The atheists favorite bible verses

The one that comes coupled with honesty, sincerity and integrity. I doubt you would understand those concepts as you have aptly demonstrated here.

You are doing a great job, though. I could never better explain than by pointing at you, why I do not believe, why I never could believe and why I think religion is both dangerous and harmful. You are why I think religion out to be fought.

Because most religious people aren't fundie enough for you? Would you rather people like ASC just bit the bullet and started stoning people for violating ancient hebrew customs? :confused:

Really? Now that's interesting.

What's dangerous and harmful about me not blindly accepting yours and others teachings on those verses especially when it's not obvious? All I've done is this thread (before it went down this current road) was question everyone's interpretation of it.

I think hes saying he respects people like Osama bin Laden more than you 'cause at least they kill people with "honesty, sincerity and integrity".
 
Last edited:
I'm saying if you really don't want someone to do something don't try to convince them to do it.

No. What you are doing is threatening people by saying: "You're actions will have consequences you do not want."

I'm sure people have considered that by telling you Matthew says "follow the OT" you may end up following the OT. They seem willing to take the risk -- on the grounds that there is also the chance that you will stop using the Bible as a moral guide.
 
Last edited:
No what you are doing is threatening people by saying: "You're actions will have consequences you do not want."

I'm not threatening anyone. You're telling me that's what Christians are supposed to be doing. If I'm convinced of that I'll research how the Jews accomplished it and go from there.

I'm sure people have considered that by telling you Matthew says "follow the OT" you may end up following the OT. They seem willing to take the risk -- on the grounds that there is also the chance that you will stop using the Bible as a moral guide.

So it's a gamble. Hopefully ACS won't actually do what we say and instead he'll abandon his faith.
 
Last edited:
Really? Now that's interesting.

What's dangerous and harmful about me not blindly accepting yours and others teachings on those verses especially when it's not obvious?

I didn't say you were dangerous, I said religion was. You are simply unbelievably stupid and ignorant. I cannot really believe that anyone could be as dense as you profess to be. And it seems that religion is doing that to you, hence I think it is dangerous.

No, in fact, I think you are dangerous. You are even warning us that you might follow the laws of the OT if we got you to believe that the Bible did tell you so. What would you not do, I wonder? Would you fly an air-plane full of passengers into a building if you thought that the bible told you to?

All I've done is this thread (before it went down this current road) was question everyone's interpretation of it.

Liar!
 
How could it be anybody else's responsibility if another person decided to take a course of action on the basis of being convinced by something they said? (Unless that person was not in a sane frame of mind or something, of course). I cannot believe that is what ACS intends.

I agree with Icnneumonwasp about what this argument is about, btw. But I cannot see what the problem is. For me the passage is clear. I cannot see the ambiguity in the words which seems to be evident to ACS. I wonder if you could parse it to show this, in terms adapted to the meanest understanding ? Because it seems perfectly plain english to me, so I am puzzled
 
Because most religious people aren't fundie enough for you? Would you rather people like ASC just bit the bullet and started stoning people for violating ancient hebrew customs? :confused:

That's quite a stretch.
Tradition is as important as sacred texts to religion -- in practise, if not in theory. The majority interpretation of the NT is that the OT laws don't apply.

I'm not entirely sure how Christians manage to interpret the verse in the OP as being against follwing the OT. I've tried to understand a bit of that from ACS's comments. But it's tough -- because he has abandoned defending his case. He has started telling people not to disagree with him because to do so might acheive ends they don't want to acheive.

So what's your suggestion?
Give in to this threat? Let him win the debate because otherwise... What?
 
I'm not threatening anyone.

You are telling people that their actions will acheive ends they do not want to acheive. At some point you will count to 3... Probably via 2 and a half.

You're telling me that's what Christians are supposed to be doing. If I'm convinced of that I'll research how the Jews accomplished it and go from there.

I'm not telling you to do anything. I'm not even telling you which interpretation you have to believe. I'm trying to understand why you hold the interpretation you hold. One of the ways I investigate this is to say: "It means something else to me when I read it." That way you might understand something about our viewpoints and be able to explain why they are different.
 
Last edited:
I agree with Icnneumonwasp about what this argument is about, btw. But I cannot see what the problem is. For me the passage is clear. I cannot see the ambiguity in the words which seems to be evident to ACS. I wonder if you could parse it to show this, in terms adapted to the meanest understanding ? Because it seems perfectly plain english to me, so I am puzzled

I did that in the first four pages somewhere. Found it. Here is where I first posted: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3702481#post3702481 According to the majority here I'm wrong though. I'm just saying it's not as clear and apparent as many take it to be. By the way - I focused on Verse 19 because that was claimed to be the most obvious verse.
 
Last edited:
But it's tough -- because he has abandoned defending his case. He has started telling people not to disagree with him because to do so might acheive ends they don't want to acheive.

Because people all of a sudden said they were not telling me Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws, which we had been discussing in relation to those verses.
 
Because people all of a sudden said they were not telling me Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws, which we had been discussing in relation to those verses.

If you're having this many problems understanding what people are saying on an internet forum, it's no wonder you have trouble interpreting the Bible.
 
If you're having this many problems understanding what people are saying on an internet forum, it's no wonder you have trouble interpreting the Bible.

Nope. Sorry. If people are now claiming they aren't arguing the position they had then this can end. If people are still arguing the same point then admit it and we can continue.

But don't tell me you're arguing X when you really mean G and that you prefer me to choose Q not X. Any of you logics experts have any idea what sort of argument that is?
 
Because most religious people aren't fundie enough for you?

Read what I said: religion is dangerous and harmful because it builds, supports and values the kind of stupidity we see in ASC.

Other than that: At least the fundies make sense on a level where others don't. They have shared areas where both don't make sense, though - hence I don't value either type of religion.

Would you rather people like ASC just bit the bullet and started stoning people for violating ancient hebrew customs? :confused:

No.

Re-read the thread for a detailed discussion of this particular kind of insanity:

Someone who claims to be a follower of Hitler would logicically have to try and kill as many Jews as possible.

Pointing that out doesn't mean I'd want them to kill anybody, Jew or not, though. It means that I simply doubt that they are actually following Hitler - or even wanting to, as the case may be.

I think hes saying he respects people like Osama bin Laden more than you 'cause at least they kill people with "honesty, sincerity and integrity".

I respect neither ASC nor Osama bin Laden. Not being a murderous terrorists isn't the kind of achievement that I deem worthy of respect.


If it makes you happy: I prefer the likes of ASC over the type of Osama bin Laden. But I don't think that one is as such better than the other. That ASC isn't a murderous terrorists is a mere coincident - maybe he just didn't get to those parts of his scripture yet or didn't develop the right kind of understanding of those words. That he might never do that doesn't make him a better person at all, though.
 
It's an honest question, and only one or two people have responded directly to it at this point.
On the contrary it was an ambiguous question, and after I requested clarification he repeated the same question unchanged. That is dishonest in my book.

I answered the question as clearly as possible in that circumstance.
 
Nope. Sorry. If people are now claiming they aren't arguing the position they had then this can end. If people are still arguing the same point then admit it and we can continue.

But don't tell me you're arguing X when you really mean G and that you prefer me to choose Q not X. Any of you logics experts have any idea what sort of argument that is?


Straw man?
 
A Christian Sceptic said:
But don't tell me you're arguing X when you really mean G and that you prefer me to choose Q not X. Any of you logics experts have any idea what sort of argument that is?
Straw man?

Nope.

X = According to Matthew Christians are supposed follow the Old Testament Laws.

G = The Bible is Contradictory.

Q = I prefer you not follow Christianity.

Choose Q not X even though we are arguing X.
 
OK. Robin thinks Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws.

Thanks.
You left out according the the words of Jesus reported in Matthew 5

In other words you refused to clarify your ambiguity, even after I asked you twice.

And then you acted as though I had answered the ambiguously worded question.

What desparate trouble your position must be in to resort to such desparate and dishonest tactics :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom