Ichneumonwasp
Unregistered
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2006
- Messages
- 6,240
There seems to be a misunderstanding. Anybody shall interpret any text however he/she wants to, and communicate this. I am seeking a definition of "The meaning of a biblical passage", not "My interpretation of ..".
To equal one with the other is fallecious.
It may be worse than misunderstanding then. How does meaning differ from interpretation? The very meaning of interpretation is meaning. Could you distinguish these in a way that makes sense to me?
My perspective: interpretation creates meaning and meaning is an emotive response to some rational enterprise. I don't see how they are separable. You can speak of the meaning of the text for the believer as being different from the meaning of the text for a non-believer, but that is what is under discussion here. I do not agree that the text means something only for the believer. It has theological purpose only for the believer, but that is a different proposition altogether.
Furthermore, the text discussed describes moral codes. It's about "What shall I do?" for believers and "What you shall do" for others. Looking at this thread, the different mindset leads to problems, which become insurmountable if one group doesn't even understand the other's mindset. I believe those problems can be overcome, but not in the way demonstrated here.
With this I fully agree and tried to explain to ACS. He approaches the text with entirely different assumptions than his interlocutors, which seems to me one of the bigger issues and why there is no meeting of minds. But the same can be said of creationists and others when discussing evolution.