The atheists favorite bible verses

You're picking and choosing here.

1) It also says that Jesus was not going to abolish the law.

Right - what did He say he was going to instead?

2) As bokonon already pointed out, we need clarification here. Does it mean:

"don't break God's law" and "don't teach others to break God"s law",

or does it mean

"you can break God's law or teach others to break God's law, as long as you don't do both"?

I think the first interpretation is reasonable and the second is nonsensical.

I've posted what it appears to be saying.

3) No, it doesn't say "Practice what you teach".

First -that was a play on the phrase "Practice What You Preach" - you know, Don't be a hypocrite.

It says you should practice and teach "these commands".

He doesn't say "You Should" anywhere in those verses.

What are "these commands", if not God's law already referred to?. Clearly Jesus wants people both to practice the laws and to teach them.

That's not clear at all. He's commenting on people who are teaching, he's not telling people they should.

4) Fair enough. This also seems to imply that the Pharisees and the teachers of the law will not enter the kingdom of heaven.

Appears to be - given the verses right above it about teachers and proper teaching I'd say he was implying specifically the Pharisees are either teaching people to do wrong or not practicing what they teach.

He doesn't seem to be talking about Atheists who are teaching commandments and not practicing them. Is insisting someone follow commandments the same as teaching?
 
Last edited:
And call me an apologist all you want, but I think the "why do you eat shrimp and wear mixed fibers" argument is one of the most insipid we've come up with. Why don't you ask Christians why they don't celebrate Passover, Jews why they aren't rabidly homophobic (since YHWH is their God, not the Triune Jeesholy Spirit) or why Muslims don't celebrate Christmas since they venerate Jesus?
I'm not sure what your emphasis of the word "argument" is meant to convey, so I may be responding to a point you're not making, but...

I use the example of "stoning children" when I'm talking to a biblical literalist, who says it's God's word and therefore inerrant. I'm not arguing that children should be stoned, I'm arguing that the bible is not a perfect guide for living. By pointing out that the literalist is already picking and choosing based on some internal moral code, and is already rejecting biblical rules which are immoral or unethical, I'm hoping the literalist will see that invoking biblical authority to justify his pet prejudice (usually the prohibition of some sex act) provides no real support.

Sometimes you encounter the "new covenant" counter-argument in such discussions, and parry with the verses in Matthew and Luke.

My motivation is never to see Christians boycott shrimp, it's to get them to consider what real, non-biblical reasons they have for insisting on the other rules they insist on. Perhaps they'll conclude that there IS no good reason to adhere to a moral code formulated by bronze-age bedouins. Perhaps they'll perceive that the internal compass is a viable alternative to biblical dogma, and be more open to the idea that atheists using that as their guide aren't necessarily demons, murderers, and rapists.

Why do you see it as a weak argument, and what would you advise using in its place?
 
I use the example of "stoning children" when I'm talking to a biblical literalist, who says it's God's word and therefore inerrant. I'm not arguing that children should be stoned, I'm arguing that the bible is not a perfect guide for living. By pointing out that the literalist is already picking and choosing based on some internal moral code, and is already rejecting biblical rules which are immoral or unethical, I'm hoping the literalist will see that invoking biblical authority to justify his pet prejudice (usually the prohibition of some sex act) provides no real support.

Sometimes you encounter the "new covenant" counter-argument in such discussions, and parry with the verses in Matthew and Luke.

My motivation is never to see Christians boycott shrimp, it's to get them to consider what real, non-biblical reasons they have for insisting on the other rules they insist on. Perhaps they'll conclude that there IS no good reason to adhere to a moral code formulated by bronze-age bedouins. Perhaps they'll perceive that the internal compass is a viable alternative to biblical dogma, and be more open to the idea that atheists using that as their guide aren't necessarily demons, murderers, and rapists.

Exactly. Well said.

And it's not as though this is a point only made by atheists. Some "moderate" Christians do the same thing to fundamentalists, arguing that "you don't take literally all the stuff in Leviticus about shrimp, etc., so you can't just use Leviticus to justify hating gays." The Christians who make that argument don't want the fundamentalists to become more fundamentalist; they're trying to point out the illogic and selectivity of those fundamentalists.
 
Why do you pretend that Christians adhere to a single practice? The Pope would agree with you, perhaps, but not in the way you'd prefer. Jews don't. Muslims don't. Buddhists don't.

Why do you require, or demand, that of Christians?

There is no need for an atheist to educate Christians "on their own faith" when the atheist himself is working under a erroneous assumption that there can Be Only One.

OK, you're quibbling over how I expressed myself. To clarify: why must atheists educate Christians about the diverse beliefs found under the umbrella of the term 'Christian'? Don't Christians have Google?

I was referring to the fact that I, an atheist, was more aware of doctrinal diversity within Christianity apparently than a Christian is. ACS showed no knowledge of there even being Christians who advocate following OT laws to the letter. I then provided him with a number of links demonstrating the opposite. He shouldn't expect others to find this out for him, though. In my opinion.

Oh, and DR, while we're nitpicking. You stated:

There is no need for an atheist to educate Christians "on their own faith" when the atheist himself is working under a erroneous assumption that there can Be Only One.

and then went on to say:

long before I adopted the Faith



Right, back to the Gospel of Matthew question...

You are expected to break some of the laws, by default, being born into the condition of sin, as in, being a sinner.

This is the theology of Paul, not Matthew, which you are then overlaying. Matthew has Jesus command his followers to 'be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect'.

The notion of being born sinful is a Pauline theme. In Matthew, one seeks forgiveness for one's sins as a purification prior to the impending end of history and establishment of Kingdom of God. However in Paul we find a desperate and overarching despair of the human condition and the notion that only the divine sacrifice of Jesus on the cross can save us.

A good example of how Matthew's gospel invalidates this notion of Paul's is that in Matthew to even receive the baptism of John the Baptist was enough to symbolically 'cleanse' people of their sins as a final act of contrition in the end times.

We read:
Then the people of Jerusalem and all Judea were going out to him, and all the region along the Jordan, and they were baptized by him in the river Jordan, confessing their sins.

But when he saw many Pharisees and Sadducees coming for baptism, he said to them, ‘You brood of vipers! Who warned you to flee from the wrath to come? 8Bear fruit worthy of repentance. Do not presume to say to yourselves, “We have Abraham as our ancestor”; for I tell you, God is able from these stones to raise up children to Abraham. Even now the axe is lying at the root of the trees; every tree therefore that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.

‘I baptize you with water for repentance, but one who is more powerful than I is coming after me; I am not worthy to carry his sandals. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire.
Matthew 3:5-11

For Matthew, Jesus will provide an even greater 'baptism', not one of water but one of bestowing spiritual vitality. However, receiving the baptism of John alone was clearly enough to signify repentance and inner purification. There is no suggestion that a divine sacrifice is needed to get rid of the 'condition' of being 'born into sin'.

The expectation is clear also from Matthew 5:48 that it was presumed that following repentance, Jesus' followers were to sin no more, and how would they do this? By following every letter of the Law until such time that the End should come. And how do we know that Matthew's Jesus advocated a strict adherence to the Law, one outstripping even that of the pious crowd of his day (the Pharisees)? Well, we return to:
For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth pass away, not one letter, not one stroke of a letter, will pass from the law until all is accomplished. Therefore, whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments, and teaches others to do the same, will be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever does them and teaches them will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. For I tell you, unless your righteousness exceeds that of the scribes and Pharisees, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven.
 
I've posted what it appears to be saying.

You're avoiding the issue. What you posted is unclear. I'll repeat the question. Do you think the phrase means:

"don't break God's law" and "don't teach others to break God's law",

or does it mean

"you can break God's law or teach others to break God's law, as long as you don't do both"?

First -that was a play on the phrase "Practice What You Preach" - you know, Don't be a hypocrite.

The fact remains that the meaning of this verse is obviously not "Practice What You Preach". A person who breaks a certain commandment and teaches others to do the same is doing nothing other than practising what they preach, but we are told here that this person "will be called least in the kingdom of heaven".

That's not clear at all. He's commenting on people who are teaching, he's not telling people they should.

Fine, the word "should" is not used, but the implication is clear. The actual phrase is "whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven", making it pretty clear that people should both practice and teach these commands in order to secure themselves a high ranking in heaven.
 
And call me an apologist all you want, but I think the "why do you eat shrimp and wear mixed fibers" argument is one of the most insipid we've come up with. Why don't you ask Christians why they don't celebrate Passover, Jews why they aren't rabidly homophobic (since YHWH is their God, not the Triune Jeesholy Spirit) or why Muslims don't celebrate Christmas since they venerate Jesus?

This really is one of the most stupd arguments atheists have come up with and I think we should abandon it for others that are more effective.
Y'know, I don't mind you being an apologist, but I tend to respect apologists more when they show, at the very least, basic comprehension towards the argument they're arguing against.

When arguing against a fundamentalist that insists that their major source of religion is factual, literal, and must be followed to the letter, it only makes sense to point out that they aren't following it to the letter. I don't know why you see this as an innately "stupid" argument, but the argument has logic in it. Personally, I will continue to use it in spite of your opinion, whether your opinion truly is as misinformed as it seems it is or not.

And it isn't even a fully Atheist-designed argument. Plenty of moderate religious folk use it to combat the extremists. So I don't quite see why you're all up in arms against atheists using it.
 
Last edited:
You're avoiding the issue.

No I'm not. I meant I've already posted that answer. You can go search for it. I'm not going to keep reposting the same answer to every person who wants me too.


The fact remains that the meaning of this verse is obviously not "Practice What You Preach". A person who breaks a certain commandment and teaches others to do the same is doing nothing other than practising what they preach, but we are told here that this person "will be called least in the kingdom of heaven".

Read what I said and where I referred to Practice What You Preach.


Fine, the word "should" is not used, but the implication is clear.

No it's not.

The actual phrase is "whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven", making it pretty clear that people should both practice and teach these commands in order to secure themselves a high ranking in heaven.

As far as I know whoever does not mean should.

But if you're convinced that's what it means then I recommend you begin practicing what you preach / teach.
 
:confused: Is the author of the Book of Revelation, another John (not the Baptist), not considered a prophet? If not, why is his 22 chapter-long prophecy included in the Bible?

Actually, some Christian theologists and Biblical scholars hold the authorship to be that of John the Baptist rather than John the Apostle / John of Patmos.

Of course, some major religious figures also hold the book to be of no worth whatsoever, and rejected it utterly. Calvin and Luther both held similar views in this regard.

I'm not certain what other apologists claim in this regard to make it jive. I think the Catholics hold that they were visions intended to reassure a certain regional group, those in Asia Minor, and not intended for everyone. Not certain if the Catholic make a distinction between prophecy and visions. <shrug>

Finally, there are some who contend that the book is a chronicle, not a prediction, of actual events. I'm sure this upsets and offends all those waiting for the Rapture to come and take them bodily to their just reward, but there it is. :D

So, depending, this either contradicts utterly, or is of no matter whatsoever, in regards to Jesus' words.
 
Last edited:
I was referring to the fact that I, an atheist, was more aware of doctrinal diversity within Christianity apparently than a Christian is. ACS showed no knowledge of there even being Christians who advocate following OT laws to the letter. I then provided him with a number of links demonstrating the opposite. He shouldn't expect others to find this out for him, though. In my opinion.

1) The question wasn't about whether there has ever been Christians who've advocated or tried following OT laws. It was about whether and how they use those verses that atheists often quote here.

2) I don't expect anyone to do anything here, but even if I did, I'm not sure how I could force anyone to post an answer to me. But if people post verses here and interpret them a certain way here and tell me that's how I'm supposed to interpret them and when I look at those verses and it's not apparent how the atheists are getting their conclusions and when it's not apparent that most, if any, Christians interpret them the same way as the atheists are telling me I'm supposed to interpret them then I'll post about it here - since, well, the people using the verses that way are here.
 
Last edited:
1) The question wasn't about whether there has ever been Christians who've advocated or tried following OT laws. It was about whether and how they use those verses that atheists often quote here.

2) I don't expect anyone to do anything here, but even if I did, I'm not sure how I could force anyone to post an answer to me. But if people post verses here and interpret them a certain way here and tell me that's how I'm supposed to interpret them and when I look at those verses and it's not apparent how the atheists are getting their conclusions and when it's not apparent that most, if any, Christians interpret them the same way as the atheists are telling me I'm supposed to interpret them then I'll post about it here - since, well, the people using the verses that way are here.


Just wondering, but have you considered this possibility -- that some of the atheists posting here could be looking at these verses with fresh eyes, while many Christians interpret them from the stance of a foregone conclusion (since Paul said we are not justified by works of the law, Jesus must have meant this............) instead of the equally likely conclusion that the early writings were a mish-mash of differing opinions about how to view Jesus?
 
DR's been posting for an hour now... any of you have any replies to him?
Hopefully, I've elicited a few chuckles so far in reply/response.

One hopes.
And call me an apologist all you want, but I think the "why do you eat shrimp and wear mixed fibers" argument is one of the most insipid we've come up with.
The demand that all True Scotsmen Christians be doctrinaire is something the Pope and some of the critical skeptics/atheists have in common.
US said:
Why don't you ask Christians why they don't celebrate Passover, Jews why they aren't rabidly homophobic (since YHWH is their God, not the Triune Jeesholy Spirit) or why Muslims don't celebrate Christmas since they venerate Jesus?
Isn't the answer obvious? ;)
US said:
This really is one of the most stupd arguments atheists have come up with and I think we should abandon it for others that are more effective.
It would raise the level of conversation/discussion, which perhaps is antithetical to the intent of some such conversations. Hard to say.

@Lonewulf:

Nice to see you again, I agree that now and again when dealing with a sola scriptura literalist one needs to get them to explain what scriptura guidance they don't follow, and why. Some come up with better responses than others.

For example, my neighbor, who is a JW, doesn't do Christmas, Easter, etcetera, nor do he and his family do birthday parties. This caused my son some distress, as he wanted to give his two best buddies Christmas presents, the boys next door, and I had to explain to him that he could do so but just drop the Christmas deal.

My neighbor doesn't go off on people who do all that corrupted stuff that nasty evil Christians do, per Watchtower propaganda, nor does he wax poetic about the vile Jesuits and their crimes against humanity.

DR
 
Just wondering, but have you considered this possibility -- that some of the atheists posting here could be looking at these verses with fresh eyes, while many Christians interpret them from the stance of a foregone conclusion (since Paul said we are not justified by works of the law, Jesus must have meant this............) instead of the equally likely conclusion that the early writings were a mish-mash of differing opinions about how to view Jesus?

Yes.
 
Actually, to clarify, - so far what it appears to me to mean is:
1) Jesus fulfills the law - because that what it says.

Fulfilling the law cannot be the same thing as abolishing the law, because Jesus says he will do one and will not do the other.

2) Don't break God's law and teach others to do the same - because that what it says

No it doesn't. You may infer that advice, but it doesn't literally say that.

"Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven"

It says that who ever does both will be least in the Kingdom of Heaven. (Or, at least, labelled such. Let's not get too pedantic). So if you break the law and refrain from teaching others to do the same, then you are better than those who do both.

So how does that allow anyone to break the law?

If you murder and teach others to murder, then you are the lowest of the low. Where in that do I say you can murder?


I also had another question: If you work on the Sabbath, are you teaching through example? If so, then you are both breaking the law and teaching others to break the law.
 
Last edited:
And call me an apologist all you want, but I think the "why do you eat shrimp and wear mixed fibers" argument is one of the most insipid we've come up with. Why don't you ask Christians why they don't celebrate Passover, Jews why they aren't rabidly homophobic (since YHWH is their God, not the Triune Jeesholy Spirit) or why Muslims don't celebrate Christmas since they venerate Jesus?

This really is one of the most stupd arguments atheists have come up with and I think we should abandon it for others that are more effective.

I don't think you're an apologist.
One of the points I often make is that religion is not just the sacred text. That's obvious when you look at the diversity of opinion all based on the same text. Tradition is important.

ACS asked for examples of Christians he didn't know about. Since then, he's gotten boxed into defending his own interpretation of Matthew. It's not really a discussion of what Christians must do/believe. It's clear that ACS's interpretation is not a new one. It has a long tradition. It is entirely valid for Christians to hold that interpretation of the verse.

ACS's interpretation of this verse doesn't work for me. But I do think that it genuinely works for him -- and many others. With discussion, I might understand why it works for him.
 
No it doesn't. You may infer that advice, but it doesn't literally say that.

"Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven"

It says that who ever does both will be least in the Kingdom of Heaven. (Or, at least, labelled such. Let's not get too pedantic).

Haha. Yes, it appears I did. Now that you've pointed that out it appears that if you don't mind being the least in the Kingdom of Heaven then feel free to break the law and teach others to do that.

That seems to definitely take care of the Christians have to follow the Old Testament Laws. In the worst case scenario - all a Christian has to do is not follow the laws, teach others not to, and then they'll be the least in the Kingdom of Heaven. :eek:

So if you break the law and refrain from teaching others to do the same, then you are greater than those who do both.

That could be. Then again - it's not even talked about so feel free to infer that.

So how does that allow anyone to break the law?

If you murder and teach others to murder, then you are the lowest of the low. Where in that do I say you can kill?

I don't have a clue who that's directed to, or what you're saying there. Sorry.

I also had another question: If you work on the Sabbath, are you teaching through example? If so, then you are both breaking the law and teaching others to break the law.

Well, if it is - then you'll be the least in the Kingdom of Heaven, apparently.:eye-poppi
 
Ah. Did I just walk into another one of those badgers-with-their-backs-against-the-wall-not-listening-to-the-other-side discussions?

Beats me. I didn't want to ignore you, didn't have much more to say then "Yes". I considered it the first time someone used those verse towards me and when I read them couldn't find out how they were reading all that into those verses. And it made me wonder if they and others (since so many others here use those same verses the same way) were aware of some Christian teachings on it. Thus this thread.
 
Last edited:
ACS asked for examples of Christians he didn't know about. Since then, he's gotten boxed into defending his own interpretation of Matthew.

Well, I've just been trying to go by what those verses say, and (thanks to your insight in your previous post) it's now even less obvious to me the conclusion from these verses is Christians need to follow the Old Testament law.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom