There is no point in continuing a fruitless discussion with someone, especially when that someone turns to ad homs and other unsavory posting patterns. The ignore feature allows one to give up talking to certain people for a reason. Sometimes there is indeed a good reason to stop wasting your time on certain people.
Here is why I find the use of ignore cowardly, except in very rare cases.I put ACS on ignore too. Since I once taunted Radrook that his "ignorance" just meant that the valid points I was making would go unanswered, you might wonder why. I don't think "cowardice" explains it, but your mileage may vary.
But (s)he's still a "coward", right?Darth Rotor said:I appreciate that you may see it differently that I do.
No.Are all Christian religions that are not Catholic, considered "protestant offshoots"? Are Baptists? Amish? Evangelicals? Mormons? Pentacostals?
You say that like it's a bad thing.The disgusting story of Lot and the claim, "God said to", made by the Hebrew religious zealots at the time they killed all the Amalkites including all the babies and children in order to justify stealing the Amalkite lands. The Hebrews of course also said God told them they could keep all the young virgin girls as sex slaves, (or was that in one of the other similar stories?).
Most Kings?Aren't most Kings and Queens supposed descendants of gods and thus rule by "divine right"?
Here is why I find the use of ignore cowardly, except in very rare cases.
Sturgeon's Law. Ninety percent of everything is garbage, but the ten percent is what is of interest. I find that internet discussions/debates follow Sturgeon's Law pretty well, so I keep scanning and seeking that precious ten percent. I find articulett's input generally useless, but I read many of her posts because I sometimes find some of that nice, tasty, juicy ten percent. ID rarely has anything to say that is on point and other than nastily stated, but when he does, his posts are well worth reading, and I thoroughly enjoy them. Ignore would deprive me of that value, food for my brain. Ignore would preclude me from seeing a different, or opposing, point of view to mull over.
Aren't skeptics supposed to have open minds? If I am wrong about that, please let me know.
It is easy enough to see a poster who you usually have trouble with and with a quick scan pass on, rather than deprive one's self of an opportunity for a tasty morsel with the blanket, fingers in ears, ignore feature.
I appreciate that you may see it differently that I do.
I agree that this thread has wandered of into "what's the point?" territory.
YMMV
DR
...You say that like it's a bad thing.
Ah, but how one uses it reflects upon the user.And yet, the patron of this site also installed an ignore feature. I do not think that they would have done such a thing, if they never intended it to be used.
Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiight.BTW, I put dishonest people who ask insincere questions on ignore,
Indeed. I agree completely with your analogy in that the user defines an object; using a hammer to kill someone doesn't reflect badly on hammers, after all.Ah, but how one uses it reflects upon the user.
Sorta like a gun. Ruger makes some fine pistols, but using it to shoot my neighbor based on a disagreement over the kind of grass in his lawn (our lawns run into each other) is hardly the intended use, nor one demonstrating any quality in me.
DR
Absolutely. I don't know if you've noted, as I have, the "I have so and so" on ignore declarations of said poster, which indicates to me a form, or if you wish a level, of intellectual cowardice.But (s)he's still a "coward", right?
And none of us ever had that position. We had the positions we clearly stated.A Christian Sceptic said:You're not ineligible. None of you were taking that position. It's clear now.
JoeTheJuggler said:I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.A Christian Sceptic said:In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally.
JoeTheJuggler said:Well it's obvious that according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus said that you still have to obey every last one of the Jewish laws (what Christians call the Old Testament). Is there any other reading of verse 19?
It may be the case that 90% of EVERYTHING is garbage, but there are large subsets of EVERYTHING which aren't garbage to me. Judicious filters help me to find those subsets. Maybe my standards are lower than yours, or maybe we just don't have the same interests.Here is why I find the use of ignore cowardly, except in very rare cases.
Sturgeon's Law. Ninety percent of everything is garbage, but the ten percent is what is of interest.
I find plenty of opposing points of view to mull over, so it isn't a problem. In fact, I find myself wishing for a second-order filter, to clear threads which respond to certain posters. There is a thread nearby which seems to have devolved into a "Jerome da Gnome" thread -- every post is either a vacuous comment by him, or a reply to one. While in this thread, the replies to ACS are still of interest, I find Jerome da Gnome to be such a waste of breath that I have no interest in the thoughts expressed in response to his either.Ignore would preclude me from seeing a different, or opposing, point of view to mull over.
"An open mind" and "unlimited time to waste" are two different things.Aren't skeptics supposed to have open minds? If I am wrong about that, please let me know.
I agree. Out of interest, which way would you adjust the percentage?I have a hard time seeing ACS as a 99% garbage poster.
Of course, it might just be that someone is tired of feeling depressed because 90% of what they read seem more to come from barely sentient Chatbots that have no concept of logic, morality, or ethics more than coming from human beings. Personally, the only way I could possibly survive the Politics forum is by ignoring posts, and even then, when a troll posts that we should bomb Mecca or Medina to "get back at" the Muslims, it's very hard for me to actually ignore that. Maybe my lack of willpower at seeing entirely immoral calls to action is a form of cowardice, and maybe you're right in that I'm a coward, but I'd much rather be a coward that doesn't feed the trolls than an internet a-hole that does.Absolutely. I don't know if you've noted, as I have, the "I have so and so" on ignore declarations of said poster, which indicates to me a form, or if you wish a level, of intellectual cowardice.
Here's the attitude behind that fingers in ears approach.
"I don't have the courage to read what ____________ posts. I am unwilling to risk seeing what I don't care for, and am unwilling to admit that something said poster has to say may be of value." It's an internet version of "one drop of blood taints all" bigotry that you may be familiar with.
Another "Law of the Internet" with dubious figures and claims.See again my Sturgeon's Law point above.
Actually, the BAUT forum, and similar forums, have for a long time been able to weed out the far more negatives in the forum. Of course, "Free Speech" extremists would rather they be forced to allow anyone that comes in shouting out at anyone for anything and saying anything they want, but pardon me if I'm not interested in extremism.I also hold that to participate on an internet discussion forum, one needs a thick skin. It comes with the territory.
And there are some people that I do not find it worth reading, and that what I do learn I already knew.For example, SG and I disagree on quite a bit, but I read what she writes because I find it worth reading, I sometimes learn something, and only reading my own PoV, or stuff I agree with, is a lousy mental diet.
Believe me, that's a relief. I stayed up all night hoping you'd forgive me.Again, YMMV, and now that I have read your second post, I not only forgive you,![]()
Well, thank you.I respect not only how you put that, but how you approach it.
I wasn't arguing that ACS is ban-worthy. I was more of arguing against the idea that ignoring other users is necessarily cowardice. Essentially, what you are arguing now isn't the process, but degree; or rather, what our personal "ignore threshold" might be.I have a hard time seeing ACS as a 99% garbage poster. You may not like his arguments or positions, and this thread certainly had its holes early on, but he's not in the league of DJJ and kurious_kathy, who are on the edge of being ignore worthy. (DJJ was banned, IIRC.)![]()
No you aren't. C'mon, we payed for a REAL strip tease.While I am at it, the title to this thread has been driving me nuts since I stumbled across it:
The atheists favorite bible verses
It is either atheists' or atheist's, arrrrrrrrrrggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh! (Rends garment.)
There, all better.
Maybe that would be the attitude behind it if you invoked the feature, but you don't speak for me.Here's the attitude behind that fingers in ears approach.
"I don't have the courage to read what ____________ posts. I am unwilling to risk seeing what I don't care for, and am unwilling to admit that something said poster has to say may be of value."
I have a fairly thick skin, and ACS hasn't insulted me. You've insulted me by calling me a coward, and yet, you're not on ignore. You may be mistaken, but I've yet to see evidence that you're disingenuous. In my opinion, ACS was, and that's why I decided his posts were a waste of time.I also hold that to participate on an internet discussion forum, one needs a thick skin. It comes with the territory.
I agree. Out of interest, which way would you adjust the percentage?