The atheists favorite bible verses

I also think that Fiona's post sets things out well.

I would highlight the point made a couple of times in the thread that many of us don't think the sacred texts are a moral guide. Your morals come from some place else -- including the traditions of your faith. I think that you would use that guide even when reading the OT -- as many apologetics sites do. They know the treatment of the Midianites needs explaining, and so they seek to explain it in a way that agrees with a just God.

btw,
Do you ever pray for guidance when reading the Bible? The intro to the NT given to me by the Gideons includes such a prayer.

As I read some of the contributions to this thread I think some sceptics are doing exactly what you say they are doing. They read the passage: they believe it is easy to understand (as I do myself); they partially or wholly accept your own position that a Christian should do what the bible says; and they conclude that you are "cherry picking" if you do not act on it. For them, it is wholly logical to see that the inherent contradictions show the bible is not error-free: or that it means what it says and is just plain nasty in parts. For some sceptics this is an unanswerable reason to reject the bible as a moral guide or as inspired. They see it as the writings of men bound by a particular culture at a particular time, with no special status at all. For them it is really hard to understand what you are arguing, But this is a dialogue of two deaf positions, not one.

I didn't see so much in this thread, more in the other which inspired ACS to start this one. Over here, we had people pointing out alternative advice to Matthew from at least as early as Egg in post 19. Obviously, it's difficult to tell how many people agreed that there are alternatives. But I didn't get the impression that this thread was so one-sidedly "the Bible says you're supposed to follow the OT". One post even corrected such a paraphrase to "Matthew says..."



It may also be worth summarising some of the attitudes to Matthew 5:

1) The OT Law stands (for all Christians)
2) The OT Law stands -- and itself states that Gentiles don't have to follow it all.
3) The OT law stands but (though you will be least in the Kingdom of Heaven) you can still get into heaven even if you break the law and teach others to break the law.
4) Teachers (law-makers) shouldn't try to abolish any part of the OT law -- it says less about the consequences of Joe Public not abiding by the least of the laws.
5) The OT law is fulfilled (though not abolished) and there is a new law.

I'm sure I've missed some.
ACS says he has five, they might be a different 5.
 
He started a thread based on a false premise, "atheists favorite bible versus"--
He started the thread because atheists have quoted the Matthew passage at him to show him how he's cherry picking his bible and pretending to be getting guidance and morality from-- god, the absolute authority.

This passage makes him uncomfortble... he is insinuating that atheists quoting this passage are telling Christians how to behave, and boy won't they be sorry (since killing infidels is a-ok) if Christians take them up on it.

He doesn't care what we think. He never answered his own dishonest question with the yes or no he demanded of us. He just wanted to assert his position ("Stop telling us christians about that passage-- or we might start to follow it! Be glad for us moderates!"). Nobody ever told him that passage as an order... it is usually used by atheists to show how theists cherry pick the "personal" message that they claim comes from god and feel like they are following some outside absolute morality when they do so. He started this thread to support his straw man view of what atheists are saying and doing in order to keep from understanding that he's cherry picking his holy book just like every body else and imagine himself more moral than those "morally relativistic" atheists.
 
Last edited:
He started a thread based on a false premise, "atheists favorite bible versus"--

Yes.

He started the thread because atheists have quoted the Matthew passage at him to show him how he's cherry picking his bible and pretending to be getting guidance and morality from-- god, the absolute authority.

Yes.

This passage makes him uncomfortble...

Yes.

he is insinuating that atheists quoting this passage are telling Christians how to behave, and boy won't they be sorry (since killing infidels is a-ok) if Christians take them up on it.


Only sort of. He begins with a different assumption, and I'm sorry, but that is just the case. He believes that when Jesus speaks in a text that this is the one and truly only living God speaking. If God speaks, then you must follow what He says. From his perspective atheists are telling him how to behave because those words from the mouth of Jesus mean that is how you are to behave.

You and I know very well that is not what others mean by their criticism, though. Others are providing a critique of literalism and trying to demonstrate potential hypocricy.

But that is not how ACS interprets it because of his different assumptions. You really do need to see this.
 
Such bravery, to stick your fingers in your ears when an opposing or uncomfortable viewpoint crosses your vision. If skeptics choose to be self blinding cowards, the skeptical movement becomes yet another brass bell clanging -- a load of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Is that what you intend? It is not what the patron of this site intends. Check out the purpose and mission of the JREF.
I put ACS on ignore too. Since I once taunted Radrook that his "ignorance" just meant that the valid points I was making would go unanswered, you might wonder why. I don't think "cowardice" explains it, but your mileage may vary.

I'm quite willing to engage in honest debate or simple discussion with any opposing or uncomfortable viewpoint you'd care to state. ACS's posts in this thread convinced me that he is not here for honest debate. The sample of his subsequent posts that I've seen quoted by others have done nothing to alter that assessment. His question has been asked and answered; continuing to repeat the same answer to the same question is not debate, it is a waste of time. At this point, I'm mostly skimming the new posts to see if anything has changed -- the subject has been derailed into something interesting, or someone has managed to restate the oft-restated response (or the oft-restated question) in a way that sparked some new understanding. That, too, is beginning to seem like a waste of time, though Fiona may be digging toward some breakthrough.
 
Only sort of. He begins with a different assumption, and I'm sorry, but that is just the case. He believes that when Jesus speaks in a text that this is the one and truly only living God speaking. If God speaks, then you must follow what He says. From his perspective atheists are telling him how to behave because those words from the mouth of Jesus mean that is how you are to behave.

You and I know very well that is not what others mean by their criticism, though. Others are providing a critique of literalism and trying to demonstrate potential hypocricy.

But that is not how ACS interprets it because of his different assumptions. You really do need to see this.

Yes, but he set up the scenario to find that conclusion. Why do you think he has not answered his own question with a "yes" or "no" while insisting other's do so? Does he think Christians should take the Matthew phrase literally? YES or NO.
 
BTW, I put dishonest people who ask insincere questions on ignore, because they don't want the answers to their question... they are using skeptics to support their delusions and pretending they came to their delusional view points skeptically. They hear what isn't there to avoid hearing what is. Arguing their continual straw men gets tiresome-- they are hear to inflict their opinion on others not consider what others have to say. It's on par with arguing with a Scientologists about the merits of Scientology or a self important 14 year old or a mentally ill person. It's not illuminating. I find it much more productive to talk about such people than talk to them. It's an anthropological interest, I suppose.

I like to prod them so they talk more... but I don't like it when they frustrate the posters I like... but I do like reading the responses myself, and feel thankful that I can keep them on ignore while waiting for the smart people to choose the best nuggets for commenting on. Besides the comments I do see, are very often handled better and nicer than I would handle such a bloviation.
 
Yes, but he set up the scenario to find that conclusion. Why do you think he has not answered his own question with a "yes" or "no" while insisting other's do so? Does he think Christians should take the Matthew phrase literally? YES or NO.

Of course he did. That is why I also told him that he was arguing with blinders on. He has a certain perspective. We have a certain perspective. For a meeting of minds to take place we must somehow bridge those perspectives and both see from the other's viewpoint, at least to some degree.

My guess about the "yes" and "no" answers is that he has answered them to his satifaction but doesn't want to share for fear of ridicule, but I could be wrong.
 
Then I'm to take it his answer to the question is "no". He wants to presume that theists are telling him his answer should be "yes" when we really want to know how he justifies his "no" and still considers that he's a moral absolutist-- he's cherry picking and making it up as he goes... he just pretends his moralilty comes from god. That's the whole thing he avoids with his little charade.
 
Last edited:
Only sort of. He begins with a different assumption, and I'm sorry, but that is just the case. He believes that when Jesus speaks in a text that this is the one and truly only living God speaking. If God speaks, then you must follow what He says. From his perspective atheists are telling him how to behave because those words from the mouth of Jesus mean that is how you are to behave.


You and I know very well that is not what others mean by their criticism, though. Others are providing a critique of literalism and trying to demonstrate potential hypocricy.

But that is not how ACS interprets it because of his different assumptions. You really do need to see this.
I do see this, and I disagree wholeheartedly with the proposition that "atheists are telling him how to behave because those words from the mouth of Jesus mean that is how you are to behave."


ETA: I just realized that your phrasing of this has the same kind of ambiguity as ACS'. "How you are to behave" has no agent. Again--"how you are to behave" according to whom? I certainly don't believe that every word out of the mouth of Jesus means that is how you are to behave. It's not how I think someone ought to behave.

I am a vegetarian. If someone tells me that there's meat in the bean salad, they are not in fact telling me I shouldn't eat the bean salad. They're telling me there's meat in it, and I'm deciding that that means I shouldn't eat it.

Also, for him to persist in the belief that my pointing out the meaning of the Matthew passage was equivalent to my telling him he should obey all the O.T. laws he also had to ignore the 50 plus times that I quite specifically told him that I don't want him or anyone else to obey all the O.T. laws.

Someone could tell me that there's meat in the bean salad, but he could still urge me to eat it because it tastes so good, or there's only a little meat or the meat is just fish (yes--in fact people do tell me that). So again, someone telling me that there's meat in the bean salad is not the same thing as someone telling me I shouldn't eat the bean salad.
 
Last edited:
Someone could tell me that there's meat in the bean salad, but he could still urge me to eat it because it tastes so good, or there's only a little meat or the meat is just fish (yes--in fact people do tell me that). So again, someone telling me that there's meat in the bean salad is not the same thing as someone telling me I shouldn't eat the bean salad.


Actually, the "fish" thing is a pretty good analogy. Hey, lots of vegetarians do eat fish, so if you chose to eat the salad with fish in it, it wouldn't make you less of a vegetarian in many eyes. You could object and say that no TRUE vegetarian eats fish, at which point someone would probably just offer you haggis instead.
 
I do see this, and I disagree wholeheartedly with the proposition that "atheists are telling him how to behave because those words from the mouth of Jesus mean that is how you are to behave."


ETA: I just realized that your phrasing of this has the same kind of ambiguity as ACS'. "How you are to behave" has no agent. Again--"how you are to behave" according to whom? I certainly don't believe that every word out of the mouth of Jesus means that is how you are to behave. It's not how I think someone ought to behave.

I am a vegetarian. If someone tells me that there's meat in the bean salad, they are not in fact telling me I shouldn't eat the bean salad. They're telling me there's meat in it, and I'm deciding that that means I shouldn't eat it.

Also, for him to persist in the belief that my pointing out the meaning of the Matthew passage was equivalent to my telling him he should obey all the O.T. laws he also had to ignore the 50 plus times that I quite specifically told him that I don't want him or anyone else to obey all the O.T. laws.

Someone could tell me that there's meat in the bean salad, but he could still urge me to eat it because it tastes so good, or there's only a little meat or the meat is just fish (yes--in fact people do tell me that). So again, someone telling me that there's meat in the bean salad is not the same thing as someone telling me I shouldn't eat the bean salad.

"How you are to behave" according to God. Remember, this is God talking. If God says something, and you believe that what God says is law, then you are supposed to follow that command.

Of course, you are not telling him what to do. I know that. You know that. Everyone else in the thread knows that. But, look at it from the perspective of someone who is not willing to see the criticism of Christianity as criticism, but still tries to incorporate it into his view of what God is telling him to do through scripture. If that interpretation of Matthew is correct, then Jesus, who is God, is telling him to follow Hebraic law because he accepts the truth of scripture.

You know and I know that it is just the author of Matthew, who had a particular view of who Jesus was, putting those words in Jesus' mouth for his own theological and rhetorical purposes. But that is not how ACS seems to see it.
 
Actually, the "fish" thing is a pretty good analogy. Hey, lots of vegetarians do eat fish, so if you chose to eat the salad with fish in it, it wouldn't make you less of a vegetarian in many eyes. You could object and say that no TRUE vegetarian eats fish, at which point someone would probably just offer you haggis instead.
I understand what you're saying, but it's sort of beside the point I was making.

If I'm a vegetarian who does not eat fish, and someone says, "There's fish in the bean salad" it would be wrong of me to say that that statement is equivalent to him saying, "I don't want you to eat the bean salad."

For that matter, if I'm a vegetarian who does eat fish and someone says, "There's fish int he bean salad" it would also be wrong of me to say that that statement is equivalent to him saying, "It's OK for you to eat the bean salad."

So again, my statement, "According to the author of Matthew, Jesus says you're supposed to obey every last one of the old commandments" is not the same as me saying, "I think you're supposed to obey every last one of the old commandments."

I even switched "should" to "supposed to" to reflect ACS' language choice.

Again, if a meat-eating friend of mine told me that there's meat in the bean salad, it is NOT the same as him telling me that I'm not supposed to eat the bean salad. The moral decision not to eat meat is mine the same way the decision to treat the author of Matthew as a moral authority to be obeyed no matter what is ACS', not mine (and not even that of a great many other Christians).
 
"How you are to behave" according to God. Remember, this is God talking.
That's just what ACS did. He wants to assume that anything without an agent is "God talking" but then he turns it around and claims that it was me talking. (Several times he asked why I was trying to convince him he is supposed to obey all the old laws.)
Ichneumonwasp said:
Of course, you are not telling him what to do. I know that. You know that. Everyone else in the thread knows that.
And he knows it as well. After all, I told him over 50 times.

Just because he has some extreme beliefs, doesn't give him license to ignore what I say and go on saying the two statements are equivalent.

Back to my analogy: Someone tells me there's meat in the bean salad. I can debate that point. I can even delude myself into thinking there is no meat in it just so I can eat it and still pretend I'm sticking to a vegetarian diet. People could call me a hypocrite and show me evidence of meat in the bean salad.

However, I am completely wrong to say that the statement, "There's meat in the bean salad" is the same as, "I'm trying to convince you not to eat the bean salad." The person telling me this may have no interest whatsoever in me sticking to a vegetarian diet. That's entirely up to me.
 
Then I'm to take it his answer to the question is "no". He wants to presume that theists are telling him his answer should be "yes" when we really want to know how he justifies his "no" and still considers that he's a moral absolutist-- he's cherry picking and making it up as he goes... he just pretends his moralilty comes from god. That's the whole thing he avoids with his little charade.

I'm sure he would say that "pretend" is too harsh a word, but if examined critically, it should appear obvious that we all decide what is moral or immoral based on internal clues. There really is no other way.

I would assume that ACS would answer that his major internal clue to what is moral and what is immoral is the word of God. If God really is saying that we must follow Hebraic law to be righteous, then that ends the debate. We must follow Hebraic law. No one in this day and age wants to believe that, so new interpretations spring eternal.

There is also the very real issue that Christianity proper is Paulism, and Paul clearly thought that no one is justified before God by following law. But he also thought that everyone should follow the law. I don't think he ever provided a very good explanation why this was supposed to be the case, but there it is.
 
That's just what ACS did. He wants to assume that anything without an agent is "God talking" but then he turns it around and claims that it was me talking. (Several times he asked why I was trying to convince him he is supposed to obey all the old laws.)

And he knows it as well. After all, I told him over 50 times.

Just because he has some extreme beliefs, doesn't give him license to ignore what I say and go on saying the two statements are equivalent.

Back to my analogy: Someone tells me there's meat in the bean salad. I can debate that point. I can even delude myself into thinking there is no meat in it just so I can eat it and still pretend I'm sticking to a vegetarian diet. People could call me a hypocrite and show me evidence of meat in the bean salad.

However, I am completely wrong to say that the statement, "There's meat in the bean salad" is the same as, "I'm trying to convince you not to eat the bean salad." The person telling me this may have no interest whatsoever in me sticking to a vegetarian diet. That's entirely up to me.

Look, I agree with you. I am not trying to argue that you are wrong and ACS is correct. This is just an attempt to lay open the assumptions behind others' opinions.

I understand your stance, and I agree with it. That is why I told ACS that he was arguing with blinders on. He was not able to see what you were saying because he approached it from a particular interpretive framework.

I don't think that he was trying to be deliberately deceptive. I think he was blind to what others were saying. I could be wrong about this, of course.

ETA: As for your example, it is not entirely up to you what you do regarding the bean salad if you accept absolutely the word of God as law. You can, of course, decide not to accept God's command and break His law. But if it is God talking, then what He says is Law.

ETAETA;
Or let me rephrase that: If one accepts that God is the moral arbiter of the universe, then if you say -- this is the proper interpretation of what God says -- then what the person who accepts God as the moral arbiter of the universe is going to hear is "Do this", because, by definition, what God says "Do" you should do.
 
Last edited:
I understand your stance, and I agree with it. That is why I told ACS that he was arguing with blinders on. He was not able to see what you were saying because he approached it from a particular interpretive framework.

I don't think that he was trying to be deliberately deceptive. I think he was blind to what others were saying. I could be wrong about this, of course.
Yeah, he's trying to say that his belief controls what I say.

I do think he was deliberately dishonest. Never once in that long exchange where he just kept asking the same question or where he was asking why I was trying to convince him to obey all the O.T. laws did he acknowledge the statement I made over 50 times (that I didn't want anyone to obey all the O.T. laws). He just kept insisting that I was telling him to obey all the O.T. laws. It was like he didn't see those statements.

If he were sincerely just wearing blinders, as you say, he would at least have noted that what he took to be a contradiction in my words should be decided on the side of the thing I was saying over and over and over. Then he would have to ask why and perhaps listen to the explanations.

He wouldn't have to change his very weird belief that he is somehow obliged to obey everything that the New Testament says Jesus said in order to acknowledge that not everyone in the world thinks that way, so therefore you can't use that as a method of determining what I was saying (especially when I said over and over that I was NOT saying that).

It would be like me assuming that everyone in the world is a vegetarian (of the exact same type that I am). Therefore saying something has meat would be the equivalent of saying it is something you shouldn't eat. In fact, I recognize the world isn't like that.

Even if ACS think the rest of the world OUGHT obey every word that some version of the Bible attributes to Jesus, he surely isn't so stupid as to think that the rest of the world DOES think that way.

That's precisely what he's doing when he insists that saying, "According to the author of Matthew, you're supposed to obey every O.T. commandment" is the same as saying, "I think you're supposed to obey every O.T. commandment".

I have heard him in numerous places acknowledge other perspectives (he even uses the term "atheists" in the thread title, so I'm sure he understands that there are completely different perspectives on the issue of whether or not you're "supposed to believe" everything the Bible says). If he didn't know before, he certainly should have learned during this thread that there are even many kinds of Christians who don't share his extreme approach.
 
It's definitely fair to say that he did a piss poor job of distinguishing you as a person from the author of Matthew, but I guess his argument was supposed to be that it is your interpretation that was so revolutionary, I guess?

It's not like you invented that interpretation out of thin air, though.

I've been trying to avoid saying this in this thread -- partly because I don't know what words he used exactly or where he said it -- but Nietzsche is credited with claiming that one of the biggest problems with Christianity is that it makes such poor readers.
 
Last edited:
Atheists favorite bible verses. I don't have any . I don't tend to quote from works of fiction .
 
Yeah, he's trying to say that his belief controls what I say.

I do think he was deliberately dishonest. Never once in that long exchange where he just kept asking the same question or where he was asking why I was trying to convince him to obey all the O.T. laws did he acknowledge the statement I made over 50 times (that I didn't want anyone to obey all the O.T. laws). He just kept insisting that I was telling him to obey all the O.T. laws. It was like he didn't see those statements.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3700873#post3700873
JoeTheJuggler said:
A Christian Sceptic said:
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally. I'm sure you know why they would like to make that case.

Now - the only place I've ever come across that teaching is here and the only people I've ever heard insist that's how to interpret those verses are atheists.

So - if you'd like to play along and take up the challenge -

Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.
I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.

If you claim to derive morality from "the Bible" (as a great many Christians claim to be able to do), then you have to explain all the abominable morality in Old Testament stories. Liberal Christians often dismiss the Old Testament (even though it still sits in their scriptural canon) by saying that Jesus taught a new way that replaced Old Testament morality.

This passage shows that (according to "the Bible") Jesus specifically said that he was not replacing Old Testament teachings.

I concede that most Christians don't adhere to this. I think they're being inconsistent.
 
That's the eternal question, isn't it? How are those who take the bible literally, and those who don't, ever to bridge the gap?

I don't have any beliefs in gods but I see things of great beauty in all kinds of scripture, whether it be the bible or the Upanishads, or various Buddhist writings. It seems to me that the vast majority of religious folk (I don't include $cientology here) are not fundamentalists, nor do the vast majority of them take scripture literally. Indeed, I'm not surprised to learn that many religious folk haven't given their scriptures much thought since Sunday School.


M.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom