The atheists favorite bible verses

ACS was called blind, stupid, and dishonest because he asked a disingenuous yes or no question which he refused to answer with a yes or no himself and refused to admit that anyone else had answered it because they would not answer it given his criteria. He was repeatedly shown why his question was bad and why atheists point out that phrase (it's not that it's an atheists' favorite... it's just one of the things that points out how "cherry picking" Christians like all believers of all woo believe they have divine "secrets" but they can't even coherently state want the hell the believe or why or what their source is.) They are endlessly claiming not to be moral relativists, but such passages illustrate that they have no choice but to be moral relativists.

He wants to believe that atheists point out that passage to get him to act upon what it says... but it's only to point out the incoherency of the Christian claim that the book is a guide to morality of some divine origin. Which parts? Which interpretation? According to whom? How do you know? Why is an omniscient omnipotent entity so unclear and so seemingly cruel? Why do you think this book is true? What do you think is literally true and why? Who wrote the words and what do they mean and how do you know and how can THAT be any kind of objective moral guide? Why should we take your interpretation of your magic book any more or less seriously than we take the Muslims interpretation of their magic book?
 
Last edited:
They differ in terms of inclusiveness. Your formulation (similar to ACS's, which only makes sense, since you were explicating his view) includes only the view of the church and/or believer. The other view includes everyone within a particular language community, allowing other viewpoints to interpret the text. There is a danger allowing only believers to interpret a particular text because hidden assumptions will remain hidden.
There seems to be a misunderstanding. Anybody shall interpret any text however he/she wants to, and communicate this. I am seeking a definition of "The meaning of a biblical passage", not "My interpretation of ..".

To equal one with the other is fallecious.

Furthermore, the text discussed describes moral codes. It's about "What shall I do?" for believers and "What you shall do" for others. Looking at this thread, the different mindset leads to problems, which become insurmountable if one group doesn't even understand the other's mindset. I believe those problems can be overcome, but not in the way demonstrated here.
 
Eh .. Christians who think Jesus was not Christ? Trinity no more? Sounds like an interesting concept, you've got more about it?

There are a number of people I have encountered who have no supernatural beliefs about Jesus qua Christ, but who still agree with some of the ideas presumably presented by this character.

A professor of mine once accused me (me!) as being very Christian. After I got done being surprised (that bastard!), I tried to explain how my idea of humanity was radically different -all while he was chuckling at me. Grrr! ;)

A band once wrote an interesting line:
"I might agree with Jesus, but I got no religious beliefs."
What's interesting about it is that we understand almost precisely what it means on first or second blush.

Still, it seems to me that referring to non-believers as "Christian" is an attempt to annex what we like about each other into Christian terms.
 
From John I believe,
From Jesus,
25"All this I have spoken while still with you. 26But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you all things and will remind you of everything I have said to you. 27Peace I leave with you; my peace I give you. I do not give to you as the world gives. Do not let your hearts be troubled and do not be afraid.

What I quoted before,
Luke 1
Introduction
1Many have undertaken to draw up an account of the things that have been fulfilled[a] among us, 2just as they were handed down to us by those who from the first were eyewitnesses and servants of the word. 3Therefore, since I myself have carefully investigated everything from the beginning, it seemed good also to me to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus, 4so that you may know the certainty of the things you have been taught.
In acts I believe 5000 are made deciples by the laying of hands of the apostils and are sent out to witness and also heal. There's the direct contact to the direct witnesses by the author.
Er.....that proves JoeTheJuggler's statement, Edge. Was that what you intended?
So what Joe and Fiona are saying is that the reporters and eyewitnesses aren’t as good as today’s reporters?
I disagree, that’s my stand, so no.
You can look at them as news channels, if the story line is the same but from different perspectives then you can get the truth, or as much as possible.


Acts 1

Jesus Taken Up Into Heaven
1In my former book, Theophilus, I wrote about all that Jesus began to do and to teach 2until the day he was taken up to heaven, after giving instructions through the Holy Spirit to the apostles he had chosen. 3After his suffering, he showed himself to these men and gave many convincing proofs that he was alive. He appeared to them over a period of forty days and spoke about the kingdom of God. 4On one occasion, while he was eating with them, he gave them this command: "Do not leave Jerusalem, but wait for the gift my Father promised, which you have heard me speak about. 5For John baptized with[a] water, but in a few days you will be baptized with the Holy Spirit."

John 21


24This is the disciple who testifies to these things and who wrote them down. We know that his testimony is true.
Same reporter.

Then Acts 10

39 We are witnesses of everything he did in the country of the Jews and in Jerusalem.

You would think with all the witnesses that the report would be accurate?
I’m being sarcastic here……


But if you read Acts you see that they had all believed the O.T. at one time, till they accepted Christ then received the power from the spirit to do what Christ had told them they would be able to do, as he himself prophesized, “the same as he did, healing and miracles”, and then not to remember all of that accurately for it to be recorded?


Really, the million dollar question had been answered and why….One of the biggest News events of the times and it's all a lie?

I find that hard to believe.
 
There are a number of people I have encountered who have no supernatural beliefs about Jesus qua Christ, but who still agree with some of the ideas presumably presented by this character.

A professor of mine once accused me (me!) as being very Christian. After I got done being surprised (that bastard!), I tried to explain how my idea of humanity was radically different -all while he was chuckling at me. Grrr! ;)

A band once wrote an interesting line:
"I might agree with Jesus, but I got no religious beliefs."
What's interesting about it is that we understand almost precisely what it means on first or second blush.

Still, it seems to me that referring to non-believers as "Christian" is an attempt to annex what we like about each other into Christian terms.

Yep. Just like all things "good" are seen as coming from god or part of god or "god" or "god's gift" or something to thank god for (lest he take the goodies away, I guess.)-- while all bad is a test from god or due to "not enough faith" or secularists or darwinists or failure to obey god etc.

It's a mental virus that hijacks thinking.
 
ACS, I take it you just cherry pick interpretations rather than cherry picking verses?

By twisting the interpretation of the Bible into what you want it to say rather than reading what it actually does say, you are being the very hypocrite you are warning against.

Well - if you're going to want to go down that road I'm going to need your exact definition of "cherry picking" and your exact position and argument spelled out in advance so we don't need a repeat of this thread. If you're willing to do that I'll discuss that with you if I think I can or if I even have a position on it - it all depends on your definitions of it all. Also - please let me know what you expect me to do if I accept your argument - that is, what is your intent?
 
Last edited:
ACS was called blind, stupid, and dishonest because he asked a disingenuous yes or no question which he refused to answer with a yes or no himself and refused to admit that anyone else had answered it because they would not answer it given his criteria.

Is that really the only reason I was called blind, stupid and dishonest. (I also believed I was called dangerous.) If the YES and NO question was the only reason, then ok. I guess that makes it alot more appropriate. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I wonder how many Christians struggling with their faith will see ACS' posts here, and recognize that any faith that requires its adherents to practice such tortured logic and dishonesty is worthless. If he saves just one individual from a life of pretending there is a magic fairy in the sky, it will all be worth it.

If any of the many Christians here in this forum have thoughts on this thread feel free to PM me. Honestly, feel free.
 
@ Edge. You responded to this post of JoeTheJuggler's by saying he was wrong.

Yeah, I noticed that you misunderstand a lot.

How about this?--just because the author of Matthew said that Jesus said it doesn't mean every Christian believes it was Jesus' words.

In fact, as I pointed out, it's pretty easy to prove that none of the direct quotes were Jesus' actual words. Furthermore it is probable that none of the 4 gospels were written by eyewitnesses to the events.

The you posted this passage:

Luke 1
Introduction
1Many have undertaken to draw up an account of the things that have been fulfilled[a] among us, 2 just as they were handed down to us by those who from the first were eyewitnesses and servants of the word. 3Therefore, since I myself have carefully investigated everything from the beginning, it seemed good also to me to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus, 4so that you may know the certainty of the things you have been taught.

And now you say:

Edge said:
So what Joe and Fiona are saying is that the reporters and eyewitnesses aren’t as good as today’s reporters?
I disagree, that’s my stand, so no.
You can look at them as news channels, if the story line is the same but from different perspectives then you can get the truth, or as much as possible.

The first part I have bolded says the accounts "were handed down to us". How is that the same as speaking to eyewitnesses? It isn't, is it? He is a historian, not a reporter. At least that is what I take it to mean. And that is what JoeTheJuggler said. Luke did not say that the eyewitnesses took shorthand either. He did not say he had a text which was written down word for word at the time. So it is unlikely he had a verbatim account. And that also is what JoeTheJuggler said. I really cannot see how you can say he is wrong
 
Last edited:
I still think that, if someone honestly believes that Matthew 5 advises following the OT, then they should argue that position -- regardless of what they WANT Christians to do. It seems like a good way to understand WHY so many Christians view those verses in a different way.

When you believe that Matthew 5 advises following the OT and you argue that with a Christian how do you expect Christians to take your argument?
I'm being serious here.
 
When you believe that Matthew 5 advises following the OT and you argue that with a Christian how do you expect Christians to take your argument?
I'm being serious here.
1) "You're right. I should follow my beliefs more closely instead of making logical errors."

2) "You're right. Maybe the Bible isn't an inerrant book after all, and isn't quite as reliable as I thought it was..."

That's what I would expect, anyways. It never happens that way, though.
 
Edge is a young earth creationist, I believe-- and extreme evangelical of some sort. I can't remember if it's him or radrook that is the Jehovah's Witness.

There are lots of quotes in the Quo'ran that illustrate it is not a religion of peace as they say. I'm sure they'd be coming up with the same nutty apologetics with the passage that people quote that pushes their buttons the most.

The bible has lots-o-unsavory passages too. When we quote them, it's usually to illustrate something that believers in the text are in denial about-- not because it's "our favorite passage"-- it's just one of those passages that shows how full of crap those who claim to "follow the bible are"-- just like those people who claim "Islam is a religion of Peace". Yeah, yeah-- it's all interpretive.

We don't think you should be getting your morals from any primitive book subject to such vast interpretation and misinterpretation-- but, hey, who are we to decide what you pick and choose to "believe in".
 
My remarks were in reference to this thread and the way it's used towards arguments with Christians. I appreciate the other atheists views and thoughts on the matter who've posted. Thanks.
Welcome. FYI, all versions of Mat 5,19 in German language differ from the English translation.

English:
Therefore, whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do so will be called least in the kingdom of heaven. But whoever obeys and teaches these commandments will be called greatest in the kingdom of heaven.

German:
Wer auch nur eines von den kleinsten Geboten aufhebt und die Menschen entsprechend lehrt, der wird im Himmelreich der Kleinste sein. Wer sie aber hält und halten lehrt, der wird groß sein im Himmelreich.

The English verb break is clearly replaced by abolish in the German text, and the verb obey by something like keep, hold. This would read:

Therefore, whoever abolishes one of the least of these commandments... But whoever keeps and teaches to keep these commandments...

H.
 
I don't know that even THAT is always the case. Aren't there some Christians who don't believe Jesus was divine? They would say his teachings were therefore subject to human error as well.

Apparently there are. I learned this from Beth in another thread, and I was very, very surprised. I was not then, and am not now, able to see in what sense such people are Christians: but they say they are and I can only accept that. I would be very interested to hear their view of the status of the bible, too, if any would like to join this thread. I suspect you are right. If Jesus is not divine then his words cannot have divine status. Indeed they cannot have any more status than yours or mine: though he seems to have been a tad more persuasive than us ;) So it seems to me, anyway.

(What do you make of the story of Jesus cursing the fig tree? Seems like a very human and imperfect thing that has no value whatsoever as a moral example.)

If you are asking for my personal opinion, I see it as I see all the rest of the bible. It is a story.

ETA: At any rate, my larger point is still valid: just saying that a passage means x is not the same as me saying that a Christian should follow x. And there are plenty of Christians who would agree. It sounds like some Christians have a huge problem with the Matthew passage in question because they think if it really means what it says that they are bound by it. That's not my issue. I don't think they should be bound by it.

Yes, I understand that is your view. It is also mine. And in light of what I learned from Beth, you are clearly right about the approach some christians would take as well. I just don't think that is a very mainstream christian view. But I am learning all the time, so I could easily be wrong. Suffice to say that many Christians who do think they should do what the bible tells them and for them it is very important to find out what that is.


Just a nitpick: you seem to be treating the concepts of literalism and inerrancy as if they were the same. Whether a passage should be taken literally or not is one thing; whether it might be wrong (or have errors in it) is another issue.

I am not sure I understand this bit. The distinction I tried to make was between literalism and fundamentalism. As I said before, most Christians (with the exceptions already discussed) take the bible as fundamental. That is, they believe it is the word of god and therefore it is the foundation of their beliefs about how they should live. This applies to both literalists and non-literalists. Literalists don't have a problem (though they should) and so I did not think they were relevant to this discussion. Nothing I have said applies to them. Non-literalists have more trouble in finding out how they should live because they do admit the possibility of error. Whether there is error in a particular passage; or in the interpretation of the passage; is an important question for such christians. I do not see how this conflates the concepts but if it does I will be glad if you can show me where I have gone wrong.
 
When you believe that Matthew 5 advises following the OT and you argue that with a Christian how do you expect Christians to take your argument?
I'm being serious here.

Seriously?
I would expect most Christians to disagree with me and then tell me why they disagree with me.

On the interpretation you gave, this thread reached the point where you chuckled when asked if it bothers you that you will be called least in the Kingdom of Heaven. I can't remember who you called funny, but they deserve some credit.
 
Welcome. FYI, all versions of Mat 5,19 in German language differ from the English translation.

English:
Therefore, whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do so will be called least in the kingdom of heaven. But whoever obeys and teaches these commandments will be called greatest in the kingdom of heaven.
Spanish:
19Cualquiera, pues, que anule uno solo de estos mandamientos, aun de los más pequeños, y así lo enseñe a otros, será llamado muy pequeño en el reino de los cielos; pero cualquiera que los guarde y los enseñe, éste será llamado grande en el reino de los cielos.

The verbs are

anular
= to annul sth. and
guardar
= to guard, keep, maintain.

Hence, this reads:

Therefore, whoever annuls one of the least of these commandments... But whoever guards and teaches these commandments...

To those asserting an "unambiguous" text, what you say about this? What does the text say?
 
Last edited:
Welcome. FYI, all versions of Mat 5,19 in German language differ from the English translation.

English:
Therefore, whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do so will be called least in the kingdom of heaven. But whoever obeys and teaches these commandments will be called greatest in the kingdom of heaven.

German:
Wer auch nur eines von den kleinsten Geboten aufhebt und die Menschen entsprechend lehrt, der wird im Himmelreich der Kleinste sein. Wer sie aber hält und halten lehrt, der wird groß sein im Himmelreich.

The English verb break is clearly replaced by abolish in the German text, and the verb obey by something like keep, hold. This would read:

Therefore, whoever abolishes one of the least of these commandments... But whoever keeps and teaches to keep these commandments...

H.

That is interesting. In the German translation it almost sounds like it's in reference to His statement before these verses where He says He hasn't come to abolish the Laws and the Prophets but to fulfill them.
 
Last edited:
Adam and Eve didn't write genesis... all the Jesus stuff was written way after the fact... some of it based on "revelation"-- much of it conflicting... and oft translated.... many of what we believe JC said doesn't appear at all in the earliest translations of what are supposed to be "the bible" (as if there was a singular "bible" ever). It's all eons of hearsay... none of it is verifiable... none of it prescient... and none of it is other that what people at the time might have written-- nothing sounds omnipotent, magical, wondrous, omniscient, or divinely inspired.

Atheists don't usually have a favorite bible verse, but lots of them know the verses that clued them into the fact that the book most certainly was not a source for morality or divine truths. The Matthew passage is one. It makes it look like all Christians are major cherry pickers--and creating their gods and their religions along with their morality as suits them.

There just seems no good reason to take people who claim to get their morality from the bible any more seriously than people who claim to get their morality form the Quo'ran or the Book of Mormon or Dianetics. When we quote scripture at you it's to make you get a good hard look at this magic book you claim is the source of your morality-- the book that you feel so damn special for "believing in" (whatever the hell you've interpreted that to mean.)
 
Last edited:
I am not sure I understand this bit. The distinction I tried to make was between literalism and fundamentalism. As I said before, most Christians (with the exceptions already discussed) take the bible as fundamental. That is, they believe it is the word of god and therefore it is the foundation of their beliefs about how they should live. This applies to both literalists and non-literalists. Literalists don't have a problem (though they should) and so I did not think they were relevant to this discussion. Nothing I have said applies to them. Non-literalists have more trouble in finding out how they should live because they do admit the possibility of error. Whether there is error in a particular passage; or in the interpretation of the passage; is an important question for such christians. I do not see how this conflates the concepts but if it does I will be glad if you can show me where I have gone wrong.

Hey Fiona,

I think I can clear this up for you. Fundamentalist has lost it's original meaning (and the meaning you're using it as) when used to describe Christians. Instead of meaning someone who has something fundamental it now means literalist. It's used towards Christians who take the bible literally (Young Earth Creationists, Etc.)

So even though to me Jesus teachings are the fundamental foundation that I build everything else upon I'm not a literalist and not what the term Fundamentalist has now come to mean when describing Christians. I don't take everything in the bible literally. I doubt I could accurately describe the process I use to someone online - but I usually start with what sort of document in the bible I'm reading as a starting point.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom