The Godless Girl

I see what you're saying. How much hair does someone have to lack before they can be described as bald or how many grains of sand can you remove before you can no longer talk about a "pile"? It's the same semantic issue we came up against in the epic "Should skeptics, by definition, be atheists?" thread.

I wouldn't be surprised to find particular Christian groups who would agree with a definition including such tenets and say "unless you believe in the things we do, you cannot call yourself a Christian", but I think we're in "No true Scotsman" territory here, more so, if one starts insisting on particular interpretations of certain concepts such as hell or original sin.

Judging by the various beliefs of those who call themselves Christians, I think any useful definition would need to be a broad enough an umbrella to cover as many as possible, while still actually carrying some kind of meaning. The original "follower of Christ" definition is pretty good even if it does leave a big gap of what that might actually entail.

Defining "Christianity" would probably need to include core doctrine, but again I don't think such a definition could be particularly specific on much of it and would almost certainly need to include some "usually" or "commonly" distinctions if it is to go into any detail.

The main point here is to be careful when ascribing beliefs to others based your own perception and understanding. In the same way that atheists tend not to like being told by theists what their actual beliefs are, I think you'd find a sufficient number of Christians who would object to your take on what they must believe to call themselves "Christian". There's a pretty good chance that if your version sounds immoral to you that it may also sound immoral to them too, and probably is a distortion of what they actually believe.
I'm having a bit of a hard time with all the rationalizing that Christians don't have to believe Jesus died for their sins and believing in Jesus gets you into heaven, not believing leaves you out. Could any of you professing these are not the core tenets of Christianity cite a Christian sect that does not claim these tenets? Arguing these are not core tenets leaves me at a loss. What the hell are you all talking about?

eta. btw. I pretty much agreed with what you were saying before if you were specifically referring to how the film could be seen to be portraying Christian values.
Here, I understand where you are coming from. Individually, especially given that this film is half a century out of date, I understand why you wouldn't want this film to represent Christian beliefs. I agree and never meant to imply the film was representative of Christian beliefs.

What I am saying, however, is the people calling themselves Christians who don't necessarily have such bad values, block out the fact that the claim one must believe in Jesus or go to hell is at the core of their beliefs.

This point is getting lost in Claus's total lack of understanding of what I'm saying. So forget that interpretation for a moment and consider a person who would never send someone to hell if they had to choose, and who goes about their merry religious way with the concept that the god they believe in is loving, merciful, and so on. This is a common Christian mentality. They've put in the back of their mind the significance of their religious beliefs. The factual version is believe as I do or go to hell. The conscious version is the Christian god is loving and merciful. It is an incredible contradiction.

The same mentality surrounds Bible stories. Lot was a good man, the Christian version of the story goes. The factual version, not considered by the Christian is this is a horrendous story. Lot would throw his virgin daughters to a mob to rape because custom is the stranger visiting should be protected. Lot's wife is doomed for the most minor disobedience when disobedience, if you consider sin disobedience is commonplace. Lot has an incestuous relationship with his daughters and the Biblical version is it is their fault.

God excuses invasion and conquering of the Amelkites' land and the slaughter of animals and children alike. Except of course, virgin women can be had as sex slaves. Again, this is seen as a wonderful story of God's people conquering sinners.

The Bible is full of this crap. Yet Christians are oblivious and repeat the stories as if the stories are wonderful examples of a loving god. Something doesn't click. The reality of the actual story or religious tenet is thought of in some bizarre glossy peachy keen way. The reality is unseen by the Christian.

I don't have an issue believing there are plenty of Christians who are good people. I do have an issue that they are oblivious to the real implications of their core Biblical religious tenets.
 
I'm having a bit of a hard time with all the rationalizing that Christians don't have to believe Jesus died for their sins and believing in Jesus gets you into heaven, not believing leaves you out. Could any of you professing these are not the core tenets of Christianity cite a Christian sect that does not claim these tenets? Arguing these are not core tenets leaves me at a loss. What the hell are you all talking about?

Try wrapping your mind around the fact that "Christianity" is not a monolithic belief system where all Christians believe the same things. Why, even in the Creationist camp, there are many different beliefs of how Creation happened.

I know it is far, far easier to try and shoot down religious people by firing at what you call their "core tenets", but your aim is way off unless you criticize people for what they actually believe in, and not what you want them to believe in.

Here, I understand where you are coming from. Individually, especially given that this film is half a century out of date, I understand why you wouldn't want this film to represent Christian beliefs. I agree and never meant to imply the film was representative of Christian beliefs.

If you can acknowledge that this particular group of Christians don't share their beliefs with the rest of them, why do you keep bringing up one example after another to emphasize how Christians as a group have such atrocious beliefs?

You have your white crow right there.

What I am saying, however, is the people calling themselves Christians who don't necessarily have such bad values, block out the fact that the claim one must believe in Jesus or go to hell is at the core of their beliefs.

