Lonewulf
Humanistic Cyborg
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2005
- Messages
- 10,375
Usually because said atheists follow the logical assumptions to their natural conclusion.The demand that all TrueScotsmenChristians be doctrinaire is something the Pope and some of the critical skeptics/atheists have in common.
If you take as a core assumption that the Bible is the written word of a holy man, someone with a view of The Truth (tm), and is at the very least inspired by Big G himself, and gives moral commandments of one sort or another, then therefore the logical conclusion seems to be -- that if you want to try to tell anyone else to look at this guide and follow it -- that you should at the very least make an effort to follow these commandments yourself.
If the Bible is not The Truth (tm) or inspired by Big G (although I suppose the latter really isn't as important as the former, although the two really should be intertwined under the assumption that God is omniscient after all), then one should wonder why we should innately trust it? I see commonly the phrase "It's in the Bible" as justification for all sorts of beliefs. But yet, if the Bible tells you to do one thing, and you do another thing, and the Bible is a moral guide, then why should I trust the latter claim? Either you are going against this moral guide purposefully, or you accept that the moral guide is, in this case, false. Which makes me wonder whether the veracity of the other morals -- given any of the above assumptions -- should be trusted.
However, I don't even have to argue using the core Big G assumption. We can get rid of religion altogether. Let's just go with the "Moral Guide" business.
Let's say that, say, Person X decided to make up a moral guide for everyone. He writes it out, details it, and gives you a set of rules that You Must Follow (and let's face it, the Bible doesn't quite put it's rules in the form of "suggestions"...)
I, Lonewulf, am a great fan of this moral code. I go crazy over it and hand it out to others that are interested and tell them that it really works.
You, Darth Rotor, say "Wait a minute. I don't agree with this moral code. Here on Line 2 it says to kill all Mexicans. Here on Line 6 it says that if people have blue eyes, they aren't human and should be kept out of certain locations. I may be a Sith, but I don't agree to that. I tend to kill everyone equally when they get in my way."
Then I say, "Oh, I don't agree with those particular rules either. But look at Lines 1, 3, 4, 5, and 7 -- ignore the others."
What would be your natural response? Assuming I were you and you were me, it would be, "Well, then, you're not really using this as a moral guide. You're just picking and selecting what you agree with". Would this really be a moral guide that you're quick to snap up? Personally, I'd be rather dubious and rather go with my own gut instinct and cultural values -- which I was going with anyways, just trying to find the bits and pieces in the Moral Guide that agreed with me.
In short, a moral guide where you ignore a decent portion of when it comes to actual morals, doesn't really seem to be a useful guide.
It gets even worse when you factor in a moral guide that's advertised to be Inspired by the Divine Creator of the Universe, who will Decide where you Go after you Die.
Of course, in the case of the Bible, there are some ways to avoid this paradox:
First, the "Moral Guide" argument:
1) The Bible isn't a moral guide at all. When it tells you to do something, you can safely ignore it.
2) The Bible is a moral guide, but only sometimes. You have to be careful and trust your gut on what is and is not the morals you should follow. The fact that you happen to choose morals that you were brought up into already by present day society is just a coincidence.
3) The Bible is a moral guide, and you have failed to follow the morals it tells you that you definitely should (even must) do. If you want to get on the good side of that which makes morality objective, Repent (but see later argument for a reason why you may not need to repent!)
Another way to avoid the paradox is to simply make the moral guide not so important. One way is to get rid of the whole "Inspired by God" argument.
1) The works aren't really inspired by God. That part was just fluff based on ancient beliefs, but there are still morals that are useful (even if they can be found in many other sources for moral philosophy, but let's ignore that).
2) The works really are inspired by God, but only sometimes. See #2 above.
3) See #3 above, and repent!
Then there's the possibility of, say, making the commands less literal.
1) Nothing in the bible is literal, except maybe when it explains events that occurred (and even then, you may believe that they were embellished a tad...)
2) Some things are literal, such as when it offers a direct command that you MUST do A. But see, the problem with this one is that many Christians still don't actually do A.
3) Perhaps it IS Literal, but was meant for Someone Else. It's not meant for you, the reader, today, as time as passed and things have changed. Although it does make people -- like me -- wonder why the morality inspired by God is so flexible...
4) It's entirely Literal whenever it talks about what you Should/Must do and gives any kinds of commands whatsoever. See #3 above.
So, see, I can see how you might be able to try to argue your way out of following the moral commands of the Bible, while also simultaneously thinking that the book is inspired by God or, to be more clear, by proxy gives you commands from Above. However, it seems that someone has to put much effort into it and brush away a few logical errors (and few pieces of scripture) under a carpet.
Thanks. I just happened to wander back thanks to a stray JREF link, and I was curious what the old boys were up to.Darth Rotor said:@Lonewulf:
Nice to see you again,
My experience tends to be that they ignore the question altogether.I agree that now and again when dealing with a sola scriptura literalist one needs to get them to explain what scriptura guidance they don't follow, and why. Some come up with better responses than others.
Is this really an example? Does it actually say in the Bible that you should/must celebrate Christmas or Easter in the first place? Actually, it seems that your example is rather opposite of what you meant, if this trustworthy random website I found with 2 seconds on a google engine has anything to say about it.For example, my neighbor, who is a JW, doesn't do Christmas, Easter, etcetera, nor do he and his family do birthday parties. This caused my son some distress, as he wanted to give his two best buddies Christmas presents, the boys next door, and I had to explain to him that he could do so but just drop the Christmas deal.
It seems that the trappings of Christmas -- outside of celebrating The Lord and all that -- actually goes against literal translations of the Bible. Of course, I'm willing to see a much better source that says otherwise; but from what I remember, some things that are accepted as "Christian", "Catholic", or whatever doesn't actually seem to stem out of the Bible at all. For instance, angels having wings seems to be more based on renaissance artwork more than what was mentioned in the Bible. As far as I know, "Hell" as a burning pit seems to be a rather creative interpretation of a line in the Bible, and doesn't seem to have the same meaning in there as the modern context. And, Christmas and Easter do not seem to be holidays as explained in the Bible with traditions that are suggested in the Bible.
Well, I'd like to think that I don't, either. Although I'm hard pressed to see where this fits in the discussion.My neighbor doesn't go off on people who do all that corrupted stuff that nasty evil Christians do, per Watchtower propaganda, nor does he wax poetic about the vile Jesuits and their crimes against humanity.
Last edited: