Egg
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2007
- Messages
- 1,585
Christianity has a couple major tenets. They are inherent in the beliefs which make up the religious beliefs. They come from the Bible. They are the core beliefs of the religion. They exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs. They include
* There is one god
* The concept of original sin
* Jesus died for those sins
* Believing in Jesus is the only way to go to heaven
* Not believing in Jesus means you go to hell
You tell me what makes a person a Christian? Which Christians don't believe in Jesus, original sin, one god, heaven, and hell? Those are the things which Christians pretty much universally believe in. Some Christians have watered down versions of what hell is. Otherwise they all believe in those major core tenets.
What I am saying is that on the face of it, those tenets are terrible. To have one of the core tenets of your belief being that those who don't believe what you do go to hell while at the same time claiming you believe in a loving peaceful god who really doesn't ask too much of people is to ignore the fact your religion has these immoral core tenets.
You seem to think the people are the religion. They are on one level. But on another level are these core beliefs and in the case of Christianity, they are terrible.
What you are missing here is I'm not saying these tenets exist in space. It isn't like contemplating if math exists without humans. That's a discussion on a whole other plane than this one. The tenets don't exist in space. But like a corporation exists core religious tenets describe a religious belief system. Regardless of where they exist or if they would exist without the individuals, these tenets still make up the core beliefs a Christian has. Without these beliefs, one is not a Christian. You might believe in gods or follow another religion, but all Christians by definition believe those core tenets. And those corp tenets have an immoral piece Christians can ignore, they can pretend it isn't as bad as it sounds but it is there in the core tenet of every Christian's belief. People who don't believe what they do go to hell.
By definition?
I would call your outlined "tenets" commonly held Christian beliefs, but you could technically still be a Christian and not believe any of those things as you have stated them.
There are actually plenty of Christians who don't believe in hell (at least not the common conception of fire and eternal torture) (WP), there are plenty of differing views on the concept of original sin (WP) and there are Christians who think everyone's going to heaven no matter what they believe or do (WP).