ACS says that I was arguing that the passage means what it says because I must be trying to say that Christians are supposed to obey the O.T. laws. That's why he can't seem to understand--despite my saying this over and over and over--that I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws. I don't think that.
You don't seem to understand. You're talking to somebody who has accepted that the Sermon on the Mount contains the core tenets of his christian ethics (I assume...). And you're telling him that following this Sermon's teaching necessarily implies a certain conduct. You thereby
demand that conduct. The fact that
your personal ethics does not follow from the same source, you actually negate its validity, is irrelevant for
him.
The reason I'm arguing that that's what the passage means is because I do in fact believe that that's what the passage means.
But what you believe the passage means is irrelevant for what the passage means. Unless you show me some christians who accept the premise "The meaning M of a biblical passage P is what JoeTheJuggler believes it to be."
That's not what I was doing in the post (see above), but I'd say a "working method" depends on the passage in question.
In this passage, the words are very plain.
Let me stop you here, because I disagree from the very beginning. What you think about the words is independent from any acceptable definition of the words theological meaning.
Let me give you some adhoc definitions I think of:
Meaning of a biblical passage is
- what a substancial amount of christians believe it to be the meaning
- what the Church teaches it to be the meaning.
If you have better definitions, go ahead!
But in no case the meaning of a biblical passage is defined by your privative interpretation.
Would you care to engage in a discussion about alternate readings?
Sure. If we agree on the formal aspect, namely that what we discuss is theologically irrelevant and hence nothing we say here is any kind of binding for any christian whatsoever.
H.