This point is getting lost in Claus's total lack of understanding of what I'm saying. So forget that interpretation for a moment and consider a person who would never send someone to hell if they had to choose, and who goes about their merry religious way with the concept that the god they believe in is loving, merciful, and so on. This is a common Christian mentality. They've put in the back of their mind the significance of their religious beliefs. The factual version is believe as I do or go to hell. The conscious version is the Christian god is loving and merciful. It is an incredible contradiction.

No, no, no. The Christian god is loving and merciful - he just isn't particularly friendly towards those who don't believe in him. He is also fickle and downright nasty, even to those who do believe in him.

However, that isn't something particular to Christian beliefs - as I keep telling you, but you don't want to acknowledge this.

The same mentality surrounds Bible stories. Lot was a good man, the Christian version of the story goes. The factual version, not considered by the Christian is this is a horrendous story. Lot would throw his virgin daughters to a mob to rape because custom is the stranger visiting should be protected. Lot's wife is doomed for the most minor disobedience when disobedience, if you consider sin disobedience is commonplace. Lot has an incestuous relationship with his daughters and the Biblical version is it is their fault.

God excuses invasion and conquering of the Amelkites' land and the slaughter of animals and children alike. Except of course, virgin women can be had as sex slaves. Again, this is seen as a wonderful story of God's people conquering sinners.

The Bible is full of this crap. Yet Christians are oblivious and repeat the stories as if the stories are wonderful examples of a loving god. Something doesn't click. The reality of the actual story or religious tenet is thought of in some bizarre glossy peachy keen way. The reality is unseen by the Christian.

I don't have an issue believing there are plenty of Christians who are good people. I do have an issue that they are oblivious to the real implications of their core Biblical religious tenets.

Here you go again, stereotyping Christians. What do you know what Christians - and you keep referring to them as a homogeneous group - are oblivious to?

Do Christians in America support the First Amendment, yes or no?

Which came first, the tenets or the people believing in them?

What invalid assumptions were you talking about in post #119?
 
I'm having a bit of a hard time with all the rationalizing that Christians don't have to believe Jesus died for their sins and believing in Jesus gets you into heaven, not believing leaves you out. Could any of you professing these are not the core tenets of Christianity cite a Christian sect that does not claim these tenets? Arguing these are not core tenets leaves me at a loss. What the hell are you all talking about?

I think it would be fair to say that a majority Christians probably would cite what you are saying here as core Christian tenets (although "leaves you out" carries a slightly different connotation to how they would put it), but you have left out the hell and original sin parts from what you were saying earlier. That said, the third Wiki link in my last post demonstrates that there are Christians who don't share all those tenets. Some believe Christ's sacrifice pays for sin no matter whether you believe it and some believe that belief alone is not sufficient.

As far as the hell part goes (and I guess for Lot's wife), I'm not sure what you are claiming as immoral. How is saving people from hell (whatever "hell" might refer to) or warning people against an action that will kill them any less moral than a parent warning a child not to touch a hot oven?
 
All I know is, everybody was having a good time making fun of a silly movie with a funny monkey in it, and then somebody came along and decided to get offended on behalf of a rather large group of people who, in my experience, are generally capable of speaking up on their own behalf, and the next thing you know people are arguing about theology and quoting dictionaries at each other and the whole thing's just tedious and unpleasant.


I guess what I'm saying is, I miss the monkey.
 
All I know is, everybody was having a good time making fun of a silly movie with a funny monkey in it, and then somebody came along and decided to get offended on behalf of a rather large group of people who, in my experience, are generally capable of speaking up on their own behalf, and the next thing you know people are arguing about theology and quoting dictionaries at each other and the whole thing's just tedious and unpleasant.


I guess what I'm saying is, I miss the monkey.

Uh Oh! Caught red handed, hi-hattting the monkey! :yikes:
 
I'll quit feeding the monkeys. No sense in ruining the thread when the discussion over what are the core tenets of Christianity is hardly something I care to debate anyway.

I'll just let the accusations I'm a hateful biased atheist stand. It isn't that I would be changing any opinions of me with this discussion anyway. I think most people knew what I meant from the beginning.
 
They did.

And we are all learning about the people on this forum who have been influenced by this nutty bias where everything an atheist says is twisted so as to find something shrill or militant and anything bad done in the name of faith is excused away as not "really" having anything to do with faith.

It's a knee jerk response that faith has inculcated upon the masses to protect itself.

I think the video was funny, because it was hyperbole... though at the time it wasn't... showing exactly how this is done by faith. They train the minds of the masses to see everything good as related to god and everything having to do with lack of belief in god as arrogant, hedonistic, and evil.

Even the benign and rather cute phrase about high hatting the monkey was presented like it was a shocking thing to say... like people are "evil" to acknowledge their shared ancestry with other primates. I think that is hilarious. But clearly the propaganda ripples live on in the minds of the indoctrinated and the churches across the world.
 
I'm not sure about "every atheist", arti, but Claus seems to look hard for an opposing position to everything I post where he joins the conversation.

I think the movie was great because there are so many from that time period where propaganda was so tempting to people they put this really blatant stuff together. Think of the mindset of the people making these films. They were out to spread their messages far and wide. You can almost see them drooling over the possibilities they were now going to correct all the things in the world they were paranoid about.
 
I'll quit feeding the monkeys.

"...feeding the monkeys"?

Tsk, tsk....what's that, now? Name calling, instead of intelligent discourse?

No sense in ruining the thread when the discussion over what are the core tenets of Christianity is hardly something I care to debate anyway.

But the core tenets of Christianity is pivotal to your argument about Christians.

I'll just let the accusations I'm a hateful biased atheist stand. It isn't that I would be changing any opinions of me with this discussion anyway. I think most people knew what I meant from the beginning.

Who has accused you of being a hateful biased atheist? This isn't about your stand as an atheist. This is about your lack of ability to present a coherent, sound argument.

They did.

And we are all learning about the people on this forum who have been influenced by this nutty bias where everything an atheist says is twisted so as to find something shrill or militant and anything bad done in the name of faith is excused away as not "really" having anything to do with faith.

It's a knee jerk response that faith has inculcated upon the masses to protect itself.

I think the video was funny, because it was hyperbole... though at the time it wasn't... showing exactly how this is done by faith. They train the minds of the masses to see everything good as related to god and everything having to do with lack of belief in god as arrogant, hedonistic, and evil.

Even the benign and rather cute phrase about high hatting the monkey was presented like it was a shocking thing to say... like people are "evil" to acknowledge their shared ancestry with other primates. I think that is hilarious. But clearly the propaganda ripples live on in the minds of the indoctrinated and the churches across the world.

I'm not sure about "every atheist", arti, but Claus seems to look hard for an opposing position to everything I post where he joins the conversation.

I think the movie was great because there are so many from that time period where propaganda was so tempting to people they put this really blatant stuff together. Think of the mindset of the people making these films. They were out to spread their messages far and wide. You can almost see them drooling over the possibilities they were now going to correct all the things in the world they were paranoid about.

Don't be so quick to label yourselves as persecuted victims of your atheist convictions.
 
I've seen the whole film now, and it's about intolerance on both sides, atheist and zealot. Treasures From American Film Archives III includes it, with commentary from DeMille's grandaughter and a film historian. Amazon has it here, along with lots of other things I haven't watched. If you're in the Los Angeles area, you can rent the single DVD containing this film (128 minutes) from Vidiots in Santa Monica for a few dollars.
 
Wow, thanks for the info, boko. My library has it. Think I'll check it out.


I put a hold on it. They'll call me in a day or so. :D
 
Last edited:
The film as a whole is really more about the horrors of early-20th century reform school than about religion, but the religious conflict bookends it.

The beauty of nature convinces Atheist Girl that "there must be something more out there," so she becomes a believer and marries the (now tolerant) zealot, and they live happily ever after.

According to the notes, De Mille shot 40 feet of film for every foot that appears in the final cut. He was no Hitchcock, and it's hard to stay engaged in this work as entertainment for the full two hours, though it still has historical interest for students of film. The line "I'll ... be ... back" appears here, half a century before the Terminator.
 
just in time for xmas

Red light Rudolf! Deep six the Grinch! Let's get the god back in egg nog...d.
Turner Classic Movies to air The Godless Girl, this Sunday [Dec 14], 9 PM Pacific Time.

Yes a timeless yuletide tale of atheist folly, fundamentalist rage and reform school sadism reconciled by faith in Christ. Hitler loved this movie*, and now you can too! (if you get TCM)

*He wrote lead actress Lina Basquette a fan letter in 1929; eight years and 1 reichstag later he would invite her to his alpine bachelor pad in Berchtesgaden. After some wining and dining, the lovestruck nazi godman made his passion play, to which the rosy apple of his eye responded with a swift sharp knee to Der Fuhrer's testicle. She later said of her number one fan: "Maybe if I hadn't been so fastidious I could have changed history; but, oh, that body odor of his! and unspeakable flatulence..." Always giving, that guy. Now if that's not the true spirit of the season, I don't know what is.

Hoo-hah for the Godless Girl (and don't even think about hi-hattin' that darn monkey)! :monkey2:

p.s. any members of skepchick.org please pass this on, as some there might be interested too.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the heads up. Watching it now.

I'm not sure that more of the movie helps to make it any clearer, but women's prison cat fights! Rowr! I'd swear I saw some ankle, too!

You almost make me believe this stuff works - when I see how white you are!
Emphasis in the original.
 
I just noticed that this will be showing on TCM tomorrow morning at 6 AM on the east coast, and an even more godless 3 AM here in Gomorrah.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom