The atheists favorite bible verses

JoeTheJuggler was very specific in this claim. He claimed a) it was obvious, b) it was Jesus teaching it, and c) I personally, and Christians in general, have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws.
Yes, I was very specific, and you are still ignoring the "according to Matthew, Jesus said". Hell, you even quoted me saying that when you wrote the above.

Since this point has been carefully explained to you over and over (that saying "according to the author of Matthew, you should do x" is not the same as me saying "you should do x"), yes I believe you are being dishonest.

ETA: For the record, saying, "According to the author of Matthew, it is obvious that Jesus said you should do x" is not even the same as saying, "Jesus said you should do x".

And yet, I'm the stupid, disingenuis, dangerous, dishonest idiot?
I do not believe you are stupid or dangerous or that you are an idiot.

I do believe you are disingenuous and dishonest.

My guess is you believe you're serving some higher purpose and that you can justify being dishonest because you believe your position is right at some higher level.

That is one of the worst aspects of dogmatic thinking. If you start from a position where you are just right (before looking at the evidence), you can ignore evidence to the contrary or twist out a strained and tortured "alternative interpretation" (as with the Matthew passage).
 
Last edited:
JTJ,
In my experience ACS does what every woo does. They need their woo to be true... so they manufacture arguments from others so they can fight those battles and protect themselves from scrutinizing their woo. He wants it to be your fault for seeing the bible as a book of conflicting barbaric advice-- that's easier than accepting that the book he considers divine is a book with conflicting barbaric advice.

The truthers and homeopaths and apologists of all sort do the same thing. They don't let you nail down or clarify the conversation. They must obfuscate-- just a like lawyer with a guilty client. What else can they do when the simple truth is so threatening?

He has to see us as the bad guy or admit that he's being dishonest or daft. The majority are following you. Nobody seems to be buying ACS's claim in the OP that atheists are trying to get Christians to follow the OT.

The bible tells us not to "suffer a witch to live"-- that's responsible for a lot of suffering-- nobody wants anyone to follow that edict or accuse people of witchcraft. An atheist doesn't believe in "witches". Surely he wouldn't play this semantic game if we quote that passage at him...

Every biblical aberrancy must have an apologist explanation lest his faith flounder-- he's posting here to build up his apologetic explanations so they feel more true in his head. Don't get frustrated. Lower your expectations (don't imagine he'll ever cede a point), learn to use such folks for amusement, or put them on ignore. They have the same effect on lots of people. Use it for practice on dealing with woo in general and garden variety cognitive dissonance and denial. Whether he understood your analogy or not-- he will NEVER cede a point. He can't. He thinks his salvation depends on his faith. Plus, I think when you insult a woo, it builds up their martyr complex--they feel like they are suffering for their faith or fighting for "the truth". Suffering for a cause (like fraternity hazing) enhances allegiance to a group or cause.

Don't keep explaining-- just be glad you don't have his meme infection. Use him for your own entertainment or woo dissection purposes.
 
Last edited:
On the meta-topic about putting people on ignore:

I never understood that. I'd be way too curious to know what was being posted that I missed. Besides, as an argumentative technique, isn't it the same as covering your ears?

The one argument I hadn't heard before that makes sense was about putting threads on ignore (like the CT ones) just so the threads that you might be interested in stay visible for a longer time. Sorry, I forgot who it was that made that point.

I guess it's a matter of taste, and de gustibus non est disputandum. As for me, I don't think I could take the not knowing. I don't take insults and such personally because. . .well, it's an impersonal message board. These people don't know me at all. If I get too frustrated about making the same point over and over and being willfully ignored, I just leave it alone for a while.

I do find it odd that you'd want to participate in a discussion on a thread ACS started, but that you'd ignore ACS. He's pretty much the only one arguing his position. RobRoy agreed for while, but then re-read bits that he'd missed and set things right. I'm not so sure what Hertz is arguing--it sounds very similar to ACS' position that saying, "according to this passage in Matthew x" is equivalent to saying "you're supposed to obey x".
 
Last edited:
But so what? What difference does that make to the discussion? If a law can never be annulled then surely that means it must stay in force. If a law stays in force then it must be obeyed, right?
Why you ask? I thought that was the obvious, literal, unequivocal meaning of the passage.
 
I put them on ignore because they say they same things... I'm more interested in the responses they generate. Also, they tend to toss out straw men or attacks of me, and then I feel drawn into a discussion or defense-- just like you keep repeating with ACS. I don't think some people are capable of having a discussion. You couldn't discuss the problems of Scientology with a Scientologists-- you CAN find out how they explain the inconsistencies to themselves however. ACS will never rectify his straw man view of what you were saying with your carefully explained analogy and explanation. The woo never do. And they will claim the problem is in your miscommunication. They always do.
It seems they see faults in others that are more inherent in themselves. They imagine themselves communication experts despite lots of evidence which shows that nobody is following them while the better communicators keep trying to fix the problem thinking it really might be them. The woo never even consider whether they are the problem--and they'll be sure to vilify you if you ask them to consider the possibility. They are hear to preach, not to learn.

Sometimes I do engage such people for a kind of stress relief... or to sharpen my own understanding. They are at a skeptics forum... and I figure that most should be as eager to hear my opinion of their opinion. I cut people a lot of slack in my regular life--but this illogical nonsense doesn't fly here.

But I've dealt with creationists a lot-- a rather recalcitrant type of woo. They are very dishonest... very big on loaded questions and straw men--ever eager to vilify those who would carefully explain the truth. I used to try to explain and re-explain and give them links and analogies and so forth... but then I realized that their goal was to NOT understand.... that I was giving them fodder to spin their favorite delusion of the evil non believer in their woo-- they would twist my words to imagine whatever stereotype they needed to believe of those who didn't "believe in" their woo. Their questions inferred their own answer or the lesson they were trying to teach. They were not "real" questions and they are never interested in the real answers. They just want you to be wrong so their woo can be true. And if they can't make you wrong-- then they'll psin you as evil and arrogant.

I started feeling like I was at church I guess. The dishonesty disgusts me-- and in the name of religion-- the stuff that people have learned not to question.

Plus, how do you ignore straw men attacks on your character or people you respect? I wondered if it was me... but then I noticed that the people I liked seemed to be having the same problems with the same people I was. I also noticed that I have the power to eviscerate with my words in a way my enemies do not-- and people applaud me when I do so (which makes me do it mroe). This can get me in trouble and make my enemies exaggerate the bad stuff about me--and I even feel a little guilty about being mean (though I don't think I ever rise to the nastiness level of those I insult.)

I guess I just realized that I don't care about the opinions of people who don't care about mine... or who are constantly hearing things in my words that aren't there and don't allow me to correct it (like ACS is doing to you.) I'd rather talk about them than to them. If they'd put me on ignore, I wouldn't have the power to piss them off. But they feel righteous not putting people on ignore, I guess.

I feel like I'm being used to prop ups someone's self important delusion of themselves and their stereotype against non believers and skeptics of their woo. I figure the people I like will quote the people I don't care about if they say something of value-- probably with a better response than I ever could say. And I don't have to hear their attacks upon me. I can like some people better if I don't know everything on their mind it seems. And if such people ignored me, I wouldn't have to worry about them hearing things in my words and extrapolating meaning that isn't there... (as ACS has done with his charicterization of atheists quoting the Matthew passage that Christians love to ignore.)

I think I'm a better person when I put people on ignore. I feel I can turn my attention towards the people I enjoy reading-- there are so many here. And the woo are going to hear what they want to hear no matter what I say. They will make me into a bad guy no matter how careful I am. So I may as well enjoy it as much as I can.

I don't think of it as covering my ears... I think of it more as fast forwarding through the commericals to see the part of the show I'm interested in.
 
Last edited:
Bull. I never agreed with your OP.

In your very first post you quoted my entire OP and then wrote:
JoeTheJuggler said:
I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.

That is an agreement with my entire OP. In fact, you said it's the exact point critics of Christianity make when you cite those passages.

Every subsequent post you made was built upon this agreement. So it doesn't matter whether you said "according to the bible" or "according to Matthew" because you also included "Jesus taught" and in addition you then said it meant I'm supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. And all that was understood through your first posts agreement with my OP.

So - I've never been dishonest here in misrepresenting you.

If you don't agree with the OP and don't have an opinion on the Matthew verses other than observing what they say then, probably unintentionally, you've misrepresented yourself through your first posts. I've just took your posts to mean what you wrote.
 
In your very first post you quoted my entire OP and then wrote:


That is an agreement with my entire OP. In fact, you said it's the exact point critics of Christianity make when you cite those passages.

:desmile:


I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.

If you claim to derive morality from "the Bible" (as a great many Christians claim to be able to do), then you have to explain all the abominable morality in Old Testament stories. Liberal Christians often dismiss the Old Testament (even though it still sits in their scriptural canon) by saying that Jesus taught a new way that replaced Old Testament morality.

This passage shows that (according to "the Bible") Jesus specifically said that he was not replacing Old Testament teachings.

I concede that most Christians don't adhere to this. I think they're being inconsistent.

Again, if you're going to completely misrepresent someone's opinion, you shouldn't make it clear where the quote came from. At least this time you didn't directly link to the quote you misrepresented. We'll make a full-fledged liar for jesus out of you yet!
 
Last edited:
:desmile:




Again, if you're going to completely misrepresent someone's opinion, you shouldn't make it clear where the quote came from. At least this time you didn't directly link to the quote you misrepresented. We'll make a full-fledged liar for jesus out of you yet!

Then explain how when JoeTheJuggler quotes the entire OP and immiediately says "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage." is not him saying "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage."
 
Last edited:
In your very first post you quoted my entire OP and then wrote:


That is an agreement with my entire OP. In fact, you said it's the exact point critics of Christianity make when you cite those passages.

No it is not. By the way, you don't have to interpret what I say, you can actually go by me telling you what I mean. I can see the difficulty you have though when it's OK for you to ignore words that I did write--sort of makes you want to fill in meaning that I never intended.

Do you actually still think that my position has ever been that I think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws?


So it doesn't matter whether you said "according to the bible" or "according to Matthew" because you also included "Jesus taught" and in addition you then said it meant I'm supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
It matters a great deal. That's why I wrote those words.

And all that was understood through your first posts agreement with my OP.
You mean all that was completely and wrongfully read into my words by you.
It certainly wasn't "understood" by me or the overwhelming majority of people participating in this thread.



I've just took your posts to mean what you wrote.
Now that's one egregious whopper! You just admitted above that you don't think it matters whether or not I used the words "according to Matthew". You persisted (maybe still do) in insisting that I am trying to convince you that you're "supposed to" follow all the O.T. laws even though I've said that I don't think anyone should (or is "supposed to") follow all the O.T. laws well over 50 times.

Of course you're ignoring the words I write and choosing to define MY argument based on YOUR beliefs.

Do you have any response to my vegetarian analogy? If you tell me there's meat in a dish (even knowing that I'm a vegetarian) is that equivalent to you tell me that I'm not supposed to eat that dish?
 
Then explain how when JoeTheJuggler quotes the entire OP and immiediately says "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage." is not him saying "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage."

Asked and answered repeatedly.

Now answer my question:

If you tell me a dish contains meat (knowing that I'm a vegetarian) is it the same as you telling me that I'm not supposed to eat that dish?
 
Then explain how when JoeTheJuggler quotes the entire OP and immiediately says "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage." is not him saying "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage."

By the way, it does mean what I said. The "that" refers to what you were pushing for in the O.P.--that few if any Christians obey all the laws of the O.T.

So, again, when I said, ""I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage" I do mean "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage".

I do NOT mean, "I think that you or anyone else should obey all the laws of the O.T." By the way, it's easily up to 75 times now that I have said this.

So. ..answer me: If a vegetarian eats meat and you point out that he's being inconsistent, is that the same as you saying you think he's supposed to refrain from eating meat?
 
Then explain how when JoeTheJuggler quotes the entire OP and immiediately says "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage." is not him saying "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage."

Because of the rest of post which provides context you ignore. The context, in fact, which is the same argument he makes throughout the thread.


Here, this is really fun, let's play a color matching game:


Every subsequent post you made was built upon this agreement. So it doesn't matter whether you said "according to the bible" or "according to Matthew" because you also included "Jesus taught" and in addition you then said it meant I'm supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. And all that was understood through your first posts agreement with my OP.


If you claim to derive morality from "the Bible" (as a great many Christians claim to be able to do), then you have to explain all the abominable morality in Old Testament stories. Liberal Christians often dismiss the Old Testament (even though it still sits in their scriptural canon) by saying that Jesus taught a new way that replaced Old Testament morality.

This passage shows that (according to "the Bible") Jesus specifically said that he was not replacing Old Testament teachings.

:dewink:
 
There seems to have been a lot of irrelevant discussion of different languages, but as far as I know the original language was Greek and the word meant "loosen", "break up" or "destroy". So annul seems a reasonable translation.

But so what? What difference does that make to the discussion?

It makes a difference because it backs up the idea that he's talking to his disciples -- not the crowd in general -- and telling them how to be good teachers.

Herzblut also pointed out that Matthew 5 begins with "Now when he saw the crowds, he went up on a mountainside and sat down. His disciples came to him, and he began to teach them saying ..."

Indicating that his message was to his disciples -- at least primarily.

Then Matthew5 14-15:
"You are the light of the world. A city on a hill cannot be hidden. Neither do people light a lamp and put it under a bowl. Instead they put it on its stand, and it gives light to everyone in the house."

So he's, effectively, telling them that they are the example for others.

Then he comes up with the "I have not come to abolish the laws..." part of the sermon. Telling them that the teachers are divided into two groups: those who are least in the Kingdom of Heaven because they broke/abolished the least part of the Law and taught others to do so; and those who are great in the Kingdom of Heaven because they kept to the law and taught others to do so.

And so Jesus is telling his disciples to be "perfect, as their heavenly father is perfect".

You may not think that furthered the discussion. But it increased my understanding of the chapter. So I've found it useful to read Herzblut's comments.

So "annul" or "break" the meaning of those verses is that each of the commandments of the old law must be obeyed.

Yes. I agree.
For those that want to be great, rather than least, in the Kingdom of Heaven -- which ACS regards as Heaven. I can see how that is natural, though my first thought was that Hell was part of the Kingdom.

I still regard Matthew 5 as an endorsement of OT laws.
 
Last edited:
No it is not.

Look - if you don't think you quoting my OP and then typing "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage." is an agreement then we can't go farther.

It's obvious now that you didn't mean it, but at the time it's what you wrote.

By the way, you don't have to interpret what I say, you can actually go by me telling you what I mean.

I can only go by what you type.

Do you actually still think that my position has ever been that I think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws?

At the time we first began - yes. Because of your agreement with my OP.


It matters a great deal. That's why I wrote those words.

It doesn't matter because they all mean the same thing - in light of your first post.

You mean all that was completely and wrongfully read into my words by you.
It certainly wasn't "understood" by me or the overwhelming majority of people participating in this thread.

It's my guess most people jumped into the debate without reading all the previous posts bringing with them their positions that were at variance to the posts previous.


You persisted (maybe still do) in insisting that I am trying to convince you that you're "supposed to" follow all the O.T. laws even though I've said that I don't think anyone should (or is "supposed to") follow all the O.T. laws well over 50 times.

Because of your agreement in your first post. Your insistence on this made no sense.

Do you have any response to my vegetarian analogy? If you tell me there's meat in a dish (even knowing that I'm a vegetarian) is that equivalent to you tell me that I'm not supposed to eat that dish?

I think it's not a good analogy.

A better one would be me going through your books about vegetarianism, finding a few sentences in one of your books that could be interpretted to mean fish is not meat and should be eaten by vegetarians, and then telling you that your not doing what it says right there in those sentences. I might also tell you an inconsistent vegetarian is one who does not eat fish. And then I could conclude by saying that it is obvious that that sentence means all vegetarians are supposed to be eating fish. I mean, how else could that sentence be read?
 
Last edited:
I predict he'll answer it... NOT.

Just like he never answered his own question with a yes or no.

(I predict JTJ will come to understand exactly why I put people on ignore.)
 
By the way, it does mean what I said. The "that" refers to what you were pushing for in the O.P.--that few if any Christians obey all the laws of the O.T.

So, again, when I said, ""I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage" I do mean "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage".

I do NOT mean, "I think that you or anyone else should obey all the laws of the O.T." By the way, it's easily up to 75 times now that I have said this.

So. ..answer me: If a vegetarian eats meat and you point out that he's being inconsistent, is that the same as you saying you think he's supposed to refrain from eating meat?

Then you should have quoted the specific section of the OP you were talking about instead of the entire OP. Because quoting the entire OP means the that in your sentence refers to everything you quoted.
 
He seems to be having some sort of disagreement with Joe the Juggler, and I don't really follow the point he's trying to make there, so I probably don't agree with it either. I think JtJ's position with regard to the Matthew quote is clear and defensible.
His argument is simply wrong. His proposition goes
There is an obvious meaning of Matt 5,19, which (happily) coincides with my privative interpretation. It is clearly obvious, that JC directly demands all Christians to obey all OT laws.

His justification goes
My interpretation is true, because the meaning is obvious.

That proposition is null and void. The meaning is obviously not obvious because atheists in this thread have suggested at least 6 other possible meanings. Not to talk about billions of Christians who do not buy into it.

Joe doesn't respond, probably because debunking his proposition totally nullifies the anti-christian argument he has built upon it, namely
Christians ignore the obvious meaning of Matt 5,19. Hence, they are obviously ignorant, stupid or hypocritical.

Hochmut kommt vor dem Fall.
 
Last edited:
Look - if you don't think you quoting my OP and then typing "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage." is an agreement then we can't go farther.

It's obvious now that you didn't mean it, but at the time it's what you wrote.



I can only go by what you type.

At the time we first began - yes. Because of your agreement with my OP.

Your technique is getting better. The context of that quote is devastating to this latest tactic and your decision to pretend it doesn't exist, ignore discussion of it, and avoid re-linking (although you shouldn't have in the last post) is an excellent obfuscation tactic.

It's also an effective device to attempt and claim the moral high ground and pretend to be disappointed that the other guy just won't participate in honest discussion. It's an excellent distraction from the misrepresentation of the discussion you're complaining about.


It doesn't matter because they all mean the same thing - in light of your first post.

See, here you screw up again. You'll never be an effective liar for jesus if you keep drawing attention to the entire points people make. You need to focus the attention on your representation of it.

The frame you want to use is:

"Joe agreed with me initally and then flip-flopped later to confuse the issue"

If presented effectively, this can undercut his credibility and gain sympathy for you, but if you actually reference where he supposedly said this, it stops working because people can check.

Just keep repeating the frame and don't anchor it in someone people can check. If you must refer to the thread, use vague terms like 'earlier' or 'toward the beginning'.





It's my guess most people jumped into the debate without reading all the previous posts bringing with them their positions that were at variance to the posts previous.

You almost bring it back together here. This is a good dodge as people often join threads in the middle, so there's a decent narrative fidelity to this line of argumentation.



Because of your agreement in your first post. Your insistence on this made no sense.

Unfortunately, you go right back to referencing the actual post.

think it's not a good analogy.

A better one would be me going through your books about vegetarianism, finding a few sentences in one of your books that could be interpretted to mean fish is not meat and should be eaten by vegetarians, and then telling you that your not doing what it says right there in those sentences. I might also tell you an inconsistent vegetarian is one who does not eat fish. And then I could include by saying that it is obvious that that sentence means all vegetarians are supposed to be eating fish. I mean, how else could that sentence be read?

I'll give you a mixed review on this one. You can't let clear analogies stand. Analogies are an excellent way to help people comprehend a new issue in terms they already understand and can undo a lot of painstaking obfuscation and misdirection, so your instinct to muddy the waters was good.

Unfortunately, your counter-analogy is torturted and unreadable. Tortured can be good, as it can make the real analogy seem absurd by association, but it has to have a good flow and be easy to read.

On the whole though, I think your technique is improving.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom