The atheists favorite bible verses

God is mentioned in Ecclesiastes. The only book where God is not mentioned is Esther...except in the Catholic version. The Catholic version has some material not found in Jewish or Protestant versions, and in the additional material, God gets mentioned.

Margin comments do carry that much weight because, as others have pointed out, in Catholicism, it is taught that only the Church has authority to really interpret the Bible. To the extent that margin comments represent Church teaching about the text, they are just as important as the text itself. Perhaps more accurately, the text is not to be fully understood without reference to the Church teaching about the text. If something in the text doesn't appear right to a Catholic, he is encouraged to find out what the Church teaching is, so that he can get the "correct" interpretation.
Sorry, my bad on Ecclesiastes.
Interesting on the Catholic view of commentary, seems similar to the Islamic idea of aHadith. One of those moments where you realize how different beliefs can be.

The other passage I'm thinking of in the NT is from Romans 3:12-31
Like (27) "...On what principle? On that of observing the law? No, but on that of faith. For we maintain that a man is justified by faith apart from observing the law..." etc.

Whether or not to circumcise was a big issue in the early church. The argument seems to clearly be that Christians are not under the law, so I can certainly understand some curiosity as to why some atheists don't see this the same way.

Matt 5 is one of those things I have a kind of fuzzy view of what Christians really believe. The version of Mormonism I was raised in is more like Quakerism in that you are encouraged to find your own way through scripture with God's help. So generally, 'Heaven' is not a single thing, but captured in the idea of 'many mansions'. So when Matt 5 says 'least in the kingdom of heaven', that's still a saved person, just not someone pursuing the best you can be. (Atheist 'grain of salt' caution applies here, remember I thought God was not mentioned in Ecclesiastes).

My understanding of Pauline doctrine though, is that faith in Christ counts as 'righteousness'. The beauty of Paul is that the idea he presents is not very complicated. Christianity would simply not be around today if the idea of obedience to the OT law remained.

More than a few atheists come this way by some non mainstream groups, so it would not surprise me that there was some variation in understanding Matt 5:19.
 
Last edited:
Eh .. Christians who think Jesus was not Christ? Trinity no more? Sounds like an interesting concept, you've got more about it?
ETA: You misread me. I said Christians who don't believe that Jesus was divine.

You might want to google "Christology".
Meanwhile,
From Wikipedia on "Christ":
wiki said:
.

Christ is the English term for the Greek Χριστός (khristos) meaning "the anointed".[1] In the (Greek) Septuagint version of the Old Testament, khristos was used to translate the Hebrew מָשִׁיחַ (Mašíaḥ,) (messiah), meaning "[one who is] anointed." [2] In contrast to Christianity, the Jewish tradition understands The Messiah to be a human being – without any overtone of deity or divinity.[3]

Followers of Jesus became known as Christians because they believed that Jesus is the Messiah, or Christ. The majority of Jews reject this claim and are still waiting for the Messiah to come (see Jewish Messiah).

The area of Christian theology focusing on the nature of Jesus as the Christ, particularly with how the divine and human are related in his person, is known as Christology.

At any rate, I suspect because the word "Jesusist" is awkward and "Jesuit" is taken, the word "Christian" is the only one left for a follower of Jesus' teachings.

Unitarians are one example of Christians who do not believe that Jesus was divine.
 
Last edited:
Atheists don't usually have a favorite bible verse, but lots of them know the verses that clued them into the fact that the book most certainly was not a source for morality or divine truths. The Matthew passage is one. It makes it look like all Christians are major cherry pickers--and creating their gods and their religions along with their morality as suits them.

Thanks to many of the links in this post it's apparent some Christians agree with your interpretation and try to do it. Maybe you should drop the "all".
 
Spanish:
19Cualquiera, pues, que anule uno solo de estos mandamientos, aun de los más pequeños, y así lo enseñe a otros, será llamado muy pequeño en el reino de los cielos; pero cualquiera que los guarde y los enseñe, éste será llamado grande en el reino de los cielos.

The verbs are

anular
= to annul sth. and
guardar
= to guard, keep, maintain.

Hence, this reads:

Therefore, whoever annuls one of the least of these commandments... But whoever guards and teaches these commandments...

To those asserting an "unambiguous" text, what you say about this? What does the text say?

I'm not saying it's "unambiguous", but....

Jesus could be talking about teachers and setting himself apart from those that do abolish/break/annul the old law. He says that he has not come to abolish the law and talks about those that would.

So it comes down to the meaning of not abolishing the law.

Good finds, btw.


ETA: New American Standard translation uses "annuls":
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=matthew 5;&version=49;
 
Last edited:
I was not then, and am not now, able to see in what sense such people are Christians<snip>
The same way a Marxist does not worship Marx as a deity, or a Buddhist doesn't necessarily worship the Buddha as a god. (See all Confucianist, Darwinist, Lamarckist, etc.) You can certainly revere the teachings of Jesus and consider him to be "annointed" ("chrism" was a kind of oil) without considering him to be divine.


Yes, I understand that is your view. It is also mine. And in light of what I learned from Beth, you are clearly right about the approach some christians would take as well. I just don't think that is a very mainstream christian view.
I guess it goes to your definition of "mainstream Christian". I think the single biggest flavor (by population) of Christianity (if you don't lump all "Protestants" into one) is Catholicism--or more accurately the Roman Catholic Church (no need to lump the orthodox Catholic churches). That's my background, and when I was young, my whole world was populated with nothing but Catholics.

By the way, I spoke to my Jesuit friend, and he confirmed what I speculated on earlier (that Darat also seconded). Catholics certainly do not subscribe to the idea of Biblical inerrancy; the teaching authority of the church is encourage to take into account history, culture, language, etc. He said my take on the Matthew question (that it reflected the controversy in the early church about whether Jesus' message was for all nations or just for Jews--and that Catholics considered the matter settled [that is, that it is for all nations] and so could basically ignore the sentence that said you should obey every least O.T. commandment).

By the way, when I mentioned my thing about not necessarily believing that the words attributed to Jesus are in fact Jesus' actual words, he said, "Of course they're not. If for no other reason but that Jesus spoke Aramaic and the Gospel of Matthew was first written in Greek."

But I am learning all the time, so I could easily be wrong. Suffice to say that many Christians who do think they should do what the bible tells them and for them it is very important to find out what that is.
I agree with that. I would guess that that "many" is still a overly-represented minority of all Christians. (I suspect too that many of those who make that profession also don't know a lot about the Bible. Given more information, they might modify their position. Just a suspicion I have, I admit.) Trouble is ACS very clearly said "all Christians" and he said that my saying the passage means something is equivalent to my saying that you have to obey it.

Clearly he was wrong.

Especially since if there was any least doubt, I said over 50 times that I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws--yet he persisted in saying that I was trying to convince him that he is supposed to obey them.

I am not sure I understand this bit. The distinction I tried to make was between literalism and fundamentalism.
It's a minor point.
I was referring to your statement:
Mainstream Christians do, to a greater or lesser extent, accept that not everything in the bible is to be taken literally, for all the reasons already mentioned: error by the writer; translation error; interpretation error etc etc etc.
You were confusing the term "literal" with the term "inerrant". Literal means you don't read in metaphorical or other figurative meaning. A literalist, for example, believes there really was a Noachian flood that covered the entire earth. Most Christians who are not literalists can take the story figuratively. Those who don't take the story literally don't need to think there was an error involved.

Inerrant means that there are no errors or mistakes. What you mention, "error by writer; translation error; interpretation error etc", really doesn't have anything to do with whether or not a passage should be taken literally or figuratively.
 
Last edited:
@JoeTheJuggler. It is a minor point and I do not want to do it to death. But I do not think I conflated them in the way you think. Your point is covered by "interpretation error" :)
 
Still wrong! :D
Still right :)
Don't know. Don't care. :)
So you don't know or care what Jesus fulfilled, you just know that he fulfilled it
But Jesus made the statement that he fulfilled the law. :D
No he didn't. If a plumber says "I have come to fix the leak" he does not mean "I have fixed the leak"
This has been addressed several times. Please feel free to review up above, I'll wait here.:cool:
It has not been addressed. As far as I recall you rather vaguely wondered to yourself what the "Kingdom of God" might mean.
"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them."

Either/or. But thanks for playing! :D
Just where, exactly, do you imagine you have shown an either/or statement?
 
Last edited:
Just so long as you carefully subedit him.

yeppers everyone has their own little subedited Jesus they worship... their personal savior and invisible friend...

their gods trump everyone... and their gods are created in their minds through the careful cherry picking through their texts and the careful indoctrination of their gurus.

There is no god but allah (or so I've heard)-- and Islam is a religion of peace. Scientologists are the experts on the mind

Everything can mean anything-- you just wrap the big "religion" bow on it and declare it off limits for discussion-- do what you will and tell everyone that god trumps them. Anything and everything you do, claim that you do it cause god says so-- you win every time and humanity has to suck up more delusional behavior of the self important and whatever invisible magic man they each invent in their separate little heads and whatever magical book and magical interpretation they spin their magical man out of.

(And I think RR must be a kid. He reasons and speaks like one, fwiw.)
 
Last edited:
I think I understand now -

You all don't think Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws, but you tell Christians they are supposed to even though you think they aren't supposed to. And when you tell them they are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws you don't really mean it. You don't really think they are supposed to be following the Old Testament Laws. Correct?
I love this point in threads. Where someone says "I think I understand now" and then proceeds to present half-baked nonsensical strawman position.

Deal with what we actually say not with what you pretend we say.
OK - how about this question then:

Are Christians not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
Oh goody - another ambiguously worded question with a YES or NO answer.

Again, ACS, "supposed to ..." according to whom?
 
Has he answered his own question yet with a yes or no? Have we heard about what the answer is according to ACS? I have him on ignore, and no one bothered to quote him if he did. I suspect he's just repeating the same old stuff he always does trying to prove that atheists are trying to get him to live by the rules of the book he calls divine...
 
And Finally:
D) IF you are arguing that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and these Matthew verses are you're proof - THEN we can continue on.

If you're position is D - that is, if you are saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and the Matthew verses are proof then please clarify - YES, my position is D.
So unless you are willing to answer ACS's deliberately ambiguous question with a YES or NO then start your own thread.

Being a Christian he is apparently under no obligation to clarify the ambiguity.

ACS, a word of advice. Stop buying your traps at Acme.
 
Has he answered his own question yet with a yes or no? Have we heard about what the answer is according to ACS?
No, and he has not yet given his opinion of the morality of those laws or of the genocides that the OT claims were ordered by God.
 
Seriously?
I would expect most Christians to disagree with me and then tell me why they disagree with me.

On the interpretation you gave, this thread reached the point where you chuckled when asked if it bothers you that you will be called least in the Kingdom of Heaven. I can't remember who you called funny, but they deserve some credit.

No Firegarden,

How do you expect Christians to take it. Because you and others seem to feel a bit shocked that Christians would actually take your argument that Matthew 5 means Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws as being an argument about what they should do.
 
ETA: You misread me. I said Christians who don't believe that Jesus was divine.
Christianity says the Messiah/Christ is God's son. Hence, there's no way Jesus could be Christ but not devine, for Christians. But maybe you like to engage yourself in semantic discussions with Christians - not with me - about how the son of God might be called not devine.
 
I love this point in threads. Where someone says "I think I understand now" and then proceeds to present half-baked nonsensical strawman position.

Deal with what we actually say not with what you pretend we say.

Oh goody - another ambiguously worded question with a YES or NO answer.

Again, ACS, "supposed to ..." according to whom?

Hi Robin,

Go here to this post of mine.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3710750#post3710750

Now post to me which position you are arguing. Then maybe we can continue.
 
So unless you are willing to answer ACS's deliberately ambiguous question with a YES or NO then start your own thread.

Being a Christian he is apparently under no obligation to clarify the ambiguity.

ACS, a word of advice. Stop buying your traps at Acme.

Oops. Didn't see this. If you're not arguing position D then we can't carry on a coherent argument. We'll be defending or supporting 2 seperate arguments.
 
I don't know much German, but:

Aufheben can be translated as to sublate, to abolish, to transcend or to supersede or even “to pick up,” “to raise,” “to keep,” “to preserve,” “to end” or “to annul.” Literally and originally, aufheben meant “to pocket,” as when someone pockets your payment but continues to work for you.

In short, there is no good English equivalent. Perhaps, "annul" is the best choice here.

The expression "break a commandment" is parallel to "break a rule" in English, and the use of "break" does not follow from any hard and fast logical connection to "breaking a stick", for example, or "breaking a habit". These are metaphorical connections, and translators must struggle with this sort of thing all the time. It is called idiomatic usage, and is specific to each language.

It would be surprising in fact if the German equivalent for "break" as in "break a leg" were used also for breaking a "commandment". Sorry if I missed Herzblut's point. But it sounded like it was astonishing somehow that the translation was not word for word in German and in Spanish using their equivalents for "break", with the meaning of "breaking in half".
 
Last edited:
I think the first bible copies that we have were written in ancient Hebrew and Greek-- so we've had eons of evolving languages, hearsay, and interpretation. I think it's pretty darn clear that you can find support for whatever behavior you have and say it comes from the bible and therefore you get your morals from god... I'm sure you can do with the same with Quo'ran.
 
Last edited:
I think the first bible copies that we have were written in Aramaic and Greek-- so we've had eons of evolving languages, hearsay, and interpretation. I think it's pretty darn clear that you can find support for whatever behavior you have and say it comes from the bible and therefore you get your morals from god... I'm sure you can do with the same with Quo'ran.
.

Heck, you could probably do it with Star Wars
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom