The atheists favorite bible verses

Maybe you could help by telling us exactly how many references you need before you'll believe that some christians take the verse the same way that some atheists take it. 6? 9? Because the sources from FireGarden certainly don't seem to be enough (for whatever reason).

IMO, you firmly believed that all christians took that verse in exactly the same way. Well, surprise, they don't. But since one person has gone out and done your work for you, you think that someone else will find you more examples which you can ignore. You're probably right, but I would hope that you would actually use your time to go find them yourself. That would be the best thing.

But the UCG explicitly doesn't believe they have to follow all of the OT laws; in one of those very articles, they explicitly name sacrificial laws and circumcision as two examples of this.

I doubt very much that there is any extant Christian tradition that requires literally all of the OT laws to be followed. Although I'm not sure what that's meant to prove, exactly.

(edit: I admit that I'm sort of nit-picking; the linked page is pretty explicit about "God's law" still applying unless the NT explicitly says something to contradict it)
 
Last edited:
http://www.mendosa.com/fluke.html
.
I liked this, 50 years ago when I first heard it.
Puts a lot of things in perspective. :)
.
The ONLY NT or OT verse worth remembering, one anyone proclaiming to be Christian should live by went something like...
"What you do to the least of My brethren, you do to Me."
Others call on the Golden Rule, which supersedes all of the garf in all of the religious tracts ever written, or to be written for a good moral/ethical way to live.
 
This very argument just came up recently in the Faith leads to evil. thread.

Mobyseven (and I believe he's an atheist, but don't quote me, few folk here wear signs saying "fundy" or "semi-religious" or "atheist" . . . except TheAtheist of course . . . but I digress) put up a nice little piece on this very subject, which I find to be an excellent bit. I don't want to pigeon-hole all atheists, of even most, but Mobyseven does take the entire chapter into consideration in providing his argument. I'm not certain I agree with him entirely, but I'm not certain I disagree with him either. He and I both agree that Jesus is presenting an either/or situation, which is what is often overlooked by most folk using these verses as an argument for keeping the Old Testament laws. I don't know why that's so hard to figure out, but there it is.

The specific part that is so well reasoned is, "none of the laws Jesus then introduces contradict the old laws - in many situations he states an old law and then (far from contradicting it) he extends its application to give it a broader meaning (such as forbidding lust by extending adultery, anger by extending murder, and so on)."

The conclusion is then that Jesus wasn't denying the old laws, but had fulfilled them, and then was extending them in his little talk as cited by the entire chapter from Matthew. Which presents an interesting sticking point for the entire argument, and really leaves neither side with much ground at all.

That's an accurate summary of my post - thanks for that. And, aye, I am an atheist.

I'll have a stab at some of the responses directed to the post, as it refers to a post of mine...let's see:

I agree that it's a good point, but we also need to take into consideration "he who is without sin cast the first stone" and the "the Sabbath is for man, not man for the Sabbath" where in both cases Jesus would appear to be going against what was written in Leviticus.

I agree. The bible is inconsistent. However, I was analysing the meaning of the verse in reference to the chapter in was contained within, taking the chapter as a whole and trying to get the meaning out of it. While I understand that there are contradictory (or at least apparently contradictory) passages in other chapters and books, I don't think that said chapters change the meaning of the passages I was analysing.

In other words, there may be passages that are inconsistent with my interpretation - by my interpretation is, I feel, pretty well justified. The inconsistency serves merely as evidence that the bible is inconsistent; it doesn't change the meaning of the passage I analysed.

As a side note, I'm not entirely sure convinced 'let he who is without sin cast the first stone' actively contradicts any of the laws from Leviticus. In theory, it is merely a new commandment - only the sinless may judge. The problem comes about when one considers the practical implications of such a commandment. In that situation Jesus has provided us not with a contradiction, but a paradox.

Can you explain what it means to fulfill a law? I can understand fulfilling a prophecy or an obligation, but the idea that you can fulfill a law is odd, to say the least.

I can give you a possible interpretation, but it is by no means definitive, and is in reality probably one of those angels-tango-pinheads problems.

A possible interpretation is that when Jesus came he fulfilled the 'Old Laws' extending them - before they were 'incomplete laws', and now they are 'complete laws'. However, the 'New Laws' (which have 'completed' the 'Old Laws') are in themselves incomplete. The fulfillment of the 'New Laws' can be fulfilled at the passing of the prophect described in Revelations - the good are judged righteous by god, the evil are thrown into the lake of fire (and permanently cease to exist), and a new covenant with god is created in the post-apocalypse world (in the biblical, not colloquial sense), fulfilling the 'New Laws'.

But, again, it's an area that is very open to interpretation.
 
Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.
Having read through the thread to this point, you've been provided with three references. Here are seven more. In the interest of full disclosure, not all of these use the verses to insist that Christians must follow ALL of the Old Testament laws literally. Some of them distinguish between "ceremonial" laws and "moral" laws, and argue that only the "moral" laws (like stoning children for sassing their parents) are re-affirmed by Matthew 5:17. Such examples are hardly difficult to find, but I don't think you're interested in discussing them or studying them, so my willingness to do your Google legwork for you is limited.

one
two
three
four
five
six
seven
 
Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.


You obviously know nothing about the beliefs of the Sacred Name Movement, which teaches that the Law should be followed, often based on those quotes from Matthew. You may say they are not Christian, but given they regard Jesus as Messiah and believe he died for humanity's sins, it's hard to see how they are not. I have met these people in real life, specifically members of the Twelve Tribes, who I chatted to regularly at a market stall they ran. They believe in following OT laws and festivals. The men even followed the OT rules regarding their hair, and all of them refused to wear clothes made from mixed fabrics.

Why must atheists educate Christians even about their own faith and their fellow Christians? Do Christians not have Google? Anyway...

From 'Yeshua – Our Torah Teacher':

On Matthew 5:17:
Many Christian (especially NTOC) teachers tell us that this means that "Jesus fulfilled the law and therefore, it is completed". This line of reasoning continues to the "logical" (to the NTOC) conclusion that the "Law" is now "complete" and has no further effect on us and we do not have to follow it. This is a poor interpretation of this verse.

On Matthew 5:18:
When someone tells you that the "Old Testament" or the "Law" (meaning Torah) is abolished or done away with, remind them of this verse. I have brought this verse to the attention of a few "learned" pastors in my discussions. Many do stop and think about it. On the other hand, some have tried to bludgeon me into submission to their "theology" with other out-of-context Scriptures. Yeshua’s words are true. If we are reading something in Scripture that seems to indicate another view point, then it is our interpretation or understanding that is in need of alignment to His words, not the other way around.


From '"I give you good instruction: Do not forsake my Torah!" - God':

Yeshua said He did NOT come to abolish Torah, so why aren't we taking this seriously? Yeshua didn't abolish - He tightened and strengthened God's original teaching and instruction! Take, for instance, the things He espoused in Matthew

[...]

Does this sound like someone who "abolished" God's original teaching and instruction?

Yeshua's intent was not to abolish or weaken or emasculate the Laws of YHWH, revealed in the Old Testament, but to expand and magnify them to their full spiritual intent and conclusion.


From 'The Torah - Law and Grace':

Yeshua said he came to fulfill the law, not abolish it, and that it would endure until heaven and earth pass away. The word "fulfill" is a Jewish idiom, meaning to fill up to the brim and make complete—not eliminate.
 
Last edited:
Incidentally, for those interested in more in depth study of the relationship of Jesus and the early messianic community to the Jewish Law, I suggest the following books:

James, Brother of Jesus by Pierre-Antoine Bernheim
A Tale of Two Missions by Michael Goulder

On the Jewish apocalyptic nature of Jesus' message, a popular yet scholarly work is:

Jesus: Apocalyptic Prophet of the New Millennium by Bart D. Ehrman

And the following essay is excellent:

Dale C. Allison, Jr., ‘The Eschatology of Jesus’ in John Joseph Collins, ed., The Encyclopedia of Apocalypticism Volume One: The Origins of Apocalypticism in Judaism and Christianity (London: Continuum, 2000), pp. 267-302

There is also some interesting material in:

Jesus and Judgement: The Eschatological Proclamation in Its Jewish Context by Marius Reiser
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.

I didn't read the whole thread and if these links have been posted, I apologise.

One from memory that I quickly found on Google but I'm sure there are others if you search:

United Church of YHWH - What is YHWH's Law? - First bible quote is a direct hit.

United Church of YHWH - Statement of Beliefs.

Can I have a gold star?

.

ETA: Having your church in an old garage is an excellent way to go for all religions. :D

Another ETA: Sometimes the forum splits the link into two. Not my doing. I blame Darat. :p
 
Last edited:
...snip...

But I have come across atheists using these verses alot here. (And no - Darat - I won't post a link to all the examples in the forum so don't bother asking me to prove that statement)

...snip...

Why single me out for asking you for evidence for your claims? And why single yourself out?
 
The Methodists certainly have an, er, interesting take on this.

http://new.gbgm-umc.org/umhistory/wesley/sermons/25/

It sounds like he was trying to make everyone happy, and, well, most people know how well that works.

...snip...

That brought back memories - we had to write an essay about that sermon back in junior school (would have been about 9 or 10 years old) I got third prize. Which, in customary Methodist "if it's enjoyable it ain't no good" of course, did not win a prize just a certificate.
 
Why is it that of all the Christian writings I've read (and it's been alot) I've yet to come across anything close to these verses being used this way except here by atheists?

But hey - find me some Christian writings teaching this and I'll study it.

What do you think the verses Matthew 5:17-20 mean?
 
http://www.mendosa.com/fluke.html
.
I liked this, 50 years ago when I first heard it.
Puts a lot of things in perspective. :)
.
The ONLY NT or OT verse worth remembering, one anyone proclaiming to be Christian should live by went something like...
"What you do to the least of My brethren, you do to Me."
Others call on the Golden Rule, which supersedes all of the garf in all of the religious tracts ever written, or to be written for a good moral/ethical way to live.

I recall an article pointing out at least a dozen different religions, all of which had their own version of the Golden Rule. I particularly liked the Jewish one:

"Do unto others as you would have them do unto you: that is the law. All else is commentary."
 
The problem is trying to discuss what Christians believe is difficult as they can't seem to agree amongst themselves. We just like to go to the primary literature if in doubt.

Plus why are you so sure Christian interpretations are the 'correct' ones?
 
I recall an article pointing out at least a dozen different religions, all of which had their own version of the Golden Rule. I particularly liked the Jewish one:

"Do unto others as you would have them do unto you: that is the law. All else is commentary."

Allow my nit pick. It's actually phrased in the negative, and part of a longer statement. It's from a passage in the Talmud that talks of a scoffer who challenged the sage Shammai (1st century BCE) to teach him all of the Torah while standing on one foot, and thus convince him to accept Judaism. Shammai of course rebuffed him. The latter then went to Hillel and issued the same challenge. Hillel rejoined with, "What is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow. The rest is commentary. Go and study."

It was more than a concise summary - it was also a rebuke, but one that was probably not understood immediately.
 
Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?

Schlitt said:
ACS, do you think the meaning of this verse is ambiguous?

What would be the reason for wanting this verse to mean something other than what it appears to mean literally?

Well - after reading and thinking about some of the links posted and some of your comments, the conclusion some of you are drawing - that Christians need to obey every last one of the Jewish laws - is not apparent at all to me. Especially from Verse 19.

Matthew 5:19 said:
19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven.

It seems the people Jesus is talking to are people who teach the law and commandments. And all he's saying is a) it doesn't matter how small of a commandment you break don't teach others to break it too and b) if you do teach - make sure you are practicing what you preach.

(Seems like pretty good advice for religious leaders of all ages!)

How are some of you going from that and coming to the conclusion that all Christians have to follow all the laws?
 
Last edited:
A Christian Sceptic,

Have you ever read any academic studies on the New Testament, early Christianity, Judaism's relationship to Christianity, Jesus' message and Jewish apocalpyticism, Jesus' message in relation to the Law as opposed to Paul's message/s regarding the Law, and so on?

How well versed in your own faith are you, and what is it about your 'version' of faith that you think makes you a sceptic?

I have listed some good texts above. I recommend you take some time to investigate Christianity's historical origins and the very specifically Jewish message of Jesus, rather than simply demanding answers from largely anonymous contributors to a discussion forum.
 
It seems the people Jesus is talking to are people who teach the law and commandments. And all he's saying is a) it doesn't matter how small of a commandment you break don't teach others to break it too and b) if you do teach - make sure you are practicing what you preach.
On the other hand maybe he just meant what he said.
How are some of you going from that and coming to the conclusion that all Christians have to follow all the laws?
Because that is what he said. He strengthened one or two and altered another couple, but it seems pretty clear that is what he meant - the law stays in force until all is accomplished.

He certainly regarded them as literal laws.
 
Allow my nit pick. It's actually phrased in the negative, and part of a longer statement. It's from a passage in the Talmud that talks of a scoffer who challenged the sage Shammai (1st century BCE) to teach him all of the Torah while standing on one foot, and thus convince him to accept Judaism. Shammai of course rebuffed him. The latter then went to Hillel and issued the same challenge. Hillel rejoined with, "What is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow. The rest is commentary. Go and study."

It was more than a concise summary - it was also a rebuke, but one that was probably not understood immediately.


I had heard both the quote I gave, and the story about Hillel, but for some reason never connected them. Thanks for the correction.
 
Well - after reading and thinking about some of the links posted and some of your comments, the conclusion some of you are drawing - that Christians need to obey every last one of the Jewish laws - is not apparent at all to me. Especially from Verse 19.
That's not quite the conclusion I draw. I spelled it out earlier: I think Christians have a big unanswered logical inconsistency in their beliefs with regard to the scriptures. In fact, I think many of the commandments are immoral.

I like Paul Tobin's observation (quoting someone else, I believe), where the Bible and Jesus are moral, they're not original, and where they're original, they're not moral.


A Christian Sceptic said:
It seems the people Jesus is talking to are people who teach the law and commandments. And all he's saying is a) it doesn't matter how small of a commandment you break don't teach others to break it too and b) if you do teach - make sure you are practicing what you preach.
Actually Jesus was talking to the crowd of people who had assembled on a hillside. This was part of the famous Sermon on the Mount.

What follows is that business about "extending" the old laws--that adultery isn't just the having sex but can be the lusting after. No where does it say or imply that the old laws (doing the having sex part of adultery, for example) no longer applies. I think MobySeven's reading is right about what "fulfilled" means.

Back to the passage in question:
You think Jesus was saying it's OK to break any of the commandments as long as you don't teach others to break them? Really? You actually think that's what the passage means?

The whole context of the passage points to the obvious meaning. "I come not to abolish the law or the prophets" somehow turns into something like, "in fact, you don't have to follow all those little commandments as long as you don't teach others to do what you're doing".

You think maybe the passage was instructing you as a Christian to maintain the teaching of all the O.T. scriptures (that is, keep them in your Bible and keep saying they're part of divinely inspired revelation), but you're free to ignore the parts that you know are immoral (or the commandments which don't make sense or are inconvenient in our era, like not working on the sabbath, leaving farmland fallow every 7th year, etc.)?

You honestly think that's what the author meant?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom