FireGarden
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2002
- Messages
- 5,047
I also think that Fiona's post sets things out well.
I would highlight the point made a couple of times in the thread that many of us don't think the sacred texts are a moral guide. Your morals come from some place else -- including the traditions of your faith. I think that you would use that guide even when reading the OT -- as many apologetics sites do. They know the treatment of the Midianites needs explaining, and so they seek to explain it in a way that agrees with a just God.
btw,
Do you ever pray for guidance when reading the Bible? The intro to the NT given to me by the Gideons includes such a prayer.
I didn't see so much in this thread, more in the other which inspired ACS to start this one. Over here, we had people pointing out alternative advice to Matthew from at least as early as Egg in post 19. Obviously, it's difficult to tell how many people agreed that there are alternatives. But I didn't get the impression that this thread was so one-sidedly "the Bible says you're supposed to follow the OT". One post even corrected such a paraphrase to "Matthew says..."
It may also be worth summarising some of the attitudes to Matthew 5:
1) The OT Law stands (for all Christians)
2) The OT Law stands -- and itself states that Gentiles don't have to follow it all.
3) The OT law stands but (though you will be least in the Kingdom of Heaven) you can still get into heaven even if you break the law and teach others to break the law.
4) Teachers (law-makers) shouldn't try to abolish any part of the OT law -- it says less about the consequences of Joe Public not abiding by the least of the laws.
5) The OT law is fulfilled (though not abolished) and there is a new law.
I'm sure I've missed some.
ACS says he has five, they might be a different 5.
I would highlight the point made a couple of times in the thread that many of us don't think the sacred texts are a moral guide. Your morals come from some place else -- including the traditions of your faith. I think that you would use that guide even when reading the OT -- as many apologetics sites do. They know the treatment of the Midianites needs explaining, and so they seek to explain it in a way that agrees with a just God.
btw,
Do you ever pray for guidance when reading the Bible? The intro to the NT given to me by the Gideons includes such a prayer.
As I read some of the contributions to this thread I think some sceptics are doing exactly what you say they are doing. They read the passage: they believe it is easy to understand (as I do myself); they partially or wholly accept your own position that a Christian should do what the bible says; and they conclude that you are "cherry picking" if you do not act on it. For them, it is wholly logical to see that the inherent contradictions show the bible is not error-free: or that it means what it says and is just plain nasty in parts. For some sceptics this is an unanswerable reason to reject the bible as a moral guide or as inspired. They see it as the writings of men bound by a particular culture at a particular time, with no special status at all. For them it is really hard to understand what you are arguing, But this is a dialogue of two deaf positions, not one.
I didn't see so much in this thread, more in the other which inspired ACS to start this one. Over here, we had people pointing out alternative advice to Matthew from at least as early as Egg in post 19. Obviously, it's difficult to tell how many people agreed that there are alternatives. But I didn't get the impression that this thread was so one-sidedly "the Bible says you're supposed to follow the OT". One post even corrected such a paraphrase to "Matthew says..."
It may also be worth summarising some of the attitudes to Matthew 5:
1) The OT Law stands (for all Christians)
2) The OT Law stands -- and itself states that Gentiles don't have to follow it all.
3) The OT law stands but (though you will be least in the Kingdom of Heaven) you can still get into heaven even if you break the law and teach others to break the law.
4) Teachers (law-makers) shouldn't try to abolish any part of the OT law -- it says less about the consequences of Joe Public not abiding by the least of the laws.
5) The OT law is fulfilled (though not abolished) and there is a new law.
I'm sure I've missed some.
ACS says he has five, they might be a different 5.