The atheists favorite bible verses

For the umpteenth time: NO. I don't think ANYONE should follow all the O.T. laws.

Why did you ask this yet again? Was I in some way not clear when I posted this same sentence many times before?

Do you think "Christians who go by Matthew" are not included in "ANYONE"?

Because you used the word "should" which doesn't tell me if Christians are supposed to or not - it just tells me you'd prefer me not to.

So - if you think Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws why were you arguing that my interpretation was wrong and that the correct interpretation shows that Christians are supposed too?
 
Nopers, I've been following along the whole time. I've even been posting almost since the begining of the thread. But thanks for assuming.:D



I did not see this post before, so we must have been posting at the same time. It was not meant to come off as being blind to your previous post. I honestly did not see it.
You mean you missed this recent post, and the post it pointed to on page 6, and the 5 posts quoted therein from page 6 and the half dozen or so (probably more) posts that also gave the same answer?

What exactly do you mean by "following along the whole time" if you were able to overlook that many posts?

RobRoy said:
JoeTheJuggler said:
I do not think ANYONE (including "all Christians" and including Christians who interpret the Matthew passage any particular way) should follow all the Old Testament rules.

Great. I'm sure ACS appreciates your participation in his poll.
You'd think, wouldn't you? Read ACS' next post. He's still asking the same question as if I haven't answered it yet.

By the way, it's not a poll. Nowhere did he say he wanted to hear an answer from a certain number of people. He's been claiming (as least as late as page 7) that no one has answered him.
 
Because you used the word "should" which doesn't tell me if Christians are supposed to or not - it just tells me you'd prefer me not to.

So - if you think Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws why were you arguing that my interpretation was wrong and that the correct interpretation shows that Christians are supposed too?
Yeah--you're really going for a "gotcha" and it just isn't working for you, is it?

I'll say it again, according to me, no one should obey all the O.T. laws. According to Matthew (or Jesus if you think those are his words), you should.

I don't know what is different about that compared to "supposed to". It sounds like you're trying to set up a circular argument where the fact that Christians don't feel obliged to follow all those laws somehow means that the passage doesn't mean what it says. I dunno. What Christians actually do or think really doesn't affect what the passage means. It's irrelevant to a discussion of the text.

I was arguing that your interpretation of the Matthew passage is wrong because it is wrong. The passage clearly says that you should obey and teach the old laws. Your interpretation, that it means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about the validity of the old laws is wrong. The text doesn't support it. That's why I was arguing that way.

It doesn't matter how many times you say it, I'm still not going to say that I think Christians are supposed to obey the O.T. laws.
 
Me lying? Why are you lying about me telling lies?
OK, I will, for the sake of argument, accede that you didn't -outright- lie in that post I quoted.

But you were definitely being dishonest. Again, and pay attention to what I'm about to say now, the question has been answered so many times that pretending it isn't is dishonest. If you were being honest, then you'd have apologised right away, like you said you would. But no, instead you're trying to pretend that those answers don't exist, just so you can get in another cheap and dishonest shot.

And until you show me evidence in that you have actually been reading the posts other people has made - by for example recognising all the posts that did in fact answer the question instead of trying a really pathetic maneuver to avoid giving out that apology you owe JoeTheJuggler - I think people are more than justified in assuming you're not really following this thread. You're posting in it, true, but your posts show no signs of you actually participating in discussion, as much as being dishonest, deliberately(?) dense, and of course defending the lies of ACS.

So, first step to getting more honest, is that you read through this thread again, this time paying attention to everyone that answered ACS' question.
 
Maybe this is what you're after: I think the Matthew passage says you're supposed to obey all the laws of the Old Testament.

(There, I used "supposed to" instead of "ought".)

I myself reject that advice, because, as I may have said somewhere, I don't think anyone should obey all the old laws.

I also gave you a pretty good idea of the context of the passage--why the author of Matthew put that in there.
 
Yeah--you're really going for a "gotcha" and it just isn't working for you, is it?

He is rather silly to try and get the nonbelievers in here to day "people should follow the OT laws" when no one is actually making that argument. He ignores the fact that we're talking about the mythology of the bible and what it says.
 
*snip*
So - if you think Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws why were you arguing that my interpretation was wrong and that the correct interpretation shows that Christians are supposed too?

Your "interpretation" is "wrong" because the text in question is unambiguous. That you feel that the text requires interpretation is problematic. IMO, you find the text to be unsettling and therefore seek to assuage your discomfort by conceptualizing its meaning to the extent that it no longer means what it says. Nothing new--
 
Your "interpretation" is "wrong" because the text in question is unambiguous. That you feel that the text requires interpretation is problematic. IMO, you find the text to be unsettling and therefore seek to assuage your discomfort by conceptualizing its meaning to the extent that it no longer means what it says. Nothing new--

So do those verses mean a Christian is supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?
 
Maybe this is what you're after: I think the Matthew passage says you're supposed to obey all the laws of the Old Testament.

(There, I used "supposed to" instead of "ought".)

I myself reject that advice, because, as I may have said somewhere, I don't think anyone should obey all the old laws.

I also gave you a pretty good idea of the context of the passage--why the author of Matthew put that in there.

Finally. Thanks.

But if your preference is Christians don't follow the Old Testament Laws why are you (or anyone who agrees with you for that matter) trying to convince me these verses say I'm supposed to? Why not be silent or encourage me in the opposite direction? Why encourage me to go the direction you don't want me too?
 
The question has already been answered so many times by so many posters, that pretending it hasn't is just another lie. Why do you keep lying about this?

Robroy is a longtime apologist as is Herzblut... they never really say anything of value. (But it is great fun to read other peoples' biting repartee in return to the inanities.) Stupid, delude, and/or liars-- you be the judge.

We don't believe in your god, ACS-- however nebulously defined-- so we don't give a rat's ass what the hell he "revealed to Mathew" anymore than we care what L. Ron Hubbard had "revealed to him". We assume that Christians who really believe in their god would care. The more they believed in the whole "life is a test for eternity" paradigm... then the more literal they'd be taking the supposed words he inspired... just like the most faithful Muslims take the Quoran.

We're glad they don't-- but we also note the huge hypocrisy-- they must not really believe what they say they believe... they must realize that they are "cherry picking" the pieces of the bible they like to create god in a palpable image and then pretending that they get their morality from god.

Yet, the morality seems to be on par with the morality all sorts of religionists and atheists pick up. It doesn't seem divine. There's nothing which makes us believe you think god inspired that text... I don't think most Christians have read the book they call the "good book". I suspect more atheists have, actually. I think if you read it, you'd know that you couldn't keep up this silly semantic illusion about it being a good book with some objective morality or special guidance.

No, we don't think you should be following your magic book any more than we think the Muslims should be following theirs. But we note that if people really believe such a book holds the key to how they'll spend their eternity-- then what we think doesn't matter-- does it? What they believe GOD wants matter utterly, however. You're the one who believes in the biblical god-- so tell us the answer. How are Christians supposed to decide what parts of the bible to take seriously? How do they justify not adhering to the stuff that is grotesque or off putting?

ACS, are Andrea Yates' kids in heaven? Yes or No. If they had lived to adulthood is there a possibility they could have sinned enough to spend eternity in hell-- Yes or No? If you answered yes, then you can see why Andrea Yates killed her kids-- she REALLY believed what others just say they believe. Do YOU really believe your magic book... or do you just say the words? We don't believe in divine books or entities. It's all woo to us. But how does a supposed believer justify treating some parts as "woo" or "parables" or "old stuff" and not others?

If you don't answer, I'll chase you down like you did until you do like you are doing.

Actually, I wouldn't. I'm a bit more intelligent and moral than that.
 
Last edited:
NO-- we don't think you should follow Matthew--

WE just want to know why the hell YOU think you shouldn't follow Matthew-- it's YOUR divine text, isn't it? Yes or No-- ACS and apologists??!

Should believers in divine truths be following the letter of the law when it comes to these divine truths... or should they pick and choose according to some nebulous rubric?
 
Last edited:
So do those verses mean a Christian is supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?

IMO, regardless of what they mean, you will interpret them as you see fit and continue to struggle with the resulting cognitive dissonance. Best of luck--
 
Last edited:
Your "interpretation" is "wrong" because the text in question is unambiguous. That you feel that the text requires interpretation is problematic. IMO, you find the text to be unsettling and therefore seek to assuage your discomfort by conceptualizing its meaning to the extent that it no longer means what it says. Nothing new--

Yep. Boring old confirmation bias and cognitive dissonance. The arsenal of every type of woo. Not to mention, tangents, semantics, and the omnipresent question that isn't meant to be answered.

And my favorite "defense"-- make those who threaten your pet delusion into bad guys-- hate them so you won't have to "hear" them say what you so desperately don't want to hear. It's better to see them as "mean" then to realize your own hypocrisy.
 
Last edited:
You mean you missed this recent post, and the post it pointed to on page 6, and the 5 posts quoted therein from page 6 and the half dozen or so (probably more) posts that also gave the same answer?

What exactly do you mean by "following along the whole time" if you were able to overlook that many posts?


You'd think, wouldn't you? Read ACS' next post. He's still asking the same question as if I haven't answered it yet.

By the way, it's not a poll. Nowhere did he say he wanted to hear an answer from a certain number of people. He's been claiming (as least as late as page 7) that no one has answered him.

OH... yes.. another common tactic. Ask a leading question meant to imply your position as some truth and then pretend no one answered it. Mijo always does that. That is another one of the signs of a "woo". After a while they just start blinking neon.
 
Bugger this for a joke. ACS just well and truly made my ignore list, and it takes rather a bit to do that.

If someone is really going to be so wilfully dense as to post the same question for - what, four pages? - and then pretend like no one has answered him, only to twist the answers he gets...

Don't feed the troll, methinks.
 
Last edited:
If the hijackers really truly believed that god wanted them to drive airplanes into buildings as a test of faith... and really believed they AND THEIR FAMILIES would live happily ever after if they did so willingly...

then do you think they should have done so?

YES or NO, ACS. YES or NO?? Shall we repeat it ad infinitum? Why don't you understand that YOUR answer to this question is the same as OUR answer to yours.

And while we're on the topic... what's your favorite verse in the Quo'ran?
 
Last edited:
Finally. Thanks.
Bull. I haven't said anything that I didn't say repeatedly before. Don't pretend for a moment that your question went unanswered all that time.

But if your preference is Christians don't follow the Old Testament Laws why are you (or anyone who agrees with you for that matter) trying to convince me these verses say I'm supposed to?
I'm trying to convince you that that's what that passage means because that IS in fact what it means. How I think you (or anyone else) should behave is completely irrelevant to a discussion of what that text actually says.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom