The atheists favorite bible verses

You left out according the the words of Jesus reported in Matthew 5

In other words you refused to clarify your ambiguity, even after I asked you twice.

And then you acted as though I had answered the ambiguously worded question.

What desparate trouble your position must be in to resort to such desparate and dishonest tactics :)

No. You pointing that out simply tells me you think Christians are supposed to be doing that.
 
Last edited:
Hallelujah!



It's closer but still not correct, try this version:

When you post or show or argue those verses are you telling a Christian that according the Bible they are supposed to be following the Old Testament Laws?
Try according to Matthew 5 - the NT is not consistent on this subject, see for example Pauls letter to the Ephesians.
 
Try according to Matthew 5 - the NT is not consistent on this subject, see for example Pauls letter to the Ephesians.

We're not and never have been talking about other sections of the bible. We are talking about what you're claims Christians are supposed to do. And according to Matthew, you argue, Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. How is that not claiming Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? That's you're whole argument.
 
Last edited:
What you're ignoring is that JoeTJ would rather you stopped using the Bible (NT included, I assume) as a moral guide. What you respond with is an ultimatum: "If you convince me that Matthew says I should follow the OT, then I will follow the OT -- so be careful what you say!"

You're claiming JoeTJ's motives are to make you react the way you threaten to react if he, in fact, convinced you to accept his interpretation of Matthew.
Well said.

But, the thing is.... Once you accept Joe's interpretation of Matthew, he'll bring up Romans 7:6
<snip>
Or some similar verse.
Yep. And I already indirectly did so. I've mentioned several times that you can find other N.T. passages that contradict Matthew--especially Paul and the Gospel of John. I'm not at all trying to do a "gotcha"--I have nothing up my sleeve.

I wasn't aware that conversion to judaism was a requisite to christianity.
As mentioned several times in this thread, it was an issue in the early church. Matthew and Luke seem to be pretty much of the opinion that Jesus' teaching was only for Jews. Paul and others disagreed and inevitably won out. I forget where, but someone (probably Paul) was given a vision of the clean and unclean animals. I disremember the details, but the symbolic message was taken as an instruction from God to bring Jesus' message to gentiles.

The above is MUCH more interesting discussion to me than the following:

I find the argument that Christians have to follow the Old Testament Laws rather limp based on those verses alone.
Nope--I never said Christians had to follow O.T. laws. I pointed out that those verses refute the argument that the O.T. is null and void. It's a problem when you use the Bible as a moral guide. You've simply got to have another source of morality already otherwise you don't know which bits of the Bible are moral and which aren't--which laws to follow and which to ignore. Therefore, the Bible is not a moral guide at all. At best, you can find passages to confirm something you already believe.



Of course - now I'm just trying to clarify if the people using those verses are telling me if Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws or not.
Clarify? It's been spelled out clearly to you at least 30 times.

The author of Matthew thinks you're "supposed to" obey and teach all the old laws. I don't think anyone should obey or teach all the old laws.

I keep asking, when you say it's clear are you saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws - YES or NO?
The author of Matthew thinks you're "supposed to" obey and teach all the old laws. I don't think anyone should obey or teach all the old laws.

We were talking about those verses becuase I thought the answer you all were saying was YES, but this thread took a left turn at Albequerquie when you all denied saying that.
Nope. You're wrong again. I and others here have very consistently said the same thing over and over and over and over again, and you pretend you don't understand.

I'll say it again: The author of Matthew thinks you're "supposed to" obey and teach all the old laws. I don't think anyone should obey or teach all the old laws.

What would suit me is if people who use bible verses for some sort of argument or conclusion on how Christians are supposed to act would simply just tell me how Christians are supposed to act.
I have no interest in telling you how Christians are supposed to act beyond my repeated statement that I don't think anyone should follow all the laws of the O.T. The author of Matthew however clearly thought that you should.

You trying to teach me that I have to follow the Old Testament Laws is simply that - you teaching me, encouraging me, telling me that I'm supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
I don't know where you get this. Maybe it's because I haven't yet said it 100 times: I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws. I haven never tried to convince you that you're supposed to. I believe it is plain as day that the author of Matthew thinks you're supposed to.

But I am not trying to teach you, encourage you or tell you that you are supposed to follow the O.T. laws.

And once again, if you don't want me to follow the Old Testament Laws - if they are so morally offensive to you or others - don't try to convince me or anyone else they are supposed to do follow them. What sort of logic is that?
It would be horribly illogical if someone here were trying to convince you to follow the O.T. laws. Maybe this will click with you when I've said it 100 times--I'm sure it's getting close. I don't think you or anyone else should obey all the O.T. laws. The author of Matthew thinks you're supposed to.

I'm saying if you really don't want someone to do something don't try to convince them to do it.
It's a good thing no one is trying to convince you to follow the O.T. laws then, isn't it?

See the problem is, you somehow keep misconstruing my statements:
me said:
I don't think you or anyone else should obey all the O.T. laws. The author of Matthew thinks you're supposed to.
to mean that I think you should obey all the O.T. laws. In fact, that interpretation is untenable because I have clearly stated exactly the opposite.

ACS, no one here is trying to convince you to follow all the O.T. laws.
 
Last edited:
We're not and never have been talking about other sections of the bible.
How can we not never have been talking about other sections of the Bible? Jesus' statement in question was directly referring to other sections of the Bible!
We are talking about what you're claims Christians are supposed to do.
No, we are talking about what the Gospel according to Matthew claims Christians are supposed to do
And according to Matthew, you argue, Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
Finally you got it - according to Matthew
How is that not claiming Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws?
Because the statement "according to a you should do x" is not equivalent to the statement "you should do x". They are simply different statements - if you can't see the difference then we should probably call a halt.
 
And according to Matthew, you argue, Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. How is that not claiming Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws?
Because it simply is not.

These two statements are NOT equivalent:

A. "I think Christians should follow all the O.T. Laws"

B. "The author of Matthew thinks Christians should follow all the O.T. Laws"

The sentence "Christians should follow all the O.T. Laws" is ambiguous because it could mean either A or B.

When you ask YES or NO, the answer is No regarding statement A and Yes regarding statement B. This ambiguity has been spelled out to you over and over.

You want to leave off "according to Matthew 5" since that's all we're talking about.

That's fine by me as long as you then take the ambiguous sentence ONLY to mean statement B and not statement A.

You've shown that you won't do that. You've said over and over that I am trying to convince you to follow all the O.T. laws, when I have said over 50 times now that I don't think anyone should follow all the O.T. laws. I'm not trying to convince you or anyone that they're supposed to follow all the O.T. laws.
ETA: In other words, you want to strip the "according to Matthew" part from statement B because it's understood. Then you want to parse the ambiguous sentence as if it were statement A. That's extremely dishonest of you.

I'm pointing out that the passage clearly refutes the argument that the O.T. is null and void. I don't do that to tell you that you should become a fundy and obey all the O.T. laws. (I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws, and I'm not trying to convince you or anyone else that they're supposed to obey all the O.T. laws.) I do that that to point out that the Bible is not a good moral guide. If you didn't already have moral sense, you wouldn't know which parts to obey or not. If you were strictly following the Bible, you'd be in a quandary. (Frankly, I think it's utterly impossible to obey all the teachings of the Bible because they aren't at all consistent.)
 
Last edited:
I was waiting for "go back into the closet" to arise yet again. Yet another game of cherry pick, completely missing the point of church as the people.
I can't speak for anyone else, but when I oppose public prayer, I have no interest in going into your church, building closets, and calling for an hour of silence. My interest is in protecting people like Nicole Smallkowski, who was thrown off her school's basketball team and suspended from school for refusing to participate in public prayer on the basketball court, before and after practices, and after games.

I cannot see what the problem is. For me the passage is clear. I cannot see the ambiguity in the words which seems to be evident to ACS.
It's the same kind of tortured apologetics that permitted earlier generations to reconcile the Golden Rule with owning slaves: "If I were a slave, I'd want the slavemaster to treat me kindly" rather than "I wouldn't want another man to consider me his property."

So what's your suggestion?
Give in to this threat? Let him win the debate because otherwise... What?
As far as I'm concerned, the rational side has won this debate many times over. It's been amply demonstrated that ACS doesn't consider what is written in the bible to be binding. He, like most people, gets his moral guidance from other sources, and only consults the bible when it endorses his core beliefs. The fact that "honesty" doesn't appear to be among those core beliefs just means he ignores passages which advocate honesty as easily as he ignores passages which advocate stoning children.

He has shown that he is quite willing to ignore biblical authority, just as he should. While his core beliefs permit him to favor hypocrisy over honesty, so he may not admit that this is what he does, I say, declare victory, and move on.
 
Last edited:
Try according to Matthew 5 - the NT is not consistent on this subject, see for example Pauls letter to the Ephesians.

OK start a thread on that because that's not what this thread is about. It's about whether those verses in Matthew say Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and how those verses are used to say they are.
 
I think that makes sense in an imminent apocalypse cult, but how in the world does fulfilling a law make any sense in the world in which we live?

How in the world does the bible make any sense as a moral guide in the world in which we live? How in the world can any one think any book was inspired or written by any invisible form of consciousness revealing "his" will?
 
OK start a thread on that because that's not what this thread is about. It's about whether those verses in Matthew say Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and how those verses are used to say they are.

If "according to Matthew" is understood, then why do you keep saying that I and others are trying to convince you that you're supposed to obey all the O.T. laws? We are not.

See my explanation above about the ambiguity. It's very clear how it works and what you're trying to do. You're trying to get us to say that "According to Matthew, you are supposed to obey every one of the O.T. laws" is the same as saying "You are supposed to obey every one of the O.T. laws", which you will then take to mean, "I think you are supposed to obey every one of the O.T. laws."

It's sleazy and obvious what you're trying to do.

If the only objection you have to "according to Matthew" is that it's unnecessary (even though I've shown it is not), then why not just leave it in there?

The reason you don't want to leave it in there, is that then you can't pounce on the statement and construe it to mean the one which I and others here have denied over and over again (i.e. that we're trying to convince you that you should obey all the O.T. laws--or that you're "supposed to"). We are not. Again, we are not the author of Matthew.
 
Defend that position then.

What, the position that you're ignoring the central argument here in order to engage in a red herring?

But if want me to do that I'll have to go and murder a small kitten - you don't want me to do that now do you?
 
I have ACS and the apologists on ignore. I just enjoy the clever responses of the skeptics.

Obviously ACS started his thread to prove to himself that when atheists quote the bible they are trying to force him into doing barbaric things (because atheists are evil and he is moral).

Of course, they are just showing him that his "moral guide" is hardly a moral guide and that theists "cherry pick" from the book they claim to be divinely inspired by the creator of the universe and then pretend that that makes them unlike those "moral relativistic atheists".

Theist believe they are more moral BECAUSE of the bible... and they believe that atheists must be immoral because they don't believe in it... and they have learned to filter, negate, and hear conversations so that it supports this false world view. They have to do so... --they have no facts... all they have is emotions, threats, manipulations, semantics, straw men, and fake sincerity to prop up their delusional "faith" is good" meme and "I'm saved by believing what I believe" meme and "atheists are evil" meme.

Faith appears to make people illogical. It is definitely not a tool that is useful in critical thinking. And ACS shows how religions promote this tool as the "means to salvation" when it's nothing but The Emperor's New Clothes.

So, ACS, should people see "the Emperor's New Clothes"?

Yes or No? Yes or No? Yes or No? No answer? I'll take that as a "yes"-- you think people should be delusional, mistaken, or lying-- they should say they see the clothes or shut up about the nakedness.
 
Last edited:
As far as I'm concerned, the rational side has won this debate many times over. It's been amply demonstrated that ACS doesn't consider what is written in the bible to be binding. He, like most people, gets his moral guidance from other sources, and only consults the bible when it endorses his core beliefs. The fact that "honesty" doesn't appear to be among those core beliefs just means he ignores passages which advocate honesty as easily as he ignores passages which advocate stoning children.

He has shown that he is quite willing to ignore biblical authority, just as he should. While his core beliefs permit him to favor hypocrisy over honesty, so he may not admit that this is what he does, I say, declare victory, and move on.
:applause:
 
What, the position that you're ignoring the central argument here in order to engage in a red herring?

The position from the OP is the following Matthew verses are used by atheists alot on these forums.

From the OP said:
Matthew 5:17-20
17"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. 19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven.
In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally.

I then wanted some examples of Christians who agree with the atheists saying that Christians need to obey the Old Testament.

And atheists then jumped in defending the position that Christians are supposed to obey the Old Testament Laws using these verses.

NOW FOLLOW CLOSELY EVERYONE:

A) IF you are arguing that Matthew is contradictory to other parts of the Bible - Start Your Own Thread - that's not what this thread is about.

B) IF you are arguing Christians shouldn't be Christians or follow any part of the bible - Start Your Own Thread - that's not what this thread is about.

C) IF you are arguing the Old Testament is bad - Start Your Own Thread - that's not what this thread is about.



And Finally:
D) IF you are arguing that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and these Matthew verses are you're proof - THEN we can continue on.

If you're position is D - that is, if you are saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws and the Matthew verses are proof then please clarify - YES, my position is D.

If you're position is A - C or any other position other than D then Start Your Own Thread.
 
Last edited:
If nothing else, Christians can be very entertaining... and a great study in cognitive dissonance.

I too applaud Bokonen as quoted-- in fact I'm starting a standing ovation....

Bravo... Bravisimo!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom