The atheists favorite bible verses

Do you have JoeTheJuggler on ignore or something?
Mashuna is simply pointing out correctly that no one has tried to persuade you to obey the Old Testament Laws.

Once again you're either being dishonest or you're really too stupid to see the distinction between me arguing that the Matthew passage says that the old laws are still valid and me urging you to obey all the O.T. laws.

In case you haven't read this before, I'll say it again:

I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws.
 
Yes I was. But you said that I was trying to convince you to obey the Old Testament laws. I definitely was not.

You're trying to convince me that those verses mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws, but you're not trying to convince me that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
 
Mashuna is simply pointing out correctly that no one has tried to persuade you to obey the Old Testament Laws.

Once again you're either being dishonest or you're really too stupid to see the distinction between me arguing that the Matthew passage says that the old laws are still valid and me urging you to obey all the O.T. laws.

What are you telling me Christians are supposed to do when you are telling me that the Old Laws are still valid?
 
So what does it mean? Does it mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws or not?

So does that mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws or not?

Really? You're back to this repeating of the same question that has been answered by now at least 20 times?

I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws.

I'm quite sure that the Matthew passage does say that the O.T. laws are still in effect.

If you like the "supposed to" language (which is not part of the passage, you'll notice, but your own little quirk)--according to the author of Matthew you are supposed to obey every last commandment.

Do you disagree with that statement? If so, why not get back to that discussion (on the meaning of that passage, and how you can possibly construe it to mean anything else) rather than this tiresome repetition of the question that's been answered.

Why do you keep asking the same question that has been answered again and again and again and again?

Are you insane? Off your meds?
 
You're trying to convince me that those verses mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws, but you're not trying to convince me that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.

Should Christians follow OT laws?

  • According to the Bible - YES
  • According to me - NO
 
If you like the "supposed to" language (which is not part of the passage, you'll notice, but your own little quirk)--according to the author of Matthew you are supposed to obey every last commandment.

Why do you keep asking the same question that has been answered again and again and again and again?

Because it hasn't been answered. Either you're arguing Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws or you're arguing Christians are not supposed to.

Everyone says "It's obvious what it means" but when asked what it means no one will say YES or NO on whether that means Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.

Because it appears that's what you and the others were arguing that those verses mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. But everyone and their mother now says that's not what any of you are arguing. And when asked for a YES or NO I get a "YES, But" and a "NO, But" which appears to mean "YES Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws, But NO I don't want you to."

Is that correct?
 
So that's a YES, Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.

Thank you.

You're funny :D.

Wait - have you found a new feature where you can put people on half-ignore? That would explain a lot, if you're only seeing half of every post. You'd better check your user CP settings.

Hang on, if you have accidentally found the half-ignore setting, you might not see the key part of this post. Best be safe.

Have you found a new feature where you can put people on half-ignore? That would explain a lot, if you're only seeing half of every post. You'd better check your user CP settings.
 
Last edited:
You're trying to convince me that those verses mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws, but you're not trying to convince me that Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
Yes.

According to the author of Matthew, Jesus said that you should obey and teach every least one of the Old Testament laws.

I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws. I am not the author of Matthew. Do you see the distinction?

As far as what Christians are "supposed to do"--I'm not a Christian, so I don't know what they're "supposed to do". I also suspect Christians are a very diverse group and have lots and lots of different ideas about what they're supposed to do. I don't think they should obey all the laws of the O.T. in case you're wondering.

I have some very dear Christian friends who also don't obey every last one of the laws. I'll check around, but I'm pretty sure their take on the passage is the one I've given several times--that there was tension in the early church around the idea that non-Jews could be Christians. Matthew and Luke came down pretty firmly on the side that Jesus' teachings were only for Jews. Other parts of the New Testament are very different (notably Paul's writings and the Gospel of John).

At any rate, when someone tries to justify, for example, anti-gay laws by citing passages in the Bible, and someone points out that the Bible has plenty of passages that advocate horrendously immoral positions (rape, slavery, etc.), they often say that those parts of the Bible (i.e. the Old Testament) don't count because Jesus gave a new law and made the old law null and void. The Matthew passage refutes that argument.

By the way, I don't think anyone (not even you) should obey all the Old Testament laws.
 
ACS says that I was arguing that the passage means what it says because I must be trying to say that Christians are supposed to obey the O.T. laws. That's why he can't seem to understand--despite my saying this over and over and over--that I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws. I don't think that.
You don't seem to understand. You're talking to somebody who has accepted that the Sermon on the Mount contains the core tenets of his christian ethics (I assume...). And you're telling him that following this Sermon's teaching necessarily implies a certain conduct. You thereby demand that conduct. The fact that your personal ethics does not follow from the same source, you actually negate its validity, is irrelevant for him.

The reason I'm arguing that that's what the passage means is because I do in fact believe that that's what the passage means.
But what you believe the passage means is irrelevant for what the passage means. Unless you show me some christians who accept the premise "The meaning M of a biblical passage P is what JoeTheJuggler believes it to be."

That's not what I was doing in the post (see above), but I'd say a "working method" depends on the passage in question.

In this passage, the words are very plain.
Let me stop you here, because I disagree from the very beginning. What you think about the words is independent from any acceptable definition of the words theological meaning.

Let me give you some adhoc definitions I think of:

Meaning of a biblical passage is

- what a substancial amount of christians believe it to be the meaning
- what the Church teaches it to be the meaning.

If you have better definitions, go ahead!

But in no case the meaning of a biblical passage is defined by your privative interpretation.

Would you care to engage in a discussion about alternate readings?
Sure. If we agree on the formal aspect, namely that what we discuss is theologically irrelevant and hence nothing we say here is any kind of binding for any christian whatsoever.

H.
 
Last edited:
Because it hasn't been answered. Either you're arguing Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws or you're arguing Christians are not supposed to.
And I've said over 30 times now that I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws.

I do think the author of Matthew has Jesus quite clearly saying that you should obey and teach every least one of the old commandments.
Everyone says "It's obvious what it means" but when asked what it means no one will say YES or NO on whether that means Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
That's because you're all hung up on some strange distinction between "should follow the laws" and "are supposed to follow" them. The only reason you cling to it, is because it has an inherent ambiguity which has been explained to you repeatedly.


Because it appears that's what you and the others were arguing that those verses mean Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. But everyone and their mother now says that's not what any of you are arguing. And when asked for a YES or NO I get a "YES, But" and a "NO, But" which appears to mean "YES Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws, But NO I don't want you to."

Is that correct?
You're a raving lunatic, ACS. I've explained this over and over, and you persist in refusing to understand. You can't possibly be that stupid.
 
At any rate, when someone tries to justify, for example, anti-gay laws by citing passages in the Bible, and someone points out that the Bible has plenty of passages that advocate horrendously immoral positions (rape, slavery, etc.), they often say that those parts of the Bible (i.e. the Old Testament) don't count because Jesus gave a new law and made the old law null and void. The Matthew passage refutes that argument.

And when you're doing that you're telling that Christian that Christians are supposed to be following all the Old Testament Laws. That's you're argument.

So you are definitely saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws when you use that argument.

That's the whole point for using those verses that way - to tell that Christian they are supposed to follow all the Old Testament Laws - correct?

That is correct. We are on the same page on this now - right?
 
You're a raving lunatic, ACS. I've explained this over and over, and you persist in refusing to understand. You can't possibly be that stupid.

How many names have I been called in this thread? Anyone keeping count? How many times have I been called a liar and dishonest? Anyone keeping count?
 
Last edited:
I don't tell Muslims how to interpret their scriptures. I also don't tell them that their interpretation of their own scriptures is the wrong interpretation of their scripture.



I don't tell Mormons how to interpret their scriptures. I also don't tell them that their interpretation of their own scriptures is the wrong interpretation of their scripture.



Why should I tell a Mormon what a Mormon should believe? For that matter - why should you?

Ah... that's what this has all been about. You want skeptics to give the credulous a free-ride if their fantastic claims relate to blokes on clouds and their mixed-up, contradictory and often downright evil publications. In fact, you won't mind too much if the muslims, mormons et al get given a bit of a working over, I don't remember seeing you leap to the defence of FredCarr anytime, it's just christianity you want to protect in a special, anti-skeptical, bubble.

I think you are going to be disappointed.
 
And when you're doing that you're telling that Christian that Christians are supposed to be following all the Old Testament Laws. That's you're argument.

So you are definitely saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws when you use that argument.

That's the whole point for using those verses that way - to tell that Christian they are supposed to follow all the Old Testament Laws - correct?

That is correct. We are on the same page on this now - right?

Ooh, I know the answer to this one too.

  1. No
  2. No
  3. No
  4. No
 
A Christian Sceptic said:
And when you're doing that you're telling that Christian that Christians are supposed to be following all the Old Testament Laws. That's you're argument.

So you are definitely saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws when you use that argument.

That's the whole point for using those verses that way - to tell that Christian they are supposed to follow all the Old Testament Laws - correct?

That is correct. We are on the same page on this now - right?
Ooh, I know the answer to this one too.

  1. No
  2. No
  3. No
  4. No

So you're actually telling them they should not be following the Old Testament Laws?
 
And when you're doing that you're telling that Christian that Christians are supposed to be following all the Old Testament Laws. That's you're argument.

So you are definitely saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws when you use that argument.
Yes, but he's unaware of that.

That's the whole point for using those verses that way - to tell that Christian they are supposed to follow all the Old Testament Laws - correct?

That is correct. We are on the same page on this now - right?
What he really wants to demonstrate to you is that Christian ethics leads to unacceptable rules of conduct, those OT Laws, hence you have to dump it.
 
Last edited:
You've stated those verses are obvious.

Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

There are two answers, which one is correct depends on the truth of certain variables.

If there is a God who is responsible for the content in the bible then; Yes.

If there is no God, and the bible is the creation of men with no divine origin; No.

What i have observed is that modern christians do not see it this way and instead go for a third option:
Follow what fits with your personal and cultural ideals. Pick out the parts of the bible you like. Ignore the parts you do not. Twist the meanings of verses to justify your actions.

The very fact that Christians are looking for reasons not to follow what is supposedly the commands of their god, should be immediate cause for concern. The fact that is does not seem to be, puzzles and saddens me.
 
What are you telling me Christians are supposed to do when you are telling me that the Old Laws are still valid?
Once again, I am not saying the O.T. laws are still valid. (I don't think they were ever valid.) The author of Matthew has Jesus saying that they are still valid in the passage you cited.

Do you still fail to see the distinction? Hint: I am still not the author of Matthew.

The only thing I'm telling you with regard to what Christians (or anyone else) are supposed to do is that I don't think anyone should follow all the O.T. laws.

So do you think Christians (or anyone else) should obey all the laws of the O.T.? I hope not.

Do you think Christians (or anyone else) should follow all the teachings of the New Testament?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom