It wasn't abundantly clear. You all stopped debating and started saying you weren't arguing Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. Apparently, to you all there was some distinction you wanted to draw between what you were arguing and what you hoped / preferred Christians to do.
It wasn't abundantly clear to you that there is a distinction between what Jesus wants you to do (according to Matthew) and what I want you to do?
Are you serious?
You can't tell the difference between me and Jesus Christ?
I am flattered, really!
But let me make it abundantly clear to you now that I am not, and never have been, Jesus Christ.
So when I say that Christians are supposed to follow OT laws
according to Matthew 5 that is quite distinct from
me wanting you to follow OT laws.
Is that distinction clear now?
How, in light of Position D, was it ambiguous? In light of any of the other positions the question might be ambiguous. Position D is either YES: Christians should follow the Old Testament Laws or NO: Christians should not follow the Old Testament Laws.
Here is your original question:
ACS said:
Give me a Yes or No - are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws?
Here is my reply:
robin said:
Are they supposed to, according to whom?
What part of that question didn't you understand? In your "Position D" you simply repeat the same ambiguity.
ACS said:
You obviously didn't have that position either. Correct?
Correct, I have had the same clear and consistent position all along. For some reason you did not include it as either A, B, C or D.
You're not ineligible. None of you were taking that position. It's clear now.
And none of us ever had that position. We had the positions we clearly stated.
Yes. Are any of you satisfied? Apparently not. Nothing I can do about that.
Well you could answer the question about the ambiguity. Is that really asking too much?
Let it be clear: I don't think any of you, that I could tell, were being dishonest.
That is big of you.
You weren't, were you? I mean - you really didn't have position D did you?
Well since none of us have said anything that even remotely implies we held that position, then clearly no.
Feel free to quote anything that suggests we ever did
None of you really understand about how arguing about a Christians potential behavior to a Christian will be taken as exactly that - arguing about a Christians behavior? Right?
Feel free to quote anything at all that might be construed to mean that within it's context.
Anything at all.
Does anyone else have anything to add about the actual OP or anything new in light of what Herz brought up? If not, then this thread can die.
I don't think what Herz brought up really adds to it.