The Godless Girl

That's the greatest line in the entire movie, I've gotta say...did someone mention t-shirts earlier?

Yes, such mention appeared on page one of this very thread... though the image in the photo is a chimp which is an ape and not a monkey...
 

Attachments

  • image.php.jpg
    image.php.jpg
    15.4 KB · Views: 221
Last edited:
a.real.girl at an initiation rite gone awry (she high-hats the monkey).

Now I've been thinking about this photo, and in actuality, I think the monkey is high hatting her. So, perhaps the initiation is going okay after all. We are forbidden from high hatting the monkey, but the monkey is not forbidden from high hatting the humans.

(He's our cousin, you know.)
 
Right, we're all going to he!! for not believing in the Christian god and you try to tell me I've stereotyped Christian values.

Of course, believe in the Christian god and get a reward for believing, go to heaven.

All Christian churches are houses of propaganda. Do you know of any that are offering people a choice of beliefs?

The only difference is in degree.

Maybe you can point out how Christian values are against free speech? For starters.
 
I'm not the one making the claim. The onus is on the claimant: Skeptigirl.

nicely evaded, CF, however on my part blasphemy laws as taught by the christian value system fit as restricting free speech.

I'm asking here beforehand, what would be your refutation of evidence of restricting free speech, should Skeptigirl come up with an example in the future? Surely you have to have evidence that christian values (?) promote free speech?

I'm obviously at liberty to ask what they might be?

I also would consider some argument from the "free will" camp to be invalid. One gives that up when accepting the christian value system, because that "free will" is replaced by "gods will". Even some limitation of free speech is still a limitation, is it not?

I'd like some examples of the promotion of free speech in the christian value system please.

I think the onus is now on you. I also am guessing you can't do it. I'm sure one can find plenty examples of the opposition of free speech, though, and i think you do know what they are. Do you not?
 
nicely evaded, CF, however on my part blasphemy laws as taught by the christian value system fit as restricting free speech.

I'm asking here beforehand, what would be your refutation of evidence of restricting free speech, should Skeptigirl come up with an example in the future? Surely you have to have evidence that christian values (?) promote free speech?

I'm obviously at liberty to ask what they might be?

I also would consider some argument from the "free will" camp to be invalid. One gives that up when accepting the christian value system, because that "free will" is replaced by "gods will". Even some limitation of free speech is still a limitation, is it not?

I'd like some examples of the promotion of free speech in the christian value system please.

I think the onus is now on you. I also am guessing you can't do it. I'm sure one can find plenty examples of the opposition of free speech, though, and i think you do know what they are. Do you not?

There is no evasion - on my part, at least.

You're fairly new on this forum, so you may not understand the importance of this.

If the onus is not on the claimant, then skeptics would have to disprove any claim made. But is that fair? If I said "Astrology works!", "Bush's politics will send the economy to hell" or "Hindus are babykilling cannibal vixens from Atlantis!", then why should you spend any time proving me wrong? I am the one making the claim, so I should definitely be the one providing evidence.

The onus is on the claimant. Always. That's why JREF has the Million Dollar Challenge. That's why it is up to 9-11 "Truthers" to prove who is behind the great conspiracy. That's why it is up to Skeptigirl to provide evidence that Christian values are against free speech.
 
Oh no.... Claus descends on another light hearted thread to try to suck people into the claus vortex-- don't be suck in!

(I suspect he high hats the monkey.)
 
Seriously, let's all just refrain from high-hatting the monkey's drumsticks, okay? Also, the inclusion of the ape face on the monkey t-shirt is intentional, I assure you -- it represents the average creationist's ignorance of evolutionary theory, and also it was the funniest face I could find.
 
Seriously, let's all just refrain from high-hatting the monkey's drumsticks, okay? Also, the inclusion of the ape face on the monkey t-shirt is intentional, I assure you -- it represents the average creationist's ignorance of evolutionary theory, and also it was the funniest face I could find.

Do monkeys have eyelids?
 
There is no evasion - on my part, at least.
You're fairly new on this forum, so you may not understand the importance of this.


If the onus is not on the claimant, then skeptics would have to disprove any claim made. But is that fair? If I said "Astrology works!", "Bush's politics will send the economy to hell" or "Hindus are babykilling cannibal vixens from Atlantis!", then why should you spend any time proving me wrong? I am the one making the claim, so I should definitely be the one providing evidence.
The onus is on the claimant. Always. That's why JREF has the Million Dollar Challenge. That's why it is up to 9-11 "Truthers" to prove who is behind the great conspiracy. That's why it is up to Skeptigirl to provide evidence that Christian values are against free speech.

I understand your not willing to answer what I'm asking.
It would be nicer if you would just decide to enlighten me out of pure curiosity.

If the evidence Skeptigal supplies for Christian values restricting free speech, as in using the example of blasphemy. How would you personally counter that?

Thats something i'm asking you, I'm allowed to ask hypothetical question of you I think?

I'm not sure I need to wait for the actual presentation of the evidence that you are asking for, if I have a related question that you might address.

I'll ask you straight then, is blashemy a restriction on free speech?
Is that admissable to you as evidence in this claim?

If it is or is not, could you say why?

(Actually according to the rules you quote, I think you have to maybe?)
 
Oh no.... Claus descends on another light hearted thread to try to suck people into the claus vortex-- don't be suck in!

(I suspect he high hats the monkey.)

Thanks for the warning.
Its a bit like that Schwarzschild radius thingy you get round black holes.
You can't see it till its got you, sort of thing.

I promise to keep my sense of humour though.
Some one has to keep feeding him too, otherwise we might get bored. well maybe not.

Regards:)
 
Oh no.... Claus descends on another light hearted thread to try to suck people into the claus vortex-- don't be suck in!

(I suspect he high hats the monkey.)

Thank you for confirming that you do not have me on ignore.

I understand your not willing to answer what I'm asking.

It's not an unwillingness. It's not my job to prove Skeptigirl wrong. It's her job to prove herself right.

You really have to understand this.

If the evidence Skeptigal supplies for Christian values restricting free speech, as in using the example of blasphemy. How would you personally counter that?

She would have to show that all Christians see blasphemy as something that should be the law. Good luck with that.

I'm not sure I need to wait for the actual presentation of the evidence that you are asking for, if I have a related question that you might address.

I'll ask you straight then, is blashemy a restriction on free speech?

Of course. There has never been a society where speech wasn't limited in one way or another.

Here's one back:

Do you think that it should be acceptable for anyone to claim that their products can cure everything, without any demands of them actually showing evidence? Just yes or no.
 
It's not an unwillingness. It's not my job to prove Skeptigirl wrong. It's her job to prove herself right.

You really have to understand this.
I do, and await her return to see what happens, and your reply(s). Thank you for the education.

She would have to show that all Christians see blasphemy as something that should be the law. Good luck with that.
Is a (any and all) bible(s) not good enough? Is that not the source of christian values, perhaps , being a newbie, I've not under stood that perhaps..

Of course. There has never been a society where speech wasn't limited in one way or another.
Thats not the point, if blasphemy is then a restriction on free speech and verified as such by your good self now as permissable evidence (yes?), then if Skeptigal uses that as evidence now then surely you have to concede to the evidence (as in the mdc, and according to you?) possibly.

You missed off the "by a religion" on the end, maybe?:)

Here's one back:

Do you think that it should be acceptable for anyone to claim that their products can cure everything,
Yes
without any demands of them actually showing evidence? Just yes or no.
No

Any good?, (A prime example of an attempt at a restriction of freedom of speech. Yes/no...., are you not shooting yourself in the foot here?)
 
Last edited:
Maybe you can point out how Christian values are against free speech? For starters.
Some Christians have some values that are against free speech. In this old thread, I discussed this with some of the Christian members of my family who had sent me an e-mail that said:
It is said that 86% of Americans believe in God. Therefore I have a very hard time understanding why there is such a mess about having "In God We Trust" on our money and having God in the Pledge of Allegiance. Why don't we just tell the 14% to Sit Down and SHUT UP!!!
After discussion, they agreed that they didn't really mean that atheists shouldn't have free speech, but whoever wrote and forwarded this very popular piece of spam certainly advocated the removal of free speech rights for non-Christians.

I wouldn't say, though, that it is a common theme with Christians, though many might agree with it if presented as a sound bite.
 
Last edited:
An example of Christian virtues that would suppress free speech if laws were based on the Bible. Just for Claus.

1 Timothy 2:12 said:
But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence.


Tricky, if you make any comment about women and "be in silence" . . .
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom