The atheists favorite bible verses

Also, if ACS doesn't think an atheist's opinion counts, why title the thread "The atheists favorite bible verses" and why post it in a skeptical forum?

Joe - did you read my OP? When those verses are used on this very forum they are never posted simply as an observation of what Matthew says. They are used as an argument or refutation as you point out.

I've laid out very clearly why this passage is one of an atheist's favorite. It is a powerful refutation to those who use the Bible as if it was an inerrant source of moral guidance and claim that the O.T. doesn't count because Jesus made it null and void by introducing his "new law".

Surely these observations are all on the topic.

When you make that claim to a Christian you are telling them they need to follow the Old Testament Laws. You're intent to show them it's contradictory is only apparent if you include other verses. If you post these Matthew verses solely you're telling the Christian they are obviously not obeying those verses, which Christians take as meaning they should. Why do they take it that way? Because they care what Jesus taught and you just told them they are not obeying Him. Your hope or thoughts on what they should do is that they'll not follow any of them, and I'm afraid to tell you your thoughts on them not following any laws doesn't matter. Jesus trumps you. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
Most people on this forum seem to understand each other most of the time and be participating in the same conversation. There are a few that nobody seems to be understanding or following: oddly enough, these people think the communication problem is everyone except them... they even give advice to all the others who aren't having this problem so that they can be more "logical" or "communicate better" as if they imagine themselves experts or role models on the subject.

Yet they are the worst at the qualities they seem to imagine others lacking! That amuses me. And it exemplifies my sig. quote.

Why does it not occur to ACS that the communication problems are coming from him? As is the failure of logic and coherency? Am I correct in my view that the majority of people following this thread understand that ACS tried to set up a common woo "gotcha" with his OP and did his damndest to convince himself that his bias regarding the topic is correct? While the majority responded that his question was disingenous and that no atheist was saying what he says they are saying and that whether someone "should" follow the teachings of their holybook requires a designation of "according to whom"?

His question was answered most excellently by very intelligent and funny people numerous times, and he pretended it was not --or claimed a straw man answer as opposed to their actual answer. At the same time he has refused to answer his own question and all other similar type questions with the yes or no criteria he demanded of others. Clearly, he's trying to "win" an argument that exists only in his head i.e.(evil atheists are trying to make moderate Christians into fundamentalists--they don't "appreciate" the bone of "moderation" us moderate xtians have tossed them.)

Is this the essence the majority is seeing? Am I missing something? Isn't this a typical woo thread started by the insincere question and then the usual tantrum-throwing we've come to expect when what the woo dishes out is served back? The usual stuff to avoid hearing what we are actually saying and avoid the hypocrisy of their viewpoint?
 
Last edited:
You really don't get the difference between saying "this is what the passage means" and "this is what I think you're supposed to do"?

I am sorry I do not seem to have made myself clear earlier. What I am trying to say is that if you believe that the bible is the word of God, then you have to do what it says. This is because it is what God says. It is not what the author of Matthew says, for example. It is not what any other human being says, either. It is the word of God. Really the word of God. I find it hard to enter this mindset but so far as I can understand it that is the claim.

You asked if the statements have a different meaning depending on who speaks them but I do not think that is really grasping the point. How it seems to me is that first you have to accept the premise above. If you do, then you still do not know what the rules are in every case because the words in the bible are often ambiguous. The Christian has to struggle hard to find an interpretation and because the bible is big it is not easy to reach a conclusion on one part without making a mess of you view of another bit. You and I (understandably) assume this is because it is inherently contradictory: but a Christian cannot possibly make the same asssumption. Because it is the word of God you see. It follows that the fault is in the Christian because it cannot be in god. It might be in the writer, because he might have been mistaken about the inspired nature of some of what he wrote; it might be in the translation; it might be in the limits of the believers intellect or in his faith. But it cannot be in god.

So the Christian has to work hard to find out what it is he has to believe and he is also human and he will come to conclusions in whatever way he does that. But once he has reached a conclusion about what the passage means then he has to do what it says. Because it is the word of God.

The bit where you and I see a choice - in this case where we conclude that it means you have to follow the OT Law but we think this is a bad idea and so we don't have to do it: that bit is missing for the Christian. Does that make more sense ?

ETA. @ Articulett. I do not wholly agree. I think the problem in communication is real and it is there because there is genuine difficulty in understanding each other's mindset.

ETA 2. I see ACS has said what I am trying to convey better than I have managed. Well I am letting myself off cos it is his mindset not mine :;
 
Last edited:
It would hardly be reasonable to disagree with your interpretation before knowing what it is.

Not to mention how you justify your interpretation. Where did it come from? How come Christians don't all interpret it the same way? Isn't their source supposed to be divine... shouldn't he have known to be clear? Shouldn't God or Jesus or whomever have know that every Christian would be picking and choosing the parts that make sense to them and reinterpreting or ignoring other parts as they see fit?? It seems a lame way to generate a holy book or moral guide if you ask me. It seems like it's only a moral guide ignorant people would adhere to --or claim to adhere to.
 
Last edited:
Your hope or thoughts on what they should do is that they'll not follow any of them, and I'm afraid to tell you your thoughts on them not following any laws doesn't matter. Jesus trumps you. Sorry.

Reality trumps your wretched delusions and pitiful aspirations. Sorry.
 
I am sorry I do not seem to have made myself clear earlier. What I am trying to say is that if you believe that the bible is the word of God, then you have to do what it says. This is because it is what God says. It is not what the author of Matthew says, for example. It is not what any other human being says, either. It is the word of God. Really the

<snip>

The bit where you and I see a choice - in this case where we conclude that it means you have to follow the OT Law but we think this is a bad idea and so we don't have to do it: that bit is missing for the Christian. Does that make more sense ?
.

I'll clarify this point even more - it's not even a matter of whether it's the word of God - it's even more specific of a claim you (the person making the argument) are making. You are claiming Jesus taught this (as recorded by Matthew). It doesn't matter if you making the argument don't even believe Jesus ever existed. A person who cares what Jesus taught will look into it. They'll decide what that means for them and then go from there.
 
I'll clarify this point even more - it's not even a matter of whether it's the word of God - it's even more specific of a claim you (the person making the argument) are making. You are claiming Jesus taught this (as recorded by Matthew). It doesn't matter if you making the argument don't even believe Jesus ever existed. A person who cares what Jesus taught will look into it. They'll decide what that means for them and then go from there.

But they don't! They clearly don't! They may want to, and perhaps are able to delude themselves into thinking they are - but they don't.
 
I know that the invisible guy trumps anything a mortal could say and all mortal laws... after all-- what wouldn't people do if they believed their eternity was at stake?

That's WHY religions scare me. Who knows what people are going to interpret their holy books to mean or their god to want. I am well aware that no believer in the "life is a test" for eternity nuttiness cares what a nonbeliever has to say about the subject. I am quite certain that ACS doesn't care what we really think about his holy book any more than Tom Cruise thinks that we think about his "inspired" texts. He has his own straw man view of what we think... and that's what he aims to prove to himself.

He can't prove the validity of his biblical interpretation or how or why he "chose" such an interpretation... so he has to pretend that atheists are demanding that he interpret it the way they do (or the way the words are written) or whatever. He cannot justify his getting his own "personal" meaning from a supposed divine text-- so he pretends this conversation is about something else-- "those evil atheists trying to force their interpretation on him".

It's like trying to tell people who believe they see the emperor's magical robes that there is no such thing as magical (invisible)robes. No matter how you try to get them to understand this... they won't-- they have to see you as the bad guy so they can keep their delusion of "magical robes" alive--a delusion that makes them feel mighty special, indeed (better than you even).
 
Last edited:
He can't prove the validity of his biblical interpretation or how or why he "chose" such an interpretation... so he has to pretend that atheists are demanding that he interpret it the way they do or the way the words are written or whatever.

Why would I have prove it to anyone? I'm not telling a single person here they need to accept it.

And I don't have to pretend atheists are demanding I see it how they interpret it - they've told me I was wrong and they were right.
 
Last edited:
What do you mean, Rasmus?

Christians do not follow the bible. It's not like the inconsistencies and problems and utterly reprehensible laws and rules it contains are new.

If Christians on average had even a trace of desire to actually follow the Bible, they would follow the Bible.

But they aren't. At large, they ignore these issues. When they are pointed out specifically, Christians tend to deny them, or explain them away.

Where are all the Christians that do follow the bible? Even if some passages are ambiguous, there should be large numbers of Christians that favour the interpretation that demands that they should follow Old Testament laws. Where are they?
 
Fiona, the ignorance is deliberate. They could plug in any other woo...or answer our questions or their own questions using the same silly yes or no criteria... and they would understand us completely. But they don't. Why don't they? They prefer their ignorance, bias, and self important delusions over understanding and the truth.

I know... I mean, I really DO understand the miscommunication. I was brought up with the whole meme... I present the questions that helped me think my way out. It won't change ACS--but lots of people read these forums... and who knows what seeds are planted. I am glad for the critical thinking seeds that have sprouted in my brain, and I hope I pass on what I've learned to those who might further it. I have ACS on ignore. I am quite certain he's here to spin his own delusion. He repeats the same nothingness over and over and over. I just enjoy the responses. He does cause other people to think. And he illustrates some of the problems with the way faith based thinking is the OPPOSITE of critical thinking... it's not ennobling; it's stupefying. He makes no sense. Religion makes no sense. So many words... nothing of value communicated. It's all about building up a feeling or belief in the believers head!

To the believer, skeptics are often used as masturbatory sounding boards so they can tell themselves they've considered the topic critically. That's why I pop in on occasion to warn others to engage them for entertainment purposes... but to keep expectations low. I've learned some things, and I hope to pass on the info. so that the people I find insightful don't think the problem is them as the woo so often infer. I find ACS, Aku, DR, Herzy, and RR part of the ick ilk-- I find everyone else in this thread comprehensible and hope that they don't let the above irritate them too much. Some of my favorite posters have posted on this thread and had the usual drivel tossed at them by the ick ilk. I don't want such people to think that they need to defend themselves from the woo straw men interpretations of what they have said. Nobody is following the ick ilk. Their commentary appear to be only for themselves and the conversation going on in their head.

And yes... anosognosia. I know that some people cannot realize they are the people with the problems they imagine in others... just as crazy people often can't realize they are crazy people. I understand that I MUST be a "bad guy" to those people--because I have said the thing they so desperately don't want to be true. But if I don't-- the "faith in faith" inanity spreads. So I don't mind being seen as mean or harsh. No matter what I say to such people or about such people, they will hear it as an attack. I've decided that I don't care what they think or feel any more than they care what I think or feel. I want to give others the verbal tools, I wish I had when I was thinking my way out of the miasma. And I am learning better tools from others' who respond.
 
Last edited:
When you make that claim to a Christian you are telling them they need to follow the Old Testament Laws.
No, I'm not. This goes back to the distinction you fail to see between me saying, "The author of Matthew states that you should obey every law of the O.T" and me saying, "You need to follow the O.T. laws."

I am not the author of the Gospel of Matthew.


You're intent to show them it's contradictory is only apparent if you include other verses.
Yes. I'll grant you that you need at least two propositions before there's a contradiction. The inconsistency is the idea that Bible is an inerrant moral source and the fact that you have to pick and choose which parts of it count (in contradiction to this passage says it all counts).

If you post these Matthew verses solely you're telling the Christian they are obviously not obeying those verses, which Christians take as meaning they should.
No. I'm telling Christians who use the argument that the old law is null and void that this passage refutes that claim. I am most certainly not telling them they should obey the old laws. I have said as much over 50 times now.

Because they care what Jesus taught and you just told them they are not obeying Him. Your hope or thoughts on what they should do is that they'll not follow any of them, and I'm afraid to tell you your thoughts on them not following any laws doesn't matter. Jesus trumps you. Sorry.
What?
First off, there are plenty of Christians who simply don't think this passage reflects what Jesus wants. There are plenty of Christians who read this passage in the context of the period of time it was written when there was a bit of controversy as to whether Jesus' teachings were for Jews only.

I think your problem is that you take it on faith that these words in Matthew are indeed the exact words of your deity. I know plenty of Christians who are educated enough to realize that that is almost certainly not the case.
 
Last edited:
But they don't! They clearly don't! They may want to, and perhaps are able to delude themselves into thinking they are - but they don't.

Phelps does... as do those who consider themselves the "most faithful".

But most people who claim to believe in Jesus or the bible haven't read much of it and yet they presume they know what it says and means and that they have gotten their morality from there and that they are saved or better or more moral because of this. Most believers sound pretty much like ACS from what I see-- incoherent, circular, tangential. They want to believe that they "follow the bible" or Jesus or god or whatever because they believe this is the key to salvation. But they have no evidence for any of it-- so they spin their delusion as best they can with parlor tricks, semantics, and straw men. I don't think they really know what they believe or why or how much they believe it or how it influences them.
 
Last edited:
You are claiming Jesus taught this (as recorded by Matthew). It doesn't matter if you making the argument don't even believe Jesus ever existed.
How could I possibly be claiming Jesus taught this if I don't believe Jesus ever existed? Surely that matters.

I have never claimed that Jesus taught this. I have said that the author of Matthew wrote this. In fact, I'd say rather than Jesus speaking through the author of Matthew, it's really the author of Matthew speaking through Jesus in this narrative.
 
Well you may be right, Articulett and Rasmus. I have no background at all in religion, so I am less well-qualified to speak about it. It seems absolutely clear to me that there are very different thought premises but I cannot put my hand on my heart and say that if I were to debate with people who attacked my particular way of approaching problems ( as distinct from the content of my conclusions) that I would be easily persuaded to abandon a critical approach. I wouldn't. I do not expect those who come to things in a different way to abandon their approach either. I think it is my responsibility to try to understand how they think and if possible why they think that way. After all they are not idiots; nor malicious; at least not by definition.

If you are right and they wish to use me and you to feel good at having stood up to sceptical scrutiny, what harm does that do me? Some at least must be trying as hard as I am to grasp how the "other" thinks. I have said before that I have learned a lot from thoughtful catholics and so I stand to gain at least some of the time. Perhaps they do too, who knows? (ACS and other religious people here, I am sorry if this sounds like I am talking about you as if you aren't here: I am but I do not mean it disrespectfully)

As to following the bible, Rasmus. I think some sincerely try to reconcile all the contradictory bits and to reconcile the whole thing with the part which make them Christian in the first place: often the parts which I can respect, though I do not believe they come from God or from religion. I do not have to integrate bad parts of the Bible with my moral outlook. But I do have to integrate genocide and a whole lot of other things with a belief in the essential goodness of man. So I have my problems and my irrationalities and my blind spots as much as anyone else. I am not really in a position to stare at a religious person's mote :D
 
Fiona, I think I get what you're saying and see where I diverge from your take.
What I am trying to say is that if you believe that the bible is the word of God, then you have to do what it says.
I think it's not so black and white for many Christians. I have most knowledge of Catholic teaching, and I know they regard the Bible as "the word of God" or divinely inspired or however you want to phrase it, but they do not consider it to be inerrant or devoid of historical context.

I'll check with a Jesuit friend in the next day or two for their take on this particular Matthew passage, but I'll be surprised if it isn't pretty close to what I have said (about the early church's controversy regarding gentiles).

This is because it is what God says. It is not what the author of Matthew says, for example. It is not what any other human being says, either. It is the word of God. Really the word of God. I find it hard to enter this mindset but so far as I can understand it that is the claim.
I think that extreme view is only held by a minority of Christians. Maybe I'm wrong, but at the very least there are certainly Christians who don't hold that extreme a view of the Bible.

You asked if the statements have a different meaning depending on who speaks them but I do not think that is really grasping the point.
Yes, I fail to see how the two statements can be seen as equivalent or how that would be changed depending on who speaks them.


My emphasis below:
How it seems to me is that first you have to accept the premise above. If you do, then you still do not know what the rules are in every case because the words in the bible are often ambiguous. The Christian has to struggle hard to find an interpretation and because the bible is big it is not easy to reach a conclusion on one part without making a mess of you view of another bit. You and I (understandably) assume this is because it is inherently contradictory: but a Christian cannot possibly make the same asssumption. Because it is the word of God you see. It follows that the fault is in the Christian because it cannot be in god. It might be in the writer, because he might have been mistaken about the inspired nature of some of what he wrote; it might be in the translation; it might be in the limits of the believers intellect or in his faith. But it cannot be in god.
I agree that the problem is difficult for those Christian who accept the extreme premise you stated before.

There are Christians that don't fit that category.

So again, when I say, "According to this passage in Matthew, you're supposed to obey all the laws of the O.T." it is not the same as saying, "I think you're supposed to obey all the laws of the O.T." Not only do I think a Christian could make both those statements, I think a Christian scholar or priest could make those statements.

So again, when I argue that the passage means that the O.T. laws are still in effect, I am not saying that Christians are supposed to obey all the O.T. laws. I'm saying that the passage says that.

It is a big problem for those who think the Bible is an inerrant moral guide. And again, if it's not inerrant, it can't be a moral guide because you'd have to have some external moral guide to tell you which parts are wrong. It'd be sort of like having a map that only works if you already know how to get where you're going.

Speaking again from the Catholic tradition, I think this is partly why Catholic lay people aren't encouraged to read the Bible on their own. It's the word of God, but depends greatly on the teaching authority of the Church for guiding through all these issues. (Again, I'm pretty sure a priest would say don't worry about this Matthew passage because it had to do with an issue that faced the early church which has long since been resolved--that is, they believe their church to be catholic--that is, universal--and not a religion just for those who adhere to the old Jewish laws.)
 
Well you may be right, Articulett and Rasmus. I have no background at all in religion, so I am less well-qualified to speak about it. It seems absolutely clear to me that there are very different thought premises but I cannot put my hand on my heart and say that if I were to debate with people who attacked my particular way of approaching problems ( as distinct from the content of my conclusions) that I would be easily persuaded to abandon a critical approach. I wouldn't. I do not expect those who come to things in a different way to abandon their approach either. I think it is my responsibility to try to understand how they think and if possible why they think that way. After all they are not idiots; nor malicious; at least not by definition.

If ACS isn't an idiot in any possible sense of the word I would just love to hear your definition of what an idiot is and I'd wonder if such a person even exists.

The problem is not changing ones approach or viewpoint, but refusing to acknowledge that a position other than your own even exits. And that is what ACS keeps doing here: He utterly refuses to accept that the arguments other people make rest on premises different than his own. (These other people might very well be mistaken; that isn't the point here.)

If you are right and they wish to use me and you to feel good at having stood up to sceptical scrutiny, what harm does that do me?

As long as you are aware of it and willingly let them proceed: None, quite possibly.

Some at least must be trying as hard as I am to grasp how the "other" thinks. I have said before that I have learned a lot from thoughtful catholics and so I stand to gain at least some of the time.

Oh, I have learned a lot from religious people. And if they ever prove that one of their various gods exists, I might even consider taking their religion(s) seriously. But I won't be holding my breath and I will not make the mistake to attribute what these people thought me to their religions.

As to following the bible, Rasmus. I think some sincerely try to reconcile all the contradictory bits and to reconcile the whole thing with the part which make them Christian in the first place: often the parts which I can respect, though I do not believe they come from God or from religion.

But that is the problem: If you believe that the stuff comes from God, then "love your neighbour" is equally good and god given and holy as is "stone every disobedient child".

There is nothing that you need to reconcile there if you want to follow the bible. All you have to do is kill children. (It's not really difficult. They are small and not very strong. They won't fight back much!) That the thought alone makes you squeamish is a shortcoming in you - if you want to follow the bible, that is. There is no difference in lusting after your neighbour's wife and being unwilling to kill little children: Both are sinful thoughts that you shouldn't even have, much less act upon.

I do not have to integrate bad parts of the Bible with my moral outlook. But I do have to integrate genocide and a whole lot of other things with a belief in the essential goodness of man.

There is something seriously wrong with you if you want to claim that Hitler was essentially a good person. Any definition of "good" that leaves room for murdering several million people i consider problematic at best.

So I have my problems and my irrationalities and my blind spots as much as anyone else. I am not really in a position to stare at a religious person's mote :D

That depends on how you explain Hitler. Do you keep changing what "good" means, and ignoring all the hideously bad stuff Hitler did, or do you simply adjust your basic belief to a slightly watered down version? ("Most people are generally good, but sometimes do bad things, and some people at least are outright bad, even if they sometimes do a few good things.")
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom