Look - if you don't think you quoting my OP and then typing "I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage." is an agreement then we can't go farther.
It's obvious now that you didn't mean it, but at the time it's what you wrote.
I can only go by what you type.
At the time we first began - yes. Because of your agreement with my OP.
Your technique is getting better. The context of that quote is devastating to this latest tactic and your decision to pretend it doesn't exist, ignore discussion of it, and avoid re-linking (although you shouldn't have in the last post) is an excellent obfuscation tactic.
It's also an effective device to attempt and claim the moral high ground and pretend to be disappointed that the other guy just won't participate in honest discussion. It's an excellent distraction from the misrepresentation of the discussion you're complaining about.
It doesn't matter because they all mean the same thing - in light of your first post.
See, here you screw up again. You'll never be an effective liar for jesus if you keep drawing attention to the entire points people make. You need to focus the attention on your representation of it.
The frame you want to use is:
"Joe agreed with me initally and then flip-flopped later to confuse the issue"
If presented effectively, this can undercut his credibility and gain sympathy for you, but if you actually reference where he supposedly said this, it stops working because people can check.
Just keep repeating the frame and don't anchor it in someone people can check. If you must refer to the thread, use vague terms like 'earlier' or 'toward the beginning'.
It's my guess most people jumped into the debate without reading all the previous posts bringing with them their positions that were at variance to the posts previous.
You almost bring it back together here. This is a good dodge as people often join threads in the middle, so there's a decent narrative fidelity to this line of argumentation.
Because of your agreement in your first post. Your insistence on this made no sense.
Unfortunately, you go right back to referencing the actual post.
think it's not a good analogy.
A better one would be me going through your books about vegetarianism, finding a few sentences in one of your books that could be interpretted to mean fish is not meat and should be eaten by vegetarians, and then telling you that your not doing what it says right there in those sentences. I might also tell you an inconsistent vegetarian is one who does not eat fish. And then I could include by saying that it is obvious that that sentence means all vegetarians are supposed to be eating fish. I mean, how else could that sentence be read?
I'll give you a mixed review on this one. You can't let clear analogies stand. Analogies are an excellent way to help people comprehend a new issue in terms they already understand and can undo a lot of painstaking obfuscation and misdirection, so your instinct to muddy the waters was good.
Unfortunately, your counter-analogy is torturted and unreadable. Tortured can be good, as it can make the real analogy seem absurd by association, but it has to have a good flow and be easy to read.
On the whole though, I think your technique is improving.