The Godless Girl

Originally Posted by 1 Timothy 2:12
But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence.

Tell me that one to my face, and there'll be suffering all right.:D
 
Is a (any and all) bible(s) not good enough? Is that not the source of christian values, perhaps , being a newbie, I've not under stood that perhaps..

It is one source of Christian values. There are many other sources, e.g. from Augustin, Calvin, Savonarola, Luther, the many church fathers, the many popes, Grundtvig, and Fred Phelps.

Do they all share exactly the same values? Easy answer: No.

Thats not the point, if blasphemy is then a restriction on free speech and verified as such by your good self now as permissable evidence (yes?), then if Skeptigal uses that as evidence now then surely you have to concede to the evidence (as in the mdc, and according to you?) possibly.

No, because she would still have to show that all Christians support suppression of free speech.

You missed off the "by a religion" on the end, maybe?:)

No, by all Christians. That was Skeptigirl's claim.


There you go. So why should skeptigirl not back up her claims with evidence?

Any good?, (A prime example of an attempt at a restriction of freedom of speech. Yes/no...., are you not shooting yourself in the foot here?)

What do you mean?

Some Christians have some values that are against free speech.


Nobody is saying otherwise.

An example of Christian virtues that would suppress free speech if laws were based on the Bible. Just for Claus.

Emphasis mine.

I'm sure Jack Chick, Fred Phelps and their particular breed of Christians would like this to be the case. But you can't say that this is what all Christians want.
 
Tricky said:
Some Christians have some values that are against free speech.
Nobody is saying otherwise.
Odd, because in post 47, I could have sworn you were asking for examples when you said:
CFLarsen said:
Maybe you can point out how Christian values are against free speech? For starters.
So did you want it pointed out or not?
 
No, by all Christians. That was Skeptigirl's claim.

looking back, where was it that "all" was mentioned in the claim. That's your bit isn't it?

I've gone back over the posts, and it looks to me though you are the claiment. You are the one claiming that the "all" bit exists. In actuality it doesn't seem to.
 
An example of Christian virtues that would suppress free speech if laws were based on the Bible. Just for Claus.

Tricky, if you make any comment about women and "be in silence" . . .


Did somebody say something?
 
Odd, because in post 47, I could have sworn you were asking for examples when you said:

So did you want it pointed out or not?

Keyword: "some".

looking back, where was it that "all" was mentioned in the claim. That's your bit isn't it?

I've gone back over the posts, and it looks to me though you are the claiment. You are the one claiming that the "all" bit exists. In actuality it doesn't seem to.

Let's take a look again:

No free speech, promotion of slander (or is it libel when you film written lies?) against a group that doesn't agree with you, and using the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith. Gotta love those Christian values.

No "some". Just "those Christian values". Everybody in the same pot.

If skeptigirl meant some Christian values, all she had to do is make that clear. But she didn't.
 
Keyword: "some".

Let's take a look again:

No "some". Just "those Christian values". Everybody in the same pot.

If skeptigirl meant some Christian values, all she had to do is make that clear. But she didn't.


"Those" refer to the values, not the Christians.

Did somebody say something?


Right.

1 Thessalonians 5:15 said:
Now we exhort you, brethren, warn them that are unruly, comfort the feebleminded, support the weak, be patient toward all men.


Poor unruly, feebleminded, weak men. :p
 
It'd probably be hard to find any universally held values (in all situations) anyway. Hang on, isn't that what all christians claim to have? Universal values? i must have read that wrong........:rolleyes:
 
Seriously, let's all just refrain from high-hatting the monkey's drumsticks, okay? Also, the inclusion of the ape face on the monkey t-shirt is intentional, I assure you -- it represents the average creationist's ignorance of evolutionary theory, and also it was the funniest face I could find.

Plus, She looks like it's wearing lipstick... very chic...
Who would high hat an ape or monkey with lipstick? Not I.
 
In my observations (aaack I'm being sucked into the vortex....) Christians are big on free speech for themselves but not for those who believe differently. They would like the atheists to shut up. They want their Nativity Scenes on public property, but they'll destroy symbols of other belief systems beside them. They want the right to praise Jesus at School but not let believers of Allah do the same. They want freedom of speech to praise God at every turn and blame secularism etc. for the worlds ills, but they want to silence those who praise other deities or speak out against the nonsense sputtered by Christians.

Evidence? See DOC.
 
Last edited:
So you are looking for universally held Christian values? I submit that you will be hard pressed to find any of these.

Actually, that's Skeptigirl's job.

"Those" refer to the values, not the Christians.

Values held by Christians.

In my observations (aaack I'm being sucked into the vortex....) Christians are big on free speech for themselves but not for those who believe differently. They would like the atheists to shut up. They want their Nativity Scenes on [ublic property, but symbols of other belief systems--they'll destroy them. They want the right to praise Jesus at School but not Allah. They want freedom of speech to praise Jesus at every turn and blame secularism etc. for the worlds ills but they want to silence those who praise other deities or speak out against the nonsense sputtered by Christians. Evidence? See DOC.

If you have only met that type of Christians, you need to broaden your horizon quite a bit.
 
i thought there might be a catch......the soviet export version is better IMO......
 
"High Hat Monkey." Good name for a band. Or a sock puppet.

Or a pope of the one (and only, really) true woo variety?

Lucian Pulvermacher of the One True Woo Catholic Church
Earl Pulvermacher was born into a Roman Catholic family; three of his brothers became priests. In 1942, at the age of 24, he joined the Capuchin Order, taking the religious name Lucian.

The True Catholic Church papal election

Until his election, Pulvermacher was a sedevacantist, believing that the Holy See has been vacant since the death of Pope Pius XII in 1958. He argues that Pope John XXIII was ineligible, as he supposedly had become a Freemason in 1935 - an act punishable by automatic excommunication under canon law. Pulvermacher also maintains that none of John XXIII's successors (Paul VI, John Paul I, John Paul II and Benedict XVI) have been true Catholics, and that they have all hence been ineligible for the papacy. In contrast to other sedevacantists he argued that the remnant faithful could elect a new legitimate pope, apart from Rome or the college of the cardinals.

<snip/>

His episcopal consecration, held on 4 July 1999 in a hotel ballroom, was attended by 28 people.

I hope, for his sake, that size doesn't matter

:mdance: :monkeyr: :mdance: :monkeyr: :mdance: :monkeyr: :mdance: :monkeyr:
_______________________​



Thinking it might be one of those 'too good to be true' stories, I had a quick Google...
Google: Results 1 - 10 of about 205 for "Lucian Pulvermacher" "True Catholic" capuchin.

Results 1 - 10 of about 135,000 for Catholic capuchin

:monkey:
 
Last edited:
Nice stereotyping.

Not really. She was commenting on what was depicted in the film.

Some Christians might think that way. But don't claim that "Christian values" in general are against free speech, or any of the other things. All Christians are not the same as Jack Chick either.

The loudest christians seem to have those "Christian values" while the moderate majority silently turn a blind eye.

We don't fight bigots by becoming bigots.

It's not bigotry to not like the bigots.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom