The atheists favorite bible verses

OK, ACS, let's try this one now:

I notice you're quoting (with bolding that you added) from my first post on this thread:
me said:
I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.
<snip>

I concede that most Christians don't adhere to this. I think they're being inconsistent.
The statements, "Most Christians don't adhere to [the obvious meaning of the Matthew passage]. I think they're being inconsistent."

is not equivalent to the statement,

"I think Christians are supposed to obey all the O.T. Laws."

I said this in reply to your O.P. which sounded very much like you were trying to make a strawman argument saying that since (as you thought) no Christians adhered to the obvious meaning of this Matthew passage, it didn't make sense for atheists to use the passage the way they do, which is follows:

When someone with beliefs like yours uses cherry-picked Bible passages to derive a moral belief or judgment, and an atheist points out that there are other passages from the Bible that condone things that even you would consider morally reprehensible, and then you counter by saying that those passages are in the O.T. which is now null and void because of Jesus, an atheist will point to this passage in Matthew to show that you're being inconsistent.

An atheist is not pointing to this passage to encourage or persuade you to obey the O.T. Laws.

Again, you have to understand that atheists have very different beliefs than you do. Just as someone who is not a vegetarian has different beliefs than a vegetarian. I'm a vegetarian. If someone who is not a vegetarian tells me there's meat in this dish, he is not telling me that I'm not supposed to eat that dish.
 
Some self-proclaimed supposed Christian pastors of certain denominations insist that tithing is still in effect in order to fleece the flock of its hard-earned money. Then they turn around and insist that the flock is not under Law. Weird! It appears that sometimes the temptation of monetary gain is just too enticing for some.
 
OK, ACS, let's try this one now:

I notice you're quoting (with bolding that you added) from my first post on this thread:

The statements, "Most Christians don't adhere to [the obvious meaning of the Matthew passage]. I think they're being inconsistent."

is not equivalent to the statement,

"I think Christians are supposed to obey all the O.T. Laws."
No, but your response

I think that's exactly the point that critics of Christianity (myself included) make when we cite this passage.

to

In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally.

is.
 
Last edited:
Of course.

But instead of following you on your route to irrelevant exceptions and semantics, let me come back to your bold assertions related to Matt 5, and refute them all.

First of all, let us agree upon what exactly are your claims. Let me propose this wording:

In Matt 5,17-20 JC literally, clearly and unequivocally demands all Christians to obey all OT laws in the traditional way.

Please correct me, if I'm wrong and clearly state your claims.

Next, let's agree to use the latest New American Standard Bible as our source (reasons see posts above):

http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew%205;&version=49;

Hence, the passages in discussion are as follows:
17"Do not think that I came to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I did not come to abolish but to fulfill.

18"For truly I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest letter or stroke shall pass from the Law until all is accomplished.

19"Whoever then annuls one of the least of these commandments, and teaches others to do the same, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever keeps and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.

20"For I say to you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the scribes and Pharisees, you will not enter the kingdom of heaven.
Awaiting an exciting discussion.
I am not sure what your point is here. You will have to admit that the passage quoted appears to say that nothing will pass from the Law until "all is accomplished". I would take that to be the establishment of the new Kingdom prophesied in Isaiah. Is there any other way you could take this?

But even if it only preserves the spirit of the law, the spirit of immoral laws is no better than the actuality of immoral laws.

And even if it abolished the old law it would not make it better. As I pointed out at the beginning if God ever commanded these laws and the OT genocides in the first place then that would totally destroy the moral basis for any religion based on these books.

If stoning aduleresses was a bad idea in first century Judah, why did God command it in the first place and place heavy penalties on disobeying these commands?
 
When someone with beliefs like yours uses cherry-picked Bible passages to derive a moral belief or judgment, and an atheist points out that there are other passages from the Bible that condone things that even you would consider morally reprehensible, and then you counter by saying that those passages are in the O.T. which is now null and void because of Jesus, an atheist will point to this passage in Matthew to show that you're being inconsistent.
No, only a complete idiot will point to Matthew in order to disprove the insane assertion about "the O.T. which is now null and void".

On the other hand, nobody would ever assert this strawmonster of yours.

Oh - and please explain what you mean by "even you" above (I bolded it for you and everybody else to see it clearly).

Thank you well

H.
 
Last edited:
If stoning aduleresses was a bad idea in first century Judah, why did God command it in the first place and place heavy penalties on disobeying these commands?
God didn't command a thing. He does not exist.
 
...
If stoning aduleresses was a bad idea in first century Judah, why did God command it in the first place and place heavy penalties on disobeying these commands?
.
If you insert "crazy old man who hates everyone around him" for "God", you'll be closer to reality.
 
No, only a complete idiot will point to Matthew in order to disprove the insane assertion about "the O.T. which is now null and void".
Why is that? The passage does in fact refute the argument that the O.T. somehow doesn't count.

On the other hand, nobody would ever assert this strawmonster of yours.
You sure you want to assert that no one has made the argument that the O.T. doesn't count? (Or are you talking about something else?)


Oh - and please explain what you mean by "even you" above (I bolded it for you and everybody else to see it clearly).
I mean that there are bits of the Bible that even someone who believes the Bible is an inerrant moral guide would agree are morally abhorrent. (The "you" was ACS.)
 
That's the eternal question, isn't it? How are those who take the bible literally, and those who don't, ever to bridge the gap?

I don't have any beliefs in gods but I see things of great beauty in all kinds of scripture, whether it be the bible or the Upanishads, or various Buddhist writings. It seems to me that the vast majority of religious folk (I don't include $cientology here) are not fundamentalists, nor do the vast majority of them take scripture literally. Indeed, I'm not surprised to learn that many religious folk haven't given their scriptures much thought since Sunday School.


M.

What about Sylvia Browne's Novus Spritus religion-- Do you see beauty there? If someone believes something is divinely inspired, shouldn't they endeavor to take it as literally as the divinity inspired?
 
Last edited:
Why is that? The passage does in fact refute the argument that the O.T. somehow doesn't count.


You sure you want to assert that no one has made the argument that the O.T. doesn't count? (Or are you talking about something else?)



I mean that there are bits of the Bible that even someone who believes the Bible is an inerrant moral guide would agree are morally abhorrent. (The "you" was ACS.)

I have Herzblut on ignore--is anyone agreeing with him? Or is he just asserting his crap as usual with the assumption that someone other than him agrees with him? I am following you fine Joe. I've never followed Herzblut--and I don't know anyone he has been able to engage in an actual conversation with for what it's worth. ("Strawmonster"... tee-hee... I think that describes him.)
 
Last edited:
Why is that? The passage does in fact refute the argument that the O.T. somehow doesn't count.
The fact that the OT is a major part of the bible refutes it.

You sure you want to assert that no one has made the argument that the O.T. doesn't count? (Or are you talking about something else?)
You sure you restrict the scope of your Matthew argument to refute those who say that the OT doesn't count?

I mean that there are bits of the Bible that even someone who believes the Bible is an inerrant moral guide would agree are morally abhorrent. (The "you" was ACS.)
This is not equivalent to "even you".
 
Last edited:
The statements, "Most Christians don't adhere to [the obvious meaning of the Matthew passage]. I think they're being inconsistent."

is not equivalent to the statement,

"I think Christians are supposed to obey all the O.T. Laws."
Please address two items I mentioned previously:

1. The strong impression that you have lied throughout almost the entire thread, and still lie, as indicated in #664.

2. You're asserting that your privative understanding of Matt 5 has identified the "obvious meaning of the Matthew passage". While you have not provided any explanation whatsoever to support your bizzare interpretation, you have permanently ignored the growing mount of counter-evidence you are facing. Without strong justification, I'm afraid, your claim is to be regarded as invalid, and your reasoning as fallacious.
 
Last edited:
I just came in here to point out that Herzblut said here:

Herzblut said:
No, only a complete idiot will point to Matthew in order to disprove the insane assertion about "the O.T. which is now null and void".

On the other hand, nobody would ever assert this strawmonster of yours.

Oh - and please explain what you mean by "even you" above (I bolded it for you and everybody else to see it clearly).

Thank you well

H.

This was posted in Post #666.

Therefore, Herzblut is the antichrist.

Sie können weitermachen. Nothing to see here.

(This interruption has been brought to you by: Stephen Colbert and Dorritos Campaign '08. Feel the crunch of a new America.)
 
Last edited:
Such bravery, to stick your fingers in your ears when an opposing or uncomfortable viewpoint crosses your vision. If skeptics choose to be self blinding cowards, the skeptical movement becomes yet another brass bell clanging -- a load of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Is that what you intend? It is not what the patron of this site intends. Check out the purpose and mission of the JREF.

DR
There is no point in continuing a fruitless discussion with someone, especially when that someone turns to ad homs and other unsavory posting patterns. The ignore feature allows one to give up talking to certain people for a reason. Sometimes there is indeed a good reason to stop wasting your time on certain people.
 
Such bravery, to stick your fingers in your ears when an opposing or uncomfortable viewpoint crosses your vision. If skeptics choose to be self blinding cowards, the skeptical movement becomes yet another brass bell clanging -- a load of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Is that what you intend? It is not what the patron of this site intends. Check out the purpose and mission of the JREF.

DR
And yet, the patron of this site also installed an ignore feature. I do not think that they would have done such a thing, if they never intended it to be used.
 
Crazy? I doubt it. The rest is just about right.
As Thomas Paine said:

Age of Reason said:
THUS much for the Bible; I now go on to the book called the New Testament. The new Testament! that is, the 'new' Will, as if there could be two wills of the Creator.

At the very least, you could accuse God of having MPD.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom