The atheists favorite bible verses

If nothing else, Christians can be very entertaining... and a great study in cognitive dissonance.

I too applaud Bokonen as quoted-- in fact I'm starting a standing ovation....

Bravo... Bravisimo!!!

How would you know about the ones in this forum? You have us on ignore and filter us through peoples responses and, if you're lucky, they're quotes of us.
 
The position from the OP is the following Matthew verses are used by atheists alot on these forums.



I then wanted some examples of Christians who agree with the atheists saying that Christians need to obey the Old Testament.



...snip...

Goodness me you are even disingenuous regarding your own opening post and what you actually said in that!

Your opening post in full with the parts you omitted in blue:

Ha,

Got you.

Of course this isn't all atheists favorite bible verses so don't bother posting that it's not yours. And please don't post your favorite verses either. Thanks.

But I have come across atheists using these verses alot here. (And no - Darat - I won't post a link to all the examples in the forum so don't bother asking me to prove that statement)

Matthew 5:17-20 said:
17"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. 19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven.

In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally. I'm sure you know why they would like to make that case. ;)

Now - the only place I've ever come across that teaching is here and the only people I've ever heard insist that's how to interpret those verses are atheists.

So - if you'd like to play along and take up the challenge -

Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.

Thanks.

And of course you got what you asked for.

Of course you did also say:

...snip...


Also - the point of the OP is not me or you to defend the position one way or another but to give me some references.


Then of course you changed what you wanted...
 
The position from the OP is the following Matthew verses are used by atheists alot on these forums.



I then wanted some examples of Christians who agree with the atheists saying that Christians need to obey the Old Testament.

And atheists then jumped in defending the position that Christians are supposed to obey the Old Testament Laws using these verses.

NOW FOLLOW CLOSELY EVERYONE:

A) IF you are arguing that Matthew is contradictory to other parts of the Bible - Start Your Own Thread - that's not what this thread is about.

B) IF you are arguing Christians shouldn't be Christians or follow any part of the bible - Start Your Own Thread - that's not what this thread is about.

C) IF you are arguing the Old Testament is bad - Start Your Own Thread - that's not what this thread is about.



And Finally:
D) IF you are arguing that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and these Matthew verses are you're proof - THEN we can continue on.

If you're position is D - that is, if you are saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and the Matthew verses are proof then please clarify - YES, my position is D.

If you're position is A - C or any other position other than D then Start Your Own Thread.

Fair enough. I'll turn off the lights on my way out.

Anyone else fancy a pint? I think we're done here.
 
As far as I'm concerned, the rational side has won this debate many times over.

Well, considering it now appears none of the atheists here arguing are even arguing on topic ...

because if you're arguing any position other than D in the post above, or not giving me links with Christians who agree with D above you're not on topic.
 
Last edited:
Then of course you changed what you wanted...

The moment people said "It's obvious what those verses mean" and "How else could you read verse 19?" it changed. Not to mention when people asked me my interpretation and then told me I was wrong.
 
Last edited:
ACS: I saw the post you linked me to. I do think it something of a stretch because you are making the word "and" carry an awful lot of weight, as I understand what you are saying. It appears to be your position that Jesus was saying that one would be considered "least in the Kingdom of heaven" if he breaks any part of the Law AND teaches others to do the same. Is that correct? If if is then I disagree. I will try to show you why, though I do not expect you to accept it. For what it is worth, then:

17"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18 I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished.

I have seen it argued that this could mean that the Law ceases to have force because the coming of the Christ fufills it and so the Law is not abolished but it is no longer the final word, in face of this fulfilllment. This seems to depend on the "accomplishment" being the death and resurrection but this cannot be so because, in the first place it renders the phrase "until heaven and earth disappear" redundant: and secondly because everything cannot be accomplished till the second coming. So I am driven to understand this passage to mean that the Law remains in force.

Now it moves on.

19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20 For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven.

The word order is part of the problem here and so is the ordering of the concepts. The person "who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven" This cannot be reconciled with the the next verse unless "these" refers to what follows rather than what goes before. You cannot be called least in the kingdom of heaven if you are not there: and verse 20 makes it plain that "unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law you will certainly not enter". Unless it is your position that believers will spend all of eternity in heaven gossiping about those who did not make it we have to assume that those who are called "least" are actually there. But they cannot be there unless their righteousness exceeds that of those who follow the Law: and they do this by keeping "these commandments". Well what makes sense of this?

21"You have heard that it was said to the people long ago, 'Do not murder,[a] and anyone who murders will be subject to judgment.' 22But I tell you that anyone who is angry with his brotherwill be subject to judgment."


I will not quote the rest because for this purpose it is redundant. It is clear that Jesus expands what is required of the Christian to include thoughts and stuff: where the Law only addressed actions. That is a simplistic characterisation but I trust you can see the point? What has happened is that Jesus has not taken anything away from the Law: he has rather added to it, but in such a way that breaking the new commandments only results in a diminishing of one's status in heaven: where breaking the old Law means you don't get in at all.

ETA. I was writing that while you and others were posting. I am sorry. I had forgotten that what you wanted was links to other Christians who subscribe to the view that this passage means you have to accept the OT laws. As I am not a Christian I am also off topic. I apologise
 
Last edited:
Then of course you changed what you wanted...
In the words of the prophet, Joni "Spice" Mitchell,
Don't it always seem to go
That you don't know what you want
What you really, really want
Until you get what you asked for in the first post
Or words to that effect.
 
Last edited:
ACS, you made some huge assumptions in your OP. You were obviously trying to set up a "gotcha" trap, and no one fell for it.

You can start a thread on a topic, but you really can't claim that any response other than the one you anticipate is off topic.

We're not the straw man you imagined us to be. If that's all you want, why not just conduct your little conversation in your own mind? The trouble with all of us is that we have thoughts and ideas that you apparently hadn't considered.

Back to the issue we've been discussing--the ambiguous statement you keep wanting us to say, "Christians are supposed to obey every law of the O.T."

Do you at least recognize that these two statements don't mean the same thing:
1. I think Christians are supposed to obey every law of the O.T.
2. According to the passage in Matthew, Christians are supposed to obey every law of the O.T.

Do you agree that those two statements are NOT equivalent?
 
ACS: I saw the post you linked me to. I do think it something of a stretch because you are making the word "and" carry an awful lot of weight, as I understand what you are saying. It appears to be your position that Jesus was saying that one would be considered "least in the Kingdom of heaven" if he breaks any part of the Law AND teaches others to do the same. Is that correct? If if is then I disagree.
Even if one accepted this tortured interpretation, it wouldn't solve ACS's problem. Since actions speak louder than words, it isn't practical to break the laws without teaching others to do the same. What are your kids supposed to think when they see you responding to backtalk with grounding instead of stoning? What conclusion could they possibly draw, except that God's Holy Word no longer applies? You are teaching by example.

When I pointed this out to him, he dismissed it with "You're funny."

Of course I'm funny. I'm holding a mirror up to him.
 
ETA. I was writing that while you and others were posting. I am sorry. I had forgotten that what you wanted was links to other Christians who subscribe to the view that this passage means you have to accept the OT laws. As I am not a Christian I am also off topic. I apologise

That's OK. It seems this thread left the OP a long time ago. But I appreciate your response to that.

I have a few other readings of those verses in addition to the one I posted.
I was simply responding to Joe's question of "How else can you read verse 19?"

But, really, judging from the reaction to the first posting I made I'm not posting any other readings of those verses although I think they would be interesting to discuss. The bottom line, though, is that I don't feel the verses alone are clear enough in their meaning for me to alter my behavior to begin obeying all the Old Testament law. So of course, as I always do, I'll do what I understand and wrestle with what I don't until I either do understand or move on to the next life. ;)
 
@ JoeTheJuggler. I think the problem with that is that they are not equivalent except if you are a Christian. For a Christian, if the passage means you should obey the OT laws then you should obey them, because the passage is the word of god. The distinction which is clear to you and me does not, and perhaps cannot, exist for a Christian. Your view does not count - only what the Christian thinks the passage means. If a Christian is driven to accept it means he should obey the OT laws then that is the end of it: he should. Does that make sense to you?

ETA: @ Bokonon: I agree with the point you raise and it is powerful. But ACS has other readings, as he has just told us, and so it is no more persuasive than my own :)
 
Last edited:
Even if one accepted this tortured interpretation, it wouldn't solve ACS's problem. Since actions speak louder than words, it isn't practical to break the laws without teaching others to do the same. What are your kids supposed to think when they see you responding to backtalk with grounding instead of stoning? What conclusion could they possibly draw, except that God's Holy Word no longer applies? You are teaching by example.

When I pointed this out to him, he dismissed it with "You're funny."

Of course I'm funny. I'm holding a mirror up to him.


Indeed. Believers are fabulous irony generators-- an endless font of amusing entertainment for skeptics.

Besides-- how are Christians who are teaching and encouraging other Christians to cherry pick from the bible (as they are clearly doing)-- NOT teaching other Christians to break the laws? How can they avoid the AND??

The more believers talks, the less sense they make. They just talk and talk to try to spin the right little story in their head and they do it on this forum so they can tell themselves that their "faith" has withstood skeptical scrutiny and in the process attempt to confirm all the biases they came with.

The only thing ACS seems skeptical about is other religions... oh, and the Christian teachings that don't agree with his interpretations of those teachings. He sure doesn't apply ihs skepticism to his own nebulous theistic beliefs.
 
Last edited:
ACS, you made some huge assumptions in your OP. You were obviously trying to set up a "gotcha" trap, and no one fell for it.

Really? Because people did post some links to some Christians who do agree with some atheists insistance that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and who use Matthew to prove it.

You can start a thread on a topic, but you really can't claim that any response other than the one you anticipate is off topic.

So posting responses off-topic or arguing an argument that isn't on topic can't be called Off-Topic?

We're not the straw man you imagined us to be. If that's all you want, why not just conduct your little conversation in your own mind? The trouble with all of us is that we have thoughts and ideas that you apparently hadn't considered.

Well - I was considering the points some were raising as they posted those Matthew Verses at me. That's why this thread exists.

Back to the issue we've been discussing--the ambiguous statement you keep wanting us to say, "Christians are supposed to obey every law of the O.T."

If you agree with how the verses are being used as in my OP then that's what you mean. If you, JoeTheJuggler, want to use those verses in a different way to compare and contrast it with other verses in different books in the bible - go ahead. But please don't do it in this thread. Because that's not what my concern is right now.

Do you at least recognize that these two statements don't mean the same thing:
1. I think Christians are supposed to obey every law of the O.T.
2. According to the passage in Matthew, Christians are supposed to obey every law of the O.T.

Do you agree that those two statements are NOT equivalent?

If you're contrasting point 2 against another passage somewhere else - then it would be a different point you are arguing - one that's not the topic of the thread. Maybe you just misunderstood the OP. If you're simply showing me that verse alone in this thread then you're telling me Christians are supposed to obey every law of the O.T. - which is on topic for this thread.

So - if you would like to argue it's contradictory to other positions in the bible and you'd like me to take part - start a new thread in a few weeks and maybe I'll take part (I say maybe because I can't promise, I say next week because if you're thread is going to go down the road like this one I'll need a break. I'm sure you can understand.:)). If you don't want me to take part - start a thread on that at your convenience. You were arguing what those verses meant without saying you weren't arguing in the context of my OP (although you did disclaim you weren't sure how literal someone should be).
 
@ JoeTheJuggler. I think the problem with that is that they are not equivalent except if you are a Christian. For a Christian, if the passage means you should obey the OT laws then you should obey them, because the passage is the word of god. The distinction which is clear to you and me does not, and perhaps cannot, exist for a Christian. Your view does not count - only what the Christian thinks the passage means. If a Christian is driven to accept it means he should obey the OT laws then that is the end of it: he should. Does that make sense to you?

I also figured JoeTheJuggler and everyone else was defending the OP position on these verses. Was there anyone who was - or was everyone arguing something not having to do with the OP? And that position is that these verses are being used to show Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws.
 
The moment people said "It's obvious what those verses mean" and "How else could you read verse 19?" it changed. Not to mention when people asked me my interpretation and then told me I was wrong.

It would hardly be reasonable to disagree with your interpretation before knowing what it is.
 
@ JoeTheJuggler. I think the problem with that is that they are not equivalent except if you are a Christian. For a Christian, if the passage means you should obey the OT laws then you should obey them, because the passage is the word of god. The distinction which is clear to you and me does not, and perhaps cannot, exist for a Christian. Your view does not count - only what the Christian thinks the passage means. If a Christian is driven to accept it means he should obey the OT laws then that is the end of it: he should. Does that make sense to you?
I don't quite follow. (Though I wanted to say you did a masterful job of explicating the Matthew passage above.)

The statements have a different meaning depending on who speaks them?

Also, I know plenty of Christians who read the passage with its obvious meaning (that the author of Matthew thinks you should obey all the old laws because I suspect that person felt that Jesus' teachings were only for Jews) but do NOT feel that because of it they are "supposed to" obey the old laws. As others have pointed out in this thread, there are other passages in the New Testament that clearly argue that Jesus' teachings should be carried to people who don't follow Jewish law. ACS doesn't want to talk about that (even though it is obviously on the topic.)

At any rate, a reasonable Christian can agree with me and make all of these statements, "I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws. I don't want to convince anyone that they are supposed to obey all the O.T. laws. However, according to the passage in Matthew, you are supposed obey every last one of the O.T. laws."

I suppose I'd say that "what the Christian thinks the passage means" is not the same thing as saying that the same Christian "is driven to accept it". As you pointed out, it really is unreasonable to think the passage means anything other than the old laws are not abolished. Yet I don't think there are any Christians who actually obey all the laws of the O.T. There are relatively few, I suspect, who even feel the need to try.

Also, if ACS doesn't think an atheist's opinion counts, why title the thread "The atheists favorite bible verses" and why post it in a skeptical forum?

I've laid out very clearly why this passage is one of an atheist's favorite. It is a powerful refutation to those who use the Bible as if it was an inerrant source of moral guidance and claim that the O.T. doesn't count because Jesus made it null and void by introducing his "new law".

Surely these observations are all on the topic.
 
Last edited:
And atheists then jumped in defending the position that Christians are supposed to obey the Old Testament Laws using these verses.

That would be a "yes".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom