The atheists favorite bible verses

And that's not arguing they should follow all the Old Testament laws? :confused:
No it's not. Perhaps your confusion is a reading problem?

Again, I find many of these old laws morally repugnant, and I don't believe anyone should follow them. That's been my position all along.

And when you said it's apparent Verse 19 means Christians have to follow Old Testament laws - that's also not arguing Christians have to follow Old Testament laws?
Nope. It's arguing that that's what that text says.

I myself don't give the Gospel of Matthew any more credence for historical accuracy than I would a work of fiction. Even if it were historically accurate, and those are the exact words a guy named Jesus spoke, I would reject them because, as I said in my very first post in this thread, I find a great deal of what's in the Old Testament morally abominable.
What is it you're arguing then?

I've recited the argument at least 3 times. I'll say it again.

Many Christians say the Bible is a source of morality. (I'll go further, some even claim that just reading the Bible is somehow a moral act in and of itself.) When critics (like me) point out that great sections of the Bible are morally reprehensible, many Christians counter that that's just the Old Testament and that Jesus replaced the old law with a new law--so the old law no longer holds.

The passage you cited from Matthew and the one I cited from Luke have Jesus saying that the old law indeed still holds.

Christians who claim that the Bible is a source of morality have a huge logical inconsistency.

For that matter (here's a point I only mentioned in passing previously), if the Old Testatment laws no longer hold, then why are they still kept in the Bible? Many other writings have been excluded from the Bible, but these are all kept in there--even though most Christians don't think they count.
 
Last edited:
And that's not arguing they should follow all the Old Testament laws? :confused:

And when you said it's apparent Verse 19 means Christians have to follow Old Testament laws - that's also not arguing Christians have to follow Old Testament laws?
For additional clarification, since you're pretending you don't understand the very transparent words I've been using:

I don't believe anyone should follow all the Old Testatment laws. I do believe that the author of the Gospel of Matthew thinks that anyone who follows Jesus' teachings should obey every last one of them.

In the early church (60+ years after the supposed events of the gospels took place--about the time Matthew was written), the issue of whether you had to be a Jew to be a follower of Jesus was a contentious one. As I mentioned before, Matthew makes a strong case that Christianity was just for Jews, while John went so far from that position that his version of Jesus seems hardly Jewish himself.

But, if you think the Bible is a source of morality, you ignore this, and try to read the passage in some other way so that you can claim to follow what Jesus supposedly said without having to stone people with some regularity.
 
He always does that. The same point has been explained a myriad of ways, but he prefers his particular straw man. Go figure. How else is he going to imagine himself "divinely inspired" and "in on" special magical truths. How else is he going to pretend that atheists are "moral relativists", and he's not?

I think believers just babble here to tell themselves that they had a logical discussion with skeptics, and they still "believe"--(therefore, their woo must be true)
 
This entire thread is 90% filler, 10% discussion.

Although that might just be a tad generous.
 
Last edited:
He always does that. The same point has been explained a myriad of ways, but he prefers his particular straw man. Go figure.

My strawman? I've never made the bloody claims about those verses that I'm questioning.

How else is he going to imagine himself "divinely inspired" and "in on" special magical truths.

So far - I'm trying to figure out why some atheists feel they are.

How else is he going to pretend that atheists are "moral relativists", and he's not?

I've never once typed and / or said the words "moral relativists" on this forum. Where the heck is that coming from? Leftovers from a different thread or something?

I think believers just babble here to tell themselves that they had a logical discussion with skeptics, and they still "believe"--(therefore, their woo must be true)

There seems like an awful lot of other posts in this thread for me to be babbling to myself.

So - you have anything constructive to contribute here or what?
 
And that's not arguing they should follow all the Old Testament laws? :confused:

And when you said it's apparent Verse 19 means Christians have to follow Old Testament laws - that's also not arguing Christians have to follow Old Testament laws?

What is it you're arguing then?

Now I'm confused. The answers to these questions were in the post two before this one. It seems entirely clear to me what JoeTJ (and many others through this thread) is saying. How are you still hung up on the idea that atheists want Christians to follow OT laws?
 
Now I'm confused. The answers to these questions were in the post two before this one. It seems entirely clear to me what JoeTJ (and many others through this thread) is saying. How are you still hung up on the idea that atheists want Christians to follow OT laws?

I don't think all atheists want anything, but I do think some atheists do. Or at least they did at the beginning of this thread.

JoeTheJuggler said:
Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?

JoeTheJuggler said:
Verse 19 clearly has Jesus saying you ought obey every single little law specified in the scriptures.

Schlitt said:
ACS, do you think the meaning of this verse is ambiguous?

What would be the reason for wanting this verse to mean something other than what it appears to mean literally?

Robin said:
He strengthened one or two and altered another couple, but it seems pretty clear that is what he meant - the law stays in force until all is accomplished.

Michael C said:
According to the quoted verses, Jesus said: "I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished".

What does this mean, if not that the "Law" will stay in force until heaven and earth disappear?

Edmund Standing said:
'Heaven' and earth haven't disappeared. Therefore your interpretation fails. The Law remains valid for the followers of Jesus until the apocalyptic transformation that was expected to be coming soon; the same transformation referred to in Revelation, the same transformation which, as it didn't happen in Jesus' lifetime, or even shortly afterwards, was then projected to be coming when Jesus 'returns', which, of course, was due to happen in or around the author's lifetime

Freethinker said:
I can't even imagine any room for interpretation there. It clearly is emphasizing no changes at all to the law. I understand your point about his emphasis on teaching others to do the wrong thing, and if addressing people who are teacher/preachers/scholars, I see the reasoning , but if the law didn't change, then people still have to follow it, don't they?

Schlitt said:
Have you considered selective reasoning due to bias from the Christian literature?

Perhaps they are twisting the interpretation to suit them, in the way you think the Atheists are. This seems likely considering the meaning of the verse seems obvious, and when you consider that surely a god's words should not require such interpretation and twisting.
 
Last edited:
Many Christians say the Bible is a source of morality. (I'll go further, some even claim that just reading the Bible is somehow a moral act in and of itself.) When critics (like me) point out that great sections of the Bible are morally reprehensible, many Christians counter that that's just the Old Testament and that Jesus replaced the old law with a new law--so the old law no longer holds.

Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?

For example, I would say that parents are a key source of morality for many people and yet I would imagine than in all cases there are occasions when the parents demonstrate immoral acts.
 
I don't think all atheists want anything, but I do think some atheists do. Or at least they did at the beginning of this thread.

Again, I have an entirely different reading of these posts.

The people you've quoted are (to my mind) not saying they think Christians should follow all OT laws. They're saying that the verses you quoted in the opening post state that all OT laws should be followed. This is a very different point.

By choosing not to follow all OT laws, Christians are making a judgement that some parts of the Bible should not be obeyed. As Joe said, this is a good thing, as many of the OT laws are, by our standards, horrendous.

The point here is that in making this judgement, Christians are applying their standards of morality to the Bible, rather than letting the Bible inform their standards of morality. This is not a problem to atheists, and people posting here agree that the decision not to follow all OT laws is a good one. It just causes a problem to those Christians who claim the Bible is the source of their morality.
 
Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?

For example, I would say that parents are a key source of morality for many people and yet I would imagine than in all cases there are occasions when the parents demonstrate immoral acts.

I would entirely agree, but then I don't think that there is some absolute morality. If you're happy that morality is a cultural creation, informed from many sources, then you can include parents, works of philosophy and ethics, and pick and choose from religious texts.

That's not normally the type of morality religion talks about though, where morality is absolute, and handed down from above through revealed works. If you're arguing for that type of morality, and you don't have a consistent and inerrant source, then you're back to interpretation and a culturally created moral system.
 
Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?

Maybe not... but there are Christians who claim that the Bible is both "100% consistent and absolutely inerrant" and "THE source of morality."
 
There is a collection of old sermons on line:
Bon appetite'
The answer to this question, however, does nothing to lead his catechumen to despair. Rather, it encourages him to obey in spite of his failings. It states: “He requires nothing which we are not bound to perform. Nevertheless, provided we take care to conform our life to what we are told here, although we are very far from reaching perfection, the Lord does not impute our faults to us” (emphasis mine). [5] Calvin says nothing about the law leading us to despair; rather we are “to take care to conform our life” to the law.

http://www.hornes.org/theologia/bill-dejong/michael-horton-john-calvin-and-law-gospel

Maybe if you read enough Calvin, a different meaning of "law" will emerge. A bit much for me to wade through.
The Instructor showed us how extensive, according to the Word of God the fifth commandment is. For it not only speaks of the love we owe our parents but also shows us that we must show all honor, love, fidelity and submission to all those whom God has placed over us. The fifth commandment not only tells us: "Honor thy father and thy mother, but the Lord also tells us thereby:
Render unto Ceasar the things which are Ceasar's and unto God the things that are God's."
How very evident it is, then, that the great Lawgiver, Who is a God of love and of order, desires our peace and salvation. He desires that love and order shall reign in our hearts, in our home, in the church and in the state.

http://www.the-highway.com/ten_commandments6.html

So there is again. Isn't this called an expository sermon? And using the OT to make its point. I sure remember a lot of sermons from the OT. You mean there is a whole world of Christianity out there that don't use the OT? I feel gypped.

But I do think CS is right on this one.

I'll admit, being someone not raised in mainstream Christianity, it can be pretty confusing though. The preponderance of sermons out there based on the OT could lead people to think that it was still valid.

The subtle difference seems to be that to be a Christian you need to accept that the OT is God's word, but as Christians believe that the purpose of the OT is not so much to obey it but to fear it and therefore cling to the NT.

This is a lot different from saying that the OT is a big mistake. The point of a lot of atheists is not so much imply that we think Christians should obey all the OT laws, just to confront them with laws that purport to be God's communication to man and no less holy now than they ever were.
 
I'm still waiting for ACS and Darth Rotor to provide a more likely interpretation of the verses under discussion to the one I have presented here, here, and here.

DR has chosen to completely ignore my responses to him, while ACS has yet to demonstrate why his interpretation is more logical than the one I and others have proposed, given the historical nature of Matthew's gospel - i.e. a First Century Jewish apocalyptic text.
 
I don't think all atheists want anything, but I do think some atheists do. Or at least they did at the beginning of this thread.

Nothing you quoted there does in any way whatsoever demand that people should follow the Bible.

Is that idea really so difficult to grasp? Can you really not comprehend that it is one thing to argue that Hitler in "Mein Kampf" clearly argued for the annihilation of the Jewish race but a totally different to support Hitler's world view and his policies?

Someone who claims that "Mein Kampf" is a good book will have to explain what is so good about murdering millions and millions of Jews.

I would rather that someone who likes "Mein Kampf" would not murder Jews. But such a person would simply not follow the advice of that book.

Do you understand that?

I would even grant one could be a follower of Hitler without agreeing on the bit about the Jews. But that would be an exception that would need to be acknowledged. Now it turns out that Hitler's stance on the Jews was rather central to his political careerer and without it there really wasn't much left to follow.

I see that the Bible has a lot to say even if you ignore some parts of it. But one cannot deny that one ignores some part and one needs to somehow justify which parts are being ignored. And, apparently, "Jesus told us to ignore the older bits" is simply not true and therefore not a valid explanation.
 
Thanks for your prompt response, RR. I'd apologize for the lateness of mine... but I have the feeling you'd just <shrug> it off, anyway. :)

Actually, some Christian theologists and Biblical scholars hold the authorship to be that of John the Baptist rather than John the Apostle / John of Patmos.

I hadn't heard that, although a quick Google confirms it. That makes I think 4 suggested authors for Revelation: John the Baptist (JtheB), John the Apostle (JtheA), John the Gospel-writer, whom most consider different from JtheA (JtheG), and John of Patmos (JofP).

Of course, some major religious figures also hold the book to be of no worth whatsoever, and rejected it utterly. Calvin and Luther both held similar views in this regard.

That's controversial. The Feast of the Reformation in Lutheran churches in Luther's lifetime commenced with a reading from Revelation, and Calvin cited Revelation as an authoritative text in several of his Biblical commentaries.

I think like any readers, they may have had some books they liked a lot and some not much at all, but apparently they both 'held their nose' and called it Scripture just the same.

I'm not certain what other apologists claim in this regard to make it jive. I think the Catholics hold that they were visions intended to reassure a certain regional group, those in Asia Minor, and not intended for everyone.

That would be a difficult case to make, as the Book describes the end of the world, of considerable interest to those outside of Asia Minor, whomever the book may be nominally addressed to.

It may be that the author of Revelation thought Asia Minor was the whole world, but to argue its demographic should be limited by the author's ignorance, one would be arguing that the entire Bible really only applies to people in that tiny part of the world its authors were aware of.

Not certain if the Catholic make a distinction between prophecy and visions. <shrug>

Luvin' the <shrug>. :p As for the distinction between prophecy and visions, not. Revelation is written in the same style as the OT prophecies which Jesus claimed to have fulfilled; the only difference is Rev. is longer and more detailed; I don't see any reason to then conclude this is a vision, while the others are prophecy (unless one defines prophecy as "fulfilled vision").

If by vision one means "collection of metaphors" or somesuch, one would still need to explain what Christ throwing nonbelievers and sinners into a pit of fire is a metaphor for. Whatever it is a metaphor for, there is no denying it embodies a tremendous amount of hatred and rage towards those who don't believe in Xtianity, an obvious contradiction to the message of universal love most Xtians derive from the Bible, or the Gospels at least, or those parts of the Gospels they've read at least, or seen in movies or on tv at least, or heard about somewhere at least, etc.

Finally, there are some who contend that the book is a chronicle, not a prediction, of actual events.

Well, part of the symbolism seems to refer to the Babylonian, Persian, and Macedonian empires, former rulers over Judea, and lastly the Roman empire, current ruler in the 1st century AD. It can then be read as the author's bitterness at the past captivities of his tribe, and expectation that God will wipe out their new captors.

So yes, "chronicle... of actual events" up to a point, but "prediction" of events to come, i.e. Judgment day and Kingdom come, after that point.

I'm sure this upsets and offends all those waiting for the Rapture to come and take them bodily to their just reward, but there it is. :D

Well, if someone lived her whole life waiting for Revelation... and it didn't happen? -- I can see how she might be a bit disappointed. :D

So, depending, this either contradicts utterly, or is of no matter whatsoever, in regards to Jesus' words.

Mmm. I'm not sure.

From above, we have four candidates for author of Revelation: JtheB, JtheA, JtheG, and JofP.

If JtheB, then Jesus' 'priest' and friend is the author of Revelation. We can assume Jesus was aware of the contents of Revelation, and given JtheB's deference to the authority of Jesus, must have appoved it. Revelation would then be integral to the Biblical canon, and not dismissible as a troubling postscript.

This would, however, preserve the sense of Matthew 5:17, Jesus coming to fulfill the Prophets (their prophecies?)

If JtheA, then a follower of Jesus, one of the dozen who accompanied God on earth, blessed by His presence, wrote Revelation. Again, it would be hard to dismiss it from the canon, especially as the less substantial letters of JtheA are included. It would also, arguably, mess up Matthew 5:17, as JtheA, as a prophet at least, came after Jesus, inplying Jesus must still fulfill him, and that Revelation is the description of the fulfillment to come.

If JtheG, then the author of the Johannine Gospel, one of the four or five most revered texts in the Xtian corpus, is also the author of Revelation. This would make it impossible to deny the canonicity of Revelation, and would surely mean Jesus still had a prophecy to fulfill.

If JofP is, I think, he best the apologist can hope for. JofP doesn't have any obvious connection to Jesus, so it leaves open the debate on how 'seriously' to take Revelation (though as I argued earlier, I'm skeptical there's much rhetorical purchase here), and thus, whether this guy is a Prophet or a "maniac" (to borrow Thomas Jefferson's epithet).

The danger of course, or so it seems to me as a skeptic, is that even to leave this an open question is to flirt with disaster, and apocalypse. As long as Revelation is in the
Bible, and as long as mores and attitudes mirror the ups and downs of civilization, there's always the chance that an economic downturn will become a fundamentalist upsurge, and all these ridiculous biblical beliefs that many of the faithful shrug off now won't seem so ridiculous in harder times. One has only to think how far much of Islam has fallen from liberalism and tolerance to extremism and ignorance; I see no reason to think Christianity should be immune.

I'm not sure what the solution is: even if you tear it out as Jefferson did for his Bible (along with any other verses that hinted at the supernatural, including Christ's resurrection), it's no big deal to reinsert them, if the occasion demands. I can't see anything else to do as skeptics except play the gadfly, to continually circle the garbage dump that is the Bible, cull out its flowers and its ****, try to cover books like Revelation with so much **** that any effort to dig it out later from under will be too much for even the most determined, desperate faith.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom