The atheists favorite bible verses

When Jesus had finished this sermon, the crowds were astonished at His teaching, because He was teaching them like one who had authority, and not like their scribes.
I like this phrase, an image pops up in my mind of a totally stunned crowd, not understanding an iota of what they've been told actually. "Wow! I didn't understand a single word but, hey!, this guy speaks with authority."

It is clear that such a huge, complex lesson can only be taught to and understood by experts, his disciples.

The crowd was mainly around for receiving some healing miracle services from JC, I think.
 
Let me give you some adhoc definitions I think of:

Meaning of a biblical passage is

- what a substancial amount of christians believe it to be the meaning
- what the Church teaches it to be the meaning.

If you have better definitions, go ahead!


OK, I'll give it a shot. How about what wins in an argument -- the interpretation that works best and makes most sense of the words in sequence and in context within the larger language community and not simply the interpretation preferred by a group with vested interests?

Your definitions seem considerably lacking to me.

Suppose, for sake of argument, a passage of text within some religious community says "The sky is blue" and that religious sect, whose teacher didn't like blue for some reason and in some other context, decides that the text really means "The sky is red." Do you mean to say that a text that says "The sky is blue" really means "The sky is red" simply because a group of people believe that is what it means? Even when it is clear to everyone else looking at it and not part of that religious community that it says "The sky is blue"? You have completely removed the possibility of group error.

Or, let's put it another way. If the group can interpret the text any old way to suit its new needs, then the text loses authoritative meaning. It loses all claim to external, authoritative truth and becomes part of a language game and cultural flotsam in the grand "scheme" of the universe.

If you wish to marginalize the real meaning of your religious heritage, then be my guest. You have simply proved Joe's point. You have choices here. Either these texts no longer speak to this day and age authoritatively, this tradition is simply a story that helps some people cope, or you got it wrong and the only proper thing to do is to start stoning kids that talk back to their parents.
 
Last edited:
when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father
I was waiting for "go back into the closet" to arise yet again. Yet another game of cherry pick, completely missing the point of church as the people.

PG, the next time I attend Mass, I'll make sure to tell everyone there to STFU when we do the Lord's Prayer.

It'll go over real well.

There are two different dynamics going on.

One is "hey, look at me, I am praying, see how holy I am."

The other is "let us pray together, we here."

Get it?

DR
 
Last edited:
But "glory" doesn't mean "a nice knock-down argument",' Alice objected.

`When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, `it means just what I choose it to mean -- neither more nor less.'

`The question is,' said Alice, `whether you can make words mean so many different things.'

`The question is,' said Humpty Dumpty, `which is to be master -- that's all.'
 
Obviously, this all stems from the fact that the primary anti-gay parts of the bible are OT. If christians went around avoiding shrimp, it wouldn't be a big deal.

Our morality (western society) has continually progressed beyond the bible. Slavery was made illegal even though the bible condones it. Indeed, people now claim that Jesus' golden rule trumps slavery and therefore proves that being anti slavery is christian.

Equal rights for women has become a mainstay of our society, even though the bible clearly places women as subserviant to men. Again, this is rectified by the golden rule.

And then Civil rights became the mainstay of our society, again using the golden rule as biblical justification.

But, for some reason, most christians view "gay is an abomination" as a line in the sand. That we can't cross. That this, among all other elements in the bible, represents a clear thing "god's not ok with." The problem is, "Why?" Why is this special compared to all other elements in the bible? Why doesn't the golden rule, which trumped so many other biblical passages, not trump this one?

What's interestingly, however, is that this "line in the sand" doesn't represent any type of sacrifice for the majority of christians. Is it really a display of love of god to ask others to sacrifice and obey something that they themselves are free from ever having to give thought to? Does god love those who oppress others?
 
I like this phrase, an image pops up in my mind of a totally stunned crowd, not understanding an iota of what they've been told actually. "Wow! I didn't understand a single word but, hey!, this guy speaks with authority."

It is clear that such a huge, complex lesson can only be taught to and understood by experts, his disciples.

The crowd was mainly around for receiving some healing miracle services from JC, I think.

Yes, JC does heal a leper before moving on.

I can't see though how this lesson is so "huge and complex" that no one in the crowd JC addressed could have understood a single word of it. It's the essence of Xtian ethics which were disseminated through the Ancient World, first and especially among the less educated lower-classes, like those in the crowd. Some one of them at some point, other than JC's dozen, must have been able to figure it out.

But if, as you maintain, the message was intended only for the apostles, then Xtians may be in serious apostasy for having assumed all this time it was intended for everyone. Reciting the pater noster, for example, could be heresy, according to your... 'novel'... interpretation. :)

It would also contradict the verses under discussion, Matthew 5:17-19, wherein Jesus says whoever practices and teaches these commands will be great in the kingdom of heaven. If Jesus intends the updated commandments he is describing in the Sermon on the Mount not spread beyond his inner circle, why does He say those who teach them will be favored? It makes no sense for Him to be whispering a doctrine to his disciples which he wishes them to spread, when the crowd to whom they are to spread it eventually is right there within earshot?

Are you arguing that Jesus would rather they learn about the new commandments secondhand from his apostles rather than directly from Him?

(p.s. I do admire your dedicated Pyrrhonism, Herzblut; I wish I could stay so detached, sometimes; however, it's a fine line between pure skepticism and sophistry, no?) -- Here endeth the mini-Sermon on the Doubt. ;)
 
Last edited:
Wow, I admire all your patience in continuing this thread. Personally I've reached the point where I clearly understand why Nero would have fed xians to the lions. ACS's
display of willful stupidity, dishonesty and utter lack of integrity displayed in this thread
is a perfect example of why so many atheist no longer give theists the benefit of the doubt.


The short and long of it is when it comes to ACS and his ilk is this


ChimpNoEvil.jpg
 
Finally. Thanks.

But if your preference is Christians don't follow the Old Testament Laws why are you (or anyone who agrees with you for that matter) trying to convince me these verses say I'm supposed to? Why not be silent or encourage me in the opposite direction? Why encourage me to go the direction you don't want me too?

This question translates as: "Why aren't you more manipulative and dishonest?"

What you're ignoring is that JoeTJ would rather you stopped using the Bible (NT included, I assume) as a moral guide. What you respond with is an ultimatum: "If you convince me that Matthew says I should follow the OT, then I will follow the OT -- so be careful what you say!"

You're claiming JoeTJ's motives are to make you react the way you threaten to react if he, in fact, convinced you to accept his interpretation of Matthew.

Maybe that's reason to think twice before discussing religion. But, the thing is.... Once you accept Joe's interpretation of Matthew, he'll bring up Romans 7:6
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Romans 7:6;&version=31;

But now, by dying to what once bound us, we have been released from the law so that we serve in the new way of the Spirit, and not in the old way of the written code.

Or some similar verse.
 
Last edited:
Well of course it might lead to a proliferation of "schedules" like they have in Acts of Parliament, but I do think there must be some things which all Christians can agree are both necessary and sufficient. Otherwise there is no such thing as Christianity ( at least I think that follows)

So what's necessary and sufficient for Jazz to be Jazz?

All Christians believe that Jesus was a prophet of God. I think, after that, it gets a bit... well, un-agreed.

The trinity isn't believed by all. Even the divinity of Jesus is denied by some Unitarians:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarianism

Adhering to strict monotheism, they maintain that Jesus was a great man and a prophet of God, perhaps even a supernatural being, but not God himself. Unitarians believe in the moral authority, but not necessarily the divinity, of Jesus. They do not pray to Jesus.
 
I wasn't aware that conversion to judaism was a requisite to christianity.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't aware that conversion to judaism was a requisite to christianity.

It wasn't in Paul's eyes, but clearly was according to others -- which is why Paul went to great lengths to oppose the idea. But Paul was also clear that the law should still be followed, at least as regards morality, though not in those special cases having to do with the separation of Jews from others (circumcision, dietary restrictions, etc.).
 
Do you believe that Mormons, Muslims, and/or Christians have some particular expertise in interpreting their scriptures that non-Mormons, non-Muslims, and non-Christians lack?

So far - in regards to these verses the only people on this thread claiming to be experts and to KNOW what those verses mean because the meaning is so obvious are atheists.

All I've ever said it it's NOT obvious and doesn't appear to say what you KNOW it means. I find the argument that Christians have to follow the Old Testament Laws rather limp based on those verses alone.

Of course, that conversation ended once you all started saying you were neither telling me Christians had to follow the Old Testament Laws and were not telling me Christians did not have to follow the Old Testament Laws.
 
What he really wants to demonstrate to you is that Christian ethics leads to unacceptable rules of conduct, those OT Laws, hence you have to dump it.

I don't care what he's trying to demonstrate to me. I care what Jesus meant. And so far, I don't think Jesus meant Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws in those verses.

Of course - now I'm just trying to clarify if the people using those verses are telling me if Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws or not.
 
Last edited:
I think I can help. It seems to me that ACS and others have a problem because this passage clearly states what they, as Christians, should do, but they don't want to do it.

What's it clear about?

I keep asking, when you say it's clear are you saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws - YES or NO?

We were talking about those verses becuase I thought the answer you all were saying was YES, but this thread took a left turn at Albequerquie when you all denied saying that.

Other passages are less clear and so they can be "interpreted", but that does not work easily with this one. In another thread ACS told me how he decides what to accept and not accept in the bible and it is based on a few very simple tenets which he believes Jesus gave us and which we should apply to everything in religious and moral life ( I hope I am not misrepresenting you ACS?)

When he applies those bedrock tenets to certain passages in the bible they are in conflict with the text and in those cases he must assume that he is not understanding those passages properly: or that they are indeed wrong and can be ignored.

Sort of. Not really applicable at this time to the fact I am just trying to know what some of you are arguing.



What I suggest is that the Christians all get together and re-write the bible leaving out all those passages which they do not believe are in keeping with the fundamental message. It might take a little while, but it has been done before so it is not impossible.

Would that suit you, ACS?

What would suit me is if people who use bible verses for some sort of argument or conclusion on how Christians are supposed to act would simply just tell me how Christians are supposed to act.
 
Yes I think that is what the passage says they should do. I think it is clear that is what it says. Not doing so is not apparently a mortal sin though, since it does not exclude you from heaven: you just get the equivalent of a McJob instead of being middle management.
 
Last edited:
What would you do if you were convinced that these verses do tell you to follow all the laws of the old testament?

I'd probably tried to figure out how to do that. Probably I'd consult some Jewish people since they did do it.

We are not encouraging you to follow old testament laws. We are not saying you should follow it. We are saying the Bible is encouraging you to. We (I, at least) want you to realize that you are simply not following the bible, but that you are making up your own set of rules that you follow and that some of these coincide with parts of the Bible.

Nope - sorry - I'm currently following as much of the Bible as I understand. And as I learn more I'll try to apply that knowledge. And if you teach me something new in the Bible, I'll try to apply that.

You trying to teach me that I have to follow the Old Testament Laws is simply that - you teaching me, encouraging me, telling me that I'm supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.

So far, though, your argument I'm supposed to based on those verses is not that compelling because it's not clear.

And once again, if you don't want me to follow the Old Testament Laws - if they are so morally offensive to you or others - don't try to convince me or anyone else they are supposed to do follow them. What sort of logic is that?
 
And once again, if you don't want me to follow the Old Testament Laws - if they are so morally offensive to you or others - don't try to convince me or anyone else they are supposed to do follow them. What sort of logic is that?

The one that comes coupled with honesty, sincerity and integrity. I doubt you would understand those concepts as you have aptly demonstrated here.

You are doing a great job, though. I could never better explain than by pointing at you, why I do not believe, why I never could believe and why I think religion is both dangerous and harmful. You are why I think religion out to be fought.
 
This question translates as: "Why aren't you more manipulative and dishonest?"

What you're ignoring is that JoeTJ would rather you stopped using the Bible (NT included, I assume) as a moral guide. What you respond with is an ultimatum: "If you convince me that Matthew says I should follow the OT, then I will follow the OT -- so be careful what you say!"

You're claiming JoeTJ's motives are to make you react the way you threaten to react if he, in fact, convinced you to accept his interpretation of Matthew.

I'm saying if you really don't want someone to do something don't try to convince them to do it.
 
And once again, if you don't want me to follow the Old Testament Laws - if they are so morally offensive to you or others - don't try to convince me or anyone else they are supposed to do follow them. What sort of logic is that?

It's the logic that says that there is a contradiction between the internal message and the external world, which is the whole point of the critique.

You approach this from the viewpoint that the Bible is correct and try to make sense of what appear to be the contradictions within it. Your interlocutors do not share that assumption and try to show you internal contradictions and contradictions between internal information and external behavior as a critique.

It's no more complicated than that. They are not telling you to follow OT laws. They are telling you that there is a contradiction here, making Christianity problematic.
 
The one that comes coupled with honesty, sincerity and integrity. I doubt you would understand those concepts as you have aptly demonstrated here.

You are doing a great job, though. I could never better explain than by pointing at you, why I do not believe, why I never could believe and why I think religion is both dangerous and harmful. You are why I think religion out to be fought.

Really? Now that's interesting.

What's dangerous and harmful about me not blindly accepting yours and others teachings on those verses especially when it's not obvious? All I've done is this thread (before it went down this current road) was question everyone's interpretation of it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom