The atheists favorite bible verses

So that's a YES, Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.

Thank you.

Wait a second, are you suggesting that Christians must follow every word of the New Testament? That sounds rather... fundamentalist of you. Are the "Fundamentalist Atheists" you refer to in your sig correct?
 
I don't tell Muslims how to interpret their scriptures. I also don't tell them that their interpretation of their own scriptures is the wrong interpretation of their scripture.



I don't tell Mormons how to interpret their scriptures. I also don't tell them that their interpretation of their own scriptures is the wrong interpretation of their scripture.



Why should I tell a Mormon what a Mormon should believe? For that matter - why should you?

Do you believe that Mormons, Muslims, and/or Christians have some particular expertise in interpreting their scriptures that non-Mormons, non-Muslims, and non-Christians lack?

If so, where does this expertise come from? Does it happen at the moment of conversion? If I "find Jesus" and am born again tonight, are my interpretations of the New Testament suddenly more authoritative?
 
Do you believe that Mormons, Muslims, and/or Christians have some particular expertise in interpreting their scriptures that non-Mormons, non-Muslims, and non-Christians lack?
Yes, I would like to hear a good answer to this one.

How is it that when multiple people see the same passage, that you can have five different interpretations? If any source were so vague, I'd consider it utterly useless as a source of anything.

Could you imagine an engineering manual like that? "Well, if you translate it this way, you should build the walls all at a 45 degree angle and use cement... but the Stone Fundamentalists insist on going by the Stone Testament, but only because Engineer Matthew can be interpreted as stating that the Stone Testament should still be followed..."

Blah, my head hurts already.
 
I think I can help. It seems to me that ACS and others have a problem because this passage clearly states what they, as Christians, should do, but they don't want to do it. Other passages are less clear and so they can be "interpreted", but that does not work easily with this one. In another thread ACS told me how he decides what to accept and not accept in the bible and it is based on a few very simple tenets which he believes Jesus gave us and which we should apply to everything in religious and moral life ( I hope I am not misrepresenting you ACS?) When he applies those bedrock tenets to certain passages in the bible they are in conflict with the text and in those cases he must assume that he is not understanding those passages properly: or that they are indeed wrong and can be ignored.

What I suggest is that the Christians all get together and re-write the bible leaving out all those passages which they do not believe are in keeping with the fundamental message. It might take a little while, but it has been done before so it is not impossible.

Would that suit you, ACS?
 
What I suggest is that the Christians all get together and re-write the bible leaving out all those passages which they do not believe are in keeping with the fundamental message. It might take a little while, but it has been done before so it is not impossible.

Would that suit you, ACS?
Wouldn't this just further send the message that the Bible isn't by the hand of God or even inspired by the hand of God, but only means what humans want to force it to mean?
 
Last edited:
Well no. It was written by people who were "inspired" at the time, and what God can do once he can surely do again (well except the flood, cos he proooooommiiiiissseed). It seems that some of the people who wrote it the first time were mistaken about the inspiration on occasion, but that is not so surprising because they are only human and God can be a bit cryptic and indirect at times (NONONO this has nothing to do with less than perfect workmen and tools at all: how dare you!). Often knowledge proceeds by trying things out and then revising or improving the theory on the basis of experience. We need not deny religion the benefits of the application of intelligence, since God presumably made that too. And the bible will be a lot shorter when they are done, so it won't take so long to study theology and that is a good thing in this modern world :)
 
Wow, this God guy sure loves to work in weird and incomprehensible ways.

Personally, I think that he could increase efficiency by <Tons of a>% by simply getting it all down in clear terms the first time, with no overlap between outdated rules and regulations and what he really wants people to do.
 
Wouldn't this just further send the message that the Bible isn't by the hand of God or even inspired by the hand of God, but only means what humans want to force it to mean?

But Christians have such varying opinions on what should be followed and what shouldn't that there would never be a general consensus.
That's just how confusing the Bible is. Even if I was a Christian, how would I know I was going to Heaven?
 
Well of course it might lead to a proliferation of "schedules" like they have in Acts of Parliament, but I do think there must be some things which all Christians can agree are both necessary and sufficient. Otherwise there is no such thing as Christianity ( at least I think that follows)
 
And when you're doing that you're telling that Christian that Christians are supposed to be following all the Old Testament Laws. That's you're argument.

So you are definitely saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws when you use that argument.

That's the whole point for using those verses that way - to tell that Christian they are supposed to follow all the Old Testament Laws - correct?

That is correct. We are on the same page on this now - right?
Perhap this will help (perhaps pigs will fly).

You have been told many times that Matthew, a book in the bible, tells people to follow the old laws.

That does not mean that we are telling anyone they should follow the old laws unless those people have said that they will follow every word in the bible. Even then we would not be telling them that they should follow the rules for any reason other than they said they would follow them.

It is an individuals choice on whether they follow what is written in the bible.
As an atheist I don't take anything in the bible into account when deciding how to behave.

I suspect that Christians differ and do take some notice. I have never been a Christian, I have never attended bible lessons. I honestly don't know how much notice Christians are supposed to take of the contents of the bible. I don't know what is taught in respect of the new testament, old testament, or whether some books or verses take precedence over others.

So to summarise. the only people (Christians or not) who should follow all the rules in the old testament are those who have said they will follow what is written in Matthew, and even then they should only follow them to be true to themselves. We see no reason for them to follow the rules.

So can you tell me. Are Christians supposed to follow what is written in Matthew and are they supposed to follow all, some or none of the old testament rules.
 
ACS - you don't really seem to get this incredibly simple concept:

It's your religion - I don't think anyone here really cares how you specifically decide what it is.

We're commenting on the propositions put forward and noting the logical inconsistencies. Sceptics generally don't like logical inconsistencies - it's a bad smell.

The logical inconsistency here is:

"You do what the Bible says to be a Christian. The Bible says you do X. You do not do X. Yet you are still a Christian"

So the resolutions offered are:

"The Bible says you do X but means Y."

"The Bible says you do X but X is now deprecated as a rule."

"That's not what being a Christian is about."

"I do X."

"I'm not a Christian."

The last two are the least problematic resolutions for obvious reasons.
 
So to summarise. the only people (Christians or not) who should follow all the rules in the old testament are those who have said they will follow what is written in Matthew,
I was not aware Jews said they would follow what is written in Matthew. Where did you get this from?
 
Finally. Thanks.

How did you manage to miss essentially the same answer the first couple of dozen times it was given?

But trust me to reference this post in the future when you get back to pretending the answer had never been given, or that you never understood it!

But if your preference is Christians don't follow the Old Testament Laws why are you (or anyone who agrees with you for that matter) trying to convince me these verses say I'm supposed to?

As far as I am concerned, that shows you are finally admitting to understand, or finally understanding what we are going on about.

Yes, this is a legitimate question. I will attempt to answer it.

What would you do if you were convinced that these verses do tell you to follow all the laws of the old testament?

I think it is much more likely you would realize the problems with your logic than that you would start to actually follow those laws.

I think it is much more likely that you will understand that you are not following the bible as it is written and that you are not using it as a source of your morals.

It is an argument by proxy.

Why not be silent or encourage me in the opposite direction? Why encourage me to go the direction you don't want me too?

But nobody is encouraging you! It's only in your mind. Remember my earlier example:

If I say "In Hitler's My Kampf it clearly says that the Jewish race must be fully annihilated", am I then encouraging genocide?

No, I am not! I am summarizing the message of a book. I might well disagree with that message, though. But my disagreement doesn't change the message.

Now, some people seem to think the book is important and should be followed. Would it not be wise, then, to first come to an agreement about what the book actually says?

This is what this thread is all about so far: What does the Bibel even say?

As long as we don't know that, we can't really discuss things. We can't know what it means for someone to say they are a "Christian". We can't know if being Christian would seem like a good or a bad thing. (This would depend on whether a Christian believes, e.g. that disobedient or insolent children should be killed.)

We are not encouraging you to follow old testament laws. We are not saying you should follow it. We are saying the Bible is encouraging you to. We (I, at least) want you to realize that you are simply not following the bible, but that you are making up your own set of rules that you follow and that some of these coincide with parts of the Bible.
 
... Often knowledge proceeds by trying things out and then revising or improving the theory on the basis of experience. We need not deny religion the benefits of the application of intelligence, since God presumably made that too. And the bible will be a lot shorter when they are done, so it won't take so long to study theology and that is a good thing in this modern world :)

Wow, an up-to-date, coherent bible that ALL Christians agree on? That certainly would be a lot shorter. Something like:

"In the beginning... vanity... breasts... Jesus Christ."
 
But Christians have such varying opinions on what should be followed and what shouldn't that there would never be a general consensus.
That's just how confusing the Bible is. Even if I was a Christian, how would I know I was going to Heaven?
Well, yes. I'm pretty sure that you're rehashing my own point. :)

There doesn't seem to be any real way to "fix" the Bible. It's innately broken and "fixing" it just further points out it's broken without actually fixing anything.
 
I think I can help. It seems to me that ACS and others have a problem because this passage clearly states what they, as Christians, should do, but they don't want to do it.
This is clearly a misunderstanding. Matthew 5 starts pointing out

Now when he saw the crowds, he went up on a mountainside and sat down. His disciples came to him, and he began to teach them saying:

Hence, he flew a crowd by running up a hill and hiding behind his disciples. He obviously talked to just this fistfull of disciples and what he directly told them in regards to some legal stuff was for their ears only. Since the guys are probably all dead by now it does not effect any living christians anymore.

I don't see any other valid interpretation. The text is unambiguous.
 
Last edited:
So, is everyone still masturbating daily?

YES or NO?

YES or NO?

YES or NO?

I will take all non answers and all answers that aren't NO, as a YES. I will assume that those who ignore the question are doing so because they are masturbating right now.

Don't you love how ACS always weasels out of these YES or NO questions without a YES or NO and still demands that we answer his inanities with a YES or NO?... He'll insert his own interpretation of whether we said "yes" or "no" as he sees fit to justify his beliefs about us and his magic book He gives himself leeway he won't give us.

"do unto others" ACS-- if you want a yes or no answer from us-- give us one. If you can't answer with a yes or no without clarification-- cut us the same slack.
 
Last edited:
This is clearly a misunderstanding. Matthew 5 starts pointing out

Now when he saw the crowds, he went up on a mountainside and sat down. His disciples came to him, and he began to teach them saying:

Hence, he flew a crowd by running up a hill and hiding behind his disciples. He obviously talked to just this fistfull of disciples and what he directly told them in regards to some legal stuff was for their ears only. Since the guys are probably all dead by now it does not effect any living christians anymore.

I don't see any other valid interpretation. The text is unambiguous.

Matthew 5 is the beginning of the Sermon on the Mount. It continues through Matthew 6 and concludes with Matthew 7:28-29 [HCSB transl.]:

When Jesus had finished this sermon, the crowds were astonished at His teaching, because He was teaching them like one who had authority, and not like their scribes.

While I agree with your general point that any text is open to interpretation, this text doesn't seem open to your particular interpretation. It would be disastrous for Xtians, anyway, implying the sometimes magnificent language of the Sermon on the Mount was an insider secret that died with the apostles.
 
Last edited:
Why is this still being discussed?

One issue is that Paul seemed to make a distinction between laws that separated Jews from the rest of the communities of earth -- circumcision, not eating pork and shellfish, etc. -- and moral laws. He was clearly of the opinion that Christians should follow the old laws, even though following the laws, in and of themselves. does not justify man to God.

So, the simple answer is "Yes", Christians should follow the old laws, but not the laws specific to Jews as Jews. I guess we can treat Paul's rationalizations the way we treat all rationalizations, though. That distinction is far from clear and fraught with interpretive traps.

But, then, Hebrews tells a different tale. How to decide?

If not done so already, could someone answer one of the earlier questions? What does it mean to fulfill a law? I think that makes sense in an imminent apocalypse cult, but how in the world does fulfilling a law make any sense in the world in which we live?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom