The atheists favorite bible verses

Could someone clarify how telling a Christian that Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws is not saying Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

Let's keep this simple:
Give me a Yes or No - are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

JoeTheJuggler?

Robin?

Michael C?

Edmund Standing?

Freethinker?

Schlitt?

Anyone else?

I think others have made it perfectly clear that we're arguing about what the Bible says, not if we want you to follow its teachings or not.

If you want to know what I think people should do, here's my personal stance:

Christians shouldn't follow Old Testament Laws. Jews shouldn't follow Old Testament laws. Nobody should follow Old Testament laws. The New Testament does say that people should follow Old Testament laws, so I don't agree with it.

(OK; that's not the only reason why I don't agree with the New Testament, just one of many.)
 
Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?

For example, I would say that parents are a key source of morality for many people and yet I would imagine than in all cases there are occasions when the parents demonstrate immoral acts.
Sure, but if the parents are mass-murdering nut jobs it might raise certain questions as to the soundness of the moral advice they would pass on.
 
Could someone clarify how telling a Christian that Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws is not saying Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

Let's keep this simple:
Give me a Yes or No - are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

JoeTheJuggler?

Robin?

Michael C?

Edmund Standing?

Freethinker?

Schlitt?

Anyone else?
Jesus for example?

If you are asking if I personally want Christians to follow the commandments a fictional bronze-age God then of course not. And I would very much appreciate if they would quit trying to foist Leviticus style values onto the rest of us. Very much.

I think you guys should go completely cold turkey on the whole OT thing. If you disapprove of Yahweh's child slaughtering policy or his unbeliever murdering policies (and you have not yet stated that you do) then there is no reason to approve of his gay hating policies.

If, on the other hand, you are asking if I think the intention of Matthew 5 is to reaffirm the authority of the Mosaic law over Christians (with a handful of variations), then I have already answered, yes, I think that is the intention of those words. I am not sure why you need to ask again.
 
Sorry, you're wrong.
Sorry, I'm right :D

Do you really think Christian doctrine is that Jesus accomplished everything two thousands years ago? Can you not think of anything else that was supposed to be accomplished?

Oh, just little things like Heaven and Earth passing away before the establishment of the Kingdom of God?

Wasn't Jesus claiming to be the Redeemer prophesied by Isaiah? And Isaiah promised:

"Behold, I will create
new heavens and a new earth.
The former things will not be remembered,
nor will they come to mind. "
Isaiah 65:17

So clearly his audience would have well understood that heaven and earth would pass away when these things were accomplished.

"I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished."

Not either/or. Both.
 
Yes it is, several of the people you mention have explicitly told you that is their point, see Rasmus and Kopji's posts above as examples of people telling you explicitly that you have their position wrong.

And they're not those who I quoted are they?

And I presume you will say that you still will not provide the evidence that enables you to make this claim?

see the OP.



So - YES or NO. Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?
 
Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?

For example, I would say that parents are a key source of morality for many people and yet I would imagine than in all cases there are occasions when the parents demonstrate immoral acts.
The inconsistency part is with regard to whether or not to "count" the Old Testament which is well over 50% of most Christian Bibles. So at issue is how do you decide to ignore such a big chunk of it when even instruction in the part you think counts says that you shouldn't ignore any smallest bit of the old law.

If you go to the Bible with no other moral guide (not even what I think is an innate sense of morality that most people have), you would have no clue as to what parts to follow and what parts to ignore.

If your parents gave good moral guidance say 10% of the time, and advocated hideously immoral behavior (rape, murder, slavery, etc.) say 30% of the time, and spouted a lot of meaningless rules the rest of the time, I would say that they are not good moral guides.
 
So - YES or NO. Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?

You're still studiously ignoring the bit where I pointed out your feigned confusion.

I suspect that none of us here (none of us that you quoted) advocate anyone following the Old Testament laws. What we have said is that the passage that includes the purported words of your Lord and God incarnate says that you should.


Do you understand the difference?
 
Does something need to be 100% consistent and absolutely inerrant in order for it to be a source of morality?

For example, I would say that parents are a key source of morality for many people and yet I would imagine than in all cases there are occasions when the parents demonstrate immoral acts.
There comes a certain time, at least in my opinion, when you reach extremes.

When two people can read the Bible, and one comes out with a lovey-dovey message of peace and pacifism, and another person comes out with a Hellfire and Brimstone message that promotes prejudice and outright hatred, and both can find tons of passages (the latter more than the former) to support their particular ideals in the source in question... then I start to see the source as less than useful as a source for morality. I certainly start to feel like I could do much better, personally.

To put it another way, no, nothing needs to be 100% consistent and inerrant for it to be a source of morality. But I'd appreciate being at least 10%, and a lot more than that for starters.
 
Last edited:
You're still studiously ignoring the bit where I pointed out your feigned confusion.

I suspect that none of us here (none of us that you quoted) advocate anyone following the Old Testament laws. What we have said is that the passage that includes the purported words of your Lord and God incarnate says that you should.


Do you understand the difference?

So - is that a YES or NO?
 
Jesus for example?

If you are asking if I personally want Christians to follow the commandments a fictional bronze-age God then of course not. And I would very much appreciate if they would quit trying to foist Leviticus style values onto the rest of us. Very much.

I think you guys should go completely cold turkey on the whole OT thing. If you disapprove of Yahweh's child slaughtering policy or his unbeliever murdering policies (and you have not yet stated that you do) then there is no reason to approve of his gay hating policies.

If, on the other hand, you are asking if I think the intention of Matthew 5 is to reaffirm the authority of the Mosaic law over Christians (with a handful of variations), then I have already answered, yes, I think that is the intention of those words. I am not sure why you need to ask again.

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws? YES or NO?
 
I think others have made it perfectly clear that we're arguing about what the Bible says, not if we want you to follow its teachings or not.

If you want to know what I think people should do, here's my personal stance:

Christians shouldn't follow Old Testament Laws. Jews shouldn't follow Old Testament laws. Nobody should follow Old Testament laws. The New Testament does say that people should follow Old Testament laws, so I don't agree with it.

(OK; that's not the only reason why I don't agree with the New Testament, just one of many.)

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
 
Let's keep this simple:
Give me a Yes or No - are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

JoeTheJuggler?
You're purposely keeping this ambiguous, and you seem to be unable to read the dozens of responses that make the position a lot of us share very clear.

NO: I don't think anyone should follow all the Old Testament Laws.

YES: I think the passage in Matthew that you cited does say that you should follow every last one of the Old Testament Law.

Do you get it yet?

When you try to argue that it's OK to ignore the Old Testament (im)moral teachings, you are in fact also ignoring New Testament teachings.

Your reading of the passage from Matthew to mean "practice what you preach" is indefensible. The passage clearly says you should obey and teach every last one of the old laws. The old law is not abolished. (And I've given you a pretty reasonable historical argument for why the author of Matthew probably put that in there.)

There's also the similar passage in Luke which says nothing about teaching at all but clearly states that not one bit of the old law disappears.
 
You're purposely keeping this ambiguous, and you seem to be unable to read the dozens of responses that make the position a lot of us share very clear.

NO: I don't think anyone should follow all the Old Testament Laws.

YES: I think the passage in Matthew that you cited does say that you should follow every last one of the Old Testament Law.

Do you get it yet?

When you try to argue that it's OK to ignore the Old Testament (im)moral teachings, you are in fact also ignoring New Testament teachings.

Your reading of the passage from Matthew to mean "practice what you preach" is indefensible. The passage clearly says you should obey and teach every last one of the old laws. The old law is not abolished. (And I've given you a pretty reasonable historical argument for why the author of Matthew probably put that in there.)

There's also the similar passage in Luke which says nothing about teaching at all but clearly states that not one bit of the old law disappears.

There's nothing ambiguous about the phrase "supposed to".

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
 
So - is that a YES or NO?

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws? YES or NO?

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

You can't possibly be this dense.

Your question has been answered repeatedly. It's not hard to understand.

Now it's your turn:

YES or NO--are Christians supposed to follow every last bit of the New Testatament teachings?
 
Sorry I missed that. Can you please explain again, I would much rather a Christian than an athiest explained it to me.

Should Christians stick to all, some or none of the laws of the OT ?

So - YES or NO. Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?

So - is that a YES or NO?

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws? YES or NO?

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

There's nothing ambiguous about the phrase "supposed to".

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
Good you understand my question. Do you have an answer ?
 
There's nothing ambiguous about the phrase "supposed to".

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
That's just it - the phrase "supposed to" is completely ambiguous, and we don't know what you mean by it. The two likely interpretations are:

1. What Christians are supposed to do, according to our personal views of good behavior, and

2. What Christians are supposed to do according to their own sacred book.

Please tell us which you mean, and we can answer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom