A Christian Sceptic
Master Poster
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2007
- Messages
- 2,288
Well then, I'll just sit over here and watch from the sidelines, shall I?
Sure. Make sure you order a Pint from Darth, though.
Well then, I'll just sit over here and watch from the sidelines, shall I?
No it's not. Perhaps your confusion is a reading problem?And that's not arguing they should follow all the Old Testament laws?![]()
Nope. It's arguing that that's what that text says.And when you said it's apparent Verse 19 means Christians have to follow Old Testament laws - that's also not arguing Christians have to follow Old Testament laws?
What is it you're arguing then?
No it's not. Perhaps your confusion ...
<snip>
... don't think they count.

For additional clarification, since you're pretending you don't understand the very transparent words I've been using:And that's not arguing they should follow all the Old Testament laws?
And when you said it's apparent Verse 19 means Christians have to follow Old Testament laws - that's also not arguing Christians have to follow Old Testament laws?
Well that clears things up perfectly.![]()
He always does that. The same point has been explained a myriad of ways, but he prefers his particular straw man. Go figure.
How else is he going to imagine himself "divinely inspired" and "in on" special magical truths.
How else is he going to pretend that atheists are "moral relativists", and he's not?
I think believers just babble here to tell themselves that they had a logical discussion with skeptics, and they still "believe"--(therefore, their woo must be true)
And that's not arguing they should follow all the Old Testament laws?
And when you said it's apparent Verse 19 means Christians have to follow Old Testament laws - that's also not arguing Christians have to follow Old Testament laws?
What is it you're arguing then?
Now I'm confused. The answers to these questions were in the post two before this one. It seems entirely clear to me what JoeTJ (and many others through this thread) is saying. How are you still hung up on the idea that atheists want Christians to follow OT laws?
JoeTheJuggler said:Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?
JoeTheJuggler said:Verse 19 clearly has Jesus saying you ought obey every single little law specified in the scriptures.
Schlitt said:ACS, do you think the meaning of this verse is ambiguous?
What would be the reason for wanting this verse to mean something other than what it appears to mean literally?
Robin said:He strengthened one or two and altered another couple, but it seems pretty clear that is what he meant - the law stays in force until all is accomplished.
Michael C said:According to the quoted verses, Jesus said: "I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished".
What does this mean, if not that the "Law" will stay in force until heaven and earth disappear?
Edmund Standing said:'Heaven' and earth haven't disappeared. Therefore your interpretation fails. The Law remains valid for the followers of Jesus until the apocalyptic transformation that was expected to be coming soon; the same transformation referred to in Revelation, the same transformation which, as it didn't happen in Jesus' lifetime, or even shortly afterwards, was then projected to be coming when Jesus 'returns', which, of course, was due to happen in or around the author's lifetime
Freethinker said:I can't even imagine any room for interpretation there. It clearly is emphasizing no changes at all to the law. I understand your point about his emphasis on teaching others to do the wrong thing, and if addressing people who are teacher/preachers/scholars, I see the reasoning , but if the law didn't change, then people still have to follow it, don't they?
Schlitt said:Have you considered selective reasoning due to bias from the Christian literature?
Perhaps they are twisting the interpretation to suit them, in the way you think the Atheists are. This seems likely considering the meaning of the verse seems obvious, and when you consider that surely a god's words should not require such interpretation and twisting.
Many Christians say the Bible is a source of morality. (I'll go further, some even claim that just reading the Bible is somehow a moral act in and of itself.) When critics (like me) point out that great sections of the Bible are morally reprehensible, many Christians counter that that's just the Old Testament and that Jesus replaced the old law with a new law--so the old law no longer holds.
I don't think all atheists want anything, but I do think some atheists do. Or at least they did at the beginning of this thread.
Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?
For example, I would say that parents are a key source of morality for many people and yet I would imagine than in all cases there are occasions when the parents demonstrate immoral acts.
Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?
The answer to this question, however, does nothing to lead his catechumen to despair. Rather, it encourages him to obey in spite of his failings. It states: “He requires nothing which we are not bound to perform. Nevertheless, provided we take care to conform our life to what we are told here, although we are very far from reaching perfection, the Lord does not impute our faults to us” (emphasis mine). [5] Calvin says nothing about the law leading us to despair; rather we are “to take care to conform our life” to the law.
http://www.hornes.org/theologia/bill-dejong/michael-horton-john-calvin-and-law-gospel
The Instructor showed us how extensive, according to the Word of God the fifth commandment is. For it not only speaks of the love we owe our parents but also shows us that we must show all honor, love, fidelity and submission to all those whom God has placed over us. The fifth commandment not only tells us: "Honor thy father and thy mother, but the Lord also tells us thereby:
Render unto Ceasar the things which are Ceasar's and unto God the things that are God's."
How very evident it is, then, that the great Lawgiver, Who is a God of love and of order, desires our peace and salvation. He desires that love and order shall reign in our hearts, in our home, in the church and in the state.
http://www.the-highway.com/ten_commandments6.html
I don't think all atheists want anything, but I do think some atheists do. Or at least they did at the beginning of this thread.
I don't think all atheists want anything, but I do think some atheists do. Or at least they did at the beginning of this thread.
Actually, some Christian theologists and Biblical scholars hold the authorship to be that of John the Baptist rather than John the Apostle / John of Patmos.
Of course, some major religious figures also hold the book to be of no worth whatsoever, and rejected it utterly. Calvin and Luther both held similar views in this regard.
I'm not certain what other apologists claim in this regard to make it jive. I think the Catholics hold that they were visions intended to reassure a certain regional group, those in Asia Minor, and not intended for everyone.
Not certain if the Catholic make a distinction between prophecy and visions. <shrug>
Finally, there are some who contend that the book is a chronicle, not a prediction, of actual events.
I'm sure this upsets and offends all those waiting for the Rapture to come and take them bodily to their just reward, but there it is.![]()
So, depending, this either contradicts utterly, or is of no matter whatsoever, in regards to Jesus' words.
If we actually achieved the Sturgeon's Law standard, that's a win, this being the internet.This entire thread is 90% filler, 10% discussion.
Although that might just be a tad generous.