The atheists favorite bible verses

No Firegarden,

How do you expect Christians to take it. Because you and others seem to feel a bit shocked that Christians would actually take your argument that Matthew 5 means Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws as being an argument about what they should do.

The reason I am surprised is that I've had many conversations with religious people, including discussing the meaning of texts, and what normally happens is what I suggested would happen most: when there is a disagreement in interpretation, the religious explain why they hold their views -- just like anybody else would.

As a result, I've become familiar with quite a few interpretations of quite a few verses. I share some of these on this forum -- often enough to be called a Muslim apologist by some.

Yes, logically, if you become convinced that following the OT is required of a good Christian, then you will follow the OT -- it's no skin off my nose, plenty of people follow the OT without being genocidal maniacs. Interpretation, again. Morality is in the eye of the beholder, not some book.
 
You are claiming your own individual interpretation is correct.

Nope. Never clamed it was correct.

You have no expertise in the language of the original text as it was written.

And I suppose the people in this thread who did say I was wrong and that they are right do? Every single one of them?

You are simply interpreting the words to mean either what you want the words to mean, or what someone else told you the words mean.

How do you know? I've only told you 1 of the 5 ways that verse can be read in this thread.

That is the very definition of cherry picking the meaning of the text.

Please give me an exact specific definition of "cherry picking". It's one of those phrase used around here alot and I'd prefer not starting any conversation about "cherry picking" without knowing exactly what you mean.
 
That's quite a stretch.
Tradition is as important as sacred texts to religion -- in practise, if not in theory. The majority interpretation of the NT is that the OT laws don't apply.

I'm not entirely sure how Christians manage to interpret the verse in the OP as being against follwing the OT. I've tried to understand a bit of that from ACS's comments. But it's tough -- because he has abandoned defending his case. He has started telling people not to disagree with him because to do so might acheive ends they don't want to acheive.

So what's your suggestion?
Give in to this threat? Let him win the debate because otherwise... What?

Well you're pretty much dealing with a theological debate that began during the early days of the church and was pretty much resolved once the vast majority of it's followers were no longer jewish. When Christianity was simply an off-shot cult of judaism that were seriously arguing about whether or not new converts should be circumcised and follow jewish laws. Needless to say the christian-as-jew interpretation lost out pretty early on.

As someone whose been raised in a christian background I can pretty much say that the main interpretation these days seems to be that the Old Testament is just the theological and prophetic precursor to the New Testament and that the NT is a fulfillment and summation of the OT. Depending on the denomination the interpretation is either Convenant theology or Dispensationalism. In either case, christians are said to operate under a different covenant [contract with god] or dispensation [religious era] than that of the israelites and are thus not strictly bound to Mosaic law since Jesus symbolically/prohetically fufiled them by his 'sacrificial' death. In short, the OT is more for posterity; its considered the prelude to christianity.

Arbitray? Of course it is. This is religion we're talking about after all. Would it be preferable for them to NOT employ such elaborate theological nuances to avoid acting like bloodthirsty bronze age fanatics who stone folks to death for wearing the wrong threads? No.
 
Well you're pretty much dealing with a theological debate that began during the early days of the church and was pretty much resolved once the vast majority of it's followers were no longer jewish. When Christianity was simply an off-shot cult of judaism that were seriously arguing about whether or not new converts should be circumcised and follow jewish laws. Needless to say the christian-as-jew interpretation lost out pretty early on.

...snip...

Well put.

Of course this hasn't stopped Popes and other church authorities from quoting Leviticus as support for Church doctrine or a decision when convenient to do so.... !
 
Just for the record, I sent JoeTheJuggler a PM on this, with my apology, but since I was so far behind from catching up on the entire thread, I didn't want to derail it with response to this. My bad for not reading over the weekend.

But I felt this needed a public response.

But you were definitely being dishonest.

No, I wasn't.

Again, and pay attention to what I'm about to say now, the question has been answered so many times that pretending it isn't is dishonest.

Yes, in reviewing the posts JoeTheJuggler provided, I saw that he was correct in his assertion and that ACS seemed to be dissembling for some reason. What reason that is, I don't know. At the time, I thought he was just being pedantic, but this does appear to step over the edge into true dishonesty or planned blindness.

If you were being honest, then you'd have apologised right away, like you said you would. But no, instead you're trying to pretend that those answers don't exist, just so you can get in another cheap and dishonest shot.

What?! Talk about dishonesty! This makes no sense whatsoever. I offered to review the posts that JoeTheJuggler provided. The fact that I didn't do so immediately doesn't mean I'm being I'm trying to "get in another cheap and dishonest shot". There was no shot, now, or ever.

I have apologized to JoeTheJuggler as soon as I saw that I was in error after reviewing the posts he provided. That I didn't do so on your time schedule in no way impugns my integrity or that of what I said I would do.

And until you show me evidence in that you have actually been reading the posts other people has made - [snip] You're posting in it, true, but your posts show no signs of you actually participating in discussion, as much as being dishonest, deliberately(?) dense, and of course defending the lies of ACS.

There is, or at least there was, more than one set of arguments being made and traded. I was not following closely to every line of argumentation, but I was reading the posts everyone was making. Do you recall every single from every forum member from the begining to the end of this thread, or any thread that you've participated in?

Now, I've done exactly as I said I would do. I was wrong about ACS in this thread, and I've apologized for it.

Does anyone else want to call me a liar?
 
the posts JoeTheJuggler provided, I saw that he was correct in his assertion and that ACS seemed to be dissembling for some reason. What reason that is, I don't know. At the time, I thought he was just being pedantic, but this does appear to step over the edge into true dishonesty or planned blindness.

I was assuming everyone was defending the use of those verses as described in the OP. why that assumption - well, because that's what that thread was about. Apparently not a single person who was arguing me was defending that position. My attempt to get a simple YES or NO on what their claim was eventually made this clear.

Here is where I clarified the various arguments that might be being made:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3710750#post3710750

Joe appears to have been arguing the contradictory position. Position A on that list. And his answer (or rather refusal to answer) my YES or NO question makes sense if that was really his position.

And here is where I explained how I had recently experienced these verses used, which also led to this thread. They were used as described in Position D and in my OP:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3712833#post3712833

So - with that argument in mind my answer of a YES or NO was really that simple.

No one clarified that they weren't arguing the use of the verses as in the OP. So when they began saying "We're really not arguing Christians should do this" it made no sense - since that's exactly the argument that was talked about in the OP. And until clarification was made - A YES or NO on your actual position - we couldn't go further.

I may have been annoying, but hardly dishonest.
 
Well you're pretty much dealing with a theological debate that began during the early days of the church and was pretty much resolved once the vast majority of it's followers were no longer jewish. When Christianity was simply an off-shot cult of judaism that were seriously arguing about whether or not new converts should be circumcised and follow jewish laws. Needless to say the christian-as-jew interpretation lost out pretty early on.

As someone whose been raised in a christian background I can pretty much say that the main interpretation these days seems to be that the Old Testament is just the theological and prophetic precursor to the New Testament and that the NT is a fulfillment and summation of the OT. Depending on the denomination the interpretation is either Convenant theology or Dispensationalism. In either case, christians are said to operate under a different covenant [contract with god] or dispensation [religious era] than that of the israelites and are thus not strictly bound to Mosaic law since Jesus symbolically/prohetically fufiled them by his 'sacrificial' death. In short, the OT is more for posterity; its considered the prelude to christianity.

Arbitray? Of course it is. This is religion we're talking about after all. Would it be preferable for them to NOT employ such elaborate theological nuances to avoid acting like bloodthirsty bronze age fanatics who stone folks to death for wearing the wrong threads? No.

I think this is pretty much accurate. There is one other twist, closely related to this, that might help understand the debate.

According to Judaism, the Law does not apply to non-Jews. It doesn't matter if those people happen to be righteous, God-fearing, believers in Jehovah. If they aren't of the race of Moses, God didn't command them to do all those ritualistic things.

In Judaism, you can be a completely righteous and holy person, and not be Jewish. If you are born into the Jewish race, or accept the Law at some later time, you are bound by the Law. There's no sin in having a complete penis or eating a bacon cheeseburger unless you happen to be Jewish. Non-Jews are only required to follow the much simpler Noachide code. (You can look it up if interested. I hope I spelled it right. The only dietary restriction is that every animal you eat has to be dead.)


During New Testament times, there was a lot of debate about whether the people entering this new sect of Judaism, called Christianity, should adopt full fledged Judaism. It was decided that they didn't have to, and so the Law did not apply. Generally, since then, the law codes which seemed to be of a moral nature, like "Thou shalt not steal" are considered still applicable, but those of a cultural or ritual nature, like Kashrut, are considered part of the Jews-only requirements.
 
According to Judaism, the Law does not apply to non-Jews. It doesn't matter if those people happen to be righteous, God-fearing, believers in Jehovah. If they aren't of the race of Moses, God didn't command them to do all those ritualistic things.

If that's in the law Jesus said he wouldn't abolish, then there's no problem. Christians can follow the OT by following the bits that apply to them.

Non-Jews are only required to follow the much simpler Noachide code. (You can look it up if interested. I hope I spelled it right. The only dietary restriction is that every animal you eat has to be dead.)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noahide_Laws
 
In Judaism, you can be a completely righteous and holy person, and not be Jewish. If you are born into the Jewish race, or accept the Law at some later time, you are bound by the Law. There's no sin in having a complete penis or eating a bacon cheeseburger unless you happen to be Jewish. Non-Jews are only required to follow the much simpler Noachide code. (You can look it up if interested. I hope I spelled it right. The only dietary restriction is that every animal you eat has to be dead.).

Here they are Noahide Laws (Didn't see Firegarden's post. The Forum acting buggy.)

I think Jesus taught behavior on all the Noahide laws except possibly 6 - the dietary restriction you noted. And maybe 7.
 
Last edited:
They were used as described in Position D and in my OP:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3712833#post3712833

So - with that argument in mind my answer of a YES or NO was really that simple.
It was explained to you dozens of times that your question was ambiguous. One could answer YES or NO depending on which question we assumed you were asking, so we refused to provide a simple YES or NO answer until you cleared up the ambiguity. You never did.

Ignoring the requests to clear that up, while continuing to complain that your question had not been answered, dozens and dozens of times, is what told everyone that you were not being honest.
 
Last edited:
It was explained to you dozens of times that your question was ambiguous. One could answer YES or NO depending on which question we assumed you were answering, so we refused to provide a simple YES or NO answer until you cleared up the ambiguity. You never did.

Once I realized NO ONE was apparently arguing with me about Position D - I did clarify.

But, still, for some reason people think a Christian needs to care about your preference (Which was a resounding NO apparently) for what they do or don't do with what you're arguing with them about.

There's no point going on about that though. Or rather, I refuse to go around and around about that. I'm not the only one here pointing that out. If that points not understood, that's fine. Don't be surprised though that a Christian may actually take your argument seriously as an argument on their behavior as a Christian and not as some "obvious" and "apparent" argument that proves their entire religion false or whatever other intent you meant it for.

Dishonesty has to do with intent. I don't think any of you were being dishonest by never answering the question and instead rephrasing to a different question.
 
Last edited:
....

..... I also don't think you should follow the New Testament Laws. Just in case you were wondering.
 
....

..... I also don't think you should follow the New Testament Laws. Just in case you were wondering.

Is that in reference to how I should behave? ;)

At any rate, this thread can die unless you want to carry on amongst yourselves about side things that came up. I got the links I was interested in and the multiple ways of reading those passages to ponder. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Once I realized NO ONE was apparently arguing with me about Position D - I did clarify.

But, still, for some reason people think a Christian needs to care about your preference (Which was a resounding NO apparently) for what they do or don't do with what you're arguing with them about.

There's no point going on about that though. Or rather, I refuse to go around and around about that. I'm not the only one here pointing that out. If that points not understood, that's fine. Don't be surprised though that a Christian may actually take your argument seriously as an argument on their behavior as a Christian and not as some "obvious" and "apparent" argument that proves their entire religion false or whatever other intent you meant it for.

Dishonesty has to do with intent. I don't think any of you were being dishonest by never answering the question and instead rephrasing to a different question.
And the next time a Christian tells me that the Bible is anything to go by as a moral guide, I'll just roll my eyes and not take them seriously, either.
 
To those asserting an "unambiguous" text, what you say about this?

The German translation I came acoss said:

"Wenn du nicht den alten Gesetzen folgst, mache ich deine Katze zu drei Pfund Spargel. Ich bin leistungsfähig. Ich bin launisch. Auf deinen Knien."


I figure its has about the same meaning...
 
Once I realized NO ONE was apparently arguing with me about Position D - I did clarify.
We all made our positions abundantly clear. From the first time you asked the question. Why didn't you clarify then?
There's no point going on about that though. Or rather, I refuse to go around and around about that. I'm not the only one here pointing that out. If that points not understood, that's fine. Don't be surprised though that a Christian may actually take your argument seriously as an argument on their behavior as a Christian and not as some "obvious" and "apparent" argument that proves their entire religion false or whatever other intent you meant it for.
I don't know where you get all this nonsense. Apparently you have forgotten that you brought the whole subject up when you told another poster not to worry about the atrocities in the OT since Jesus superceded the OT law.

We simply responded by pointing out the existence of a verse where Jesus reaffirmed OT law. I don't see what is so unclear about that.
Dishonesty has to do with intent. I don't think any of you were being dishonest by never answering the question and instead rephrasing to a different question.
Nobody rephrased it to a different question, we rephrased it to address the ambiguity.

We made full disclosure and clear of why we had to rephrase the question.

And you have never addressed the ambiguity or even acknowledged that we requested this clarification. You simply insisted that we provide a yes/no response to your ambiguous question.

Then you decided the people to whom you explicitly addressed the question in the first place were, for some unknown reason, ineligible to answer the question.

Now tell me, are you really satisfied that you have been quite honest with us?
 
Non-Jews are only required to follow the much simpler Noachide code. (You can look it up if interested. I hope I spelled it right. The only dietary restriction is that every animal you eat has to be dead.)

Dude thats the easiest religion ever. As of now I'm converting from atheism to Noachianism [sp?] :p
 
OK, apparently this thread isn't going to die.

We all made our positions abundantly clear.

It wasn't abundantly clear. You all stopped debating and started saying you weren't arguing Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. Apparently, to you all there was some distinction you wanted to draw between what you were arguing and what you hoped / preferred Christians to do.

Apparently you have forgotten that you brought the whole subject up when you told another poster not to worry about the atrocities in the OT since Jesus superceded the OT law.

I never used the phrase "not to worry" and I never even mentioned anything about atrocities of any sort. But if someone is interested in Christianity my recomendation, apart from discussing with a Christian friend, is I'd start with the teachings of the guy who started it - Jesus.

This is what I said:
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic

By the way - if you're interested in being a Christian you might want to first stick with Jesus teachings first since He's the founder and Teacher - his teachings, for Christians, supersede and reinterpret the Old Testament teachings. (Well - actually, He put the intention of many of the laws back in line to their original purpose). Just my two cents.


And you have never addressed the ambiguity or even acknowledged that we requested this clarification. You simply insisted that we provide a yes/no response to your ambiguous question.

How, in light of Position D, was it ambiguous? In light of any of the other positions the question might be ambiguous. Position D is either YES: Christians should follow the Old Testament Laws or NO: Christians should not follow the Old Testament Laws.

You obviously didn't have that position either. Correct?

Then you decided the people to whom you explicitly addressed the question in the first place were, for some unknown reason, ineligible to answer the question.

You're not ineligible. None of you were taking that position. It's clear now.

Now tell me, are you really satisfied that you have been quite honest with us?

Yes. Are any of you satisfied? Apparently not. Nothing I can do about that. Let it be clear: I don't think any of you, that I could tell, were being dishonest. You weren't, were you? I mean - you really didn't have position D did you? None of you really understand about how arguing about a Christians potential behavior to a Christian will be taken as exactly that - arguing about a Christians behavior? Right?

Does anyone else have anything to add about the actual OP or anything new in light of what Herz brought up? If not, then this thread can die.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom