but that's just me. as far as the Jewish people is concerned, all that matters is your mom's religion, and if you converted.

genetics is meaningless.

and yet, it appears that some people in this forum insist on accusing the Jews of having some sort of "blood-test" for Jewishness, which is such a lie.....based on either pure and stubborn ignorance of the Jews and Judaism, or anti-Semitism. but I will not guess which one.
I don't think genetics is meaningless but I've never argued the point from a Jewish POV and I'm not sure why it is important to those who are not Jewish. I don't accuse the Jews of having some sort of "blood-test" and I'm not sure of any relevance or if I've seen any such claims.

Forgive me if I'm wrong.

The current discussion, it seems to me, is simply around whether or not Jews can be classified as an ethnicity, culturaly or genetically? I think they can by both methods. I personaly know atheists who are cultural jews. They might also have genetic markers that can be traced back hundreds or thousands of years to a group of individuals who identified themselves as Jews.

wiki said:
Secular Jewish culture

Secular Jewish culture embraces several related phenomena; above all, it is the culture of secular communities of Jewish people, but it can also include the cultural contributions of individuals who identify as secular Jews.
The Jewish people is generally considered to be an ethnoreligious community rather than solely a religious grouping; Judaism guides its adherents in both practice and belief, so that it has been called not only a religion, but also a "way of life". This makes it difficult to draw a clear distinction between the cultural production of members of the Jewish people, and culture that is specifically Jewish. Furthermore, not all individuals or all cultural phenomena can be easily classified as either "secular" or "religious", a distinction native to European Enlightenment thinking and foreign to most of the history of non-European Jews.
Throughout history, in eras and places as diverse as the ancient Hellenic world, in Europe before and after the Age of Enlightenment, in Islamic Spain and Portugal, in North Africa and the Middle East, in India and China, and in the contemporary United States and Israel, Jewish communities have seen the development of cultural phenomena that are in some sense characteristically Jewish without being at all specifically religious. Some factors in this come from within Judaism, others from the interaction of Jews with others around them, and others from the inner social and cultural dynamics of the community, as opposed to religion itself. This phenomenon has led to considerably different Jewish cultures unique to their own communities, each as authentically Jewish as the next.
 
Last edited:
the issue was raised because someone here has decided to accuse the Jews of having a "blood-test" to decide who is a pure Jew..and who is an unpure Jew.

he also accused me..of following this Nazi-like logic, regardless of me telling him I do not.

I will give anyone $10, if they can find some official writing by any Orthodox, Conservative, or Reform rabbi, stating that we should consider possession of the Levite or Kohain haplotype as sufficient background to consider someone a Jew, regardless of their religious practice.
 
Last edited:
as far as the Jewish people is concerned, all that matters is your mom's religion, and if you converted.

But even that isn't exactly true. The Reform branch of Judaism accepts that one is Jewish if one's father is Jewish too.
 
But even that isn't exactly true. The Reform branch of Judaism accepts that one is Jewish if one's father is Jewish too.

right. Orthodox and Conservative Jews only look at the mother. Reform Jews look at both mom and dad.

but it has NOTHING to do with genetics and haplotypes.
 
Shlowmo's goal is to deligitimise Israels existence.

Only problem for him is that Israel was created by the UN. But to people like Shlowmo, Israel existing anywhere (whether inside its 47 boundaries or not) is a travesty.

Mailman
 
Well, I've just finished the book (in Hebrew) and must agree with mailman's interpretation of it. The book is not merely "The Jewish nationality is a messy concept" (perfectly true in itself) but "The Jewish nationality is a messy concept, and therefore THE EVIL ZIONIST ENTERPRISE IS ALL BASED ON A DISGUSTING LIE" (not in those exact words, but in effect.)

This doesn't stop the man from living his life in "occupied Palestine", with all those "disgusting" and "lying" zionists, as part of the country's intelligentsia. He doesn't, God forbid, think for a minute about -- say -- giving up his posh job as history professor in a top Israeli university to a deserving Palestinian, for example. That would be inconvenient. It's just a book to flatter the typical post-zionist's ego, a self-indulgent guilt trip.

It's much like those God-awful American "history" books to the effect of "oh how evil and disgusting the sexist and racist founding fathers were" are there to flatter the typical liberal's ego. They, too, never ever think about doing anything like giving up their lifestyle to the benefit of those whom they allegedly wronged so much (Indians, this time, not Palestinians). They're all just about flattering oneself for "knowing the truth" those uneducated masses do not.

Ah well.
 
Last edited:
Shlowmo's goal is to deligitimise Israels existence.

Only problem for him is that Israel was created by the UN. But to people like Shlowmo, Israel existing anywhere (whether inside its 47 boundaries or not) is a travesty.

Mailman

eh??

who is "shlowmo"?
 
No, it is more of an ethno-religious state, as Jews can be of any race..and are.

Just go to Israel and see the black, white, and brown Jews. Jewish is not and CANNOT be a race.

Jews are one race..huh?

[qimg]http://photos-h.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc3/hs072.snc3/13946_1190411574476_1653977305_471097_3833999_n.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://photos-a.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc3/hs052.snc3/13946_1190413174516_1653977305_471099_1397670_n.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://photos-c.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc3/hs052.snc3/13946_1190415334570_1653977305_471100_4530749_n.jpg[/qimg]

Who is the blonde chick?

Does she date gentiles?
 
13946_1190411574476_1653977305_471097_3833999_n.jpg


Why am I thinking of "Blazing Saddles" all of a sudden?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom