The atheists favorite bible verses

@JoeTheJuggler. I do know that there are other ways to interpret bits of the Bible so that they are not a problem for particular Christians and for some sects. I did list a few things which help them to reach a conclusion which is different from mine on this issue and you named one of them quite early on: the internal dissension as whether Christianity was only for jews is well known and I believe that Paul is sometimes described as the apostle for the gentiles (something like that, anyway). As I said, sometimes it is possible to decide the writer was mistaken about the inspired nature of some of his work. That does not really tell me that the Christian's default position is not that the Bible is the word of God, however: just that they have to work and think hard to decide what to make of it, especially where it contradicts itself or where it contradicts what they feel to be decent behaviour. The very fact that you note that the catholic laity is not encouraged to read it by themselves seems to support my understanding, actually: does it not suggest that the church teaches it is the word of God but acknowledges its complexity; rather than that they deny what you term an "extreme view"? Maybe not. Like I said I have no background in this and I certainly don't want to misrepresent anyone. It just seems to me that there is a difference between a literalist view of the bible and a "fundamentalist" view if by the latter you can accept it to mean a belief that the bible is the (imperfectly rendered) word of god? Indeed I think your own argument shows this must be true. It cannot be a moral guide if it is not inerrant: so there has to be a real effort to integrate it all and a lot of concensus to throw bits out as not inspired
 
Last edited:
...snip...

Speaking again from the Catholic tradition, I think this is partly why Catholic lay people aren't encouraged to read the Bible on their own. It's the word of God, but depends greatly on the teaching authority of the Church for guiding through all these issues. (Again, I'm pretty sure a priest would say don't worry about this Matthew passage because it had to do with an issue that faced the early church which has long since been resolved--that is, they believe their church to be catholic--that is, universal--and not a religion just for those who adhere to the old Jewish laws.)

You would be mostly correct. The whole edifice of the RCC is based on the idea that it is the living church, that it is only through the church that people are brought to salvation. The doctrines, lessons, preachings of the RCC should be more important to a RC than the text of the Bible.

It's only the Protestant Christians that believe that scripture (the Bible) is the only authority on spiritual matters. It's really only the followers of protestant variations of Christianity that find this type of contradiction in the Bible problematic. (Never mind the fact that Catholics and Protestants have different bibles!)
 
Last edited:
I do have to integrate genocide and a whole lot of other things with a belief in the essential goodness of man.
I don't necessarily believe in the essential goodness of man. I think science has actually done more than religion to make "goodness" easier to practice.

A lot of the outright barbarity we see in the bible is a result of the harsh environment in which it was written. In a time when a pair of shoes and a water jug made you "middle class," when food was scarce and lotion for your feet was a luxury, it's easier to understand how people could be driven to genocide, as famine drives people to genocide in Africa today.

By making it possible to grow not only sufficient, but surplus, crops, science has made theft and murder to satisfy one's basic needs unnecessary for large numbers of people.

Listen to the accounts of good Christians and Jews who spent time in Nazi death camps or participated in the Bataan Death March. There are lots of accounts of people who stole from their fellow prisoners who were too sick or weak to prevent it, or who betrayed their fellow prisoners for a better chance at survival for themselves. The famous aborted college experiment in which one group played guards and another group played prisoners highlighted just how situational a lot of ethical behavior can be.

I think people need civilized society to be good.
 
If ACS isn't an idiot in any possible sense of the word I would just love to hear your definition of what an idiot is and I'd wonder if such a person even exists.

Well challenged :) I suppose I would say that an idiot is one who has not the mental capacity to learn in the same way as the rest of us. One way this might show is an inability to learn to tie shoelaces: another might be an inability to attain the stage of abstract thinking and formal operations (a form or arrested development if you like) I would exclude everyone who is normally competent in the tasks of every day life: and everyone who can construct a rational argument if you accept the premises they adopt. Not sure if that helps.

The problem is not changing ones approach or viewpoint, but refusing to acknowledge that a position other than your own even exits. And that is what ACS keeps doing here: He utterly refuses to accept that the arguments other people make rest on premises different than his own. (These other people might very well be mistaken; that isn't the point here.)

Well I am not sure that is true. I have been attempting in the last few posts to determine what his premises might be. I am not there yet. I hope he has been doing the same. Seems to be an uphill struggle for us all :)

As long as you are aware of it and willingly let them proceed: None, quite possibly.

I agree

Oh, I have learned a lot from religious people. And if they ever prove that one of their various gods exists, I might even consider taking their religion(s) seriously. But I won't be holding my breath and I will not make the mistake to attribute what these people thought me to their religions.

Well in my experience some of what they taught me did come from their religion, but only in the limited sense that they seemed to have a deeper appreciation of the complexities of morality than I do myself. I think this is because when they ran across a moral problem as children or as young teenagers they had access to people who took those worries seriously: I did not. I had to kind of work it out for myself and that is quite a slow process. I am quite retarded in this field in some ways, though I try. There is a benefit in having a tradition to draw on even though it has a big downside as well.


But that is the problem: If you believe that the stuff comes from God, then "love your neighbour" is equally good and god given and holy as is "stone every disobedient child".

There is nothing that you need to reconcile there if you want to follow the bible. All you have to do is kill children. (It's not really difficult. They are small and not very strong. They won't fight back much!) That the thought alone makes you squeamish is a shortcoming in you - if you want to follow the bible, that is. There is no difference in lusting after your neighbour's wife and being unwilling to kill little children: Both are sinful thoughts that you shouldn't even have, much less act upon.

I suspect that is disingenuous but in case it is not I will refer you to the distinction I made between literalism and fundamentalism in an earlier post

There is something seriously wrong with you if you want to claim that Hitler was essentially a good person. Any definition of "good" that leaves room for murdering several million people i consider problematic at best.

Yes it is a bit problematic. I am working on it :p



That depends on how you explain Hitler. Do you keep changing what "good" means, and ignoring all the hideously bad stuff Hitler did, or do you simply adjust your basic belief to a slightly watered down version? ("Most people are generally good, but sometimes do bad things, and some people at least are outright bad, even if they sometimes do a few good things.")

Well I am not alone in being uncomfortable with the notions of good and bad: why there are people on this very board who deny that any action which is survival oriented can have any moral value at all. We do what we can, do we not?
 
What JoetJ and Darat said. I follow completely. It's sounds to me like what the majority is saying and understanding.

How does the theist "decide" what parts of the divine text to take seriously and how to interpret those things and why isn't there any agreement? Why don't the words just mean what they say? Why does anyone think this is a book of morality-- whose morality? Which interpretation? Which parts? What are parables and what is real? What are directives? What rubric gets you to "live happily ever after"? Which revelations? Which saviors? Which prophets? How do you KNOW??! It's crazy. It makes no sense. Even if I thought there was some god that wanted me to believe some way or follow some commandments-- who would I go to tell me which laws and which version are to be followed to which extent and how would I control what I "believe" or "feel" or "love" anyhow? I can't even make sense of "thou shall not kill" given all the killing in the bible (including Jesus) or the fact that you can't really kill any one who has an immortal soul-- you can just start their eternity earlier... their pass/fail celebration (or damnation). And who cares when the beginning of an eternity starts unless it affects how that eternity is going to be? Doesn't the Omniscient One know the final outcome of this charade?

And it's not like it says, "thou shall not kill humans"-- what exactly can't you kill? Plants, animals, bacteria... it does NOT say. And that's just one little piece of guidance-- the whole text-- like all "scriptures" are filled with this kind of miasma. And people think it's a source of divine truth?? Moral guidance? They think that they are better for "believing in" it? For twisting it to make sense to them?

I fail to find any reason to think anyone should take any of it seriously or as a moral guide... I think the people who say they take it as a moral guide, don't actually take it as a moral guide. I think they just want to BELIEVE they do... because they believe that faith is the ticket to salvation! But everyone has the same dilemma that I illustrated above in regards to which faith and which parts etc. so they just stop thinking about the whole thing... they tell themselves that they believe the "right "stuff" and make anyone who points out what they are doing into bad guys (who are supposedly trying to get them to do evil things as advised by the text they call holy.) They focus their energies on the delusion, so they don't have to think about the implications as outlined above!
 
Last edited:
Ok I'll try again.

Although Christians are not to follow OT law, they must assent to its divinity. If a Christian does not assent to the righteousness of the OT laws, what is the justification for existing as a religion?

More simply - IF you met a perfectly righteous person they would be someone who followed all the OT laws. But there are no righteous people, so through Jesus as Christ, faith in Christ is counted as if it were adherence to the laws - "righteousness". This is the New Covenant that replaced the Old.

To believe that somehow God was wrong in the OT, or "evolved", is viewed as heresy. You might be a Mormon or some other fringe religion and believe that, but not mainstream Protestant or Catholic.

What I don't understand, is a Christian tendency to deny their own reason for being, and say that Christ 'did away with all that'. The inherent righteousness of OT law is never denied in the NT, only claimed that adherence was impossible (without God).
 
PLUS Jesus' cruicifixion (the basis of the whole Christian religion) is premised upon the old testament--especially the OT genesis story, right? Original Sin? If the OT doesn't count or genesis is just a parable--then why isn't Jesus? Or all of it? How do theists rationalize away this miasma of contradiction, inconsistency, and incoherency?

I claim that they do so by NOT THINKING about it--claiming that it's all "part of the mystery"... and by vilifying all those who try to get them to see this.

And I'm supposed to think there's something wrong with me for pointing this out?
 
Last edited:
I'll clarify this point even more - it's not even a matter of whether it's the word of God - it's even more specific of a claim you (the person making the argument) are making. You are claiming Jesus taught this (as recorded by Matthew). It doesn't matter if you making the argument don't even believe Jesus ever existed. A person who cares what Jesus taught will look into it. They'll decide what that means for them and then go from there.
Of course. I tried to explain this to Joe in my post #371, http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3709984&postcount=371

Obviously without much clarity, Fiona did a better job here. Well done. A Christian defines itself by following what Jesus Christ says, period. Hence, an assertion like "JC taught a certain conduct" is automatically binding, for a Christian, if accepted to be true.
 
Last edited:
I wonder how many Christians struggling with their faith will see ACS' posts here, and recognize that any faith that requires its adherents to practice such tortured logic and dishonesty is worthless. If he saves just one individual from a life of pretending there is a magic fairy in the sky, it will all be worth it.
 
Obviously without much clarity, Fiona did a better job here. Well done. A Christian defines itself by following what Jesus Christ says, period. Hence, an assertion like "JC taught a certain conduct" is automatically binding, for a Christian, if accepted to be true.
First, as noted above (in discussion of the Roman Catholic Church's view of the Bible), your rules aren't the rules that all Christians use.

Also, what you just said isn't the statement in question. What about the statement, "The author of Matthew says Jesus taught a certain conduct"? Does that automatically create a binding rule for all Christians?

I'm certain it does not.
 
You would be mostly correct. The whole edifice of the RCC is based on the idea that it is the living church, that it is only through the church that people are brought to salvation. The doctrines, lessons, preachings of the RCC should be more important to a RC than the text of the Bible.

It's only the Protestant Christians that believe that scripture (the Bible) is the only authority on spiritual matters. It's really only the followers of protestant variations of Christianity that find this type of contradiction in the Bible problematic. (Never mind the fact that Catholics and Protestants have different bibles!)

Thanks, Darat. I'll still consult my Jesuit friend and another friend who is an ex-seminarian (Catholic).

Are all Protestants that strict about the Bible as THE word of God? I thought there were quite a few very progressive Protestant churches. I can't imagine anyone with any amount of education (or at least an awareness of the many Biblical contradictions, errors, altered translations, etc.) who could espouse that view.

I realize "Protestants" are a monolithic group of people either. In fact, aren't there some different Bibles even among Protestant religions? (Perhaps not as different as any Protestant Bible is from a Catholic one. . .)
 
But I have come across atheists using these verses alot here. (And no - Darat - I won't post a link to all the examples in the forum so don't bother asking me to prove that statement)

In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally. I'm sure you know why they would like to make that case. ;)

Now - the only place I've ever come across that teaching is here and the only people I've ever heard insist that's how to interpret those verses are atheists.

So - if you'd like to play along and take up the challenge -

Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.
Thanks.
I think you are looking for those Torah-submissive Christians:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torah-submissive_Christian

To check what the most christian denominations think of "Torah-submission", namely nothing, see here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblical_law_in_Christianity
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sermon_on_the_Mount

Let's check for the biggest denomination:

The Double Standard View is the official position of the Catholic Church. It divides the teachings of the Sermon into general precepts and specific counsels. Obedience to the general precepts is essential for salvation, but obedience to the counsels is only necessary for perfection. The great mass of the population need only concern themselves with the precepts; the counsels must be followed by only a pious few such as the clergy and monks.

Hence, the Roman Catholic view's grossly: from the OT follow the 10 commandments, and you're OK.

H.
 
Last edited:
First, as noted above (in discussion of the Roman Catholic Church's view of the Bible), your rules aren't the rules that all Christians use.
Sorry? Where does the catechism of any christian church conflict with their own understanding of JC's words? That sounds weird to me, but I might misunderstand here.

Also, what you just said isn't the statement in question. What about the statement, "The author of Matthew says Jesus taught a certain conduct"? Does that automatically create a binding rule for all Christians?

I'm certain it does not.
You might want to check the importance of the Sermon on the Mount

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sermon_on_the_Mount

That answers your question, I think.
 
Last edited:
Are all Christian religions that are not Catholic, considered "protestant offshoots"? Are Baptists? Amish? Evangelicals? Mormons? Pentacostals? Isn't protestantism "protests" of the first "Christianity"? I was raised Catholic, and I was told "Christian" meant "Christ like"--but I've come to learn that Christians don't agree who is Christian much less what it means and who is interpreting which words the right way. I mean... I know everyone thinks "their" interpretation is right-- but as a kid I found the whole thing insane.

Conviction certainly couldn't be a sign of "rightness" since lots of people seemed very convinced of conflicting information... and yet most Gods seem to demand that sort of "faith"... or so the convinced tell me. They all act like they are getting their messages via god via the bible or some prophet or church leader-- but they sure aren't getting the same messages. Clearly, they are all picking and choosing their beliefs to fit them and then claiming their morality comes from god, and is thus "superior" or "salvation worthy". The assorted religions never seem to worry about going to the other religions' hells ,though they are seem certain that those others aren't "saved" while they are.

I think religion is insanity. I don't think anyone should follow any of it. I think it's funny when people say they are, but they don't even seem to have a clue as to what it is they are following nor where their "directives" are coming from.
 
Last edited:
To believe that somehow God was wrong in the OT, or "evolved", is viewed as heresy. You might be a Mormon or some other fringe religion and believe that, but not mainstream Protestant or Catholic.

Not exactly. I have my Bible here, and it is the Fireside Family Edition of the New American Bible,published in the 1970s under the supervision of His Holiness, Pope Paul VI. It is extensively footnoted with explanatory introductions from a Catholic perspective.

In the introduction to the Book of Ecclesiastes, it says, "The moral teaching of the book is imperfect, like the Old Testament itself (Heb 7, 19), yet it marks an advance in the development of the doctrine of divine retribution. While rejecting the older solution of earthly rewards and punishments, Ecclesiastes looks forward to a more lasting one. The clear answer to the problem was to come with the light of Christ's teaching concerning future life."

So, according to Catholics, it is not true that God was wrong in the OT, but it is true that some of the OT is wrong, or, to be generous, incomplete and misleading.

As it turns out, that little phrase played a key role in my conversion from Catholic to atheist. The realization that even the Church could spot holes in the Bible made me reconsider whether it made sense to believe any of it, and a few weeks after I read that passage, I concluded it did not.

P.S. For those who can't find a Bible handy, Heb 7, 19 says, "for the law brought nothing to perfection. But a better hope has supervened, and through it we draw near to God."
 
Sorry? Where does the catechism of any christian church conflict with their own understanding of JC's words? That sounds weird to me, but I might misunderstand here.
Yeah, I noticed that you misunderstand a lot.

How about this?--just because the author of Matthew said that Jesus said it doesn't mean every Christian believes it was Jesus' words.

In fact, as I pointed out, it's pretty easy to prove that none of the direct quotes were Jesus' actual words. Furthermore it is probable that none of the 4 gospels were written by eyewitnesses to the events.
 
Yeah, I noticed that you misunderstand a lot.

How about this?--just because the author of Matthew said that Jesus said it doesn't mean every Christian believes it was Jesus' words.

In fact, as I pointed out, it's pretty easy to prove that none of the direct quotes were Jesus' actual words. Furthermore it is probable that none of the 4 gospels were written by eyewitnesses to the events.

You are so wrong.
 
Still at cross purposes I think.

Herzblut said:
Hence, an assertion like "JC taught a certain conduct" is automatically binding, for a Christian, if accepted to be true.
(my bold)

JoeTheJuggler said:
just because the author of Matthew said that Jesus said it doesn't mean every Christian believes it was Jesus' words.

You are both right. If a Christian comes to believe a statement is truly part of Christ's teaching, and satisfies himself as to what it means, either through thought;or argument; or his church's doctrine; or his Ph.D research or in any other way, then he is bound to do what it tells him to do.

There are many Christian sects, and they do not agree on which statements in the Bible are true. There are literalists, but I think they need not concern us here. Mainstream Christians do, to a greater or lesser extent, accept that not everything in the bible is to be taken literally, for all the reasons already mentioned: error by the writer; translation error; interpretation error etc etc etc.

The churches have doctrine, and at its best it represent the best efforts of intelligent and honest people to reconcile the contradictions in the Bible over a long period of time. Some of what they say strikes me as trivial (number of angels on a pinhead is the usual example cited to demonstrate this kind of thing - not sure if it was ever actually a debate but it does speak to the way such arguments can become terribly divorced from the price of fish): some seems tortured and sophistical ( is that even a word :confused:): some is quite profound. But however it strikes me, it always appears to be very very important to the religious and they spend a lot of time and effort at it.

In another thread I expressed my surprise that Americans seem to have no difficulty in changing denomination: that turned out to be only partially true but it is apparently more true than it is in Europe. The paragraph above reprises why it so surprises me, and why I think the idea of changing from, say, catholic to baptist is so odd to the european mind.

Not all Christians do this work for themselves, and some take no interest at all. This is because many people are "culturally" religious only. But there are "faith believers" and there are "intellectual believers", to draw a crude distinction. They are all, to some extent, dependent on faith; but some are dependent on it only for the premise God exists: others are dependent on it to reconcile the contradictions in the bible and they may take it on faith without thought: or on faith that the church is doing the work for them and if they bothered to research they would find the answers in the doctrine. The latter is not much different to my own approach to science. I do not do the work myself. I accept much on "faith" that the scientists are doing the work properly and that peer review and the method is valid: so I accept what the scietists tell me most of the time.

For the atheist looking at all this these religious differences (and they all overlap, as human stuff tends to, so I am not making black and white groupings here) it is hard to see why our knock down arguments do not persuade the religious. It is easy to believe the religious are dishonest if they seem to ignore what appear to be obvious facts and obvious inferences. But I honestly don't think they are. There really is a different mindset and it takes work to understand it. That does not mean I have to accept it, but it does mean I have to start from the idea that folk are honest in what they say.

Critical thinkers value certain types of approach and we believe that the truth is the same for everyone and that knowledge can be based on hard evidence and replicable findings. That is great for the fields where it applies; but it does not apply to morality (and I personally believe it has been overextended into what is called social science, but that is a whole other argument). I think that the religious use a lot of the same tools we do when they come to "unscientific" issues. It is true that they have often used their set of tools inappropriately in fields where science works better: but I think some so-called sceptics do that too, and we see fundie evolutionists who think there is no moral or political question which cannot be answered by the tenet "survival of the fittest" (see reverbision's recent thread "biology and government" for a prime example).

Sorry I am perhaps rambling. In short all Christians must be bound by the word of god once they decide what it is. But it is also true that this does not lead to literal acceptance of the whole bible and we do them a disservice to pretend that it does. So you are both correct, as I said
 
Luke 1
Introduction
1Many have undertaken to draw up an account of the things that have been fulfilled[a] among us, 2just as they were handed down to us by those who from the first were eyewitnesses and servants of the word. 3Therefore, since I myself have carefully investigated everything from the beginning, it seemed good also to me to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus, 4so that you may know the certainty of the things you have been taught.
 
Er.....that proves JoeTheJuggler's statement, Edge. Was that what you intended?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom