What? You really think it's reasonable to say that in the story in Matthew of Jesus preaching to a crowd on the hillside (of which this passage is one small part) is only addressing the matter of teaching the law and is not an admonishment in the strongest of terms to continue obeying every last little commandment in the extant scriptures?
No, I didn't say that. I said ACS's interpretation of this passage was reasonable. You're putting a lot of words in my mouth that I'm not saying at all.
Again, the case that critics of Christianity bring is that modern Christians see fit to ignore the laws and commandments in the Old Testament. Their justification is that Jesus brought a new law in, and therefore the old laws are null and void. This passage certainly says that they are not.
I've already disagreed with this interpretation of Matthew above. Feel free to review. I'll wait here.
Ah. . .so Christians abide by a strange reading of this passage in Matthew, but not a similar one in Luke? So the Old Testament laws and Luke are no longer part of their canon?
Again, not what I'm saying. You've moved the goal posts by suggesting another scripture which doesn't mention teaching, which was the crux of ACS's position.
FWIW, Matthew and Luke were probably both based largely on Mark and another source commonly referred to as Q.
That's what I understand also. But, not being a Biblical scholar, and not having reviewed Mark in some time, I can't confirm or deny if he suggests anything of the nature of adhering to the OT laws. Can you? That's not said with sarcasm at all. I'd like to see quotes from Mark that suggest the OT laws should still be adhered to. It would definitely give us something more to chew on.
The Luke passage does not say that the law expired when John the Baptist came around.
That's not what the passage says. If you recall it states, "The law and the prophets were
until John." [emphasis added] That seems clear to me, but perhaps not to you.
Still, my understanding of Christian belief is that John was the last prophet, and there were no others needed or necessary because of Jesus. I believe there's a scripture to that effect. That would then suggest that the provided expiration of both "the law" and "prophets" came about with John.
Or are there other Christian prophets that came after John? Can you name them for me and point them out in the Bible? Thanks.