The Godless Girl

....
None of this addresses your claim that Christian values are against free speech.

Ah, well. I'll ask you at TAM. Along with the other questions.
I wish you could, but I'm not going to TAM this year. Galapagos is too expensive.

The comment I made was in reference to not allowing any other god beliefs. Technically, (as you think) you could say that doesn't stop people from talking about other gods. But think about it, can you stand up and preach other religions in any Christian Church you know of? I don't think so.

My comments were in that context. You are trying to apply my comments to all the speech not involved in "having other gods before [the Christian God].
 
Plenty of evidence to show that freedom of speech is actually not a Christian value has been shown. Do you have any evidence to counter that, Clause,?

It isn't particularly a Christian value. You can say the same about just about all religions.

I wish you could, but I'm not going to TAM this year. Galapagos is too expensive.

That's OK. TAM7, then.

The comment I made was in reference to not allowing any other god beliefs. Technically, (as you think) you could say that doesn't stop people from talking about other gods. But think about it, can you stand up and preach other religions in any Christian Church you know of? I don't think so.

Again, this isn't something that is particularly Christian.

My comments were in that context. You are trying to apply my comments to all the speech not involved in "having other gods before [the Christian God].

No, I wasn't, and you said a hell of a lot more than that. You made the blanket statement that Christian values were against free speech:

No free speech, promotion of slander (or is it libel when you film written lies?) against a group that doesn't agree with you, and using the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith. Gotta love those Christian values.

You extrapolated what the Christians said in the clip said to encompass what all Christians everywhere say.
 
skeptigirl: No free speech, promotion of slander (or is it libel when you film written lies?) against a group that doesn't agree with you, and using the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith. Gotta love those Christian values.

Claus: You extrapolated what the Christians said in the clip said to encompass what all Christians everywhere say.
You take things out of context, Claus. That comment was specifically about the film clip producers. It's about the Godless Girl film, not about all Christians everywhere. I was being sarcastic. Those are terrible values. The film uses terrible values in promoting their supposed good values. They are hypocrites. That is what my comment says.
 
You take things out of context, Claus. That comment was specifically about the film clip producers. It's about the Godless Girl film, not about all Christians everywhere. I was being sarcastic. Those are terrible values. The film uses terrible values in promoting their supposed good values. They are hypocrites. That is what my comment says.

Let's see what you said:

Right, we're all going to he!! for not believing in the Christian god and you try to tell me I've stereotyped Christian values.
Of course, believe in the Christian god and get a reward for believing, go to heaven.

All Christian churches are houses of propaganda. Do you know of any that are offering people a choice of beliefs?

The only difference is in degree.

Is it not a Christian tenet that non-believers go to hell? And is it not a Christian tenet that one is supposed to believe in the one and only "true God"? How is that not supposed to apply to all Christians?

The comment I made was in reference to not allowing any other god beliefs. Technically, (as you think) you could say that doesn't stop people from talking about other gods. But think about it, can you stand up and preach other religions in any Christian Church you know of? I don't think so.
My comments were in that context. You are trying to apply my comments to all the speech not involved in "having other gods before [the Christian God].

Can you please explain how the highlighted sentences applied to only the clip?
 
Let's see what you said: [snip]
Can you please explain how the highlighted sentences applied to only the clip?
It's really hard to communicate with you, Claus. I hope you realize that by now.

I'll give this one more go then I'm not bothering with this particular side track anymore. What happens is you don't seem to get the gist of the message. You pick out something out of context or you take something literal that isn't intended to be literal and then you harp and harp on it as if you're winning brownie points by finding flaws in people's posts. And when I try (and others I'm sure) to clarify something, instead of trying to understand what someone is saying you continue on with the thing you took out of context or the thing you took literally that was not intended to be literal. I try to tell you what I said but you'd rather find those brownie points than actually try to communicate.

Is it that you are so focused on your false belief I made some broad accusation against all Christians, or that you don't want to consider you misinterpreted something I said? That would be interesting to know, but I'm sure you cannot answer it. Maybe someone else reading this will know what I'm talking about.

I have already clarified your misunderstanding of the original statement.
skeptigirl: No free speech, promotion of slander (or is it libel when you film written lies?) against a group that doesn't agree with you, and using the bribes of Christmas presents to entice kids to keep the faith. Gotta love those Christian values.

Claus: You extrapolated what the Christians said in the clip said to encompass what all Christians everywhere say.

skeptigirl: You take things out of context, Claus. That comment was specifically about the film clip producers. It's about the Godless Girl film, not about all Christians everywhere. I was being sarcastic. Those are terrible values. The film uses terrible values in promoting their supposed good values. They are hypocrites. That is what my comment says.
When you initially responded to my comments the exchange was:
CFLarsen: Nice stereotyping.

Some Christians might think that way. But don't claim that "Christian values" in general are against free speech, or any of the other things. All Christians are not the same as Jack Chick either.

We don't fight bigots by becoming bigots.

Skeptigirl: Right, we're all going to he!! for not believing in the Christian god and you try to tell me I've stereotyped Christian values.

Of course, believe in the Christian god and get a reward for believing, go to heaven.

All Christian churches are houses of propaganda. Do you know of any that are offering people a choice of beliefs?

The only difference is in degree.
I didn't say "all Christians" anything. I commented on Christian values. Your comment implied that inherent Christian values, meaning the ones espoused in core Christian religious tenets didn't exist and that the religious values of individual Christians themselves were the core tenets. But individual Christians overlook the true significance of their core beliefs.

Core Christian values do not espouse freedom of speech, nor freedom of beliefs. There is one god, you must follow Jesus. Christians themselves are not the equivalent of core Christian values. Quite the contrary, most of them don't even think those core values through.

When a Christian says you can only get to heaven by accepting Christ, they are not considering the reality of what that core belief is. The reality is believing a supposedly loving god will heap the most vile painful atrocities on non-believers for eternity. You listen to Christians and they say things like, "All God asks of us is that we believe (or worship) Him for all the wonderful things yadda yadda." It ignores the reality of the core belief. It glosses over the reality of that core belief.

What you have taken out of context is that my sarcasm and my comments were aimed at those core beliefs, not the believers and all the ways the believers view those core beliefs. This is the Christian religion, Claus. Christianity is a religion which says these are the things you must believe, and if not you'll rot in he!!. Christians themselves, I'm sure, have the same mix of morals and values as any similar population that are not Christians.
 
Last edited:
It's really hard to communicate with you, Claus. I hope you realize that by now.

No, it isn't hard to communicate with me. It is, however, really hard to reconcile what you said earlier with what you are saying now.

I'll give this one more go then I'm not bothering with this particular side track anymore. What happens is you don't seem to get the gist of the message. You pick out something out of context or you take something literal that isn't intended to be literal and then you harp and harp on it as if you're winning brownie points by finding flaws in people's posts. And when I try (and others I'm sure) to clarify something, instead of trying to understand what someone is saying you continue on with the thing you took out of context or the thing you took literally that was not intended to be literal. I try to tell you what I said but you'd rather find those brownie points than actually try to communicate.

The problem with your posts is that you give no indication when we should read what you say literally, and when we shouldn't. Not until you made a complete turn-around did you in any way indicate that we shouldn't take you literally. On the contrary, you kept harping on the same argument, over and over again.

If you meant it sarcastically from the start, why didn't you just say so the moment I first misinterpreted you (if that is what I did)? Stop whining about me misunderstanding you - if I have misunderstood you, it is solely because you did nothing to rectify the situation. On the contrary, you continued in the same vein.

Is it that you are so focused on your false belief I made some broad accusation against all Christians, or that you don't want to consider you misinterpreted something I said? That would be interesting to know, but I'm sure you cannot answer it. Maybe someone else reading this will know what I'm talking about.

The reason I quote what you have said is precisely because I want to find out what exactly it is you really mean. Your posts contradict each other grossly: First, you make blanket statements about Christians and their values, then you only meant your statements to mean the film clip producers.

I have already clarified your misunderstanding of the original statement.When you initially responded to my comments the exchange was:I didn't say "all Christians" anything. I commented on Christian values.

Bull. You are clearly commenting on all Christians, and not just their values.

Your comment implied that inherent Christian values, meaning the ones espoused in core Christian religious tenets didn't exist

I asked you to show that one Christian value was abandoning free speech. You have not been able to do that.

and that the religious values of individual Christians themselves were the core tenets. But individual Christians overlook the true significance of their core beliefs.

Excuse me? Who are you to tell people what the "true significance" of their core beliefs is?

Core Christian values do not espouse freedom of speech, nor freedom of beliefs. There is one god, you must follow Jesus. Christians themselves are not the equivalent of core Christian values. Quite the contrary, most of them don't even think those core values through.

Are you saying that Christian values exist outside Christians?

When a Christian says you can only get to heaven by accepting Christ, they are not considering the reality of what that core belief is. The reality is believing a supposedly loving god will heap the most vile painful atrocities on non-believers for eternity. You listen to Christians and they say things like, "All God asks of us is that we believe (or worship) Him for all the wonderful things yadda yadda." It ignores the reality of the core belief. It glosses over the reality of that core belief.

So, since Christians really are against free speech, Christianity is unconstitutional?

What you have taken out of context is that my sarcasm and my comments were aimed at those core beliefs, not the believers and all the ways the believers view those core beliefs. This is the Christian religion, Claus. Christianity is a religion which says these are the things you must believe, and if not you'll rot in he!!. Christians themselves, I'm sure, have the same mix of morals and values as any similar population that are not Christians.

Again, this is not particular to Christians. Other religions say the same. Why aren't you striking out at those, too?
 
Once again, Claus demonstrates his inexplicable power to build strawmen while the real argument stands neatly by yelling, "Hello? I'm right here! I've even written myself down using big letters and small words!"
 
Once again, Claus demonstrates his inexplicable power to build strawmen while the real argument stands neatly by yelling, "Hello? I'm right here! I've even written myself down using big letters and small words!"
Part of me thinks he means well and really does see the world in a unique way and part of me thinks he's unable to have a conversation with me because he's working too hard for those brownie points he imagines he's getting.
 
Part of me thinks he means well and really does see the world in a unique way and part of me thinks he's unable to have a conversation with me because he's working too hard for those brownie points he imagines he's getting.

I know it's late where you are, and you have already indicated in another thread that you are very tired. But if you have time for such a personal attack, you should have time to answer the questions, too:

Who are you to tell people what the "true significance" of their core beliefs is?

Are you saying that Christian values exist outside Christians?

Since Christians really are against free speech, does that mean that Christianity is unconstitutional?

Why aren't you striking out at other religions too?
 
Who are you to tell people what the "true significance" of their core beliefs is?

Who are you to deny what she claims? Are you an expert?

Since Christians really are against free speech, does that mean that Christianity is unconstitutional?

Religions are not bound by constitutional law. They can believe whatever they want.

Why aren't you striking out at other religions too?

Do you think she doesn't? This thread happens to be a film about Christians and atheists.
 
I know it's late where you are, and you have already indicated in another thread that you are very tired. But if you have time for such a personal attack, you should have time to answer the questions, too:
Sorry, Claus, but I do post what I observe even when it might be a little politically/socially incorrect. You are a unique person. I see no better way to have a discussion with you than to bring that up when it seems to get in the way of the conversation. Were I to have posted those comments in a PM to Moby, that to me is worse, talking behind people's backs.

Who are you to tell people what the "true significance" of their core beliefs is?

Are you saying that Christian values exist outside Christians?

Since Christians really are against free speech, does that mean that Christianity is unconstitutional?
This is an example of what I was talking about in the above post. The way you perceive things has a significant impact on discussions with you. You do not perceive things the way I do and you don't understand my posts. That's bad enough, but then when I try to get through to you as to what I am saying, you insist on keeping the initial incorrect interpretation you had of what I've posted.

Can't you for once try to understand someone is telling you that you are misinterpreting posts?

I'm talking about the major core religious tenets of Christianity and you can't understand that I am separating that from people who hold beliefs and have morals that may or may not reflect those core tenets. If they didn't, they wouldn't be Christians!

Christianity has a couple major tenets. They are inherent in the beliefs which make up the religious beliefs. They come from the Bible. They are the core beliefs of the religion. They exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs. They include
  • There is one god
  • The concept of original sin
  • Jesus died for those sins
  • Believing in Jesus is the only way to go to heaven
  • Not believing in Jesus means you go to hell
You tell me what makes a person a Christian? Which Christians don't believe in Jesus, original sin, one god, heaven, and hell? Those are the things which Christians pretty much universally believe in. Some Christians have watered down versions of what hell is. Otherwise they all believe in those major core tenets.

What I am saying is that on the face of it, those tenets are terrible. To have one of the core tenets of your belief being that those who don't believe what you do go to hell while at the same time claiming you believe in a loving peaceful god who really doesn't ask too much of people is to ignore the fact your religion has these immoral core tenets.

You seem to think the people are the religion. They are on one level. But on another level are these core beliefs and in the case of Christianity, they are terrible.

Why aren't you striking out at other religions too?
What thai said.

But also, Christianity dominates the US religious and political scene currently. So the subject comes up much more often than other religions.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, Claus, but I do post what I observe even when it might be a little politically/socially incorrect. You are a unique person.

We all are.

I see no better way to have a discussion with you than to bring that up when it seems to get in the way of the conversation. Were I to have posted those comments in a PM to Moby, that to me is worse, talking behind people's backs.

Maybe. But your comments make you a hypocrite when you also complain about people being hostile and insulting to you.

This is an example of what I was talking about in the above post. The way you perceive things has a significant impact on discussions with you. You do not perceive things the way I do and you don't understand my posts. That's bad enough, but then when I try to get through to you as to what I am saying, you insist on keeping the initial incorrect interpretation you had of what I've posted.

Can't you for once try to understand someone is telling you that you are misinterpreting posts?

Can't you for once try to understand what the meaning of "?" is? I am asking you questions following your argumentation.

Since Christians really are against free speech, does that mean that Christianity is unconstitutional?

I'm talking about the major core religious tenets of Christianity and you can't understand that I am separating that from people who hold beliefs and have morals that may or may not reflect those core tenets. If they didn't, they wouldn't be Christians!

Christianity has a couple major tenets. They are inherent in the beliefs which make up the religious beliefs. They come from the Bible. They are the core beliefs of the religion. They exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs. They include
  • There is one god
  • The concept of original sin
  • Jesus died for those sins
  • Believing in Jesus is the only way to go to heaven
  • Not believing in Jesus means you go to hell
You tell me what makes a person a Christian? Which Christians don't believe in Jesus, original sin, one god, heaven, and hell? Those are the things which Christians pretty much universally believe in. Some Christians have watered down versions of what hell is. Otherwise they all believe in those major core tenets.

What I am saying is that on the face of it, those tenets are terrible. To have one of the core tenets of your belief being that those who don't believe what you do go to hell while at the same time claiming you believe in a loving peaceful god who really doesn't ask too much of people is to ignore the fact your religion has these immoral core tenets.

You seem to think the people are the religion. They are on one level. But on another level are these core beliefs and in the case of Christianity, they are terrible.

Wait, wait, wait. They "exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs", on some other "level"? You are saying that Christian values exist outside Christians, then.

How does that work? Where do these Christian values come from, if not from Christians?

But also, Christianity dominates the US religious and political scene currently. So the subject comes up much more often than other religions.

Huh? What does this thread have to do with the current political scene? Grayman opened the thread to show a film clip from three-quarters of a century ago.
 
A video I found at http://skepchick.org/blog/

I got a kick out of it. Sorry if it's been posted here before.


Finally found this thread this evening: what a hoot! :biggrin: "DHHTM", indeed... :monkey4: Thxx for posting.

As it's fairly dated anyway, I thought it might be fun to really date it, you know, another two millenia or so; so, from silent stage to Greek theatre, presenting:

Atheiste (a fragment) aka: Bozopuss Unbound

{recently recovered and translated from something a cat hacked up in a souvlaki shop}

[Note: strophe and antistrophe spoken by chorus, similar to angel and devil cliche, conscience of the protagonist, Bozopuss; antagonist, versus his virtue, is Atheiste, "the godless girl".]

Strophe:

Callow youth, wet ear
Dark atheism beguiles.
A secret glance
Bozopuss and Atheiste
Their pamphleteering hide.
The tryst affirmed
Empedocles' cabal --
Whelps! -- whelm academia
With talk of Democritus,
Pygmalion's paradox:
But for some grit the clay
In man and chimp adheres
In Euclidean strands --
A laurel for the monkey?

Antistrophe:

Gods are made by man
So spoke Xenophanes.
Oracles the stuff
Hercules did assuage
From Augean stables.
Pay no heed to hibernal
Festival, Bozopuss.
Save your largesse for
Thy simian cousin,
Olympian usurper.
Give no more faith to
Oracles save this:
High-hat the monkey not!

Atheiste:

My body, does it not
Please you, Bozopuss?
Closer, Pleiades flash
On the waters of my eyes.
The bobbing of my raven hair
So much fairer than the fair
Locks of Aphrodite.
For what locks on liver
She has wrought, invisible,
Have no more reticence
But like the Kraken’s are
Rust by seas of sophistry.
Unbind thyself my Titan!
This golden age shoos gods.
High-hat the monkey not!

Bozopuss [vexed]:

The mind of man is double
Say my professors,
A chariot yanked
Hither and yon, twin mares
Dark and fair, forever
Yoked in rivalry.
Yet is it I or monkey
At the reins, the name
“Bozo” might as easy
Summon ape as me?
And if brute, is it not knave
To in rein the brunette
Always, always
To follow but the blonde?
Is as must be, I will will it...
High-hat the monkey not!

(Enter the monkey, deus ex machina, to locrian strains of theremin... the text breaks off here.)

-- Cebeas Demillicon (c. 285 BC) :tragedy: :dqueen
 
Last edited:
....
Can't you for once try to understand what the meaning of "?" is? I am asking you questions following your argumentation.
Your questions are based on invalid assumptions about what has been said. As such, the discussion cannot proceed. It's one of those, "when did you stop beating your husband" category of questions when you ask about something based on a false assumption.

Take the whole rest of this post for example. Because you do not have a clear understanding of the way I conceptualize 'underlying basic religious tenets', you ask questions that are based on all kinds of false assumptions about what I've said.

I can see that you don't understand what I am talking about. Why can't you see that you don't understand what I'm talking about?
....Since Christians really are against free speech, does that mean that Christianity is unconstitutional?

Wait, wait, wait. They "exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs", on some other "level"? You are saying that Christian values exist outside Christians, then.

How does that work? Where do these Christian values come from, if not from Christians?
This is like you ignored what I said in its entirety. I'm going to repeat it. I couldn't have said it any more plainly. You'll just have to re-read it and try again to understand.

Christianity has a couple major tenets. They are inherent in the beliefs which make up the religious beliefs. They come from the Bible. They are the core beliefs of the religion. They exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs. They include

* There is one god
* The concept of original sin
* Jesus died for those sins
* Believing in Jesus is the only way to go to heaven
* Not believing in Jesus means you go to hell

You tell me what makes a person a Christian? Which Christians don't believe in Jesus, original sin, one god, heaven, and hell? Those are the things which Christians pretty much universally believe in. Some Christians have watered down versions of what hell is. Otherwise they all believe in those major core tenets.

What I am saying is that on the face of it, those tenets are terrible. To have one of the core tenets of your belief being that those who don't believe what you do go to hell while at the same time claiming you believe in a loving peaceful god who really doesn't ask too much of people is to ignore the fact your religion has these immoral core tenets.

You seem to think the people are the religion. They are on one level. But on another level are these core beliefs and in the case of Christianity, they are terrible.

What you are missing here is I'm not saying these tenets exist in space. It isn't like contemplating if math exists without humans. That's a discussion on a whole other plane than this one. The tenets don't exist in space. But like a corporation exists core religious tenets describe a religious belief system. Regardless of where they exist or if they would exist without the individuals, these tenets still make up the core beliefs a Christian has. Without these beliefs, one is not a Christian. You might believe in gods or follow another religion, but all Christians by definition believe those core tenets. And those corp tenets have an immoral piece Christians can ignore, they can pretend it isn't as bad as it sounds but it is there in the core tenet of every Christian's belief. People who don't believe what they do go to hell.
....Huh? What does this thread have to do with the current political scene? Grayman opened the thread to show a film clip from three-quarters of a century ago.
This is mind boggling to me Claus. The comment I made was merely a reason explaining to you why I address the subject of Christianity more often than other religions after you made the comment, "Other religions say the same. Why aren't you striking out at those, too?"
 
Last edited:
Your questions are based on invalid assumptions about what has been said. As such, the discussion cannot proceed. It's one of those, "when did you stop beating your husband" category of questions when you ask about something based on a false assumption.

Take the whole rest of this post for example. Because you do not have a clear understanding of the way I conceptualize 'underlying basic religious tenets', you ask questions that are based on all kinds of false assumptions about what I've said.

You clearly said that Christians are against free speech.

That was not an assumption or misunderstanding.

The US Constitution, Bill of Rights, state:

Amendment I

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.​

This is not an assumption or misunderstanding either.

Since you say that Christians are against free speech, does that mean that Christianity is unconstitutional?

I can see that you don't understand what I am talking about. Why can't you see that you don't understand what I'm talking about?This is like you ignored what I said in its entirety. I'm going to repeat it. I couldn't have said it any more plainly. You'll just have to re-read it and try again to understand.

No, you don't need to repeat it.

Did you not say that Christian beliefs "exist completely independent of people who adopt Christian religious beliefs", on some other "level"?

Yes, you did.

You are saying that Christian values exist outside Christians, then.

The question "Where do these Christian values come from, if not from Christians?" was perfectly valid.

What you are missing here is I'm not saying these tenets exist in space. It isn't like contemplating if math exists without humans. That's a discussion on a whole other plane than this one. The tenets don't exist in space. But like a corporation exists core religious tenets describe a religious belief system. Regardless of where they exist or if they would exist without the individuals, these tenets still make up the core beliefs a Christian has. Without these beliefs, one is not a Christian. You might believe in gods or follow another religion, but all Christians by definition believe those core tenets. And those corp tenets have an immoral piece Christians can ignore, they can pretend it isn't as bad as it sounds but it is there in the core tenet of every Christian's belief. People who don't believe what they do go to hell.

But if the Christian tenets don't exist in space, and they exist outside Christians - where the heck do they come from??

This is mind boggling to me Claus. The comment I made was merely a reason explaining to you why I address the subject of Christianity more often than other religions after you made the comment, "Other religions say the same. Why aren't you striking out at those, too?"

:hb:

Just stop this incessant "You don't understand me, Claus" complaint, OK? Just answer the questions when they are put to you.
 
I'm going to make a list of replies and pull them out by number as needed. Here's answer #1 in regards to your last demand there:

#1)Your questions are based on invalid assumptions about what has been said. As such, the discussion cannot proceed. It's one of those, "when did you stop beating your husband" category of questions when you ask about something based on a false assumption.


I'll get to the rest later, but no promises. If I can't think of a different way of stating something you don't understand, there'll be no sense repeating myself.
 
Last edited:
Freedict.com
Noun 1. tenet - a religious doctrine that is proclaimed as true without proof
dogma
article of faith, credendum - (Christianity) any of the sections into which a creed or other statement of doctrine is divided
church doctrine, religious doctrine, creed, gospel - the written body of teachings of a religious group that are generally accepted by that group
Chris·ti·an·i·ty (krsch-n-t, krst-)
n.
1. The Christian religion, founded on the life and teachings of Jesus.
2. Christians as a group; Christendom.
3. The state or fact of being a Christian.
4. pl. Chris·ti·an·i·ties A particular form or sect of the Christian religion: the Christianities of antiquity.
Are you saying, Claus, there is no such thing as a core religious tenet of Christianity?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom