The atheists favorite bible verses

THis is BS. Just look at his response to Robin above where he completely distorted Robin's position. It's just a pansy-arse attempt to distract from the fact that he can't support his nonsense about how the passage only refers to those who break the law AND teach others to break it at the same time.

He's a dishonest putz, and you are nearing one for supporting such BS.

Wow. I'm totally convinced now.

Totally.

I think it was the name-calling that finally swayed me.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
To be honest, I don't think it is my place to tell Christians which rules they follow, which they can modify and which they determine are no longer relevant. Equally, though, I would like a say before they come my way.
 
I just like people who start throwing claims at me to justify their claims, or at the very least demonstrate some ability at being consistent with them...
 
I just like people who start throwing claims at me to justify their claims, or at the very least demonstrate some ability at being consistent with them...

Agreed but much is fairly loose and open to a degree of interpretation.

Jesus said keep your prayers simple and don't repeat them like the heathens do. The Evangelicals will sing the same chorus 20 times and get a hit off the mantraishness of it all. They will see that as a genuine blessing and an Eastern mantra as fake. There is an awful lot of wriggle room in my experience.
 
I kinda smell that these laws are a no-no. But why? What's bad about e.g. not murdering?
Do you need a commandment not to commit murder to tell you that murder is wrong? If you don't have a source of morality independent from the Bible, how do you know to obey that one and not the ones we all consider to be heinous (or just silly)?

The question is about following every last one of the commandments of the old Jewish scripture (what Matthew calls "the law and the prophets" and what we've generally been calling "Old Testament laws").

There are hundreds of these laws.

Examples include death penalty for working on the Sabbath, requiring all farm fields to lie fallow every 7th year and letting the poor glean from them, dietary proscriptions, not wearing cloth made of two different fibers, rules about slavery, etc.

The broader question, as I've said, is the claim that the Bible can be used as a moral guide. My opinion is that you've got to have some other morality before you approach the Bible or you'd never know which bits are good and which are bad. If you really used the Bible as a source of your morality, you'd be pretty messed up.

When people use a Bible quote to justify a certain moral stance (like the stance that homosexuality is bad), it's frequently pointed out that you can find Bible passages to support just about any moral position, even ideas that pretty much everyone agrees are completely heinous. The response is often that since these passages come from the Old Testament they're no longer valid because Jesus replaced them with the new law. The passage in Matthew and the one I cited from Luke say that this isn't so.

Again, if you have no external source of morality, how would possibly know what commandments should be obeyed? If you go by this text, you would obey every least of the commandments in the old scripture.* I don't think even orthodox Jews accomplish this.

*ACS: note the emphasis added in that sentence. I do not think ANYONE should obey all the commandments of the Old Testament. I've said it repeatedly, but you don't seem to be able to understand it. The text clearly says that you should.
 
This isn't about being dense or dishonest. ACS might be being stubborn on his point, but it's valid to avoid the broad generalization of what side of the question each individual lands on?
He's being dishonest when he keeps pretending that I and others have stated that we think Christians should obey all the laws of the Old Testament.

He's not engaging in legitimate discussion because he just keeps repeating the ambiguous yes/no question even though several of us have spelled out the ambiguity and answered it repeatedly.

Seriously, I can't answer his question any more thoroughly or honestly, yet he still pretends his question hasn't been answered.

I suspect it's because he wants to avoid discussion about his very strange interpretation of the Matthew passage. His position that the passage only means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about whether the old laws are still in force is indefensible, so he keeps trying to do a "Gotcha!" by imagining that we are saying something we're clearly not saying.
 
OK - tell me what have they have been arguing for the first four pages:

1) That Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws
2) That Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws

1 or 2?


Neither, as you have been told repeatedly.
 
The problem with these types of discussion is the lack of propensity to step outside circular reasoning. Since ACS automagically assumes everything in the bible is correct and God is real, he cannot possibly fathom considering this issue from a neutral level.
To him the verse is correct in whatever capacity you consider it, and the thought that it may just be a flawed piece of reasoning from a primitive mind does not even enter his considerations.
These types of converstations seldom lead to anywhere constructive.
But oh well, sow those seeds. ;)
 
Last edited:
If you go by this text, you would obey every least of the commandments in the old scripture.* I don't think even orthodox Jews accomplish this.

*ACS: note the emphasis added in that sentence. I do not think ANYONE should obey all the commandments of the Old Testament. I've said it repeatedly, but you don't seem to be able to understand it. The text clearly says that you should.

So Christians who go by Matthew should follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
 
I suspect it's because he wants to avoid discussion about his very strange interpretation of the Matthew passage. His position that the passage only means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about whether the old laws are still in force is indefensible, so he keeps trying to do a "Gotcha!" by imagining that we are saying something we're clearly not saying.

What's my interpretation matter unless you've decided on a YES or NO that based on those verses whether Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws?
 
Last edited:
The problem with these types of discussion is the lack of propensity to step outside circular reasoning. Since ACS automagically assumes everything in the bible is correct and God is real, he cannot possibly fathom considering this issue from a neutral level.
To him the verse is correct in whatever capacity you consider it, and the thought that it may just be a flawed piece of reasoning from a primitive mind does not even enter his considerations.
These types of converstations seldom lead to anywhere constructive.
But oh well, sow those seeds. ;)

You've stated those verses are obvious.

Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
 
RobRoy said:
So ACS has asked for clarification from each individual to determine what the atheist contingent thinks Christians should do in the adherence of what Jesus said.

It's an honest question, and only one or two people have responded directly to it at this point.
Bull.

On page 6, in this post, I quoted something like 5 clear answers from 3 different people to his question from that page alone. (If he can't understand that words like "of course not" mean "NO" and "certainly" mean "YES", there's a bigger problem. Even so, I made sure to quote several answers that used the all caps YES and NO just so he could see the answers.) Others have answered as well, just as clearly (CurtC for one. You can easily read through those pages to find others).

You even admit that "one or two people" have directly answered. (The number is at least 5.) How many people have to give the same answer before he considers his question to have been answered?

It's a discussion, not a poll. He asked a question that was answered repeatedly, and he continues to ask it.

Then he willfully mis-characterized some of these very clearly worded answers (Robin's in particular, and another time that didn't specify whose, but I think was meant to refer to me) by saying that we in fact do think Christians should obey all the O.T. laws.

On page 7 he says,
I'm still waiting for the answer.
As if no one had answered him yet.

Yes, this is dishonest. This is not engaging in a discussion.
 
Last edited:
He's being dishonest when he keeps pretending that I and others have stated that we think Christians should obey all the laws of the Old Testament.

Fair enough. Point me to the post where you, and the others he asked, provided a yes or no response. I'll humbly beg your pardon on the entire matter.

Otherwise, I could equally claim that you're being dishonest by dancing around the requested response on the matter. You're willing to provide your interpretation of the scripture to prove ACS wrong, but you're unwilling to tell him if Christians who accept your interpretation should or should not follow the OT laws.

It might be pedantic, but it seems important to ACS, and there's no reason not to answer. <shrug>
 
Good question. Perhaps you could go back and get them to define "murder", because it seems like that outright genocide of other tribes didn't actually fall under their particular definition.
You suggest me to ask ACS whether genocide is excluded from the christian definition of murder? Seriously?
 
Fair enough. Point me to the post where you, and the others he asked, provided a yes or no response. I'll humbly beg your pardon on the entire matter.
Ah! So you haven't been reading the thread, but are ready to jump in. See my last post I pointed to 5 clear answers. There have been others, and they've all said about the same thing.

RobRoy said:
Otherwise, I could equally claim that you're being dishonest by dancing around the requested response on the matter. You're willing to provide your interpretation of the scripture to prove ACS wrong, but you're unwilling to tell him if Christians who accept your interpretation should or should not follow the OT laws.
Yeah. .you haven't read the last few pages I see.

I'm sure I've said this at least 10 times now, but here it is again:

I do not think ANYONE (including "all Christians" and including Christians who interpret the Matthew passage any particular way) should follow all the Old Testament rules.

RobRoy, kindly read the thread before you post again.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough. Point me to the post where you, and the others he asked, provided a yes or no response. I'll humbly beg your pardon on the entire matter.

Otherwise, I could equally claim that you're being dishonest by dancing around the requested response on the matter. You're willing to provide your interpretation of the scripture to prove ACS wrong, but you're unwilling to tell him if Christians who accept your interpretation should or should not follow the OT laws.

It might be pedantic, but it seems important to ACS, and there's no reason not to answer. <shrug>

The question has already been answered so many times by so many posters, that pretending it hasn't is just another lie. Why do you keep lying about this?
 
Ah! So you haven't been reading the thread, but are ready to jump in.

Nopers, I've been following along the whole time. I've even been posting almost since the begining of the thread. But thanks for assuming.:D

See my last post I pointed to 5 clear answers. There have been others, and they've all said about the same thing.

I did not see this post before, so we must have been posting at the same time. It was not meant to come off as being blind to your previous post. I honestly did not see it.

I'll review it and get back to you.

[/quote]I do not think ANYONE (including "all Christians" and including Christians who interpret the Matthew passage any particular way) should follow all the Old Testament rules.[/quote]

Great. I'm sure ACS appreciates your participation in his poll. :D

RobRoy, kindly read the thread before you post again.

Kindly don't make assumptions before you post again. :D
 
So Christians who go by Matthew should follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
For the umpteenth time: NO. I don't think ANYONE should follow all the O.T. laws.

Why did you ask this yet again? Was I in some way not clear when I posted this same sentence many times before?

Do you think "Christians who go by Matthew" are not included in "ANYONE"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom