The atheists favorite bible verses


Shiller:

"Chiller!

Thriller!!

Christ as serial killer!!!

Xtians, you can't afford to miss the heart-pounding, earth-stopping, 'gut-wrenching' (see Jesus, the prince of peace, feed the entrails of his slain enemies to vultures!), infidel-burning-for-all-eternity conclusion of... THE BIBLE!!!!" :scared:

(what some folks won't do to move a few more books -- sheesh!)
 
Last edited:
Prior to this thread, I'd never seen this quote from the bible before, so my take on it is from this brief introduction and is probably flawed, but anyway...

I'm not sure it can be read any way other than the way JoeTheJuggler's describing it without it becoming illogical. It doesn't seem to me to make much sense any other way.

"19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven"

Now, if you can break one of these least commandments, then why can't you tell someone else that they can too? If it's allowable for you to break a commandment, then it must not be relevant any more, in which case teaching someone else to do the same can hardly be an offense.

Also, if it's ok to teach someone else to break a commandment, again, it must no longer be relevant, so breaking it yourself must be ok too.

Interpreting the passage as saying that it's only wrong to both break a commandment AND teach others to do the same seems illogical to me.
 
Jesus gives an either/or statement. Either the law will stay in place or they will be fulfilled.
But that is not what he says. Firstly there is no either or and he does not say until they are fulfilled. He says until all or everything is accomplished (or takes place)
 
But that is not what he says. Firstly there is no either or and he does not say until they are fulfilled. He says until all or everything is accomplished (or takes place)

Precisely. The all/everything that will be accomplished before the Law is also completed is the winding up of worldly events and the coming of the Kingdom of God. This is Jewish apocalyptic material.

To repeat, seeing as ACS seems to be refusing to respond to this important point about the apocalyptic nature of this passage:

"I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished."

And what would it mean for heaven and earth to disappear? The renewal of the earth following, in Matthew, the consummation of history by divine intervention (which was already seen to be unfolding with the coming of what Jesus' followers believed to be the Messiah), and, in Revelation, the heralding of the Kingdom of God on earth with the Second Coming of Christ:

Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth; for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and the sea was no more.
Revelation 21:1

The earth hasn't disappeared or been transformed, and Jesus hasn't returned. Therefore, 'not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law'. In other words, this passage of Matthew invalidates any Christian claims that the OT Law is no longer to be followed.
 
I see no evidence that ACS is in any way a 'sceptic', incidentally, but every indication that he is a faith head who will use any spurious form of hermeneutical trickery to make Jesus say what he wants him to say, in this instance turning what he actually says upside down in order to claim that a passage actually means the opposite of what it says. Unfortunately, I can't see us getting anywhere fast with this issue, because ACS and a few others here are blinded by faith and consequently rational arguments will likely fall on deaf ears. I've recommended some good mainstream academic studies on early Christianity and Judaism in previous posts; whether ACS or others will bother to read any of them seems to me to be sadly unlikely.

Because I don't accept your conclusion (or anyone's conclusion yet for that matter) I'm not a sceptic? [Now where have I heard that before? ;) ] Seems to me - I'm being rather sceptical about the conclusion being drawn from these verses. So far - since the claim was made these verses are SO obvious (in particular Verse 19) that it means Christians need to follow the Old Testament law - in regards to that verse I've simply pointed out what it actually says.

For now, I think I'll just stick with what it actually says.
 
What the verse HAS to mean is a different topic all together. I read it as the law still applies. ACS reads it as the law can be ignored as long as you don't teach others to break the law.

Actually, to clarify, - so far what it appears to me to mean is:
1) Jesus fulfills the law - because that what it says.
2) Don't break God's law and teach others to do the same - because that what it says
3) Practice what you teach - because that's what it says
4) Be better (more righteous) then the Pharisees and other teachers of the law - because that what it says.

What an individual needs to do with God's commandments apart from teaching and what those commandments explicitly are (apart from those teachings following these verses) don't seemed to be talked about in this section except in the beginning where Jesus says he's come to fulfill them. It doesn't appear to be the point for those verses for specifics.
 
Last edited:
Interpreting the passage as saying that it's only wrong to both break a commandment AND teach others to do the same seems illogical to me.

Well - so far - the only people in this thread coming to that conclusion are atheists. I've never said that - I've just said all it talks about is teaching.

It's beginning to appear to me to be another jab in the eyes of the Pharisess by Jesus and an admonition to the people to not be like them.
 
Actually, to clarify, - so far what it appears to me to mean is:
2) Don't break God's law and teach others to do the same - because that what it says
This is still ambiguous, so why don't you clarify just a wee bit more.

Do you think it means "Don't break God's law, and don't teach others to do the same"? Or do you think that it's okay to break the law, as long as you don't teach others to break it?
 
Why must atheists educate Christians even about their own faith and their fellow Christians? Do Christians not have Google? Anyway...
Why do you pretend that Christians adhere to a single practice? The Pope would agree with you, perhaps, but not in the way you'd prefer. Jews don't. Muslims don't. Buddhists don't.

Why do you require, or demand, that of Christians?

There is no need for an atheist to educate Christians "on their own faith" when the atheist himself is working under a erroneous assumption that there can Be Only One. I find the Christian educational sources, and the library, and the internet, fertile ground for learning. In short, don't kid yourself.

As to my favorite verse in the Bible, it tends to either defy interpretation, due to its pith, or to lend itself to great speculation. It all depends upon where you are, mentally and emotionally, when reading it.

Jesus wept.

(Perhaps He wept due to shaking with internal laughter, overcome by his mirth over how silly people can be when they want to give each other the needle. )

DR
 
Last edited:
Actually, to clarify, - so far what it appears to me to mean is:
1) Jesus fulfills the law - because that what it says.
2) Don't break God's law and teach others to do the same - because that what it says
3) Practice what you teach - because that's what it says
4) Be better (more righteous) then the Pharisees and other teachers of the law - because that what it says.

1) I don't know. That is pretty well nonsensical to me
2)I agree that's what it says
3)I'd say it is implied, at least as far as the Law is concerned, but not stated, and I don't see how it can be inferred that this applies outside the law.
4)I don't know about that. It seems fairly un-Jesus-like to denounce an entire people like that. There surely had to be one who this didn't apply to.

What about this part:
...until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law

I can't even imagine any room for interpretation there. It clearly is emphasizing no changes at all to the law. I understand your point about his emphasis on teaching others to do the wrong thing, and if addressing people who are teacher/preachers/scholars, I see the reasoning , but if the law didn't change, then people still have to follow it, don't they? It appears to me that this passage says:

"The law hasn't changed one tiny bit, and it never will. So you folks who teach the law had better teach it right and practice what you preach or you will be right at the top of god's naughty list when the kingdom of god arrives."

I see no exemption for those not in the business of teaching the law, only an extra emphasis on how bad it is to be one who teaches the law incorrectly or who teaches the law but doesn't live accordingly.
 
Last edited:
"19 Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven"

Now, if you can break one of these least commandments, then why can't you tell someone else that they can too? If it's allowable for you to break a commandment, then it must not be relevant any more, in which case teaching someone else to do the same can hardly be an offense.
You seem to be missing a subtle point here, since we are taking this verse in isolation: you can still break the law and get into heaven.

How is that accomplished? Confession, pennance, reconcilliation, etcetera.

You are expected to break some of the laws, by default, being born into the condition of sin, as in, being a sinner.

But hey, why should I argue with a Greek Chorus of people who think that more rules are what make the world a better place? The fallacy of The Perfect Rule leaps from the page of this forum, and of the internet, and of the secularist dialogue.

Oddly enough, all that writing more rules seems to do is get more people put into jail. Maybe Libertarians and Anarchists are wiser than we give them credit for.

FWIW: long before I adopted the Faith, I was a big fan of single material clothing. All Cotton. All Wool. All linen. All silk. How nice to find out that my preference in clothing makes God happy, even though I made the choices in purest ignorance.

But of course, I sin.

My socks are cotton poly blend.


DR
 
Last edited:
Actually, to clarify, - so far what it appears to me to mean is:
1) Jesus fulfills the law - because that what it says.
2) Don't break God's law and teach others to do the same - because that what it says
3) Practice what you teach - because that's what it says
4) Be better (more righteous) then the Pharisees and other teachers of the law - because that what it says.

What an individual needs to do with God's commandments apart from teaching and what those commandments explicitly are (apart from those teachings following these verses) don't seemed to be talked about in this section except in the beginning where Jesus says he's come to fulfill them. It doesn't appear to be the point for those verses for specifics.

Don't these commandments come from the Old Testament?
 
Actually, to clarify, - so far what it appears to me to mean is:
1) Jesus fulfills the law - because that what it says.
2) Don't break God's law and teach others to do the same - because that what it says
3) Practice what you teach - because that's what it says
4) Be better (more righteous) then the Pharisees and other teachers of the law - because that what it says.

You're picking and choosing here.

1) It also says that Jesus was not going to abolish the law.

2) As bokonon already pointed out, we need clarification here. Does it mean:

"don't break God's law" and "don't teach others to break God"s law",

or does it mean

"you can break God's law or teach others to break God's law, as long as you don't do both"?

I think the first interpretation is reasonable and the second is nonsensical.

3) No, it doesn't say "Practice what you teach". It says you should practice and teach "these commands". What are "these commands", if not God's law already referred to?. Clearly Jesus wants people both to practice the laws and to teach them.

4) Fair enough. This also seems to imply that the Pharisees and the teachers of the law will not enter the kingdom of heaven.
 
Last edited:
I see no evidence that ACS is in any way a 'sceptic', incidentally, but every indication that he is a faith head...

Wow. This presents an interesting dilemma to an atheist skeptic like me since, leaving ACS's comments aside for the moment, I don't consider strong atheists skeptics either.

What to do.. what to do...

DR's been posting for an hour now... any of you have any replies to him?

And call me an apologist all you want, but I think the "why do you eat shrimp and wear mixed fibers" argument is one of the most insipid we've come up with. Why don't you ask Christians why they don't celebrate Passover, Jews why they aren't rabidly homophobic (since YHWH is their God, not the Triune Jeesholy Spirit) or why Muslims don't celebrate Christmas since they venerate Jesus?

This really is one of the most stupd arguments atheists have come up with and I think we should abandon it for others that are more effective.
 
This is still ambiguous, so why don't you clarify just a wee bit more.

Do you think it means "Don't break God's law, and don't teach others to do the same"? Or do you think that it's okay to break the law, as long as you don't teach others to break it?

So far I don't think it's talking about an individual's relationship with the law, but teachers actions when teaching.

I think it's talking about attitudes of when you are in a position of religious authority and are teaching. It's not saying "don't break God's law" it's saying "it doesn't matter how miniscule of a law you break don't teach others to do the same."

It follows it up with saying if you are teaching practice what you teach.

This doesn't really seem to be the verses to determine what an individual is supposed to do in regards to themselves. It doesn't seem likes it's intent.

It could be that you're right and this section was only time specific to the exact audience he had.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom