The atheists favorite bible verses

Yay! Finally. Thanks.

Any more?


The Methodists certainly have an, er, interesting take on this.

http://new.gbgm-umc.org/umhistory/wesley/sermons/25/

It sounds like he was trying to make everyone happy, and, well, most people know how well that works.

BTW, are you really interested in this topic, or are you just fishing? It seems like you could have simply punched in Matthew 5:17 in any search engine and used the results as a springboard for discussion. As worded, the OP sounds a bit like a "Gotcha!" to me.
 
BTW, are you really interested in this topic, or are you just fishing? It seems like you could have simply punched in Matthew 5:17 in any search engine and used the results as a springboard for discussion. As worded, the OP sounds a bit like a "Gotcha!" to me.

Well - atheists here are the ones that bring these verses up in this context and with a rather consistent interpretation amongst themselves. Since it's their insistence that's how Christians need to interpret it I figured that maybe they were aware of Christians who teach that's how to interpret it.
 
Well - atheists here are the ones that bring these verses up in this context and with a rather consistent interpretation amongst themselves. Since it's their insistence that's how Christians need to interpret it I figured that maybe they were aware of Christians who teach that's how to interpret it.
I have been labelled atheist and I do not share this interpretation. As such, I think your generalization is rather unbecoming.
 
I have been labelled atheist and I do not share this interpretation. As such, I think your generalization is rather unbecoming.

Did I say all atheists here?

ETA: By the way - my answer was to the question why I don't just Google it. And it's because atheists here .... well you know.
 
Last edited:
Since it's their insistence that's how Christians need to interpret it I figured that maybe they were aware of Christians who teach that's how to interpret it.

No one insists that Christians interpret it in any way. It is used as a counterpoint to the argument that the OT is not applicable or to point out the hypocrisy of the fundies who use the OT as the basis for their homophobia, but then try to hide behind the "new covenant" idea to explain why they don't follow all of the OT laws.
 
Last edited:
The conclusion is then that Jesus wasn't denying the old laws, but had fulfilled them, and then was extending them in his little talk as cited by the entire chapter from Matthew. Which presents an interesting sticking point for the entire argument, and really leaves neither side with much ground at all.

Can you explain what it means to fulfill a law? I can understand fulfilling a prophecy or an obligation, but the idea that you can fulfill a law is odd, to say the least.
 
Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?

Christians largely view most of those least little commandments to be completely out dated, and connected to a certain culture in a certain period of history.

So, Christian Sceptic, how do you justify this? Was Jesus wrong? Is the Gospel of Matthew unreliable? Is there some strange way you interpret verse 19 to mean it's OK to break all those little commandments in the traditional "law and the prophets" scriptures?

Again, I have no problem with parables, poetry, just-so myths, and so on being read as if the author intended them to be metaphors. The listing of laws is not that type of literature. I haven't heard any credible evidence that these commandments were meant to be figurative in some way. If that's the case, then modern liberal Christians must believe that most Christians (and most Jews) throughout all of history got it wrong.
 
Last edited:
Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?

I could tell you but you'd say I was wrong and then others would jump in saying I was wrong so really - what's the point?

But I'd love for you to give me more references of Christians who agree with you.
 
I could tell you but you'd say I was wrong and then others would jump in saying I was wrong so really - what's the point?
You could but you won't? Sorry, dude, I call shenanigans. If you think this discussion is pointless, why did you start the thread?

Verse 19 clearly has Jesus saying you ought obey every single little law specified in the scriptures. You said it's not so, but you won't say how. Yes, I believe you're wrong, but don't you think if you were right you could at least make a cogent argument and defend it?

But I'd love for you to give me more references of Christians who agree with you.
Please re-read my posts. I said that's exactly the point, most Christians don't accept the Matthew passage you cited, at least not as it is clearly written. If they did, they'd need to abide by all the laws because that's what Jesus said to do.

I admit, most (if not all) Christians disagree with me. So? If they agreed with me, they'd see a glaring inconsistency in how they approach what they believe to be the revelations of God.

Most Christians assert that "the Bible" is the divinely-inspired word of God. (And a source of moral teaching!) Most Christians include the Old Testament as part of that Bible. It includes long lists of laws that most Christians don't feel the need to obey. Yet there is this passage in Matthew that you cite. At best, you can devise some sort of apology to support the conclusion that Jesus didn't mean what he apparently said.

You don't find that intellectually dishonest?
 
Last edited:
You could but you won't? Sorry, dude, I call shenanigans. If you think this discussion is pointless, why did you start the thread?

I don't think this discussion is pointless. I'd love to read what Christians agree with you and I'd love some help in finding their writings.
 
I don't think this discussion is pointless. I'd love to read what Christians agree with you and I'd love some help in finding their writings.
I'd cite now jailed Buffalo Bill Hawkins' cult, the House of Yahweh as a sort of Christian religion that advocated adhering to something like 613 commandments.

Why are you interested in this? I can tell you that mainstream Christians don't agree with me. Lots of them actually do work on the Sabbath--and the Old Testament shows where God demanded death as the punishment for that particular violation.

Either they disagree with the obvious meaning of the passage you cited or they're good at handling the cognitive dissonance involved in obeying what Jesus said unless it's not what they think they need to do.



BTW, are you really interested in this topic, or are you just fishing? It seems like you could have simply punched in Matthew 5:17 in any search engine and used the results as a springboard for discussion. As worded, the OP sounds a bit like a "Gotcha!" to me.

I think you're right, Hokulele.

Especially since the OP began:
Ha,

Got you.
 
Last edited:
you can't just rely on the teachings of God/Jesus as a moral guide. You have to rely on your own reason, and use your reason to select from among the many teachings of God/Jesus those which make sense and apply, and reject the others.
So far so good, given what is in Scripture.
Once we have you doing that, we have removed one of the major arguments against religion: that it is a source of moral guidance.
No and yes. It is a source of moral guidance. As the RCC has shown over about 1500 years, our own reasoning skills add to that moral guidance.

What you might have meant to say was "as THE source of moral guidance" per the sola scriptura argument.

If you take the position that the Bible is not a good source of moral guidance, I cannot agree with you. There's a treasure trove of good moral guidance, good spiritual guidance, and good philosophy in there.

DR
 
Last edited:
Especially since the OP began:

That's in reference to the title and that atheists (as they should) hate it when someone says something that sounds like it is being applied to all atheists.

JoeTheJuggler said:
You could but you won't? Sorry, dude, I call shenanigans. If you think this discussion is pointless, why did you start the thread?
Also - the point of the OP is not me or you to defend the position one way or another but to give me some references.
 
So - if you'd like to play along and take up the challenge -

Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.

Thanks.

Like Joe, I take issue with the use of the word "literally".

Here's an example of Christians who believe the OT applies:
Ethiopian Orthodox Church
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethiopian_Orthodox_Church#Similarities_to_Judaism



That isn't exactly what you asked for, since it doesn't cite the verse. But they do obey quite a bit of the OT.






Hold the presses!
I have a citation....

http://www.ucg.org/booklets/CU/



From the United Church of God:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Church_of_God

I don't think this discussion is pointless. I'd love to read what Christians agree with you and I'd love some help in finding their writings.

Maybe you could help by telling us exactly how many references you need before you'll believe that some christians take the verse the same way that some atheists take it. 6? 9? Because the sources from FireGarden certainly don't seem to be enough (for whatever reason).

IMO, you firmly believed that all christians took that verse in exactly the same way. Well, surprise, they don't. But since one person has gone out and done your work for you, you think that someone else will find you more examples which you can ignore. You're probably right, but I would hope that you would actually use your time to go find them yourself. That would be the best thing.
 
Straw men aside, it's good to know that there are Christians who are aware that there are some pretty horrifying things written in the Old Testament that they wish to distance themselves from. However, I'm still curious as to why God wrote such evil things in the first place. Did he make a mistake?
 
I'm still curious as to why God wrote such evil things in the first place. Did he make a mistake?

How could you say such a thing? God is infallible! It must have been the fault of the mortal authors He "divinely inspired" to write it for him.

Of course, how a "perfect" being would choose imperfect, corruptible means to spread its message is a bit of a poser.

It must be part of His "plan," just like serial killers, tsunamis, and childhood cancer.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom