Lonewulf
Humanistic Cyborg
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2005
- Messages
- 10,375
Have you ever taken a philosophy class? If you ever did, you should know that any argument has within it certain assumptions that lead to the conclusion.Sorry Lonewulf. I've had to simplify it.
Because they were saying Christians are supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws. And they used Matthew verses to try to prove it. They also said it was obvious that's what those verses meant. And they argued that position.
That would be a YES.
Except, now they're saying it's not a YES.
So - is it a YES or NO?
If you make the assumption that the Bible is the inerrant word of God (or at the very least, inspired enough by God to be useful), then you would reach one conclusion.
If you don't make this assumption, then it leads to another conclusion.
Personally, I'd take heaven above fitting in society. I'd look deep into the Bible and follow it 100% if I really honestly believed that that was the way into the pearly gates. But I don't, because I don't tend to believe in things that have no backing for them.
Because as far as I see it, the Bible is pretty clear on one thing: To please God, you need to do certain things and uphold certain rituals. When you don't follow those rituals, but also claim that the Bible is something that you should follow, then I really start to wonder who you're trying to fool. Not me, at least.
Like I said, it's the natural conclusion when you factor in all of the fundamental logical assumptions. Personally, I'm a person of logic; I lead where the truth would take me, and I attempt not to contradict myself or go down paths littered with fallacies.
I still don't see any kind of evidence for the soul, much less the afterlife, and much less one kind of afterlife. It's like attempting to talk about the speed of the sun as it revolves around the earth. More like, the effects of the sun's speed on other planets as it spins around the Earth. It seems like a conclusion based on an assumption that has no backing for it in the first place.
But if I was led (through logic and empricism, naturally) to the conclusion that there was an afterlife, a creator of the Universe, and only one real way to please Him... well, to be honest, I might just spite him for the hell of it. But I'd know I'd have to pay dearly. If I was interested in pleasing Him (as Christians usually are), I'd do what it takes.
Although I would dislike others harming me because of their silly beliefs, if I felt their beliefs actually had something to do it, I'd be more tempted to follow along. But so far, I have seen 0 evidence that any religious claim has any kind of backing of any kind whatsoever. So no, I don't want you to follow the Old Testament.
All in all, if you ask me what you should and should not do, then I'd ask, "What are your terms?" What do you actually want to do? What are your assumptions? If you believe that the Bible is the inerrant word of God, and you want to go to heaven and don't care what society thinks of you... then you probably should ask yourself what's more important: God or us?
Of course, I would also point out that the assumptions that lead up to your conclusion are definitely questionable. But when has that ever stopped the religious?
Last edited: