The atheists favorite bible verses

The demand that all True Scotsmen Christians be doctrinaire is something the Pope and some of the critical skeptics/atheists have in common.
Usually because said atheists follow the logical assumptions to their natural conclusion.

If you take as a core assumption that the Bible is the written word of a holy man, someone with a view of The Truth (tm), and is at the very least inspired by Big G himself, and gives moral commandments of one sort or another, then therefore the logical conclusion seems to be -- that if you want to try to tell anyone else to look at this guide and follow it -- that you should at the very least make an effort to follow these commandments yourself.

If the Bible is not The Truth (tm) or inspired by Big G (although I suppose the latter really isn't as important as the former, although the two really should be intertwined under the assumption that God is omniscient after all), then one should wonder why we should innately trust it? I see commonly the phrase "It's in the Bible" as justification for all sorts of beliefs. But yet, if the Bible tells you to do one thing, and you do another thing, and the Bible is a moral guide, then why should I trust the latter claim? Either you are going against this moral guide purposefully, or you accept that the moral guide is, in this case, false. Which makes me wonder whether the veracity of the other morals -- given any of the above assumptions -- should be trusted.

However, I don't even have to argue using the core Big G assumption. We can get rid of religion altogether. Let's just go with the "Moral Guide" business.

Let's say that, say, Person X decided to make up a moral guide for everyone. He writes it out, details it, and gives you a set of rules that You Must Follow (and let's face it, the Bible doesn't quite put it's rules in the form of "suggestions"...)

I, Lonewulf, am a great fan of this moral code. I go crazy over it and hand it out to others that are interested and tell them that it really works.

You, Darth Rotor, say "Wait a minute. I don't agree with this moral code. Here on Line 2 it says to kill all Mexicans. Here on Line 6 it says that if people have blue eyes, they aren't human and should be kept out of certain locations. I may be a Sith, but I don't agree to that. I tend to kill everyone equally when they get in my way."

Then I say, "Oh, I don't agree with those particular rules either. But look at Lines 1, 3, 4, 5, and 7 -- ignore the others."

What would be your natural response? Assuming I were you and you were me, it would be, "Well, then, you're not really using this as a moral guide. You're just picking and selecting what you agree with". Would this really be a moral guide that you're quick to snap up? Personally, I'd be rather dubious and rather go with my own gut instinct and cultural values -- which I was going with anyways, just trying to find the bits and pieces in the Moral Guide that agreed with me.

In short, a moral guide where you ignore a decent portion of when it comes to actual morals, doesn't really seem to be a useful guide.

It gets even worse when you factor in a moral guide that's advertised to be Inspired by the Divine Creator of the Universe, who will Decide where you Go after you Die.

Of course, in the case of the Bible, there are some ways to avoid this paradox:

First, the "Moral Guide" argument:

1) The Bible isn't a moral guide at all. When it tells you to do something, you can safely ignore it.

2) The Bible is a moral guide, but only sometimes. You have to be careful and trust your gut on what is and is not the morals you should follow. The fact that you happen to choose morals that you were brought up into already by present day society is just a coincidence.

3) The Bible is a moral guide, and you have failed to follow the morals it tells you that you definitely should (even must) do. If you want to get on the good side of that which makes morality objective, Repent (but see later argument for a reason why you may not need to repent!)

Another way to avoid the paradox is to simply make the moral guide not so important. One way is to get rid of the whole "Inspired by God" argument.

1) The works aren't really inspired by God. That part was just fluff based on ancient beliefs, but there are still morals that are useful (even if they can be found in many other sources for moral philosophy, but let's ignore that).

2) The works really are inspired by God, but only sometimes. See #2 above.

3) See #3 above, and repent!

Then there's the possibility of, say, making the commands less literal.

1) Nothing in the bible is literal, except maybe when it explains events that occurred (and even then, you may believe that they were embellished a tad...)

2) Some things are literal, such as when it offers a direct command that you MUST do A. But see, the problem with this one is that many Christians still don't actually do A.

3) Perhaps it IS Literal, but was meant for Someone Else. It's not meant for you, the reader, today, as time as passed and things have changed. Although it does make people -- like me -- wonder why the morality inspired by God is so flexible...

4) It's entirely Literal whenever it talks about what you Should/Must do and gives any kinds of commands whatsoever. See #3 above.



So, see, I can see how you might be able to try to argue your way out of following the moral commands of the Bible, while also simultaneously thinking that the book is inspired by God or, to be more clear, by proxy gives you commands from Above. However, it seems that someone has to put much effort into it and brush away a few logical errors (and few pieces of scripture) under a carpet.



Darth Rotor said:
@Lonewulf:

Nice to see you again,
Thanks. I just happened to wander back thanks to a stray JREF link, and I was curious what the old boys were up to.

I agree that now and again when dealing with a sola scriptura literalist one needs to get them to explain what scriptura guidance they don't follow, and why. Some come up with better responses than others.
My experience tends to be that they ignore the question altogether.

For example, my neighbor, who is a JW, doesn't do Christmas, Easter, etcetera, nor do he and his family do birthday parties. This caused my son some distress, as he wanted to give his two best buddies Christmas presents, the boys next door, and I had to explain to him that he could do so but just drop the Christmas deal.
Is this really an example? Does it actually say in the Bible that you should/must celebrate Christmas or Easter in the first place? Actually, it seems that your example is rather opposite of what you meant, if this trustworthy random website I found with 2 seconds on a google engine has anything to say about it.

It seems that the trappings of Christmas -- outside of celebrating The Lord and all that -- actually goes against literal translations of the Bible. Of course, I'm willing to see a much better source that says otherwise; but from what I remember, some things that are accepted as "Christian", "Catholic", or whatever doesn't actually seem to stem out of the Bible at all. For instance, angels having wings seems to be more based on renaissance artwork more than what was mentioned in the Bible. As far as I know, "Hell" as a burning pit seems to be a rather creative interpretation of a line in the Bible, and doesn't seem to have the same meaning in there as the modern context. And, Christmas and Easter do not seem to be holidays as explained in the Bible with traditions that are suggested in the Bible.

My neighbor doesn't go off on people who do all that corrupted stuff that nasty evil Christians do, per Watchtower propaganda, nor does he wax poetic about the vile Jesuits and their crimes against humanity.
Well, I'd like to think that I don't, either. Although I'm hard pressed to see where this fits in the discussion.
 
Last edited:
Beats me. I didn't want to ignore you, didn't have much more to say then "Yes". I considered it the first time someone used those verse towards me and when I read them couldn't find out how they were reading all that into those verses. And it made me wonder if they and others (since so many others here use those same verses the same way) were aware of some Christian teachings on it. Thus this thread.

OK, could still generate useful discussion if everyone (and I mean both sides) thinks more broadly, perhaps. I'm pretty sure I understand DR's and Bokonon's and Joe's positions, but I'm not really sure I can say that for every involved, but some of that is probably just me.

By the way, I'm heading to the bookstore when I leave work in an hour or so, but I misplaced the title of that book about the context of the early church that you suggested to me in another thread. Do you happen to remember the name of it or the author? I know it's been a few months, but I have time to read it now and hoped you might remember.
 
I don't have a clue who that's directed to, or what you're saying there. Sorry.

The internet genie, obviously.
You're just dodging the point other people have been trying to get you to address. Do you think that Jesus' words give you the right to break the law?

I don't see how they do.

Hence my very clear example.
A murderer is low, even if he isn't the lowest of the low.

Well, if it is - then you'll be the least in the Kingdom of Heaven, apparently.:eye-poppi

And if it isn't, then I only broke the law of the Sabbath and never taught anyone to do the same. And so I won't be the least in the Kingdom of Heaven -- Oh Frabjous Day! Calloo, Callay. There couldn't possibly be anything bad in that.
 
Last edited:
it appears that if you don't mind being the least in the Kingdom of Heaven then feel free to break the law and teach others to do that.
I assume that you're not following the old testament rules you don't feel like following. Since you're also stating on an internet forum that you don't think it's necessary for Christians to follow those rules, it seems that you're teaching others to do the same.

Can I assume that you don't mind being the least in the KOH?
 
By the way, I'm heading to the bookstore when I leave work in an hour or so, but I misplaced the title of that book about the context of the early church that you suggested to me in another thread. Do you happen to remember the name of it or the author? I know it's been a few months, but I have time to read it now and hoped you might remember.

It was probably this one:
The Rise of Christianity: How the Obscure, Marginal, Jesus Movement Became the Dominant Religious Force by Rodney Stark.

Let me know what you think.
 
Can I assume that you don't mind being the least in the KOH?

It's just occured to me that perhaps ACS sees it this way:
If you're in the lowest tier of the Kingdom of heaven, then you're in Heaven.

He may not see Hell as part of the Kingdom of Heaven.


I haven't been thinking of it that way. I thought the Kingdom of Heaven was everything that Heaven had jurisdiction over. And, thus, I would have included the correctional facilities.
 
Last edited:
No I'm not. I meant I've already posted that answer. You can go search for it. I'm not going to keep reposting the same answer to every person who wants me too.

No, you haven't answered the question. Fine, if you want to avoid it, the discussion stops here.

Read what I said and where I referred to Practice What You Preach.

Yes, I read that. Now I'll take the pains to repeat my point, using an example:

A man breaks the commandment of Deuteronomy 22:11, by wearing a garment of wool and linen together. He also teaches others to do the same. This man is clearly practising what he preaches. However, according to Matthew 5:19, "Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven". The man has indeed broken one of the commandments and taught others to do the same, so he will apparently be "called least in the kingdom of heaven". Although he has simply practised what he preached.

Matthew 5:19 certainly doesn't mean "practice what you preach". It means "you should both practice and teach the old commandments, if you want a good place in heaven."

As far as I know whoever does not mean should.
Nobody said it did. We're talking about the sense of the whole phrase, not just one word.
 
Last edited:
I assume that you're not following the old testament rules you don't feel like following.

I have my plate full trying to follow Jesus teachings. So, apart from whatever teachings he's taught that were based on the Old Testament I'm probably not following any. I've never gone through Leveticus thinking - hmm, let's see, which rules do I want to follow and which don't I.

I have known some Christians who do - although they've never used those Matthew verses in this thread to explain. They've actually never given me a good explanation on why they do that. The two biggies (laws that is) I've seen the most is to justify how they discipline their kids and why homosexuality is bad.

<shrugs>

Since you're also stating on an internet forum that you don't think it's necessary for Christians to follow those rules, it seems that you're teaching others to do the same.

Can I assume that you don't mind being the least in the KOH?

haha. You're funny. :D

I thought your point about if there was a comma in the middle of the beginning of Verse 19 was one of the best points here so far, by the way. At least you were dealing with the actual text.
 
No, you haven't answered the question. Fine, if you want to avoid it, the discussion stops here.

Okelly Dokelly.

Yes, I read that. Now I'll take the pains to repeat my point, using an example:

A man breaks the commandment of Deuteronomy 22:11, by wearing a garment of wool and linen together. He also teaches others to do the same. This man is clearly practising what he preaches. However, according to Matthew 5:19, "Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven". The man has indeed broken one of the commandments and taught others to do the same, so he will apparently be "called least in the kingdom of heaven". Although he has simply practised what he preached.

Or it means "Practice what you preach/teach when you teach people to obey the commandments, if you are going to break the commandments - don't preach/teach others to do it."

Nobody said it did. We're talking about the sense of the whole phrase, not just one word.

I see nowhere that the word SHOULD is implied. Doesn't the word SHOULD mean it's a recommendation and optional?
 
I'm not sure what your emphasis of the word "argument" is meant to convey, so I may be responding to a point you're not making, but...

I use the example of "stoning children" when I'm talking to a biblical literalist, who says it's God's word and therefore inerrant. I'm not arguing that children should be stoned, I'm arguing that the bible is not a perfect guide for living. By pointing out that the literalist is already picking and choosing based on some internal moral code, and is already rejecting biblical rules which are immoral or unethical, I'm hoping the literalist will see that invoking biblical authority to justify his pet prejudice (usually the prohibition of some sex act) provides no real support.

Sometimes you encounter the "new covenant" counter-argument in such discussions, and parry with the verses in Matthew and Luke.

My motivation is never to see Christians boycott shrimp, it's to get them to consider what real, non-biblical reasons they have for insisting on the other rules they insist on. Perhaps they'll conclude that there IS no good reason to adhere to a moral code formulated by bronze-age bedouins. Perhaps they'll perceive that the internal compass is a viable alternative to biblical dogma, and be more open to the idea that atheists using that as their guide aren't necessarily demons, murderers, and rapists.

Why do you see it as a weak argument, and what would you advise using in its place?
This is well said.

ACS and others said that our argument is that we think all Christians should obey all the laws of the Old Testament. I do NOT think that at all. I agree with them that many of the laws are deplorable, others are petty and meaningless.

My argument is that there is a glaring inconsistency when Christians claim the Bible is a source of morality but they pick and choose which bits of it count based on sources of morality that have nothing to do with the text.

At best, you can find support in the Bible for almost any moral position you have. If you don't already have some sense of morality, going to the Bible to find it could be disastrous.

If anything, I'd like Christians to admit that the Bible is not the source of their morality.
 
I have my plate full trying to follow Jesus teachings. So, apart from whatever teachings he's taught that were based on the Old Testament I'm probably not following any. I've never gone through Leveticus thinking - hmm, let's see, which rules do I want to follow and which don't I.

I have known some Christians who do - although they've never used those Matthew verses in this thread to explain. They've actually never given me a good explanation on why they do that. The two biggies (laws that is) I've seen the most is to justify how they discipline their kids and why homosexuality is bad.

They don't need the Old Testament for that. They can use Matthew 15:4 to justify how they discipline their kids ("He that curseth father or mother, let him die the death") and Paul says enough against homosexuality.
 
ACS and others said that our argument is that we think all Christians should obey all the laws of the Old Testament. I do NOT think that at all. I agree with them that many of the laws are deplorable, others are petty and meaningless.

That's not what you said here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3700873#post3700873

And you've been arguing that Christians do need to throughout this thread.

But if you've changed your mind, that's cool.
 
That's not what you said here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3700873#post3700873

And you've been arguing that Christians do need to throughout this thread.

But if you've changed your mind, that's cool.

You know, when you decide to completely misrepresent someone's position, it helps if you don't link to their post.

Joe said if Christians claim their morality from the bible then they need to explain the atrocities and since they don't follow the evil bits they are inconsistent.

Nothing in that is an endorsement of the barbarism of your book. The implication is that they should give up the book as a source of morality, not immerse fully in the murder, rape, and genocide it promotes.
 
Last edited:
You know, when you decide to completely misrepresent someone's position, it helps if you don't link to their post.

Joe said if Christians claim their morality from the bible then they need to explain the atrocities and since they don't follow the evil bits they are inconsistent.

Nothing in that is an endorsement of the barbarism of your book. The implication is that they should give up the book as a source of morality, not immerse fully in the murder, rape, and genocide it promotes.

Nope. He agreed with my OP. And he said:
JoeTheJuggler said:
I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.

And through this thread he's been arguing that Christians must based on Verse 19 specifically.

So - no misrepresentation coming from my side.
 
That's not what you said here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3700873#post3700873

And you've been arguing that Christians do need to throughout this thread.

But if you've changed your mind, that's cool.
I'm not sure what you think you read.

I never said I thought Christians should obey the laws. I said the fact that they don't even though they claim to derive morality from the Bible presents them with a huge inconsistency.

Here's the post of mine you cited above:


I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.

If you claim to derive morality from "the Bible" (as a great many Christians claim to be able to do), then you have to explain all the abominable morality in Old Testament stories. Liberal Christians often dismiss the Old Testament (even though it still sits in their scriptural canon) by saying that Jesus taught a new way that replaced Old Testament morality.

This passage shows that (according to "the Bible") Jesus specifically said that he was not replacing Old Testament teachings.

I concede that most Christians don't adhere to this. I think they're being inconsistent.

ETA: Oops--I missed QuixoteCoyote's response to this same post. I'll let mine stand anyway, even though it's a repetition.
 
Last edited:
Nope. He agreed with my OP. And he said:


And through this thread he's been arguing that Christians must based on Verse 19 specifically.

So - no misrepresentation coming from my side.

You're not even carrying on a legitimate discussion anymore, my friend.

I never said I think Christians should do things like let farm fields lie fallow every 7th year or exercise the death penalty for any number of things which aren't even considered sins these days. I never said I wanted them to follow these laws, or that they ought.

I only agreed with you that most Christians do not. I further pointed out that it is a glaring and huge inconsistency in using the Bible as a source of morality.

Again, the argument is usually made when a Christian points to a Bible passage to justify something (homophobia or whatever). Critics (such as me) point out that the Bible has plenty of stuff in it that everyone would consider deplorable (justifying slavery, rape, murder, etc.). Some Christians respond that that's only in the old law which was replaced (i.e. made no longer valid) by Jesus. I am one of many who cite the passage your raised in Matthew and the analogous one I cited in Luke that Jesus clearly said that not one bit of the old law has been changed (or disappeared or made null and void). So, Christians making this argument have a serious logical problem.

It seems that you would agree with that point except that you think the passage in Matthew does NOT have Jesus saying that you should obey every least of the commandments in the "law and the prophets" (i.e. the Jewish scriptures at the time--what I've been referring to using the short-hand "Old Testament" or simply "old laws".) You seem to think the passage doesn't say anything about whether the old law is still in effect. You seem to think it says something similar to "practice what you preach" and is directed to the issue of teaching and not the issue of the status of the old laws.

I could care less whether you eat shrimp or wear two different fibers in your clothes, but I believe the word I used to describe the morality of much of the Old Testament was "abominable". I certainly don't think Christians or anyone else should follow those commandments. That you and others find them equally deplorable argues that the Bible really isn't a source of morality.
 
Last edited:
Again, the argument is usually made when a Christian points to a Bible passage to justify something (homophobia or whatever). Critics (such as me) point out that the Bible has plenty of stuff in it that everyone would consider deplorable (justifying slavery, rape, murder, etc.). Some Christians respond that that's only in the old law which was replaced (i.e. made no longer valid) by Jesus. I am one of many who cite the passage your raised in Matthew and the analogous one I cited in Luke that Jesus clearly said that not one bit of the old law has been changed (or disappeared or made null and void). So, Christians making this argument have a serious logical problem.

And that's not arguing they should follow all the Old Testament laws? :confused:

And when you said it's apparent Verse 19 means Christians have to follow Old Testament laws - that's also not arguing Christians have to follow Old Testament laws?

What is it you're arguing then?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom