The atheists favorite bible verses

Sorry Lonewulf. I've had to simplify it.

Because they were saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. And they used Matthew verses to try to prove it. They also said it was obvious that's what those verses meant. And they argued that position.

That would be a YES.

Except, now they're saying it's not a YES.

So - is it a YES or NO?
Have you ever taken a philosophy class? If you ever did, you should know that any argument has within it certain assumptions that lead to the conclusion.

If you make the assumption that the Bible is the inerrant word of God (or at the very least, inspired enough by God to be useful), then you would reach one conclusion.

If you don't make this assumption, then it leads to another conclusion.

Personally, I'd take heaven above fitting in society. I'd look deep into the Bible and follow it 100% if I really honestly believed that that was the way into the pearly gates. But I don't, because I don't tend to believe in things that have no backing for them.

Because as far as I see it, the Bible is pretty clear on one thing: To please God, you need to do certain things and uphold certain rituals. When you don't follow those rituals, but also claim that the Bible is something that you should follow, then I really start to wonder who you're trying to fool. Not me, at least.

Like I said, it's the natural conclusion when you factor in all of the fundamental logical assumptions. Personally, I'm a person of logic; I lead where the truth would take me, and I attempt not to contradict myself or go down paths littered with fallacies.

I still don't see any kind of evidence for the soul, much less the afterlife, and much less one kind of afterlife. It's like attempting to talk about the speed of the sun as it revolves around the earth. More like, the effects of the sun's speed on other planets as it spins around the Earth. It seems like a conclusion based on an assumption that has no backing for it in the first place.

But if I was led (through logic and empricism, naturally) to the conclusion that there was an afterlife, a creator of the Universe, and only one real way to please Him... well, to be honest, I might just spite him for the hell of it. But I'd know I'd have to pay dearly. If I was interested in pleasing Him (as Christians usually are), I'd do what it takes.

Although I would dislike others harming me because of their silly beliefs, if I felt their beliefs actually had something to do it, I'd be more tempted to follow along. But so far, I have seen 0 evidence that any religious claim has any kind of backing of any kind whatsoever. So no, I don't want you to follow the Old Testament.

All in all, if you ask me what you should and should not do, then I'd ask, "What are your terms?" What do you actually want to do? What are your assumptions? If you believe that the Bible is the inerrant word of God, and you want to go to heaven and don't care what society thinks of you... then you probably should ask yourself what's more important: God or us?

Of course, I would also point out that the assumptions that lead up to your conclusion are definitely questionable. But when has that ever stopped the religious?
 
Last edited:
No one said that. No one here believes that anyone should follow an ancient book of myths, and no one has said so, except maybe you in your attempts to twist what is being said.

OK - tell me what have they have been arguing for the first four pages:

1) That Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws
2) That Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws

1 or 2?
 
Last edited:
Have you ever taken a philosophy class? If you ever did, you should know that any argument has within it certain assumptions that lead to the conclusion.

If you make the assumption that the Bible is the inerrant word of God (or at the very least, inspired enough by God to be useful), then you would reach one conclusion.

If you don't make this assumption, then it leads to another conclusion.

Personally, I'd take heaven above fitting in society. I'd look deep into the Bible and follow it 100% if I really honestly believed that that was the way into the pearly gates. But I don't, because I don't tend to believe in things that have no backing for them.

Because as far as I see it, the Bible is pretty clear on one thing: To please God, you need to do certain things and uphold certain rituals. When you don't follow those rituals, but also claim that the Bible is something that you should follow, then I really start to wonder who you're trying to fool. Not me, at least.

Like I said, it's the natural conclusion when you factor in all of the fundamental logical assumptions. Personally, I'm a person of logic; I lead where the truth would take me, and I attempt not to contradict myself or go down paths littered with fallacies.

Sorry - the YES or NO question wasn't to you. It was to the people who were arguing a position and now claim it's not what they meant. I'm trying to clarify if it's a YES or NO.
 
Sorry for my ignorance. But what precisely are those laws, apart from those 10 items on the slab?

Sorry Herz,
I'm still trying to find out if their argument is whether Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. Maybe some of the YES's here could tell Herz which one's Christians are supposed to follow.
 
Sorry - the YES or NO question wasn't to you. It was to the people who were arguing a position and now claim it's not what they meant. I'm trying to clarify if it's a YES or NO.
I didn't think it was. I was attempting to clarify what my interpretation was. I may be wrong, and I probably shouldn't attempt to talk for other people in the first place.

Herzblut said:
Sorry for my ignorance. But what precisely are those laws, apart from the 10 items on the slab?
Heyo, old bean! Took you off the old ignore list; I figure I've grown a thicker skin since I was last on this place. Anyways, to answer your question...

There's an interpretation here, where you can decide whether or not have the "correct" interpretation: Here (scroll down a little).

From the website:

The Old Testament (OT) can be grouped into three main themes, namely, the Laws, the Prophets, and Writings (like Psalms, Proverbs, Job, Daniel and Ruth). The OT and the New Testaments (NT) compromise each other. The NT is not meant to replace the OT but to fulfill it. As Jesus said it himself, Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. Paul also pointed out, All Scripture is God-breathed/ (Timothy 3:16). Therefore not only should we not abolish the OT, we must consider its messages carefully for it is the inspired work of God. Also, one should keep in mind not to interpret the teaching of the Bible through one or two verses, but to look at the Bibles view as a whole towards any subject.

And the whole "Ten Commandments being the only laws"... well, do you have a cite on that? Because as far as I see it, there's no reason to deny all of these as being guidelines and rules for living:

1) Paul told us that God gave us the Laws so that we know what is sin (Roman 3:20)- like the Ten Commandments (Ex 20, Lev 19, Dt 5), laws on servants (Ex 21), laws on properties (Ex 20:15, Dt 5:19, Ex 21:33-36, 22:1-5, 23:4-5, Lev 19:35-36, Dt 22:1-4, 25:13-15), laws of justice and mercy (Ex 23), on unlawful sexual relations (Lev 18), false accusations (Ex 20:16, Dt 5:20, Ex 23:1-3, Lev 19:16, Dt 19:15-21), punishment for wrongdoing (Dt 25:1-5), marriage (Ex 20:14, Dt: 5:18, Lev 18:6-23, 20:10-21, Dt 22:13-30), and fair trials (Ex 23:6-8, Lev 19:15, Dt 1:17, 10:17-18, 16:18-20, 17:8-13, 19:15-21), social order (Ex 20:12, Dt 5:16, Ex 21:15-17, 22:28, Lev 19:3,32, 20:9, Dt 17:8-13, 21:15-21, 27:16)

That seems to be a lot more than just 10 commandments, but I may be wrong.

Of course, I'm getting this off a website for a certain brand of Christian. However, I figured that this was a good summary of biblical chapters, and some evidence that there are, indeed, people that believe that the Old Testament laws should be followed.

As far as I see it, just because it's filed under Old Testament, is no reason to automatically believe that Big G filed them away under "no longer sins". If it was wrong once...
 
Last edited:
Why favour any bile verse in the first place? Sure, some are kind of nice, other are outdated, and many are just imbecile. What’s so great about that particular bronze-aged myth that couldn’t be replaced with better newer narratives?
 
OK - tell me what have they have been arguing for the first four pages:

1) That Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws
2) That Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws

1 or 2?

Well the first four pages had a quite a lot of what you asked for in your opening post in case you'd forgotten. Perhaps you meant the last 4 pages - I know you seem to have a problem knowing which half is the half you have to pay attention to.... ? ;)
 
Last edited:
OK - tell me what have they have been arguing for the first four pages:

1) That Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws
2) That Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws

1 or 2?

After all this time, if you honestly had been not understanding our answers, you would have figured it out by now. I like to give people the benefit of the doubt, but it's now clear that you are being dishonest.

A conversation should not be to score rhetorical points, it should be to honestly have a discussion. You are unwilling to do that.

For the last time, your YES/NO question is ambiguous. According to the Bible, Christians are supposed to follow the OT laws. According to our own views, they should not. Your answer depends on whom "supposed to" is according to.
 
Hi there.
And the whole "Ten Commandments being the only laws"... well, do you have a cite on that?
Who? I? Hey, that was my question!

However, I figured that this was a good summary of biblical chapters, and some evidence that there are, indeed, people that believe that the Old Testament laws should be followed.
I kinda smell that these laws are a no-no. But why? What's bad about e.g. not murdering?
 
Last edited:
I think I understand now -
I think you do understand but are willfully pretending not to.

You're still pretending not to understand the difference between what we say and what we say Matthew says.

I'm glad to see you've abandoned your silly argument that the Matthew passage means "practice what you preach" and has nothing to say about whether the old laws must be obeyed.

You all don't think Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws, but you tell Christians they are supposed to even though you think they aren't supposed to.
Nope. That's simply wrong. No one said that. In fact, many of us have said quite clearly many times that we don't think anyone (including Christians) should follow all the O.T. laws.



I'm still waiting for the answer.
Read the thread. You're pretending to be a dolt, but nobody could possibly be that stupid.

Sorry Lonewulf. I've had to simplify it.
No you don't. You're clearly trying very hard to get us to say something that none of us said or implied while you ignore the basic issue. That the argument that the O.T. laws no longer apply is refuted by the passage you cited from Matthew and the one I cited in Luke.

Because they were saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
Nope. It's still the case that no one here said that. It's also monotonously clear that several of us have said that we don't think anyone should follow all the O.T. laws repeatedly. Yet you still keep saying that we say the opposite.

And they used Matthew verses to try to prove it. They also said it was obvious that's what those verses meant. And they argued that position.
Nope. We point out that the passage in Matthew refutes the argument that Jesus replaced the old law and said it can be ignored. Quite obviously, the passage says you are to obey and teach every last one of the old commandments.

That would be a YES.

Except, now they're saying it's not a YES.
Nope. Not even close. No one here has been unclear about it either. You just keep pretending you can't understand the plain sense of our words. I think it's similar to the way you read the Matthew passage to somehow have nothing to say about whether the old laws still apply.


OK - tell me what have they have been arguing for the first four pages:

1) That Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws
2) That Christians are not supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws

1 or 2?
Neither.

When you asked the ambiguous question (without telling us according to whom), we answered both versions--none of us think anyone should follow all the old laws, but according to the Matthew passage Jesus said in fact that you are to obey the old laws.

Really, I can keep repeating this as long as you want to pretend not to understand the position clearly stated by me and several others on this thread. Seems like a waste of time though. You'll just keep saying that we said Christians are supposed to follow all the O.T. laws, even though no one here has said that.
 
Last edited:
Who? I? Hey, that was my question!
Well, sure. Though I am rather curious what lead you to that conclusion, even if you were attempting to clear it up. Not important, though, and I drop the question.

I kinda smell that these laws are a no-no.
I was not aware they were selling scratch-and-sniff Bibles, and much less aware that you could tell the veracity of something by it's olfactory odor. I am intrigued and wish to learn more.

But why? What's bad about e.g. not murdering?
Good question. Perhaps you could go back and get them to define "murder", because it seems like that outright genocide of other tribes didn't actually fall under their particular definition.

The Bible said:
16 But of the cities of these people, which the LORD thy God doth give thee for an inheritance, thou shalt save alive nothing that breatheth:

17 But thou shalt utterly destroy them; namely, the Hittites, and the Amorites, the Canaanites, and the Perizzites, the Hivites, and the Jebusites; as the LORD thy God hath commanded thee:

18 That they teach you not to do after all their abominations, which they have done unto their gods; so should ye sin against the LORD your God.

The 10 Commandments were given again in Deuteronomy 5:2 (the first set in Exodus); so in the exact same chapter that states a set of rules in which it is stated that murder is wrong in the eyes of the Lord, it also talks about outright genocide of people just for being in other tribes.

Personally, I think that my definition of "murder" doesn't quite equal "save alive nothing that breatheth". But I may be wrong...

And if you want to go with moral codes, I do like what a certain comedian had to say about it. Trim out the first three, get rid of the "coveting is wrong", remove the fluff (such as "Honor thy Mother and Father" -- respect is earned, not granted), and you could easily come out with 3-4 commandments that far more people can agree with.
 
Last edited:
You're still pretending not to understand the difference between what we say and what we say Matthew says.

I fail to see how telling a Christian "Hey, you're supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws because it says so in Matthew" is not telling them that a Christian is supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.

No you don't. You're clearly trying very hard to get us to say something that none of us said or implied while you ignore the basic issue. That the argument that the O.T. laws no longer apply is refuted by the passage you cited from Matthew and the one I cited in Luke.

Like right here in the above quotation. You are saying the Old Testament Laws still apply. Does that mean Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

Nope. We point out that the passage in Matthew refutes the argument that Jesus replaced the old law and said it can be ignored. Quite obviously, the passage says you are to obey and teach every last one of the old commandments.

OK then. Going with what you just wrote:
Are Christians supposed to "obey and teach every last one of the old commandments"? YES or NO?

You'll just keep saying that we said Christians are supposed to follow all the O.T. laws, even though no one here has said that.
Well tell me - YES or NO?
 
Last edited:
I fail to see how telling a Christian "Hey, you're supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws because it says so in Matthew" is not telling them that a Christian is supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
Has anyone said this. I have seen lots of people say the bible says in Matthew you should follow the old testament laws. I don't think anyone has said that Christians should follow them. But you are the expert. Should they ?
 
Ha,

Got you.

Of course this isn't all atheists favorite bible verses so don't bother posting that it's not yours. And please don't post your favorite verses either. Thanks.

But I have come across atheists using these verses alot here. (And no - Darat - I won't post a link to all the examples in the forum so don't bother asking me to prove that statement)



In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally. I'm sure you know why they would like to make that case. ;)

Now - the only place I've ever come across that teaching is here and the only people I've ever heard insist that's how to interpret those verses are atheists.

So - if you'd like to play along and take up the challenge -

Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.

Thanks.

I can't be arsed to go and check but I am sure Radrook has used those verses to suggest that Christians should have more cognisance of the Old Testament. However, he does lean to a rather literal reading of the OT.
 
I'm probably going to regret wading into this, but here goes:

ACS, what some posters have been saying is:

2. The New Testament says that all of the Old Testament laws are binding.

You are interpreting that to mean:

3. Christians should follow all of the Old Testament laws.

You keep trying to equate (2) with (3), but they are not the same thing. Nor does (3)
logically follow directly from (2). You are implicitly assuming another proposition:

1. Christians should follow all of the New Testament laws.

which most of these same posters are telling you is not a proposition they agree with.
 
I have seen lots of people say the bible says in Matthew you should follow the old testament laws. I don't think anyone has said that Christians should follow them.

But you are the expert. Should they ?

Sorry. Maybe I'l take part in your thread. But right now I want to know if they think Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws.
 
Last edited:
Nope. That's simply wrong. No one said that. In fact, many of us have said quite clearly many times that we don't think anyone (including Christians) should follow all the O.T. laws.

This isn't about being dense or dishonest. ACS might be being stubborn on his point, but it's valid to avoid the broad generalization of what side of the question each individual lands on?

Some individuals, apparently atheist (if any aren't, my apologies for the generalization), are making the argument that Jesus told his followers to adhere to the OT laws. Most of these folk think, as you've stated that no one should follow the OT laws, but that's not immediately obvious from their arguments, which are often vehemently for the interpretation of Matthew and other NT books. So ACS has asked for clarification from each individual to determine what the atheist contingent thinks Christians should do in the adherence of what Jesus said.

It's an honest question, and only one or two people have responded directly to it at this point.

I can't be arsed to go and check but I am sure Radrook has used those verses to suggest that Christians should have more cognisance of the Old Testament. However, he does lean to a rather literal reading of the OT.

Lean nothing. He's fallen over into a black hole of his own making, and now sucks the will to live out of anyone who tries to have a discussion with him or asks for clarification.
 
Last edited:
This isn't about being dense or dishonest. ACS might be being stubborn on his point, but it's valid to avoid the broad generalization of what side of the question each individual lands on?

Some individuals, apparently atheist (if any aren't, my apologies for the generalization), are making the argument that Jesus told his followers to adhere to the OT laws. Most of these folk think, as you've stated that no one should follow the OT laws, but that's not immediately obvious from their arguments, which are often vehemently for the interpretation of Matthew and other NT books. So ACS has asked for clarification from each individual to determine what the atheist contingent thinks Christians should do in the adherence of what Jesus said

THis is BS. Just look at his response to Robin above where he completely distorted Robin's position. It's just a pansy-arse attempt to distract from the fact that he can't support his nonsense about how the passage only refers to those who break the law AND teach others to break it at the same time.

He's a dishonest putz, and you are nearing one for supporting such BS.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom