The Godless Girl

Maybe you can point out how Christian values are against free speech? For starters.

10 commandments, read them. The bible has plenty of anti-free speech "laws."

If a Christian happens to value free speech, that's fine, but that doesn't make freedom of speech a Christian value. Freedom of speech is a secular value that just happens to have been adopted by many Christians. Of course, many of those same Christians seem to change their minds if that speech "offends" them.
 
Last edited:
You know, in the context of this thread, a reasonable person -- a person who wasn't spoiling for a fight, or determined to take everything in the worst possible light -- would read something like this:

No free speech, promotion of slander (or is it libel when you film written lies?) against a group that doesn't agree with you, and using the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith. Gotta love those Christian values.

And understand that skeptigirl was referring to the specific Christians who were responsible for the video that's the subject of the thread, and what their specific actions reveal about their own personal "Christian values."
 
Not really. She was commenting on what was depicted in the film.

Nope. Look at post #38: She makes it clear that she is talking about all Christians.

The loudest christians seem to have those "Christian values" while the moderate majority silently turn a blind eye.

Or, maybe, they don't have those values at all.

It's not bigotry to not like the bigots.

Do you think all Muslims are terrorists?

10 commandments, read them. The bible has plenty of anti-free speech "laws."

How are these commandments:

You shall not murder.

You shall not commit adultery.

You shall not steal.

You shall not bear false witness against your neighbour.

against free speech?

If a Christian happens to value free speech, that's fine, but that doesn't make freedom of speech a Christian value. Freedom of speech is a secular value that just happens to have been adopted by many Christians. Of course, many of those same Christians seem to change their minds if that speech "offends" them.

Maybe. But that doesn't make the rest think the same.
 
Thaiboxerken beat me to it (I only just read this thread); I think you've misunderstood the point that skeptigirl was making, Claus.

Anyway, having checked the film out on IMBD, it seems some things don't change; there is a character called The Goat...
 
You know, in the context of this thread, a reasonable person -- a person who wasn't spoiling for a fight, or determined to take everything in the worst possible light -- would read something like this:



And understand that skeptigirl was referring to the specific Christians who were responsible for the video that's the subject of the thread, and what their specific actions reveal about their own personal "Christian values."

Exactly. It was a light hearted thread where atheists got to laugh at the way Christians have promoted a "fear of atheists" while turning a blind eye to how very unethical their own actions are in doing so. It's an old story... and funny. It's funny the way propaganda was used (and still is) to make people fear atheists and the way the holier than thou are blind to their own less than savory behavior in promoting this prejudice. The video provided giggle worthy irony being enjoyed by people on a thread who have, on occasion, been victims of the bigotry in the video (even on a skeptics forum).

Just as in the video, the things an outspoken atheist or religious critic says is inculcated with dire meaning and words that were not said by the apologists and vigilantes and holier-than- thou in an attempt to spread such bigotry while blinding themselves to the fact that their own words are more offensive than the people they criticize.

Who the heck or what are they defending and why does it need defending any more than people need to defend against the godless girl in the video?

Why are some people so eager to wrongly accuse others of "raining on other peoples' parade" while raining on other peoples' parade?
 
Thaiboxerken beat me to it (I only just read this thread); I think you've misunderstood the point that skeptigirl was making, Claus.

Anyway, having checked the film out on IMBD, it seems some things don't change; there is a character called The Goat...

You mean it wasn't a joke? I thought maybe this was only made to look like an old movie and well done at that.

Will wonders never cease?
 
Why are some people so eager to wrongly accuse others of "raining on other peoples' parade" while raining on other peoples' parade?

To be fair, though, when a nutcase implies that my sarcasm is the result of demonic possession, I don't really feel as though my parade has been rained on. More like my cake has been frosted.

OTOH, when I say (or rather, imply by my position; I'd never say something so unnecessary to anyone grieving) "The loved one who died will not be waiting for you in heaven," THAT can be a downer.
 
Last edited:
That really made me want to see the whole movie. Shame it can't be found online, like a lot of other silent movies. At least, I didn't find it.
 
That really made me want to see the whole movie. Shame it can't be found online, like a lot of other silent movies. At least, I didn't find it.
I didn't find it online (yet) either, but what a lot of fascinating trivia there is at
this site. Some excerpts:

THE GODLESS GIRL, a story about atheism in high school and sadism in reform school, [was based] on fact.

The film’s high school “Godless Society” was partly inspired by a controversy that broke out at Hollywood High School in 1927 when American Association for the Advancement of Atheism flyers were found in student lockers. The ringleader of the Godless Society, played by Lina Basquette, was loosely based on Queen Silver, a precocious agitator from Los Angeles, who at the age of 12 wrote a pamphlet on evolution that came to national attention during the “Scopes Monkey Trial.”

Pathé released the silent version of THE GODLESS GIRL in August 1928 to lackluster business. By early winter, the distributor recognized that silent films had little chance of finding an audience during the “all-talking” picture craze and withdrew the film. Pathé attempted to revitalize the movie by tacking on dialogue scenes, a process known as “goat gland.” Goat gland took its name from a surgical procedure developed around 1920 by quack doctor J.R. Brinkley, who implanted goat testes into humans as a way to cure maladies such as impotence, arteriosclerosis, and dementia.

In the Soviet Union, the film became an unexpected success when Soviet distributor Sovkino “remontaged” the film by pulling out the last reel, in which the Godless Girl finds redemption, so that the picture played as celebration of atheism among American youth. DeMille claimed that when he visited the Soviet Union in 1931, he was hailed as a national hero for having made the film. In Germany, the movie attracted many admirers, including an aspiring politician named Adolph Hitler, who sent a fan letter to Lina Basquette. According to Basquette, by 1937, Hitler, Joseph Goebbels, and Leni Riefenstahl wanted to groom the American actress to become UFA’s biggest star. However, this plan was quickly abandoned after Basquette kneed the monorchid Führer in the groin when he made an unwelcome pass at her during a visit to his Berghof Alpine retreat.

For many years the film was projected silent, sans the goat gland scenes. However, the UCLA Film and TV Archive preserved the film with its grafted-on dialogue scenes, ensuring that the movie could be seen in all its part-talkie glory. The goat gland version is a poignant illustration of the aesthetic and technical problems that arose during the conversion from silence to sound, as the film moves from the dynamic editing and staging of the reformatory fire sequence to the inert and banal talking conclusion. With its peculiar mix of silent and talking scenes, fundamentalism and atheism, innocence and sadism, moralizing and decadence, THE GODLESS GIRL is a film oddity worthy of appreciation.
Now I want to see the whole thing. I wonder how hard it is to screen it at UCLA.
 
You shall not murder.

You shall not commit adultery.

You shall not steal.

You shall not bear false witness against your neighbour.
against free speech?.

How convenient that these where left out of your list:
I am the Lord your god, You shall have no other gods before me.
You shall not make graven images.
You shall not take the Lord's name in vain.
Those hardly seem friendly to the notions of free speech or freedom of religion for that matter.

Here's more... ahem... "commentary" on free expression found in the Bible so beloved by Christians:

13:6 If thy brother, the son of thy mother, or thy son, or thy daughter, or the wife of thy bosom, or thy friend, which is as thine own soul, entice thee secretly, saying, Let us go and serve other gods, which thou hast not known, thou, nor thy fathers;
13:7 Namely, of the gods of the people which are round about you, nigh unto thee, or far off from thee, from the one end of the earth even unto the other end of the earth;
13:8 Thou shalt not consent unto him, nor hearken unto him; neither shall thine eye pity him, neither shalt thou spare, neither shalt thou conceal him:
13:9 But thou shalt surely kill him; thine hand shall be first upon him to put him to death, and afterwards the hand of all the people.
13:10 And thou shalt stone him with stones, that he die; because he hath sought to thrust thee away from the LORD thy God, which brought thee out of the land of Egypt, from the house of bondage.
13:11 And all Israel shall hear, and fear, and shall do no more any such wickedness as this is among you.
13:12 If thou shalt hear say in one of thy cities, which the LORD thy God hath given thee to dwell there, saying,
13:13 Certain men, the children of Belial, are gone out from among you, and have withdrawn the inhabitants of their city, saying, Let us go and serve other gods, which ye have not known;
If you hear of a city where another god is worshiped, then destroy everyone in the city (even the cattle) and burn it down.
13:14 Then shalt thou enquire, and make search, and ask diligently; and, behold, if it be truth, and the thing certain, that such abomination is wrought among you;
13:15 Thou shalt surely smite the inhabitants of that city with the edge of the sword, destroying it utterly, and all that is therein, and the cattle thereof, with the edge of the sword.

Deuteronomy 13: 6-15
 
Last edited:
That's interesting. We saw the version without the redemption and it doesn't really seem like a celebration of atheism amongst American godless youth to me. It seems like a weird propaganda piece about what people imagine atheists are like...

Of course it's true... I would never high hat a monkey and I have no desire for Christmas presents.

Now that I think of it, I suppose that most youth would find godless girl more attractive a role model than Bozo Johnson and the priggish anti-free speech school administration. So I guess it could be used as a "pro atheism" piece although intended as a "beware of atheists" piece. I'd like a full screening too. Interesting. I wonder if the actress really kneed the guy in the groin and how much of the above history is accurate?

(Suddenly I feel so proud of being a godless girl.)
 
Now that I think of it, I suppose that most youth would find godless girl more attractive a role model than Bozo Johnson and the priggish anti-free speech school administration. So I guess it could be used as a "pro atheism" piece although intended as a "beware of atheists" piece. I'd like a full screening too. Interesting. I wonder if the actress really kneed the guy in the groin and how much of the above history is accurate?

(Suddenly I feel so proud of being a godless girl.)


Heh... I think we've found atheism's "Reefer MadnessWP."
 
Heh... I think we've found atheism's "Reefer MadnessWP."


Yes... but I think that people are more afraid of atheists than of reefer users in present days. It appears that users of illegal substances are more electable than atheists.

All the more reason to giggle at propaganda. I look forward to a day when most Americans would see "godless girl" as on par with "reefer madness" in regards to fear mongering propaganda. Humor may be the best best tool we have at raising consciousness. Plus, I think "don't high hat the monkey" makes a great meme.
 
Yes... but I think that people are more afraid of atheists than of reefer users in present days. It appears that users of illegal substances are more electable than atheists.

Only if they recant the horrendous, unspeakable, "crime" of smoking a joint or two at a Grateful Dead concert back in 1974. They also have to make sure they credit JEZZ-us with their "rehabilitation" from their "addiction." (I remember my anti-drug education classes back in middle school that reminded me that "ALL use is ABUSE.")
 
Only if they recant the horrendous, unspeakable, "crime" of smoking a joint or two at a Grateful Dead concert back in 1974. They also have to make sure they credit JEZZ-us with their "rehabilitation" from their "addiction." (I remember my anti-drug education classes back in middle school that reminded me that "ALL use is ABUSE.")

Yes, it bothers me too... I think kids need information about what drugs are the most likely to destroy your life and which ones aren't. Lumping in everything together just means that you lose credibility as a source once one of your fears is shown to be overblown and unfounded. As a young teen I thought pot smokers were on par with thieves or other "bad guys". I'm sure I had prejudices and fears regarding atheists too.

I think a lot of adults have a childish view of athiesm.
 
Yes, it bothers me too... I think kids need information about what drugs are the most likely to destroy your life and which ones aren't. Lumping in everything together just means that you lose credibility as a source once one of your fears is shown to be overblown and unfounded. As a young teen I thought pot smokers were on par with thieves or other "bad guys". I'm sure I had prejudices and fears regarding atheists too.

Oh, I know I used to have hard core prejudices toward atheists as anyone raised on a steady diet of pre-Vatican II Catholicism and Rush Limbaugh would. I was no better than DOC or Plumjam from my teens up to the early 20s. I even used many of the same lame brain arguments like accusing atheists of being in league with communists/Nazis. I never thought that I'd ever become one.

As for my view on drug use: When I was a kid, I opined that the U.S. should institute Singapore's policy toward anyone caught with illegal drugs: A public hanging. Why? Well, my parents and teachers told me that drugs where BAD. These days, I advocate the complete legalization or, at least, the decriminalization of drugs. Again, who'd have thought?

How many quarter bags of pot have I smoked, or lines of coke have I done? Not a one. I confess I'm curious about marijuana, but I'd rather not run afoul of any drug tests that might come my way. When it comes to drugs, the worst you can say is that I'm a caffeine freak (like any other self-respecting nerd) while the one or two cigars I treat myself to every few months or so make me a tobacco fiend.

I'm so ashamed... oh wait, no I'm not.

I think a lot of adults have a childish view of athiesm.

It's funny since many people I know love to equate religious belief with maturity. My younger sister seems to take my atheism as part of some childish rebellion that I'll eventually grow out of. "Mark will come back to God his own way" she tells my father whenever he complains about my willful lack of religiosity.

This from people who think that Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny, and the Tooth Fairy--all having as much credibility as Yahweh, Jehovah, or Allah-- are for "kids."
 
Last edited:
My history mirror yours in many ways. I am ever surprised by people who seemed to be as uninterested in religion as I was in my teens... (such as my siblings) who have returned to it.

Once I wasn't forced to go to church, I didn't go, and I slowly lost any faith I had over the years... I can't make sense out of the people who go back. They must have been "rebelling"... whereas me, I just couldn't make sense of it and eventually realized I didn't believe any of it...

They must "believe" it on some level and I want to probe exactly what it is they believe, but they get defensive and accusatory of me, so I just avoid the topic. I want to know, though, if they believe in devils and transubstantiation and "original sin" and all that stuff. It's just so mythological to me. I don't even think they KNOW what they believe... they've just learned to say they believe and not ask questions because they think it's "right" or "good" or "humble" to do so or at least say as much.
 
....And understand that skeptigirl was referring to the specific Christians who were responsible for the video that's the subject of the thread, and what their specific actions reveal about their own personal "Christian values."
To be fair to Claus, though I don't know why it matters, the exchange in post 38 was:
CFLarsen:Nice stereotyping.

Some Christians might think that way. But don't claim that "Christian values" in general are against free speech, or any of the other things. All Christians are not the same as Jack Chick either.

We don't fight bigots by becoming bigots.


Skeptigirl: Right, we're all going to he!! for not believing in the Christian god and you try to tell me I've stereotyped Christian values.

Of course, believe in the Christian god and get a reward for believing, go to heaven.

All Christian churches are houses of propaganda. Do you know of any that are offering people a choice of beliefs?

The only difference is in degree.
But to clarify what I have said here, though it never seems to matter to Claus if one elaborates on a post,...

Is it not a Christian tenet that non-believers go to hell? And is it not a Christian tenet that one is supposed to believe in the one and only "true God"?

How is that not supposed to apply to all Christians?

Note I have not said Christians are bad people, nor have I said they are all hateful or anything along those lines of accusation.

There are good people and bad people in this world and I'm inclined to believe religion has nothing to do with it one way or the other. But the actual Christian religion is one claiming they have the exclusive path to heaven and there is torment for those who don't follow it. That's a pretty disgusting message. Christians don't see it that way because they aren't looking at that message objectively. They have all these slogans tied in with their beliefs about God is love and so on. The claims do not match the text.


On another note:
In the film, the kid who resists does so when the thought of losing out on Christmas presents is too much of a sacrifice for him. That is so incredibly ironic you'd could suspect an atheist slipped a secret message into the plot and the Christians didn't notice.
 
Last edited:
How convenient that these where left out of your list:

I didn't leave out anything. I asked for Christian values that were against free speech, to which thaiboxerken answered "The 10 commandments". I then pointed out that at least 4 of them have nothing to do with that.

Those hardly seem friendly to the notions of free speech or freedom of religion for that matter.

The same notions apply to e.g. Muslims: I doubt that Muslims would accept that they are really holding Christian values.

Here's more... ahem... "commentary" on free expression found in the Bible so beloved by Christians:

You know as well as I that Christians pick and choose the parts in the bible that they find appealing. Therefore, it is not fair to Joanie the Christian to criticize her for thinking that gays should be stoned, if that is a part which she does not believe in.



To be fair to Claus, though I don't know why it matters, the exchange in post 38 was:But to clarify what I have said here, though it never seems to matter to Claus if one elaborates on a post,...

Is it not a Christian tenet that non-believers go to hell? And is it not a Christian tenet that one is supposed to believe in the one and only "true God"?

How is that not supposed to apply to all Christians?

Note I have not said Christians are bad people, nor have I said they are all hateful or anything along those lines of accusation.

There are good people and bad people in this world and I'm inclined to believe religion has nothing to do with it one way or the other. But the actual Christian religion is one claiming they have the exclusive path to heaven and there is torment for those who don't follow it. That's a pretty disgusting message. Christians don't see it that way because they aren't looking at that message objectively. They have all these slogans tied in with their beliefs about God is love and so on. The claims do not match the text.


On another note:
In the film, the kid who resists does so when the thought of losing out on Christmas presents is too much of a sacrifice for him. That is so incredibly ironic you'd could suspect an atheist slipped a secret message into the plot and the Christians didn't notice.

None of this addresses your claim that Christian values are against free speech.

Ah, well. I'll ask you at TAM. Along with the other questions.
 
Plenty of evidence to show that freedom of speech is actually not a Christian value has been shown. Do you have any evidence to counter that, Clause,?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom