The atheists favorite bible verses

It wasn't abundantly clear. You all stopped debating and started saying you weren't arguing Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. Apparently, to you all there was some distinction you wanted to draw between what you were arguing and what you hoped / preferred Christians to do.
You're full of it.

I said over 50 times that I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws, and you continued to say that I was trying to convince you that you're supposed to follow all the O.T. laws.

You're a flat out liar to say otherwise.

I've explained the argument made about the text over and over and how yes in fact that is a separate issue from what I "hoped/ preferred Christians to do".

You simply haven't been engaging in an honest discussion.
 
So did he ever answer his own weasely question with a yes or no or is he still spinning his apologetics and delusional "mean atheist are trying to get me to interpret my bible as written" scenario.

Atheists very often know the bible better than Christians, don't they? I guess it's what has lead many to be atheists.
 
Position D is either YES: Christians should follow the Old Testament Laws or NO: Christians should not follow the Old Testament Laws.

Here we go 'round again. Let me make this clear:

What you call "Position D" is ambiguous.

Got that? Please don't answer another post until you address this; it's what has caused pages and pages of frustration on our side. When you say "should follow" or previously "supposed to," there is an ambiguity about who you're asking. WE say you should not follow the OT. THE BIBLE says you should.

It's really quite simple, and if you continue to pretend you don't get the idea, then you are the most dishonest person I've ever seen post here.
 
For whatever reason, ACS decided to reply to my last post via PM:

ACS via PM said:
JoetheJuggler said:
You're full of it.

I said over 50 times that I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws, and you continued to say that I was trying to convince you that you're supposed to follow all the O.T. laws.

You're a flat out liar to say otherwise.

I've explained the argument made about the text over and over and how yes in fact that is a separate issue from what I "hoped/ preferred Christians to do".

You simply haven't been engaging in an honest discussion.
Sorry you felt that way. As soon as I finally understood none of you were arguing from the position I was taking you as arguing from I clarified everything. Up until that point - your insistence that "saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws" wasn't the same as "you personally saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws." made NO sense. I don't think you ever said I'm not arguer from the OP's position or anything like that.

Really though, take a step back and fill in the word Christians with any other group of people you belong to (maybe a bowling team or something) and fill in an action appropriate to it that someone might argue towards you about (maybe they say all bowlers have to take four steps before releasing he ball according to 1964 rules or something). As a bowler it won't matter if the arguer doesn't really think he's telling you something, you'll take it as an argument of what bowlers are supposed to do.

You don't have to believe me, but I apologize if I hurt your feelings or something.
Surely you understand the difference between someone saying, "According to the 1964 rules, you're supposed to take 4 steps before releasing the ball" and someone saying "I think you should take 4 steps before releasing the ball".

The ambiguous statement, "You're supposed to take 4 steps before releasing the ball" could be read as equivalent to either (though it sounds more like the second one). Why not just address the ambiguity?

Your contention that arguing that a N.T. passage says X is the same thing as saying "All Christians are supposed to abide by X" is simply untrue. I've proven that many times over.

If you made the assertion that all swans are white, I only have to show that one swan is not white to prove you wrong. The approach to these matters taken by Catholics and Unitarians (as discussed in this very thread) does just that.

Please stop repeating the same point. It's utterly tiresome.

My feelings aren't hurt. The fact that you aren't being honest is apparent to everyone here, and it doesn't hurt my feelings at all that you are that way.
 
Last edited:
It's really quite simple, and if you continue to pretend you don't get the idea, then you are the most dishonest person I've ever seen post here.



Or just stupid in the way that faith is known to make people stupid. They become impenetrable to anything and everything which threatens their magical delusion (which throws in demonization of atheists to keep the "faith is good" meme thriving.)

He's building up his illusion of himself as a martryr with a bunch of mean atheists picking on him. Is anyone buying it any more? Or is he just spinning for himself now?

And I snort at the bowling analogy. I thought we were talking about a supposedly sacred book written by the invisible man who created the universe and determines how you'll spend you eternity... not bowling. How interesting that he chose such a banal example to keep himself from understanding what everyone else has understood from the get go.

So should you take 4 step when you release the ball-- yes or no... yes or no ....yes or no????

And did you ever answer your own disingenuous question so we could hear what the hell sort of answer you expected? Did you answer with your required "yes or no" only??? Or are you still continuing with your lie that you were interested in our answers... when you really just wanted to spin your little lie for yourself?

So--answer your own question, hypocrite. With a yes or no. Should Muslims take the Quoran literally? Should Mormon men take multiple wives if god commands it? Should Tom Cruise continue with his Scientology clearing since he's been so successful? Should the hijackers fly into buildings if they really really believe that is what Allah is telling them to do? Does your sacred text tell you that you are supposed to follow the Old Testament or give you a pass on all that stuff? Who are you getting your information as to what god intended from? Your ass? yes or no yes or no yes or no?

YES OR NO. YeS or no.... yes or no.... Still playing with yourself daily? Yes or no??? Yes or no???

Don't you see how a Christian might take that question? yes or no yes or no yes or no.... or I"ll just make up my own answer to fit whatever I want to believe and argue that straw man as you have done in every thread you have started.
 
Last edited:
Nope. Never clamed it was correct.
So then your interpretation is meaningless. Even you have no confidence in it.

And I suppose the people in this thread who did say I was wrong and that they are right do? Every single one of them?
The people I am referring to including myself are interpreting the verses at face value. You seem to be finding some unique meaning in the verses.


How do you know? I've only told you 1 of the 5 ways that verse can be read in this thread.
I don't understand your point here.


Please give me an exact specific definition of "cherry picking". It's one of those phrase used around here alot and I'd prefer not starting any conversation about "cherry picking" without knowing exactly what you mean.
This is just a stall tactic. Cherry picking is a plain and simple concept. The Bible says A and it says B. A & B are not compatible truths. You claim A is the truth and B really means something else or doesn't count. The evidence is there are incompatible truths in the Bible. The evidence is the Bible is not a reliable source of truths as is claimed by believers. You cherry pick a truth and claim there are not incompatible truths in the Bible. But the rest of us can still see the Bible says both A & B plainly and clearly and they are incompatible truths.
 
What I don't get about bible passages is how God evolves throughout the whole thing, and yet people still accept him as "perfect". Even though he seemed to sway to the beat of cultural values in their particular Zeitgeist...
 
Last edited:
OK, apparently this thread isn't going to die.



It wasn't abundantly clear. You all stopped debating and started saying you weren't arguing Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. Apparently, to you all there was some distinction you wanted to draw between what you were arguing and what you hoped / preferred Christians to do.
Just to be clear here, my position was and still is that there is a claim oft heard out the mouths of Christians that all the cruelty and disgusting things the God they worship does in the OT doesn't count because Jesus supposedly changed all that and ...wait for it...

Jesus is Love

But you can find numerous passages in the NT where Jesus personally utters cruel things such as killing non-believers and Jesus never says anywhere anything to the effect that all the cruel and disgusting things the Biblical God does and wants done in the OT are now irrelevant and ...wait for it...

God is Love :rolleyes:

There are, of course, some passages referring to a loving god, in between the many passages telling followers who to kill and who will suffer for not believing and obeying and worshiping the cruel and disgusting Biblical God.

Cruelty and violence list from the Bible

One example from a very long list.
1:7 And to you who are troubled rest with us, when the Lord Jesus shall be revealed from heaven with his mighty angels,
1:8 In flaming fire taking vengeance on them that know not God, and that obey not the gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ:
1:9 Who shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord, and from the glory of his power;

All this reminded me of my favorite Bible story of all time, John 3:16. The SAB has a concise version:
As an example to parents everywhere and to save the world (from himself), God had his own son tortured and killed.
I cannot for the life of me figure out what logic there is in this absurd premise. I've heard all the nonsense about the symbolism. All God had to do was forgive people. Heck, it wasn't even the same people it was some distant ancestors. And as if eating some forbidden fruit wasn't bad enough, torturing and murdering someone fixes it? Insane!
 
Last edited:
The German translation I came acoss said:

"Wenn du nicht den alten Gesetzen folgst, mache ich deine Katze zu drei Pfund Spargel. Ich bin leistungsfähig. Ich bin launisch. Auf deinen Knien."
I figure its has about the same meaning...
Only for the pinheads who prefer a lousy cat over a load of Spargel.
 
Last edited:
For that reason this version is less clear than the King James one, but I still see the central meaning to be "The OT laws are still to be obeyed".
I fail to see how this follows. The whole passage is addressed to policymakers, not the public. It defines fundamentals of future law systems and demands a righteous society. This is its central message.
 
Last edited:
It wasn't abundantly clear. You all stopped debating and started saying you weren't arguing Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. Apparently, to you all there was some distinction you wanted to draw between what you were arguing and what you hoped / preferred Christians to do.
It wasn't abundantly clear to you that there is a distinction between what Jesus wants you to do (according to Matthew) and what I want you to do?

Are you serious?

You can't tell the difference between me and Jesus Christ?

I am flattered, really!

But let me make it abundantly clear to you now that I am not, and never have been, Jesus Christ.

So when I say that Christians are supposed to follow OT laws according to Matthew 5 that is quite distinct from me wanting you to follow OT laws.

Is that distinction clear now?
How, in light of Position D, was it ambiguous? In light of any of the other positions the question might be ambiguous. Position D is either YES: Christians should follow the Old Testament Laws or NO: Christians should not follow the Old Testament Laws.
Here is your original question:
ACS said:
Give me a Yes or No - are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws?
Here is my reply:
robin said:
Are they supposed to, according to whom?
What part of that question didn't you understand? In your "Position D" you simply repeat the same ambiguity.
ACS said:
You obviously didn't have that position either. Correct?
Correct, I have had the same clear and consistent position all along. For some reason you did not include it as either A, B, C or D.
You're not ineligible. None of you were taking that position. It's clear now.
And none of us ever had that position. We had the positions we clearly stated.
Yes. Are any of you satisfied? Apparently not. Nothing I can do about that.
Well you could answer the question about the ambiguity. Is that really asking too much?
Let it be clear: I don't think any of you, that I could tell, were being dishonest.
That is big of you.
You weren't, were you? I mean - you really didn't have position D did you?
Well since none of us have said anything that even remotely implies we held that position, then clearly no.

Feel free to quote anything that suggests we ever did
None of you really understand about how arguing about a Christians potential behavior to a Christian will be taken as exactly that - arguing about a Christians behavior? Right?
Feel free to quote anything at all that might be construed to mean that within it's context.

Anything at all.
Does anyone else have anything to add about the actual OP or anything new in light of what Herz brought up? If not, then this thread can die.
I don't think what Herz brought up really adds to it.
 
@ ACS. At the risk of boring everyone let me go over this again.

You believe the bible is the word of god. Like many Christians you are therefore reluctant to conclude that any of it is wrong. When you come across a passage which seems at odds with other bits of the bible you will start from the default position that they are reconcilable. You will investigate as seriously as you can: read in the original language; consider alternative meanings of the words or the syntax; think about possible symbolism; and/or any other approach which seems to have a bearing, and which might illuminate the passage in a different way. If that all fails you can conclude it is in error, if you are one who admits that possibility: or you will perhaps decide that you just don't have the ability/knowledge to understand it, or you do not have it yet.

For you, if anyone says the bible tells you to do X, then, if they are right, you must do X. It follows that when people say "this passage means a christian should do X", you hear them saying "ACS should do X". For you the statement is prescriptive by definition. The only question is "are they right about what it tells you to do". As you are clearly struggling with this passage, shown by the fact that you have read a number of interpretations by other people, you are interested in how those who say it says you should follow the OT Laws justify that conclusion. Naturally you are more interested in how Christians reach that conclusion (if they do) than in how others do, because you think that more hangs on it for them (well that is my assumption: perhaps that is not the reason you asked about Christian quotes).

As I read some of the contributions to this thread I think some sceptics are doing exactly what you say they are doing. They read the passage: they believe it is easy to understand (as I do myself); they partially or wholly accept your own position that a Christian should do what the bible says; and they conclude that you are "cherry picking" if you do not act on it. For them, it is wholly logical to see that the inherent contradictions show the bible is not error-free: or that it means what it says and is just plain nasty in parts. For some sceptics this is an unanswerable reason to reject the bible as a moral guide or as inspired. They see it as the writings of men bound by a particular culture at a particular time, with no special status at all. For them it is really hard to understand what you are arguing, But this is a dialogue of two deaf positions, not one.

JoeTheJuggler has helped to clarify this because his contribution has made it plain that there are many different kinds of Christian. I think you need to accept that. I do not know what tradition you come out of but as you are no doubt aware the relationship with the bible is different depending on the sect. As has been noted the catholics, for example, rely on church doctrine as the definitive interpretation. They assume that the church has seriously addressed all these issues; they believe that the conclusions are conscientious and that if a passage is bothering them that the church has put in the time and effort to decide what it means; and that some parts of the bible are actually wrong. It follows that someone from that background does not see that arguing this passage means X, implies that you should do X. It may be that the church has decided the passage does mean that and it is wrong. That is a perfectly possible outcome within some parts of the Christian faith and it seems to me you should take that into account when you are having such discussions. It really matters to listen to what they are saying rather than to filter it through your own strand: Christianity is not monolithic and that is not trivial.

As I understand it at least some protestant sects do not take the same view of the status of the church. They think the relationship with god is individual and they expect their adherents to study the bible for themselves. This gives those kinds of Christian more problems because they cannot fall back on authority and the reconciliation must make sense to them personally. From one perspective every protestant has to re-invent the wheel, and for some at least the bible cannot be wrong.( For most in all traditions the idea it is wrong is, as I said, a last resort, even where the possibility is accepted). In one way you give the sceptics who argue with you more respect than a catholic would, since you at least admit the possibility that if they are right that has implications for your behaviour. So to that extent both you and some of the sceptics here are agreed. For you this is not simple because it is your belief and your behaviour which are at stake; not theirs. But you are not so far apart in some ways. Other sceptics like other Christians, do not see it that way, as I have tried to show

You need to recognise that when people say "I think the passage says you should follow the OT laws, but that does not mean I think you should actually do so" that is exactly what they mean. By itself it does not tell you whether they think that generally because they admit the possibility of error: or if tey think it is a knock down argument for your whole religion. It is important take small steps to find out what their position actually is. Much of this has not been spelled out. Neither had your own stance, though. You took it as read that if it can be shown the passsge means you should do x then there is no question that that is what you should do. I hope some of what I have said helps you to see why that is not so.
 
Last edited:
I don't know if it's helped ACS, but I'd like to say that Fiona's posts (and some other people's) have helped me see where the possible misunderstanding is (I don't always agree with your posts Fiona, but I do find them enjoyable and thought-provoking).

ACS, I must admit I thought you were being deliberately disingenuous when you kept asking your yes/no question.

D) IF you are arguing that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and these Matthew verses are you're proof - THEN we can continue on.

If Fiona is accurately representing your position, then, to you, there is no difference between me saying, "I think the Bible says you should follow the OT laws" and, "I think you should follow the OT laws". In this context, your question makes sense.

To the people responding, those two statements are not equivalent. Because if you ask atheists about their interpretation of Bible verses, they're going to tell you what they think the verses mean. Your question is ambiguous because it conflates literary interpretation with moral judgement (with those two words supposed to). My interpretation of the words of the bible are that it is saying the OT laws are still in force. My moral position is that you should not follow the OT laws.

So I apologise to ACS for any misunderstanding (assuming I have correctly interpreted his position now). I also hope he now understands why people keep refusing to answer his question D) above. It's still, to us, entirely ambiguous.
 
All he had to do was answer his own question or the many similar questions directed at him with the same "yes" or "no" criteria to see that it was an ambiguous question that skeptics repeatedly answered carefully from the beginning. They answered exactly like he would answer such ambiguous questions... and he refused to answer "according to whom" so he could lie and pretend atheists were trying to tell him what to do--not what his bible says.

He never answered his own question with a yes or no... but he insisted that atheist do so so he could mischaracterize their position. ACS has been around a while... he is always the same... he never changes... like all woo pretending to want conversation but intent on preaching-- his question wasn't meant to be answered... he never cared about the answers...he was trying to prove a point-- and it's obvious from his OP. It's obvious from all his posts and the funny ways he plays with semantics. I don't know if he's aware of this... but if he's ever lucky enough to become a rational person not blighted by faith, he will have a good laugh at himself.
 
Last edited:
All he had to do was answer his own question or the many similar questions directed at him with the same "yes" or "no" criteria to see that it was an ambiguous question that skeptics repeatedly answered carefully from the beginning. They answered exactly like he would answer such ambiguous questions... and he refused to answer "according to whom" so he could lie and pretend atheists were trying to tell him what to do--not what his bible says.

He never answered his own question with a yes or no... but he insisted that atheist do so so he could mischaracterize their position. ACS has been around a while... he is always the same... he never changes... like all woo pretending to want conversation but intent on preaching-- his question wasn't meant to be answered... he never cared about the answers...he was trying to prove a point-- and it's obvious from his OP. It's obvious from all his posts and the funny ways he plays with semantics. I don't know if he's aware of this... but if he's ever lucky enough to become a rational person not blighted by faith, he will have a good laugh at himself.


I'm sorry, but I disagree. He approached the issue from a different set of assumptions and so arrived at different conclusions, creating this impasse. The issue is that we all need to examine our underlying assumptions. For him there is a simple yes or no answer to the questions. The same is not true for those responding to him.
 
I have ACS and the apologists on ignore.
Such bravery, to stick your fingers in your ears when an opposing or uncomfortable viewpoint crosses your vision. If skeptics choose to be self blinding cowards, the skeptical movement becomes yet another brass bell clanging -- a load of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Is that what you intend? It is not what the patron of this site intends. Check out the purpose and mission of the JREF.

DR
 
What I don't get about bible passages is how God evolves throughout the whole thing, and yet people still accept him as "perfect". Even though he seemed to sway to the beat of cultural values in their particular Zeitgeist...
God evolved, or the understanding of God evolved as written down?

Looking at the OT, the understanding, the grasp of what God was demanding of His people was patchy at best, given the number of times the Hebrews cocked it all up and got the wrath and distemper of God laid upon them. See Moses' punishment for a fine example.

A thought just came to me: you don't want to see me when I'm angry. A line from The Hulk TV show, 70's vintage, but also an admonition from the Almighty to more than one of his OT contacts.

DR
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, but I disagree. He approached the issue from a different set of assumptions and so arrived at different conclusions, creating this impasse. The issue is that we all need to examine our underlying assumptions. For him there is a simple yes or no answer to the questions. The same is not true for those responding to him.

Nope. He has the same assumptions... it's why he won't answer his question or any question with a yes or no. He had the question to prove a point... that atheists are trying to tell him what to do... and then he inferred that they might be getting Christians to take them up on this suggestions (which they never made in the first place.)
 
God evolved, or the understanding of God evolved as written down?
Whatever pseudo-explanation can cover it up real quick, I guess.

The "evolution" of the "understanding of God"" seems to correlate just as much as worshipper's "understanding of Zeus" or any number of other gods that also just seemed to happen to latch onto the morals and culture of whatever culture happens to make them up.

Personally, I don't know many Christians that really would be happy with outright genocide, or the outright mass murder of first-born children to piss off an official. Yet God was once upon a time just fine with it... although now that I hear the "God is love" stuff, it makes me wonder just how much our "understanding" would have had to change to accept this Doublethought.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom