JoeTheJuggler
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2006
- Messages
- 27,766
OK, ACS, let's try this one now:
I notice you're quoting (with bolding that you added) from my first post on this thread:
is not equivalent to the statement,
"I think Christians are supposed to obey all the O.T. Laws."
I said this in reply to your O.P. which sounded very much like you were trying to make a strawman argument saying that since (as you thought) no Christians adhered to the obvious meaning of this Matthew passage, it didn't make sense for atheists to use the passage the way they do, which is follows:
When someone with beliefs like yours uses cherry-picked Bible passages to derive a moral belief or judgment, and an atheist points out that there are other passages from the Bible that condone things that even you would consider morally reprehensible, and then you counter by saying that those passages are in the O.T. which is now null and void because of Jesus, an atheist will point to this passage in Matthew to show that you're being inconsistent.
An atheist is not pointing to this passage to encourage or persuade you to obey the O.T. Laws.
Again, you have to understand that atheists have very different beliefs than you do. Just as someone who is not a vegetarian has different beliefs than a vegetarian. I'm a vegetarian. If someone who is not a vegetarian tells me there's meat in this dish, he is not telling me that I'm not supposed to eat that dish.
I notice you're quoting (with bolding that you added) from my first post on this thread:
The statements, "Most Christians don't adhere to [the obvious meaning of the Matthew passage]. I think they're being inconsistent."me said:I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.
<snip>
I concede that most Christians don't adhere to this. I think they're being inconsistent.
is not equivalent to the statement,
"I think Christians are supposed to obey all the O.T. Laws."
I said this in reply to your O.P. which sounded very much like you were trying to make a strawman argument saying that since (as you thought) no Christians adhered to the obvious meaning of this Matthew passage, it didn't make sense for atheists to use the passage the way they do, which is follows:
When someone with beliefs like yours uses cherry-picked Bible passages to derive a moral belief or judgment, and an atheist points out that there are other passages from the Bible that condone things that even you would consider morally reprehensible, and then you counter by saying that those passages are in the O.T. which is now null and void because of Jesus, an atheist will point to this passage in Matthew to show that you're being inconsistent.
An atheist is not pointing to this passage to encourage or persuade you to obey the O.T. Laws.
Again, you have to understand that atheists have very different beliefs than you do. Just as someone who is not a vegetarian has different beliefs than a vegetarian. I'm a vegetarian. If someone who is not a vegetarian tells me there's meat in this dish, he is not telling me that I'm not supposed to eat that dish.