Kopji
Philosopher
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2003
- Messages
- 8,004
Sorry, my bad on Ecclesiastes.God is mentioned in Ecclesiastes. The only book where God is not mentioned is Esther...except in the Catholic version. The Catholic version has some material not found in Jewish or Protestant versions, and in the additional material, God gets mentioned.
Margin comments do carry that much weight because, as others have pointed out, in Catholicism, it is taught that only the Church has authority to really interpret the Bible. To the extent that margin comments represent Church teaching about the text, they are just as important as the text itself. Perhaps more accurately, the text is not to be fully understood without reference to the Church teaching about the text. If something in the text doesn't appear right to a Catholic, he is encouraged to find out what the Church teaching is, so that he can get the "correct" interpretation.
Interesting on the Catholic view of commentary, seems similar to the Islamic idea of aHadith. One of those moments where you realize how different beliefs can be.
The other passage I'm thinking of in the NT is from Romans 3:12-31
Like (27) "...On what principle? On that of observing the law? No, but on that of faith. For we maintain that a man is justified by faith apart from observing the law..." etc.
Whether or not to circumcise was a big issue in the early church. The argument seems to clearly be that Christians are not under the law, so I can certainly understand some curiosity as to why some atheists don't see this the same way.
Matt 5 is one of those things I have a kind of fuzzy view of what Christians really believe. The version of Mormonism I was raised in is more like Quakerism in that you are encouraged to find your own way through scripture with God's help. So generally, 'Heaven' is not a single thing, but captured in the idea of 'many mansions'. So when Matt 5 says 'least in the kingdom of heaven', that's still a saved person, just not someone pursuing the best you can be. (Atheist 'grain of salt' caution applies here, remember I thought God was not mentioned in Ecclesiastes).
My understanding of Pauline doctrine though, is that faith in Christ counts as 'righteousness'. The beauty of Paul is that the idea he presents is not very complicated. Christianity would simply not be around today if the idea of obedience to the OT law remained.
More than a few atheists come this way by some non mainstream groups, so it would not surprise me that there was some variation in understanding Matt 5:19.
Last edited: