The atheists favorite bible verses

I noticed you never answered my question, ACS. YES or NO, do you think Christians should obey every bit of teaching in the New Testament?

You also never answered Lotharian's question (the one you were pressing on all of us): Do YOU think Christians should obey every least one of the Old Testament laws?

If not, what criterion do you use to distinguish which ones are good and which ones aren't?

Do you think the Bible is a source of morality?
 
If the hijackers really truly believed that god wanted them to drive airplanes into buildings as a test of faith... and really believed they AND THEIR FAMILIES would live happily ever after if they did so willingly...

then do you think they should have done so?

YES or NO, ACS. YES or NO?? Shall we repeat it ad infinitum? Why don't you understand that YOUR answer to this question is the same as OUR answer to yours.

And while we're on the topic... what's your favorite verse in the Quo'ran?
Well done! (Wish I'd've thought of that.)

Yes, ACS, your relation to Muslims is probably similar to my relation to Christians. If their holy scriptures tells them to do something, do you think they're "supposed to" do it? How is this question different from asking you if you think they should do it?
 
Should Muslims obey the teachings in the Quoran if they really really believe it's the word of God (Allah)?

Yes or No? Yes or No? Yes or No? Yes or No? YES OR NO?

Did Andrea Yates ensure her childrens' eternal bliss by killing them before they were old enough to sin in a hell potentiating way??

YES OR NO? YES OR NO? YES OR NO???

Or can only Christians ask questions to infer their answers and then demand a specific type of answer that doesn't appropriately answer the question so they can pretend the question wasn't answered?

WHAT'S YOUR FAVORITE PASSAGE IN THE BOOK OF MORMON?

Should Mormons baptize for the dead?
YES OR NO? YES OR NO? YES OR NO???

Nobody is answering my question dammit. How come no Christians ever answer my questions?

YES or NO? YES or NO? (No answer means you recognize your hypocrisy, and you finally realize what an insincere bozoface you have been.)

So, is it yes or no?

If you actually want to understand our answer (which we know you don't), you need to try and answer these kinds of questions yourself using your same inane "yes or no" criteria.

Just give me a YES or NO (or I win. :D)
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to convince you that that's what that passage means because that IS in fact what it means.
I like your circular reasoning. :)

But would you please provide a working method to falsify/verify the statement

"The meaning of biblical passage P is M"

for a given P and M?
 
Last edited:
Should Muslims obey the teachings in the Quoran if they really really believe it's the word of God (Allah)?

I don't tell Muslims how to interpret their scriptures. I also don't tell them that their interpretation of their own scriptures is the wrong interpretation of their scripture.

WHAT'S YOUR FAVORITE PASSAGE IN THE BOOK OF MORMON?

I don't tell Mormons how to interpret their scriptures. I also don't tell them that their interpretation of their own scriptures is the wrong interpretation of their scripture.

Should Mormons baptize for the dead?
YES OR NO? YES OR NO? YES OR NO???

Nobody is answering my question dammit. How come no Christians ever answer my questions?

YES or NO? YES or NO? (No answer means you recognize your hypocrisy, and you finally realize what an insincere bozoface you have been.)

So, is it yes or no?

Why should I tell a Mormon what a Mormon should believe? For that matter - why should you?
 
Yes, ACS, your relation to Muslims is probably similar to my relation to Christians. If their holy scriptures tells them to do something, do you think they're "supposed to" do it?

I've never told a Muslim what they should or shouldn't believe as a Muslim. And I've never told them how to interpret their scripture. I've also never told them their interpretation is wrong.
 
Bugger this for a joke. ACS just well and truly made my ignore list, and it takes rather a bit to do that.

If someone is really going to be so wilfully dense as to post the same question for - what, four pages? - and then pretend like no one has answered him, only to twist the answers he gets...

Don't feed the troll, methinks.

That's too bad.
 
I'm trying to convince you that that's what that passage means because that IS in fact what it means.

Why?

How I think you (or anyone else) should behave is completely irrelevant to a discussion of what that text actually says.

If it's irrelevant why even try to convince me?

If you don't want me to try to follow the Old Testament Laws don't try to convince me to follow the Old Testament Laws.
 
If it's irrelevant why even try to convince me?
Because the passage in question refutes the argument given by Christian apologists that the Old Testament laws are no longer valid.

I've told you this before.
If you don't want me to try to follow the Old Testament Laws don't try to convince me to follow the Old Testament Laws.
I'm not trying to convince you (or anyone else) to follow Old Testament Laws.

I have said about 15 times that I don't think anyone should follow all the O.T. laws.

Is this beginning to sound familiar? I say that same statement, and you act as if I said the opposite.
 
I like your circular reasoning. :)
No it's not. This was not an argument for a certain reading of the passage, but an answer to my motivation for arguing for that meaning of the passage.

ACS says that I was arguing that the passage means what it says because I must be trying to say that Christians are supposed to obey the O.T. laws. That's why he can't seem to understand--despite my saying this over and over and over--that I don't think anyone should obey all the O.T. laws. I don't think that.

The reason I'm arguing that that's what the passage means is because I do in fact believe that that's what the passage means.


But would you please provide a working method to falsify/verify the statement

"The meaning of biblical passage P is M"

for a given P and M?
That's not what I was doing in the post (see above), but I'd say a "working method" depends on the passage in question.

In this passage, the words are very plain. It has Jesus saying he's not here to abolish the old scriptures but to fulfill them. He says further that if you don't obey and teach every least one of the old commandments, you will be regarded as "least" in heaven. I don't see any way to construe that to mean that the old laws are null and void. I also don't see how anyone can deny that it is directly addressing the question of the validity of the old laws.

Would you care to engage in a discussion about alternate readings?

Do you buy ACS' interpretation that the passage means "practice what you preach" and that it doesn't address the question of the validity of the old commandments?
 
Mashuna... you always make me laugh. I wish you'd be at TAM.

Joe... Herzblut and ACS are not capable of reasonable dialogue. Engage them for entertainment purposes only. Really. It's not you, and it's not fixable. They have the same effect on everyone. Eventually people put them on ignore and they suck in new victims for their mental games to support whatever self important opinion that they have of themselves.

http://www.wired.com/culture/lifestyle/commentary/alttext/2007/06/alttext_0620


Pugilistic Discussion Syndrome

In this curious form of aphasia, the subject is unable to distinguish between a discussion and a contest. The subject approaches any online forum as a sort of playing field, and attempts to "win" the discussion by any means necessary. The rules of the imaginary contest are apparently clear to the individual as he or she will often point out when others break them, but when asked to outline these rules the individual is reluctant, perhaps not wishing to confer an "advantage" on any "opponents." The conditions for winning are similarly difficult to pin down, although in some cases the individual will declare himself the winner of a discussion that, to all others, appears to be ongoing.

Read my sig article; the afflicted never realize they're afflicted.
 
Last edited:
JoeTheJuggler just said he's trying to convince me that's what those verses mean.

Yes I was. But you said that I was trying to convince you to obey the Old Testament laws. I definitely was not.


You said:
A Christian Sceptic said:
If you don't want me to try to follow the Old Testament Laws don't try to convince me to follow the Old Testament Laws.

In case you haven't read it before, I don't believe that anyone should obey all the O.T. laws. I most certainly never tried to "convince" you to follow the Old Testament Laws.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom