He seems to be having some sort of disagreement with Joe the Juggler, and I don't really follow the point he's trying to make there, so I probably don't agree with it either. I think JtJ's position with regard to the Matthew quote is clear and defensible.
I'm not sure on all Herzblut's points. But one of his replies was about the quotes I posted. Those quotes show what JoeTheJuggler's
original position was.
His
original position was:
1) A Complete agreement with my OP premise. (Not only an agreement he said he thought that was also the exact point other critics of Christianity make when quoting those verses.)
2) He provided me a definition of what he thought an inconsistent Christian was: An inconsistent Christian according to JoeTheJuggler's post was a Christian who did not adhere to Jesus teaching that Christians are to follow the Old Testament Laws.
3) My posting of my reading of the verses was a response to Joe's specific claim that in the Bible, in the book of Matthew (and according to Verse 19 specifically) Jesus taught that
I am supposed to follow everyone of the Jewish laws. In fact, he said this was obvious.
Bolding Mine.
JoeTheJuggler said:
Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?
JoeTheJuggler was very specific in this claim. He claimed a) it was obvious, b) it was Jesus teaching it, and c) I personally, and Christians in general, have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws.
The following debate about the verses were founded on JoeTheJuggler's claim.
What JoeTheJuggler did, whether intentional or not,
was to switch or change his position without notice and without any formal statement in the middle of the discussion.
What everyone else did is hop into the middle of this discussion between JoeTheJuggler and I that was based on
his claim. Absolutely no one began their arguments against me about my conclusions in regards to JoeTheJuggler's claim with any disclaimer saying they disagreed with the OP or disagreed with JoeTheJuggler's
original claim. Instead, they said I was reading the verses wrong and my conclusion, which was based around JoeTheJuggler's
original claim, was wrong. Which meant, because their was absolutely no notice they disagreed with JoeTheJuggler or my OP and because they were arguing alongside him, that they agreed with his
original claim.
And yet, I'm the stupid, disingenuis, dangerous, dishonest idiot? I've maintained my position all along and became confused when everyone, including JoeTheJuggler, denied having JoeTheJuggler's
original position.
P.S. Please someone quote this so Bokonon can read this since I'm, unfortunately, on his ignore list.