The atheists favorite bible verses

This is the theology of Paul, not Matthew, which you are then overlaying. Matthew has Jesus command his followers to 'be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect'.
Is this not more frequently framed as the difference between the theology of Peter and Paul? Or am I confusing arguments here?
The notion of being born sinful is a Pauline theme.
Really? It's not an OT theme? The imperfection of man in his fallen state is Pauline in origin? Tell me more, I find this intriguing.
In Matthew, one seeks forgiveness for one's sins as a purification prior to the impending end of history and establishment of Kingdom of God.
However in Paul we find a desperate and overarching despair of the human condition and the notion that only the divine sacrifice of Jesus on the cross can save us.
Why do you find that irreconcilable? As to the italics, that's IMO a narrow view of his message, but no matter for the moment.
A good example of how Matthew's gospel invalidates this notion of Paul's is that in Matthew to even receive the baptism of John the Baptist was enough to symbolically 'cleanse' people of their sins as a final act of contrition in the end times.
For Matthew, Jesus will provide an even greater 'baptism', not one of water but one of bestowing spiritual vitality. However, receiving the baptism of John alone was clearly enough to signify repentance and inner purification. There is no suggestion that a divine sacrifice is needed to get rid of the 'condition' of being 'born into sin'.
And the other Gospels are to be ignored? :confused: (Don't have it on the tip of my tongue, but there's a passage in John that applies. I'll get back to you after I've checked my notes. )
The expectation is clear also from Matthew 5:48 that it was presumed that following repentance, Jesus' followers were to sin no more, and how would they do this? By following every letter of the Law until such time that the End should come.
That was the admonition, to strive to achieve that end, to be sure. (We seem to be drifting toward the Gnostic theme of becoming perfecti here, intentionally or otherwise.)
And how do we know that Matthew's Jesus advocated a strict adherence to the Law, one outstripping even that of the pious crowd of his day (the Pharisees)? Well, we return to:
Thank you for that take on the matter of sin and forgiveness. I'll chew on it a bit before I respond.

DR
 
Last edited:
This entire thread is 90% filler, 10% discussion.

Although that might just be a tad generous.

Yes--but you're back! I missed your surly, biting sarcasm and your sexy avatar. That boosts this threads value by at least 10% in my book!

ACS and the other apologists are just silly. The texts they claim to be divine are clearly the work of primitive peoples that people assign all sorts of truth/metaphor/moral relativity to. Theists get their morals the same way all other humans do--they just pretend it comes from a higher (divinely inspired) source. When we try to get them to realize this or explain how or what they interpret as "divinely inspired", they pretend we are trying to force our view of the bible on them! It's like they are having their own conversation in their head. I don't believe they can even make sense of each other, much less their bible.

In this way, they can pretend atheists are bad guys and they are good because they have faith in and are defending THE TRUTH. Of course, all theists have a different "truth" and it's all nebulous, because in order to keep the faith, you can't think logically about what you believe, and who inspired it, --nor how you know it's true. You'd rather just believe you are a better person for "believing in" whatever nebulous thing you have been indoctrinated to "believe in".

But the cognitive dissonance, semantic floundering, and straw man view of atheists are interesting to parse. So are the attempts to put "faith" on some pedestal-- rather then admitting it's another a nice sounding word for "gullibility" and "arrogant ignorance".

The bible was written based on memory and revelation many years after the fact by very ignorant people... and it's been subject to eons of embellishment, translation, interpretation-- certainly not a good way for an omniscient anyone to share anything of value.

How can anyone think any of it is true given what we know about memories:

http://scienceblogs.com/cortex/2008/05/false_memory.php

(fabulous video clip)
 
Is this not more frequently framed as the difference between the theology of Peter and Paul? Or am I confusing arguments here?
Really? It's not an OT theme? The imperfection of man in his fallen state is Pauline in origin? Tell me more, I find this intriguing.

...snip...

When you think about it since it is not part of the Judaic tradition it has to be something new added by Christianity to the interpretation of the shared OT/Torah books.
 
If you take as a core assumption that the Bible is the written word of a holy man, someone with a view of The Truth (tm), and is at the very least inspired by Big G himself, and gives moral commandments of one sort or another, then therefore the logical conclusion seems to be -- that if you want to try to tell anyone else to look at this guide and follow it -- that you should at the very least make an effort to follow these commandments yourself.
Indeed. I consider leadership by example the best kind.
I, Lonewulf, am a great fan of this moral code. I go crazy over it and hand it out to others that are interested and tell them that it really works.

You, Darth Rotor, say "Wait a minute. I don't agree with this moral code. Here on Line 2 it says to kill all Mexicans. Here on Line 6 it says that if people have blue eyes, they aren't human and should be kept out of certain locations. I may be a Sith, but I don't agree to that. I tend to kill everyone equally when they get in my way."

Then I say, "Oh, I don't agree with those particular rules either. But look at Lines 1, 3, 4, 5, and 7 -- ignore the others."

In short, a moral guide where you ignore a decent portion of when it comes to actual morals, doesn't really seem to be a useful guide.
And a maintenance manual that applies to more than one type of car is therefore also useless? :confused:

_snip moral guide discussion, enjoyed, not inspired to riposte at the moment__

Thanks. I just happened to wander back thanks to a stray JREF link, and I was curious what the old boys were up to.
I'm not old, I'm 37 -- oh, wait, I'm 48, never mind. :blush:
My experience tends to be that they ignore the question altogether. Is this really an example? Does it actually say in the Bible that you should/must celebrate Christmas or Easter in the first place?
No. The point is that my neighbor is far more enamored of a stricter interpretation of Scripture than I am.
Actually, it seems that your example is rather opposite of what you meant, if this trustworthy random website I found with 2 seconds on a google engine has anything to say about it.
It seems that the trappings of Christmas -- outside of celebrating The Lord and all that -- actually goes against literal translations of the Bible.
So my JW friend would argue, and we agree to disagree, since religion does not get practiced in isolation, but with a greater social framework.
Of course, I'm willing to see a much better source that says otherwise; but from what I remember, some things that are accepted as "Christian", "Catholic", or whatever doesn't actually seem to stem out of the Bible at all.
Yes, and I have no problem with that.

For instance, angels having wings seems to be more based on renaissance artwork more than what was mentioned in the Bible. As far as I know, "Hell" as a burning pit seems to be a rather creative interpretation of a line in the Bible, and doesn't seem to have the same meaning in there as the modern context. And, Christmas and Easter do not seem to be holidays as explained in the Bible with traditions that are suggested in the Bible.
Right, back to my neighbor being more literal in his framework.
Well, I'd like to think that I don't, either. Although I'm hard pressed to see where this fits in the discussion.
The issue of how doctrinaire one chooses to be, and why.

DR
 
Darth - to expand a bit on the Pauline thing. The (or perhaps just a) major difference between Christianity and Judaism is that Judaism teaches that you get to god by actions and keeping to what he tells you whilst Christianity teaches that you get to God only via Jesus.

Paul came up with a a very tortured way of reinterpreting the OT to support his view. One of his ways of doing this was the concept of original sin i.e. everyone is inherently corrupt and bad (and their breath smells), this created the reason why Jesus was so important - he had washed this inherent sin away.

As support for the "very tortured" reinterpretation, have a look at quotes Paul uses from the OT as they are recorded in the NT to support his interpretation and then compare them with the actual OT versus, you will see that Paul is sometimes ...er.... economical with the truth. That Paul could get away with this indicates that his primary audience was the gentiles of the time and not Jews since the Jews would know that what he was claiming about the Jewish text was not correct.
 
Last edited:
So can someone please clarify. Is it ok to kill again?

Well, the bible isn't really specific about what "thou shall not kill", but I think humans are safe to kill since they never really die... they just start their eternity earlier.

But, I don't think animals, plants, bugs, etc. have immortal souls-- so I think they should be included in the "thou shall not kill".

But, this is just my no-nonsense interpretation. Of course, I'm someone who thinks "born again" sounds like reincarnation... I'd never have extrapolated it to "accepting Jesus Christ as your personal Savior" (or whatever it is the fundies imagine it to mean).
 
Last edited:
So can someone please clarify. Is it ok to kill again?

Could someone clarify how telling a Christian that Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws is not saying Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

Let's keep this simple:
Give me a Yes or No - are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

JoeTheJuggler?

Robin?

Michael C?

Edmund Standing?

Freethinker?

Schlitt?

Anyone else?
 
Last edited:
Could someone clarify how telling a Christian that Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws is not saying Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

...snip...

Why ask them a question about a position they have not put forward?

A better question, based on what those folks have actually posted, would be:

Give me a Yes or No - according to Matthew 5:17-20 does Jesus state that his followers are to follow Old Testament laws?
 
Yes, and if so-- how do Christians justify "over riding" them... do they decide which ones to over ride individually? Who does their interpreting of the text for them and decides which are parables and such.

Oh... and original sin... that's from the old testament... but it's the reason Jesus was "sacrificed" right? So is it a parable or not? Who decides? Do some Christians believe that Jesus was "sacrificed" for a parable?

If it's not a parable... what parts are real? Who decides? What is the meaning behind it? Why isn't it clear?

The bible makes no sense to me. And I suspect that it doesn't make sense to theists either... they've just trained their brain not to think too much or question too much so they can believe it's an "inspired" magical text that is a good guide book for something or other.
 
Why ask them a question about a position they have not put forward?

A better question, based on what those folks have actually posted, would be:

Give me a Yes or No - according to Matthew 5:17-20 does Jesus state that his followers are to follow Old Testament laws?

Because that is not their position.

The way these verses are used is 1) to tell a Christian who is picking laws from the Old Testament that they are supposed to be picking all the laws. and 2) to tell a Christian in general that they are supposed to be following Old Testament Laws.

That's how it's used here in this forum, and that's how it's been used towards me and others.

Not only that - they claim it is obvious and apparent that's what those verses mean.
 
I'm still waiting for ACS and Darth Rotor to provide a more likely interpretation of the verses under discussion to the one I have presented here, here, and here.

DR has chosen to completely ignore my responses to him, while ACS has yet to demonstrate why his interpretation is more logical than the one I and others have proposed, given the historical nature of Matthew's gospel - i.e. a First Century Jewish apocalyptic text.

I've explained what I've thought. And I've done it using the text only and not grabbing other verses and other information. Why? Because that's the claim here and everytime an atheist posts those verses only as a rebuttal they make the same claim - that those verses obviously show Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament laws.

So - give me a YES or NO Edmund. Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?
 
Last edited:
I think the bible is quite clearly a manipulative work of fiction. As such I take it no more seriously than other such works-- the Quoran, The Book of Mormon, Dianetics, etc.

It's up to those who think such things have are divine in origin to prove it as far as I'm concerned. They are all equally unimportant to me. I don't know how anyone could objectively read the stuff in such texts and imagine them as having other than mortal origins.
 
...snip...

Oh... and original sin... that's from the old testament... but it's the reason Jesus was "sacrificed" right? So is it a parable or not? Who decides? Do some Christians believe that Jesus was "sacrificed" for a parable?

...snip...

Not the Christian doctrine of "original sin", that's a NT creation by Paul and it would seem that he created it to explain why just doing as you were told (Judaism) was no longer enough to get you in with God, you now had to also get in with Jesus as he was the new cool-kid on the block.


...snip...

If it's not a parable... what parts are real? Who decides? What is the meaning behind it? Why isn't it clear?

The bible makes no sense to me. And I suspect that it doesn't make sense to theists either... they've just trained their brain not to think too much or question too much so they can believe it's an "inspired" magical text that is a good guide book for something or other.

Part of the reason it doesn't make sense to many of us is that we are so far removed from the original audience; we just do not get the references and the referents that people of the time would have done. Plus of course all the editing that has been done over the last couple of thousand years to support a particular view or to denounce a view.
 
Last edited:
Because that is not their position.

Yes it is, several of the people you mention have explicitly told you that is their point, see Rasmus and Kopji's posts above as examples of people telling you explicitly that you have their position wrong.

"...The point of a lot of atheists is not so much imply that we think Christians should obey all the OT laws, just to confront them with laws that purport to be God's communication to man and no less holy now than they ever were....."

"...I see that the Bible has a lot to say even if you ignore some parts of it. But one cannot deny that one ignores some part and one needs to somehow justify which parts are being ignored. And, apparently, "Jesus told us to ignore the older bits" is simply not true and therefore not a valid explanation...."



The way these verses are used is 1) to tell a Christian who is picking laws from the Old Testament that they are supposed to be picking all the laws. and 2) to tell a Christian in general that they are supposed to be following Old Testament Laws.


...snip...

Not true.

That's how it's used here in this forum, and that's how it's been used towards me and others.


And I presume you will say that you still will not provide the evidence that enables you to make this claim?

Not only that - they claim it is obvious and apparent that's what those verses mean.

It is.
 
Last edited:
I've explained what I've thought. And I've done it using the text only and not grabbing other verses and other information. Why? Because that's the claim here and everytime an atheist posts those verses only as a rebuttal they make the same claim - that those verses obviously show Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament laws.
Sorry I missed that. Can you please explain again, I would much rather a Christian than an athiest explained it to me.

Should Christians stick to all, some or none of the laws of the OT ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom