The atheists favorite bible verses

'Heaven' and earth haven't disappeared. Therefore your interpretation fails.

No, his interpretation doesn't fail, since Jesus says he's come to "fulfill" the laws, and that nothing will "disappear from the law until everything is accomplished by them. Jesus fulfills them, the laws are accomplished and thus no need for heaven and earth to disappear.

It's an either/or statement.

The author, and Jesus himself, would no doubt be astounded to discover that 2,000 years on, the Kingdom of God still hasn't arrived.

I sincerely doubt that Jesus would be surprised by that. I think he would be surprised at what belief in him has caused. At the strife he unfortunately created, at the misinterpretation of his message, and what people think the "kingdom of God" is.
 
I didn't use the word OK anywhere.
I know. I did. And you didn't answer my question.

You said that you and most Christians disagree with my reading of the passage which is the very obvious one that Jesus said that you must obey every last little commandment given in the Jewish scriptures ("the law and the prophets"). Again, the problem is that when many modern liberal Christians are presented with deplorable morality presented in the Old Testament, they answer that Jesus introduced a new law that made the old laws null and void. This passage makes clear that he did no such thing.

I'm really curious as to how you can strain the context of the passage and claim it means something else.

I'll repeat my question to you:
JoeTheJuggler said:
Back to the passage in question:
You think Jesus was saying it's OK to break any of the commandments as long as you don't teach others to break them? Really? You actually think that's what the passage means?
 
I know. I did. And you didn't answer my question.

You want me to answer a question about a statement I didn't make? Sorry.


I'm really curious as to how you can strain the context of the passage and claim it means something else.

I'm curious how you can.

Matthew 5:19 said:
19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven.

Who is the first half of this verse about?:
Someone "who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same"

Someone who breaks a commandment without teaching someone else to do it is not even being talked about here.

Someone who breaks a commandment but teaches someone else to not break it is not even talked about here.

Who is the second half of this verse about?:
Someone who "practices and teaches these commands"

Someone who does not practice what they teach is not talked about here.
(Although Jesus did like to say Hypocrite to the Religious Leaders around Him. So, I'm sure you can find out what he thought of hypocrites.)

Feel free to read any of the stuff not being talked about into that verse, though.

I'd like to know why and how you're deciding to read any of that into it and then coming to your conclusion based on that verse. You haven't really described that process except to by saying "That's what it says". Which - it doesn't say that. So how are you arriving at that conclusion?
 
Last edited:
And most of the people he was talking about are probably dead by now anyway, so anything goes.
 
Well if it's only applicable to the people he physically spoke to ...
Horse hockey. You're the one who was trying to limit the audience. You did so when you said:
It seems the people Jesus is talking to are people who teach the law and commandments.
This was in stark contrast to your continued use of "all Christians".

A Christian Sceptic said:
Actually - he spoke to the crowd of people ABOUT people who teach. How do I know this - because he uses the word TEACH.
Ah. . .and we can just ignore all the other words (that come before the "and teaches" part)??

I know he was addressing the people vis a vis their duty to obey the law because he uses these words, "Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments. . . ."

So again--do you really think this passage only concerns teaching the law? I ask because it makes little sense to me that he'd stress the importance of continuing to teach the old laws if it didn't matter whether or not you break them.
 
You want me to answer a question about a statement I didn't make? Sorry.
I want you to answer my question about a the passage in Matthew that purports to be a quotation of Jesus. This is the passage you cited in the O.P.

Why so coy? You're pretending you don't know what I'm even asking, but I've been pretty transparent.

You said that my reading of this passage (the obvious one--that Jesus is telling everyone that he is not tossing out the old scriptures--that you must still obey every last little commandment) isn't correct. I'm asking what yours is.

Do you think the passage means that it's OK to break any of these commandments?


Someone who breaks a commandment without teaching someone else to do it is not even being talked about here.
OK--so again. Do you think this passage means it's OK to break these commandments as long as you don't teach someone to do the same?

Seems to me you're giving undue importance to one half of the conjoined elements. To be logical, would you also say that someone who breaks the commandments but teaches people that it's wrong to do so is NOT being addressed?

Someone who does not practice what they teach is not talked about here.
You really believe that? Please read the entire chapter in question. It has all the nice beatitudes at the beginning, then goes on to talk about the stricter meaning of adultery and murder (that you can sin even without doing the deed). You really think this is all addressed to the question of teaching?


I think Edmund Standing's post is to the point.

The question of whether you can be a Christian without being a Jew was an important point in the early church.

In Matthew the answer is decidedly "no" (see Matt. 15:24), but in John, it seems that even Jesus was hardly even a Jew himself. (He refers to the Jews as sons of the devil [John 8:44] speaks of Jewish Law as "your law" [John 8:17] as if he weren't Jewish himself.)
 
Last edited:
You said that my reading of this passage (the obvious one--that Jesus is telling everyone that he is not tossing out the old scriptures--that you must still obey every last little commandment) isn't correct. I'm asking what yours is.

I've posted above. In the post you're responding to. About Verse 19 which you brought up HERE where you asked

JoeTheJuggler said:
Is there any other reading of verse 19?

And you repeatedly say it's obvious from that verse your conclusion is correct.

Do you think the passage means that it's OK to break any of these commandments?

It appears this isn't what that verse is about.

OK--so again. Do you think this passage means it's OK to break these commandments as long as you don't teach someone to do the same?

It appears this isn't what that verse is about.

Seems to me you're giving undue importance to one half of the conjoined elements. To be logical, would you also say that someone who breaks the commandments but teaches people that it's wrong to do so is NOT being addressed?

I answered that in the very post you are replying to.

You really believe that? Please read the entire chapter in question. It has all the nice beatitudes at the beginning, then goes on to talk about the stricter meaning of adultery and murder (that you can sin even without doing the deed). You really think this is all addressed to the question of teaching?

You're the one who said Verse 19 is so obvious, so that's what we're talking about. Where is it obvious?

You made the claim Verse 19 is so obvious. I don't think your conclusion is obvious. Please explain how Verse 19 is obvious.
 
Last edited:
You said that my reading of this passage (the obvious one--that Jesus is telling everyone that he is not tossing out the old scriptures--that you must still obey every last little commandment) isn't correct. I'm asking what yours is.

I just went through the pages and nowhere that I could find do I say you're incorrect. I do say your conclusion about Verse 19 is NOT APPARENT to me and I have shown you what Verse 19 says and it appears to be saying. I'm asking you to show me how Verse 19 is so apparent that you can draw the conclusion you've drawn.

So - let me ask again:

How is it apparent from Verse 19 that Christians need to obey every little law in the Old Testament?
 
How about a similar passage in Luke?
KJV-Luke 16:16-17 said:
16 “The law and the prophets were until John. Since that time the kingdom of God has been preached, and everyone is pressing into it. 17 And it is easier for heaven and earth to pass away than for one tittle of the law to fail.

You still think this only applies to teaching the law and not to obeying it?
 
You still think this only applies to teaching the law and not to obeying it?

This appears to be a different scripture than the one being discussed. I don't see mention of teaching in this one, but by the same token, I fail to see how this disproves what ACS is saying.

I don't know that ACS is right, but the scripture he cites does contain the addendum of "and teaches others to do the same". It's hard to say if Jesus was talking about two groups, or just one, but the end of the passage does seem to be talking about one group when it mentions anyone who "practices and teaches". ACS's interpretation is reasonable. <shrug>

Throwing a new scripture in the mix feels like you're moving the goal posts, Joe. And this is despite the fact that the scripture you cite provides an expirations of "until John". :D
 
Last edited:
How is it apparent from Verse 19 that Christians need to obey every little law in the Old Testament?

The words?
KJV Matt. 5:19 said:
19Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.
What do you think it means to "break one of these least commandments"? And what does it mean to "do" them?

Here's the New International Version of the verse:
NIV Matt. 5:19 said:
19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven.

Here's the New Living Translation:
NLT Matt. 5:19 said:
19 So if you ignore the least commandment and teach others to do the same, you will be called the least in the Kingdom of Heaven. But anyone who obeys God’s laws and teaches them will be called great in the Kingdom of Heaven.

The other translations have a similar spin on "do" (using "practices" or "keeps" or "obeys").

It's obvious that Jesus is urging people to obey every last little law--and in verse 18 that not the smallest detail will disappear from the law.
 
I don't know that ACS is right, but the scripture he cites does contain the addendum of "and teaches others to do the same". It's hard to say if Jesus was talking about two groups, or just one, but the end of the passage does seem to be talking about one group when it mentions anyone who "practices and teaches". ACS's interpretation is reasonable. <shrug>
What? You really think it's reasonable to say that in the story in Matthew of Jesus preaching to a crowd on the hillside (of which this passage is one small part) is only addressing the matter of teaching the law and is not an admonishment in the strongest of terms to continue obeying every last little commandment in the extant scriptures?

Again, the case that critics of Christianity bring is that modern Christians see fit to ignore the laws and commandments in the Old Testament. Their justification is that Jesus brought a new law in, and therefore the old laws are null and void. This passage certainly says that they are not.

Throwing a new scripture in the mix feels like you're moving the goal posts, Joe. And this is despite the fact that the scripture you cite provides an expirations of "until John". :D
Ah. . .so Christians abide by a strange reading of this passage in Matthew, but not a similar one in Luke? So the Old Testament laws and Luke are no longer part of their canon?

FWIW, Matthew and Luke were probably both based largely on Mark and another source commonly referred to as Q.

The Luke passage does not say that the law expired when John the Baptist came around. It is back to the issue mentioned before. Some early Christians thought you needed to be a Jew (abide by the laws) to follow Christ while some thought otherwise, and thought (as modern Christians do) that Jesus threw out the old laws. These passages both seem to be a response to that attitude--saying emphatically that not one detail of the law has been suspended or expired.
 
What? You really think it's reasonable to say that in the story in Matthew of Jesus preaching to a crowd on the hillside (of which this passage is one small part) is only addressing the matter of teaching the law and is not an admonishment in the strongest of terms to continue obeying every last little commandment in the extant scriptures?

No, I didn't say that. I said ACS's interpretation of this passage was reasonable. You're putting a lot of words in my mouth that I'm not saying at all. :D

Again, the case that critics of Christianity bring is that modern Christians see fit to ignore the laws and commandments in the Old Testament. Their justification is that Jesus brought a new law in, and therefore the old laws are null and void. This passage certainly says that they are not.

I've already disagreed with this interpretation of Matthew above. Feel free to review. I'll wait here. ;)

Ah. . .so Christians abide by a strange reading of this passage in Matthew, but not a similar one in Luke? So the Old Testament laws and Luke are no longer part of their canon?

Again, not what I'm saying. You've moved the goal posts by suggesting another scripture which doesn't mention teaching, which was the crux of ACS's position.

FWIW, Matthew and Luke were probably both based largely on Mark and another source commonly referred to as Q.

That's what I understand also. But, not being a Biblical scholar, and not having reviewed Mark in some time, I can't confirm or deny if he suggests anything of the nature of adhering to the OT laws. Can you? That's not said with sarcasm at all. I'd like to see quotes from Mark that suggest the OT laws should still be adhered to. It would definitely give us something more to chew on. :)

The Luke passage does not say that the law expired when John the Baptist came around.

That's not what the passage says. If you recall it states, "The law and the prophets were until John." [emphasis added] That seems clear to me, but perhaps not to you.

Still, my understanding of Christian belief is that John was the last prophet, and there were no others needed or necessary because of Jesus. I believe there's a scripture to that effect. That would then suggest that the provided expiration of both "the law" and "prophets" came about with John.

Or are there other Christian prophets that came after John? Can you name them for me and point them out in the Bible? Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Jesus gives an either/or statement. Either the law will stay in place or they will be fulfilled.

I'd like to add in here (I said this in the other thread too) that I don't think this is a real either/or statement: The first option seems to be being used for emphasis, to highlight the importance of the second option. As in, "Nothing goes from the law until either heaven or earth will pass - and good luck with that option - or until all the law is fulfilled."
 
moving the goal posts

You know this whole thread has reminded me of the typical ID argument you get about transitional species.

It seems to me that ACS has posted a similar argument and seems that he successfully sucked everyone in. You are all arguing the "every time a fossil is found it just created 2 more gaps".

The whole reason that atheists bring up the argument in the OP is because Xians
( I suppose ACS would weasel out by claiming that they are not REAL xians - though he continuously REFUSES to own up to definition) use these "laws" to justify hatred, bigotry and in some cases even murder.

Recent 20/20 ( one of those news shows anyway ) did an experiment where they had 2 women and 2 men sitting on a public park kissing. Several people actually called the police. Those interviewed almost unanimously cited biblical law for their intolerance and disapproval. To paraphrase one women I remember "It's not what I say it's what the bible says"

To this hypocrisy atheist respond with the argument in the OP.

People calling themselves xians seem to justify any level of bigotry up to and including murder of homosexuals on the one hand because it conveniently fits their ignorance. But at the same time ignoring other laws that are not convenient and using ACS's meme about how the laws don't apply anymore.

And while there are xians who talk about hate the sin not the sinner, and "as long as you are not actively engaging in homosexual acts" etc. I have never heard any xian claim that well since the laws have been fulfilled homosexuality is no longer an abomination like wearing clothes of 2 different makes.

ACS has successfully switched the burden of proof. It seems to me that it is HE and xians that need to explain WHY it is that they cherry pick some laws nad ignore others.
 
That's not what the passage says. If you recall it states, "The law and the prophets were until John." [emphasis added] That seems clear to me, but perhaps not to you.

Still, my understanding of Christian belief is that John was the last prophet, and there were no others needed or necessary because of Jesus. I believe there's a scripture to that effect. That would then suggest that the provided expiration of both "the law" and "prophets" came about with John.

Or are there other Christian prophets that came after John? Can you name them for me and point them out in the Bible? Thanks.
I have no idea what you're talking about.

I'll repeat that the passage does NOT say that the law expires with John. In fact, it clearly states that not one jot of the law "disappears". Basically it's Luke's version of the same "I come not to abolish the law" speech.

Here, try another translation:
16 “Until John the Baptist, the law of Moses and the messages of the prophets were your guides. But now the Good News of the Kingdom of God is preached, and everyone is eager to get in. 17 But that doesn’t mean that the law has lost its force. It is easier for heaven and earth to disappear than for the smallest point of God’s law to be overturned.

This reinforces what Mobyseven has been saying also.
 
I recently saw the film, The God Who Wasn't There. That guy made the point that only the fundamentalist Christians have the guts to profess what their Bible actually says.

That's what a lot of Creationists say about themselves with regards to Genesis.

Question from an ignorant bystander:

Did Jesus himself actually break the laws? I seem to recall he worked on the Sabbath, but I believe Jews allow that under certain circumstances. So was he a practicing Jew, or was he not?

Seems to me what he did should clarify what he said.

IIRC, Jesus had the Apostles collect grain, but there's no description of him doing so.

Here's the Wiki entry on that section.
 
And while there are xians who talk about hate the sin not the sinner, and "as long as you are not actively engaging in homosexual acts" etc. I have never heard any xian claim that well since the laws have been fulfilled homosexuality is no longer an abomination like wearing clothes of 2 different makes.

There is a good reason for this, which is that Christianity is really a religion invented by Paul, with all the extraordinary almost Gnostic stuff about, for example, Jesus nailing the Law to the cross and the Law bringing slavery (incidentally see Hyam Maccoby's fascinating book Paul and Hellenism for in-depth analysis of Pauls' schizophrenic positions regarding the Law and Judaism in relation to his new faith). Thanks to Paul, Christians feel they are not obliged to follow OT Law, although the historical Jesus would no doubt find such a notion appalling. However, despite this 'freedom' from the Law, Paul continued to promote its homophobia. Consequently, homophobic Christians begin with Paul's anti-gay statements and then assume that this part of the Law is still, therefore, relevant and binding. Paul lets them off all that Jewish stuff they have no interest in in the OT Law, but they can still cherry pick from the OT where it is 'confirmed' by the NT (much as they do with supposed 'prophecies' of Jesus in the OT).

I see no evidence that ACS is in any way a 'sceptic', incidentally, but every indication that he is a faith head who will use any spurious form of hermeneutical trickery to make Jesus say what he wants him to say, in this instance turning what he actually says upside down in order to claim that a passage actually means the opposite of what it says. Unfortunately, I can't see us getting anywhere fast with this issue, because ACS and a few others here are blinded by faith and consequently rational arguments will likely fall on deaf ears. I've recommended some good mainstream academic studies on early Christianity and Judaism in previous posts; whether ACS or others will bother to read any of them seems to me to be sadly unlikely.
 
ACS has successfully switched the burden of proof. It seems to me that it is HE and xians that need to explain WHY it is that they cherry pick some laws nad ignore others.

To give ACS the benefit of the doubt, his OP asked for examples of Christians who interpret the verse in the way people on this forum have suggested. Examples have been given. And ACS has ackowledged them.

Can he still say that there are Christians who interpret the verse in a different way? Of course he can. Such Christians exist.

What the verse HAS to mean is a different topic all together. I read it as the law still applies. ACS reads it as the law can be ignored as long as you don't teach others to break the law. A tough feat to accomplish, in my opinion. If you work on the Sabbath, are you teaching through example?

People are really very good at seeing things the way they want them to be. I've given this example before:
http://www.burnsidewriterscollective.com/social/2007/02/five_questions_your_pacifist_f.php

A Christian's views on Romans 13. There is an assumed “unless,” because there isn't a written "unless".
 
... Or are there other Christian prophets that came after John? Can you name them for me and point them out in the Bible? Thanks.

:confused: Is the author of the Book of Revelation, another John (not the Baptist), not considered a prophet? If not, why is his 22 chapter-long prophecy included in the Bible?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom