The Godless Girl

Christianity has a couple major tenets. They are inherent in the beliefs which make up the religious beliefs. They come from the Bible. They are the core beliefs of the religion. They exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs. They include

* There is one god
* The concept of original sin
* Jesus died for those sins
* Believing in Jesus is the only way to go to heaven
* Not believing in Jesus means you go to hell

You tell me what makes a person a Christian? Which Christians don't believe in Jesus, original sin, one god, heaven, and hell? Those are the things which Christians pretty much universally believe in. Some Christians have watered down versions of what hell is. Otherwise they all believe in those major core tenets.

What I am saying is that on the face of it, those tenets are terrible. To have one of the core tenets of your belief being that those who don't believe what you do go to hell while at the same time claiming you believe in a loving peaceful god who really doesn't ask too much of people is to ignore the fact your religion has these immoral core tenets.

You seem to think the people are the religion. They are on one level. But on another level are these core beliefs and in the case of Christianity, they are terrible.

What you are missing here is I'm not saying these tenets exist in space. It isn't like contemplating if math exists without humans. That's a discussion on a whole other plane than this one. The tenets don't exist in space. But like a corporation exists core religious tenets describe a religious belief system. Regardless of where they exist or if they would exist without the individuals, these tenets still make up the core beliefs a Christian has. Without these beliefs, one is not a Christian. You might believe in gods or follow another religion, but all Christians by definition believe those core tenets. And those corp tenets have an immoral piece Christians can ignore, they can pretend it isn't as bad as it sounds but it is there in the core tenet of every Christian's belief. People who don't believe what they do go to hell.

By definition?

I would call your outlined "tenets" commonly held Christian beliefs, but you could technically still be a Christian and not believe any of those things as you have stated them.

There are actually plenty of Christians who don't believe in hell (at least not the common conception of fire and eternal torture) (WP), there are plenty of differing views on the concept of original sin (WP) and there are Christians who think everyone's going to heaven no matter what they believe or do (WP).
 
I'm going to make a list of replies and pull them out by number as needed. Here's answer #1 in regards to your last demand there:

#1)Your questions are based on invalid assumptions about what has been said. As such, the discussion cannot proceed. It's one of those, "when did you stop beating your husband" category of questions when you ask about something based on a false assumption.

What invalid assumptions?
 
What invalid assumptions?
You clearly misuntersdood the original comment:

No free speech, promotion of slander (or is it libel when you film written lies?) against a group that doesn't agree with you, and using the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith. Gotta love those Christian values.

Nice stereotyping.

Some Christians might think that way. But don't claim that "Christian values" in general are against free speech, or any of the other things. All Christians are not the same as Jack Chick either.

We don't fight bigots by becoming bigots.

Skeptigirl is talking about the values demonstrated by the Christians in the film and by extension those who made it. You might interpret her as saying that those actually are Christian values, or that the comment was ironic, since they are values being demonstrated by Christians which are not in accordance with the teaching of Christ. I think it was actually a combination of the two, which is borne out by skeptigirl's later comments.

And I do understand the point you're trying to make, that we should not stereotype the positions of other groups, and address what they say, and not accuse a broad group of having the failings of a minority, but I don't believe that this is what skeptigirl was doing with her original comment.
 
You clearly misuntersdood the original comment:





Skeptigirl is talking about the values demonstrated by the Christians in the film and by extension those who made it. You might interpret her as saying that those actually are Christian values, or that the comment was ironic, since they are values being demonstrated by Christians which are not in accordance with the teaching of Christ. I think it was actually a combination of the two, which is borne out by skeptigirl's later comments.

And I do understand the point you're trying to make, that we should not stereotype the positions of other groups, and address what they say, and not accuse a broad group of having the failings of a minority, but I don't believe that this is what skeptigirl was doing with her original comment.

Skeptigirl makes it clear in post #38 that she meant all Christians.
 
Skeptigirl makes it clear in post #38 that she meant all Christians.

Do you really think so? So your contention is that skeptigirl believes that all Christians use "the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith"?
 
Do you really think so? So your contention is that skeptigirl believes that all Christians use "the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith"?

It is my contention that she meant that all Christians are against free speech.

Her following posts confirmed that my contention was correct.
 
It is my contention that she meant that all Christians are against free speech.

Her following posts confirmed that my contention was correct.

It was your contention that she meant that Christians stood for the other things, too:

Some Christians might think that way. But don't claim that "Christian values" in general are against free speech, or any of the other things.

(Bold added for emphasis.)

Have you dropped that contention? In what way did you manage to discern that the comment about free speech was different from the one about Christmas presents?
 
It was your contention that she meant that Christians stood for the other things, too:

(Bold added for emphasis.)

Have you dropped that contention? In what way did you manage to discern that the comment about free speech was different from the one about Christmas presents?

(Cough)

Of course, believe in the Christian god and get a reward for believing, go to heaven.

I think it is time for you to read the thread.
 
(Cough)



I think it is time for you to read the thread.
I have read the thread, ta.

So, you are claiming that you knew the reference to Christmas presents in the film was actually a metaphorical reference to going to heaven, and that skeptigirl also used it in that way in her original post?

Assuming, for the moment, that this was the case, are you then saying that it is wrong to state that Christians believe that the reward for belief is going to heaven? Surely that is a pretty universal Christian value?
 
Last edited:
By definition?

I would call your outlined "tenets" commonly held Christian beliefs, but you could technically still be a Christian and not believe any of those things as you have stated them.

There are actually plenty of Christians who don't believe in hell (at least not the common conception of fire and eternal torture) (WP), there are plenty of differing views on the concept of original sin (WP) and there are Christians who think everyone's going to heaven no matter what they believe or do (WP).
Yes, there are a variety of beliefs people who call themselves Christian have, just as some try to define hell as "not having God's love". It's kind of hard to take those versions and say therefore my list is not a list of the major tenets of Christianity. You can call yourself a Buddhist, but if you don't really believe any of the religion or in Buddha, then are you a Buddhist because you call yourself one?

The concept of Jesus is that there was this sin and Jesus died in some sacrifice to pay for the sin. And there is a reward for acknowledging that fact in that you go to heaven for doing so and hell if you don't. You start taking any of that out and you have some modified version of Christianity, but you don't have Christianity. You can call yourself a Christian, but if you make up your own version, at some point it is something else.

To say these aren't the major tenets of Christianity is a stretch. To water down the version of hell is probably still within the limits of Christianity. But even that begins to count the Bible out of the religion. And not believing in one God and at least believing the Bible has something to do with the religious tenets also starts to become a little too far from the actual religion to then claim you are a Christian with this totally modified belief system. Christian in their mind maybe, without the tenets though what do you have? I would say it starts to become something else.
 
Last edited:
It is my contention that she meant that all Christians are against free speech.

Her following posts confirmed that my contention was correct.
Claus, once more for the benefit of zooterkin but with no hope of a different outcome in your thought process, zooterkin is exactly right.

I'm talking about the concepts within the religion. I told you it wasn't about the individual several times. Regardless of your belief one cannot separate the two things, the religious tenets and the believers, I do separate them. And you are taking your belief that you cannot separate the religious tenets from the believers and assuming I am talking about the believers.

The believers are all over the map. I've posted repeatedly how many believers don't have a clue what the Bible actually says. If they don't know what the Bible says, then individually, they can hardly all be real followers of their stated religion.

Post 38
Right, we're all going to he!! for not believing in the Christian god and you try to tell me I've stereotyped Christian values.

Of course, believe in the Christian god and get a reward for believing, go to heaven.

All Christian churches are houses of propaganda. Do you know of any that are offering people a choice of beliefs?

The only difference is in degree.
Meaning they wear their Christian label and speak of love, mercy, kindness, yadda yadda. But here they are oblivious to the actual belief that forms the basis of that religion: "Believe what I believe or go to hell."

I made the point I did about propaganda because the film is a blatant propaganda piece. Common within the Christian church and I'd say also one of the major tenets is go out and convert others to the Christian religion. That is not a free speech value. Supporting the First Amendment to the US Constitution is a separate issue. Letting a Wiccan rave about the wonders of witchcraft at your Christian Church would unlikely be tolerated. Heck, some of them don't tolerate gay preachers. That is not a free speech value.

Again, I can separate the values based within the religious tenets from the people. The fact you cannot see those two things as separate comments does not make my comment about the underlying tenets of the religion a statement about individuals who call themselves Christians. But if they are going to call themselves Christians, there's a good chance they support those tenets to one degree or another. And there's quite a few of them who don't consciously think about what those main tenets really say.
 
I have read the thread, ta.

Clearly not.

So, you are claiming that you knew the reference to Christmas presents in the film was actually a metaphorical reference to going to heaven, and that skeptigirl also used it in that way in her original post?

No.

Yes, there are a variety of beliefs people who call themselves Christian have, just as some try to define hell as "not having God's love". It's kind of hard to take those versions and say therefore my list is not a list of the major tenets of Christianity. You can call yourself a Buddhist, but if you don't really believe any of the religion or in Buddha, then are you a Buddhist because you call yourself one?

The concept of Jesus is that there was this sin and Jesus died in some sacrifice to pay for the sin. And there is a reward for acknowledging that fact in that you go to heaven for doing so and hell if you don't. You start taking any of that out and you have some modified version of Christianity, but you don't have Christianity. You can call yourself a Christian, but if you make up your own version, at some point it is something else.

To say these aren't the major tenets of Christianity is a stretch. To water down the version of hell is probably still within the limits of Christianity. But even that begins to count the Bible out of the religion. And not believing in one God and at least believing the Bible has something to do with the religious tenets also starts to become a little too far from the actual religion to then claim you are a Christian with this totally modified belief system. Christian in their mind maybe, without the tenets though what do you have? I would say it starts to become something else.

Congratulations. You just excluded the biggest segment of Christians, namely the Catholics.

You clearly view Christianity with your local eyes: Those Christians you see around you are mainly Protestants who, as you describe, do see Jesus as the central figure in their religion. But Catholicism isn't by far focused on Jesus - it's the Old Man Himself who has the spotlight. After that, it's Mary, the saints and Jesus.

If you want to criticize a religion, do yourself a favor and look a bit beyond your own little backyard. Your view of what Christianity is is way too narrow.

Claus, once more for the benefit of zooterkin but with no hope of a different outcome in your thought process, zooterkin is exactly right.

You don't need to constantly poison the well. If you feel your arguments can stand on their own against mine, you don't need to make these snide personal remarks.

I'm talking about the concepts within the religion. I told you it wasn't about the individual several times. Regardless of your belief one cannot separate the two things, the religious tenets and the believers, I do separate them. And you are taking your belief that you cannot separate the religious tenets from the believers and assuming I am talking about the believers.

The believers are all over the map. I've posted repeatedly how many believers don't have a clue what the Bible actually says. If they don't know what the Bible says, then individually, they can hardly all be real followers of their stated religion.

No True Scotsman fallacy.

Post 38Meaning they wear their Christian label and speak of love, mercy, kindness, yadda yadda. But here they are oblivious to the actual belief that forms the basis of that religion: "Believe what I believe or go to hell."

But that isn't particularly something that applies to Christianity. That is something that applies to just about all religions.

I made the point I did about propaganda because the film is a blatant propaganda piece. Common within the Christian church and I'd say also one of the major tenets is go out and convert others to the Christian religion. That is not a free speech value. Supporting the First Amendment to the US Constitution is a separate issue. Letting a Wiccan rave about the wonders of witchcraft at your Christian Church would unlikely be tolerated. Heck, some of them don't tolerate gay preachers. That is not a free speech value.

No, no, no. Either you support the First Amendment or you don't.

Do Christians in America support the First Amendment, yes or no?

Again, I can separate the values based within the religious tenets from the people. The fact you cannot see those two things as separate comments does not make my comment about the underlying tenets of the religion a statement about individuals who call themselves Christians. But if they are going to call themselves Christians, there's a good chance they support those tenets to one degree or another. And there's quite a few of them who don't consciously think about what those main tenets really say.

I am asking you how religious tenets can exist without religious people believing in them. Which came first, the tenets or the people believing in them?

What invalid assumptions were you talking about in post #119?
 
skeptigirl said:
Yes, there are a variety of beliefs people who call themselves Christian have, just as some try to define hell as "not having God's love". It's kind of hard to take those versions and say therefore my list is not a list of the major tenets of Christianity. You can call yourself a Buddhist, but if you don't really believe any of the religion or in Buddha, then are you a Buddhist because you call yourself one?

The concept of Jesus is that there was this sin and Jesus died in some sacrifice to pay for the sin. And there is a reward for acknowledging that fact in that you go to heaven for doing so and hell if you don't. You start taking any of that out and you have some modified version of Christianity, but you don't have Christianity. You can call yourself a Christian, but if you make up your own version, at some point it is something else.

To say these aren't the major tenets of Christianity is a stretch. To water down the version of hell is probably still within the limits of Christianity. But even that begins to count the Bible out of the religion. And not believing in one God and at least believing the Bible has something to do with the religious tenets also starts to become a little too far from the actual religion to then claim you are a Christian with this totally modified belief system. Christian in their mind maybe, without the tenets though what do you have? I would say it starts to become something else.
Congratulations. You just excluded the biggest segment of Christians, namely the Catholics.

You clearly view Christianity with your local eyes: Those Christians you see around you are mainly Protestants who, as you describe, do see Jesus as the central figure in their religion. But Catholicism isn't by far focused on Jesus - it's the Old Man Himself who has the spotlight. After that, it's Mary, the saints and Jesus.

:confused:

As a born, christened, baptised, 1st-confessioned, holy-communionised, confirmed (hah!) and (now) (col)lapsed RC, I have no idea what the hell you're on about

If you want to criticize a religion, do yourself a favor and look a bit beyond your own little backyard. Your view of what Christianity is is way too narrow

Try making a sentence out of the following five words

Pot

Black

Calling

Kettle

The​
 
:confused:

As a born, christened, baptised, 1st-confessioned, holy-communionised, confirmed (hah!) and (now) (col)lapsed RC, I have no idea what the hell you're on about

Jesus is the centerpiece in Protestantism. You rarely hear about the OT, it's not seen as pivotal as the teachings of Jesus. It's Jesus, Jesus, Jesus.

In Catholicism, you get the whole shebang. Not just Jesus, but also Mary, the saints, and God himself. In some Catholic aspects, Mary is more important than Jesus. But you sure don't hear a lot about her in Protestant circles.
 
Non of that is the least bit relevant to what I posted, Claus. I'll be happy to give you a few tenets in the Catholic version that I find disturbing but they actually still include the main one, believe as they do or go to hell.

I may waste more time on post 132 tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
In some Catholic aspects, Mary is more important than Jesus.

No ****, Sherlock?


But you sure don't hear a lot about her in Protestant circles.

So what?

As skeptigirl points out, none (or a relatively insignificant few) of your so-called arguments are the least bit relevant to what she posted

Please, stop derailing what could, otherwise, be both a fun and informative thread
 
Last edited:
Jesus is the centerpiece in Protestantism. You rarely hear about the OT, it's not seen as pivotal as the teachings of Jesus. It's Jesus, Jesus, Jesus.
I think you may be also guilty of being a little blinkered by your own experience; there is not just one Protestant church. In the church I was brought up in, OT references were far from rare, so your statement is a little too broad.
 
Non of that is the least bit relevant to what I posted, Claus. I'll be happy to give you a few tenets in the Catholic version that I find disturbing but they actually still include the main one, believe as they do or go to hell.

Oh, no, no, no. Now you are moving the goalposts. Before, you said:

skeptigirl said:
The concept of Jesus is that there was this sin and Jesus died in some sacrifice to pay for the sin. And there is a reward for acknowledging that fact in that you go to heaven for doing so and hell if you don't. You start taking any of that out and you have some modified version of Christianity, but you don't have Christianity. You can call yourself a Christian, but if you make up your own version, at some point it is something else.

To say these aren't the major tenets of Christianity is a stretch.

Jesus, his dying for your sins, you believing in that, and you go to heaven. Those were, according to you, the major tenets of Christianity.

You now want to include specific Catholic tenets, after I point out that you are wrong to exclude Catholicism.

I may waste more time on post 132 tomorrow.

Take your time.

No ****, Sherlock?

Elementary, dear Watson.


So I was right.

I think you may be also guilty of being a little blinkered by your own experience; there is not just one Protestant church. In the church I was brought up in, OT references were far from rare, so your statement is a little too broad.

I specifically said Protestantism. I didn't say "just one Protestant church".
 
Yes, there are a variety of beliefs people who call themselves Christian have, just as some try to define hell as "not having God's love". It's kind of hard to take those versions and say therefore my list is not a list of the major tenets of Christianity. You can call yourself a Buddhist, but if you don't really believe any of the religion or in Buddha, then are you a Buddhist because you call yourself one?

The concept of Jesus is that there was this sin and Jesus died in some sacrifice to pay for the sin. And there is a reward for acknowledging that fact in that you go to heaven for doing so and hell if you don't. You start taking any of that out and you have some modified version of Christianity, but you don't have Christianity. You can call yourself a Christian, but if you make up your own version, at some point it is something else.

To say these aren't the major tenets of Christianity is a stretch. To water down the version of hell is probably still within the limits of Christianity. But even that begins to count the Bible out of the religion. And not believing in one God and at least believing the Bible has something to do with the religious tenets also starts to become a little too far from the actual religion to then claim you are a Christian with this totally modified belief system. Christian in their mind maybe, without the tenets though what do you have? I would say it starts to become something else.

I see what you're saying. How much hair does someone have to lack before they can be described as bald or how many grains of sand can you remove before you can no longer talk about a "pile"? It's the same semantic issue we came up against in the epic "Should skeptics, by definition, be atheists?" thread.

I wouldn't be surprised to find particular Christian groups who would agree with a definition including such tenets and say "unless you believe in the things we do, you cannot call yourself a Christian", but I think we're in "No true Scotsman" territory here, more so, if one starts insisting on particular interpretations of certain concepts such as hell or original sin.

Judging by the various beliefs of those who call themselves Christians, I think any useful definition would need to be a broad enough an umbrella to cover as many as possible, while still actually carrying some kind of meaning. The original "follower of Christ" definition is pretty good even if it does leave a big gap of what that might actually entail.

Defining "Christianity" would probably need to include core doctrine, but again I don't think such a definition could be particularly specific on much of it and would almost certainly need to include some "usually" or "commonly" distinctions if it is to go into any detail.

The main point here is to be careful when ascribing beliefs to others based your own perception and understanding. In the same way that atheists tend not to like being told by theists what their actual beliefs are, I think you'd find a sufficient number of Christians who would object to your take on what they must believe to call themselves "Christian". There's a pretty good chance that if your version sounds immoral to you that it may also sound immoral to them too, and probably is a distortion of what they actually believe.

eta. btw. I pretty much agreed with what you were saying before if you were specifically referring to how the film could be seen to be portraying Christian values.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom